Filed: Mar. 07, 2014
Latest Update: Mar. 07, 2014
Summary: ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL (Re: Docket Nos. 476, 490, 498, 516, 526, 528, 531, 533, 540, 541, 561, 563, 577, 582, 592, 593, 613, 632, 649, 656, 669, 676, 681, 689, 711, 721, 738, 742, 743) PAUL S. GREWAL, Magistrate Judge. Before the court are 29 administrative motions to seal 179 documents. "Historically, courts have recognized a `general right to inspect and copy public records and documents, including judicial records and documents.'" 1 Accordingly, when considering a sealing request, "a `st
Summary: ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL (Re: Docket Nos. 476, 490, 498, 516, 526, 528, 531, 533, 540, 541, 561, 563, 577, 582, 592, 593, 613, 632, 649, 656, 669, 676, 681, 689, 711, 721, 738, 742, 743) PAUL S. GREWAL, Magistrate Judge. Before the court are 29 administrative motions to seal 179 documents. "Historically, courts have recognized a `general right to inspect and copy public records and documents, including judicial records and documents.'" 1 Accordingly, when considering a sealing request, "a `str..
More
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL (Re: Docket Nos. 476, 490, 498, 516, 526, 528, 531, 533, 540, 541, 561, 563, 577, 582, 592, 593, 613, 632, 649, 656, 669, 676, 681, 689, 711, 721, 738, 742, 743)
PAUL S. GREWAL, Magistrate Judge.
Before the court are 29 administrative motions to seal 179 documents. "Historically, courts have recognized a `general right to inspect and copy public records and documents, including judicial records and documents.'"1Accordingly, when considering a sealing request, "a `strong presumption in favor of access' is the starting point."2Parties seeking to seal judicial records relating to dispositive motions bear the burden of overcoming the presumption with "compelling reasons" that outweigh the general history of access and the public policies favoring disclosure.3
However, "while protecting the public's interest in access to the courts, we must remain mindful of the parties' right to access those same courts upon terms which will not unduly harm their competitive interest."4Records attached to nondispositive motions therefore are not subject to the strong presumption of access.5Because the documents attached to nondispositive motions "are often unrelated, or only tangentially related, to the underlying cause of action," parties moving to seal must meet the lower "good cause" standard of Rule 26(c).6As with dispositive motions, the standard applicable to nondispositive motions requires a "particularized showing"7that "specific prejudice or harm will result" if the information is disclosed.8"Broad allegations of harm, unsubstantiated by specific examples of articulated reasoning" will not suffice.9A protective order sealing the documents during discovery may reflect the court's previous determination that good cause exists to keep the documents sealed,10but a blanket protective order that allows the parties to designate confidential documents does not provide sufficient judicial scrutiny to determine whether each particular document should remain sealed.11
In addition to making particularized showings of good cause, parties moving to seal documents must comply with the procedures established by Civ. L.R. 79-5. Pursuant to Civ. L.R. 79-5(b), a sealing order is appropriate only upon a request that establishes the document is "sealable," or "privileged or protectable as a trade secret or otherwise entitled to protection under the law." "The request must be narrowly tailored to seek sealing only of sealable material, and must conform with Civil L.R. 79-5(d)."12"Within 4 days of the filing of the Administrative Motion to File Under Seal, the Designating Party must file a declaration as required by subsection 79-5(d)(1)(A) establishing that all of the designated material is sealable."13
With these standards in mind, the courts rules on the instant motions as follows:
Motion Document to be Sealed Result Reason/Explanation
to Seal
476 Samsung's Motion to UNSEALED No declaration filed
Amend Infringement
Contention
476/490 Exhibit 4 to the Briggs SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Amend information
Infringement Contention
476 Exhibit 6 to the Briggs UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
476 Exhibit 7 to the Briggs UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
476 Exhibit 8 to the Briggs UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
476 Exhibit 9 to the Briggs UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
476 Exhibit 10 to the Briggs SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Amend information
Infringement Contention
498 Samsung's Motion to SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Compel Complete No. 515 confidential business
Production of Source Code information
498 Thakur Declaration ISO SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Samsung's Motion to confidential business
Compel Complete information
Production of Source Code
498 Exhibit 19 to Thakur SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's No. 515 confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Complete Production of
Source Code
498 Exhibit 26 to Thakur SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's No. 515 confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Complete Production of
Source Code
516 Apple's Opposition to SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Samsung's Motion for confidential business
Leave to Amend and information
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 1 to the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Apple's Opposition to information
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 2 to the Selwyn UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Apple's Opposition to
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 3 to the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Apple's Opposition to information
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 4 to the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Apple's Opposition to information
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 5 to the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Apple's Opposition to information
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 6 to the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Apple's Opposition to information
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 9 to the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Apple's Opposition to information
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 10 to the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Apple's Opposition to information
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
516 Exhibit 11 to the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Apple's Opposition to information
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
526 Exhibit 1 to the Declaration UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
of Joshua Furman ISO to confidential
Apple's Motion for Leave business information
to Amend
and Supplement Its
Infringement Contentions
528 Samsung's Reply in SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Support of Motion to confidential business
Amend Infringement information
Contentions
528 Exhibit 4 to the Briggs SEALED as amended in Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's No. 542 confidential business
Reply in Support of information
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
528 Exhibit 5 to the Briggs SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Reply in Support of information
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
528 Exhibit 6 to the Briggs UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
528 Exhibit 7 to the Briggs SEALED as amended in Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's No. 542 confidential business
Reply in Support of information
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
528 Exhibit 8 to the Briggs SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Reply in Support of information
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
531 Apple's Opposition to UNSEALED Declaration
Samsung's Motion to submitted indicating
Compel Documents from no redaction
Related Litigations necessary
531 Exhibit 19 to the Kolovos UNSEALED Declaration
Declaration ISO Apple's submitted indicating
Opposition to Samsung's no redaction
Motion to Compel necessary
Documents from
Related Litigations
533 Arrouye Declaration ISO SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Apple's Opposition to confidential business
Samsung's Motion to information
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
533 Chu Declaration ISO SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Apple's Opposition to confidential business
Samsung's Motion to information
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
533 Krugler Declaration ISO SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Apple's Opposition to confidential business
Samsung's Motion to information
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
533 Lew Declaration ISO SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Apple's Opposition to confidential business
Samsung's Motion to information
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
533 Manickam Declaration ISO SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Apple's Opposition to confidential business
Samsung's Motion to information
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
533 McFarlane Declaration ISO SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Apple's Opposition to confidential business
Samsung's Motion to information
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
533 Shenoy Declaration ISO SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Apple's Opposition to confidential business
Samsung's Motion to information
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
540 Samsung's Motion For UNSEALED Declaration
Leave to Amend Its submitted indicating
Invalidity Contentions no redaction
necessary
540 Exhibit 3 to Thakur UNSEALED Declaration
Declaration ISO submitted indicating
Samsung's Motion For no redaction
Leave to Amend Its necessary
Invalidity Contentions
540 Exhibit 10 to Thakur UNSEALED Declaration
Declaration ISO submitted indicating
Samsung's Motion For no redaction
Leave to Amend Its necessary
Invalidity Contentions
540 Exhibit 17 to Thakur UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Motion For business information
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
540 Exhibit 18 to Thakur UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Motion For business information
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
540 Exhibit 19 to Thakur UNSEALED Declaration
Declaration ISO submitted indicating
Samsung's Motion For no redaction
Leave to Amend Its necessary
Invalidity Contentions
540 Exhibit 20 to Thakur SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO No. 657 confidential business
Samsung's Motion For information
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
540 Exhibit 22 to Thakur SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO No. 657 confidential business
Samsung's Motion For information
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
541 Samsung's Motion To UNSEALED No declaration filed
Preclude Apple
From Asserting Untimely
Dates Of Conception
541 Exhibit C to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
541 Exhibit D to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
541 Exhibit E to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
541 Exhibit F to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
541 Exhibit G to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
541 Exhibit H to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
541 Exhibit I to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
541 Exhibit J to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
541 Exhibit K to Thakur UNSEALED No declaration filed
Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
561 Exhibit A to the SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration of Amar No. 586 confidential business
Thakur ISO Samsung's information
Reply On Its MTC
Documents From Related
Litigations
563 Samsung's Reply ISO SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel No. 587-1 confidential business
Complete Production of information
Source Code
563 Thakur Declaration ISO SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Samsung's Reply ISO No. 587-2 confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Complete Production of
Source Code
563 Exhibit 3 to Thakur SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO No. 587-3 confidential business
Samsung's Reply ISO information
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
563 Exhibit 4 to Thakur UNSEALED except last 3 pages, Public information
Declaration ISO which remain SEALED
Samsung's Reply ISO
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
563 Exhibit 10 to Thakur SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO No. 587-4 confidential business
Samsung's Reply ISO information
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
577 Samsung's Supplemental UNSEALED Declaration
Brief ISO Samsung's submitted indicating
Motion to Amend no redaction
Invalidity Contentions necessary
577 Briggs Declaration ISO UNSEALED Declaration
Samsung's Supplemental submitted indicating
Brief ISO Samsung's no redaction
Motion to Amend necessary
Invalidity Contentions
577 Exhibit 1 to Briggs UNSEALED Defended solely on
Declaration ISO attorney-client
Samsung's Supplemental privilege grounds;
Brief ISO Samsung's privilege waived by
Motion to Amend production
Invalidity Contentions
577 Exhibit 2 to Briggs SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Samsung's Supplemental information
Brief ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Invalidity Contentions
577 Exhibit 3 to Briggs UNSEALED Defended solely on
Declaration ISO attorney-client
Samsung's Supplemental privilege grounds;
Brief ISO Samsung's privilege waived by
Motion to Amend production
Invalidity Contentions
577 Exhibit 4 to Briggs UNSEALED Defended solely on
Declaration ISO attorney-client
Samsung's Supplemental privilege grounds;
Brief ISO Samsung's privilege waived by
Motion to Amend production
Invalidity Contentions
582 Apple's Opposition to UNSEALED Declaration
Samsung's Motion for submitted indicating
Leave to File Supplemental no redaction
Briefing necessary
592 Exhibit 2 to Supplemental UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Furman Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Motion for business information
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement Contentions
592 Exhibit 3 to Supplemental UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Furman Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Motion for business information
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement Contentions
592 Exhibit 4 to Supplemental UNSEALED Not moved under seal
Furman Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement Contentions
593 Exhibits B and L to the UNSEALED Declaration
Declaration of Brian submitted indicating
Buroker ISO Apple's no redaction
Opposition to Samsung's necessary
Motion to Preclude Apple
From Asserting Untimely
Dates of Conception
613 Samsung's Reply in UNSEALED No declaration filed
Support of its Motion for
Leave to Amend Invalidity
Contentions
632 Samsung's Motion to SEALED UNSEALED Sealed portions
Compel Production of 12:1-13: 1 6:1-25 reflect narrow
Documents and Response 13:7 13:5-6 tailoring to protect
to Interrogatory No 32 14:6-7 13:8-9 confidential business
14:17-20 14: 2-6 information.
14:7-8 Unsealed portions do
14: 14-17 not.
14:20-25
15:1-25
632 Exhibit 4 to Samsung's SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel No. 655-2 confidential business
Production of Documents information
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
632 Exhibit 12 to Samsung's SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel No. 655-3 confidential business
Production of Documents information
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
632 Exhibit 25 to Samsung's SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel confidential business
Production of Documents information
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
632 Exhibit 26 to Samsung's SEALED UNSEALED Sealed portions
Motion to Compel 13: 5-8 12:1-25 reflect narrow
Production of Documents 20:19-21:8 13:1-4, 9-25 tailoring to protect
and Response to 21:25-22:1 14:1-20:8 confidential business
Interrogatory No 32 22:22 20: 9-12 information.
32:6-7 21: 10-24 Unsealed portions do
33: 3-4 22: 2-21 not.
22:23-31:25
32: 1-12 Page numbers varied
33: 6-25 between versions.
34: 1-25 For purposes of this
order, pg. 12
correlates to pg. 67 of
deposition testimony.
632 Exhibit 31 to Samsung's SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel confidential business
Production of Documents information
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
632 Exhibit 32 to Samsung's SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel confidential business
Production of Documents information
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
632 Exhibit 33 to Samsung's SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel confidential business
Production of Documents information
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
632 Exhibit 34 to Samsung's SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel confidential business
Production of Documents information
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
632 Exhibit 35 to Samsung's SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Motion to Compel confidential business
Production of Documents information
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
632 Exhibit 36 to Samsung's UNSEALED except pg. 12 Public information
Motion to Compel (deposition transcript pg. 111),
Production of Documents which shall remain SEALED
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
649 CORRECTED Exhibit A UNSEALED No declaration filed
to Stipulation re Samsungs
Proposed Invalidity
Contentions
656 Exhibit 2 to Michael UNSEALED Public information
Valek's Declaration ISO
Apple Inc.'s Opposition to
Google Inc.'s Motion to
Quash Apple's Subpoenas
for the Production of
Documents and Testimony
656 Exhibit 13 to Shannon SEALED as follows: 10:2, 10: Sealed portions
Mader's Declaration ISO 21, 11: 1, 12: 4, 12: 25-27. reflect narrow
Apple Inc.'s Opposition to tailoring to protect
Google Inc.'s Motion to Remainder UNSEALED confidential business
Quash Apple's Subpoenas information.
for the Production of Unsealed portions do
Documents and Testimony not.
669 Samsung's Motion to UNSEALED Public information
Compel Production of
Financial Documents and
to Enforce the April 12,
2013 Order
669 Thakur Declaration ISO UNSEALED Public information
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Production of
Financial Documents and
to Enforce the April 12,
2013 Order
669 Exhibit 5 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 6 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 7 to Thakur UNSEALED Not marked
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential, and
Motion to Compel public information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 8 to Thakur UNSEALED Not marked
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential, and
Motion to Compel public information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 9 to Thakur UNSEALED Not marked
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential, and
Motion to Compel public information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 10 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 11 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 12 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 13 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 14 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 15 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 16 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 17 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 18 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 19 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 20 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 21 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 22 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 23 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 24 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
669 Exhibit 25 to Thakur SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Motion to Compel information
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
676 Apple's Opposition to Pgs. 3, 13: SEALED Sealed portions
Samsung's Motion to Remainder: UNSEALED reflect narrow
Compel Production of tailoring to protect
Documents and Response confidential business
to Interrogatory No. 32 information.
Unsealed portions do
not.
676 Walden Declaration ISO UNSEALED No declaration
Apple's Opposition to submitted
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Production of
Documents and Response
to Interrogatory No. 32
676 Exhibit A to Walden SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Apple's confidential business
Opposition to Samsung's information
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
676 Exhibit B to Walden UNSEALED No declaration
Declaration ISO Apple's submitted
Opposition to Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
681 Apple's Amended UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Infringement Contentions to confidential
business information
689 Samsung's Reply in UNSEALED No declaration
Support of Its Motion to submitted
Compel Production of
Documents and Response
to Interrogatory No. 32
689 Drezdzon's Declaration UNSEALED No declaration
ISO Samsung's Reply in submitted
Support of Its Motion to
Compel Production of
Documents and Response
to Interrogatory No. 32
689 Exhibit 37 to Drezdzon's SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Reply in Support of Its information
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
689 Exhibit 38 to Drezdzon's SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's No. 702 confidential business
Reply in Support of Its information
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
689 Exhibit 39 to Drezdzon's SEALED as amended by Docket Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's No. 702 confidential business
Reply in Support of Its information
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
689 Exhibit 40 to Drezdzon's SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Samsung's confidential business
Reply in Support of Its information
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
711 Apple's Opposition to UNSEALED Public information
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Production of
Financial Documents and
to Enforce the April 12,
2013 Order
721 Samsung's Reply In UNSEALED Public information
Support of Motion to
Compel Financial
Documents and Exhibits
738 Apple's Notice of Joinder UNSEALED Public information
in Nokia's Motion for a
Protective Order
742 Stipulation With Proposed UNSEALED Public information
Order Re Motion For
Protective Order By Nokia
Corporation
743 Samsung's Opposition to UNSEALED Public information
Apple's Notice of Joinder
in Nokia's Motion for a
Protective Order
IT IS SO ORDERED.
