Petitioner: REGENCY HOSPICE OF NORTHWEST FLORIDA, INC.
Respondent: ODYSSEY HEALTHCARE OF NORTHWEST FLORIDA, INC.; UNITED HOSPICE OF WEST FLORIDA; AND AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION
Judges: CHARLES A. STAMPELOS
Agency: Agency for Health Care Administration
Locations: Tallahassee, Florida
Filed: Apr. 26, 2007
Status: Closed
Recommended Order on Wednesday, April 30, 2008.
Latest Update: Aug. 19, 2008
Summary: Whether the Certificate of Need (CON) applications filed by Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. (Regency), Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc. (Odyssey), and United Hospice of West Florida, Inc. (United) for a new hospice program in Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA or the Agency) Service Area (Service Area) 1, satisfy, on balance, the applicable statutory and rule review criteria sufficiently to warrant approval and, if so, which of the three applications best meets t
Summary: Whether the Certificate of Need (CON) applications filed by Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. (Regency), Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc. (Odyssey), and United Hospice of West Florida, Inc. (United) for a new hospice program in Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA or the Agency) Service Area (Service Area) 1, satisfy, on balance, the applicable statutory and rule review criteria sufficiently to warrant approval and, if so, which of the three applications best meets the applicable criteria for approval.On balance and in this comparative review hearing, Regency proved that its proposed hospice program in AHCA Service Area 1 should be approved over the other two applicants.
More
STATE OF FLORIDA
AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION z
ie
hye PAG _
RENDITION NO.: AHCA-08- Of305 -FOF-CON 703 AL SB Ay 48
CON NO. 9954, 9955 & 9971 OE
ODYSSEY HEALTHCARE OF
NORTHWEST FLORIDA, INC.,
Petitioner, : DOAH CASE NO. 07-1658CON
AHCA NO. 2007003691
vs.
AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE
ADMINISTRATION,
Respondent.
/
UNITED HOSPICE OF WEST FLORIDA,
INC.,
Petitioner, DOAH CASE NO. 07-1659CON
AHCA NO. 2007003718
vs.
AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE
ADMINISTRATION and REGENCY
HOSPICE OF NORTHWEST FLORIDA,
INC.,
Respondents.
/
REGENCY HOSPICE OF NORTHWEST
FLORIDA, INC.,
Petitioner,
vs. DOAH CASE NO. 07-1878CON
AHCA CASE NO. 2007004287
AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE
ADMINISTRATION, ODYSSEY
HEALTHCARE OF NORTHWEST
FLORIDA, INC. and UNITED HOSPICE
OF WEST FLORIDA, INC.,
Respondents.
FINAL ORDER
3
This case was referred to the Division of Administrative Hearings (DOAH) wheré”} Ce
assigned Administrative Law Judge (ALJ), Charles A. Stampelos, conducted a formal
administrative hearing. At issue in this proceeding is whether the Certificate of Need (CON)
applications filed by Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. (“Regency”), Odyssey
Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc. (“Odyssey”), and United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.
(“United”) for a new hospice program in Agency for Health Care Administration (“Agency” or
“AHCA”) Service Area 1, satisfy, on balance, the applicable statutory and rule review criteria
sufficiently to warrant approval, and, if so, which of the three applications best meets the
applicable criteria for approval. The Recommended Order dated April 30, 2008 is attached to
this final order and incorporated herein by reference.
RULINGS ON EXCEPTIONS
Odyssey filed exceptions to the recommended order to which Regency filed responses.
In its First Exception, Odyssey took exception to the findings of fact in Paragraph 31 of
the Recommended Order, arguing that the findings were irrelevant and should be stricken.
However, Odyssey made no showing that the findings of fact in Paragraph 31 of the
Recommended Order were not based on competent, substantial evidence. The Agency can only
reject or modify findings of fact in a recommended order if those findings are not based on
competent, substantial evidence. See § 120.57(1)(D, Fla. Stat.; Heifetz v. Department of Bus.
Regulation, 475 So.2d 1277, 1281 (Fla. 1985) (holding that an agency “may not reject the
hearing officer’s finding [of fact] unless there is no competent, substantial evidence from which
the finding could reasonably be inferred”). Odyssey’s argument is irrelevant because the
findings of fact in Paragraph 31 of the Recommended Order were based on competent,
substantial evidence. See Transcript, Volume 8, Pages 1008, 1012-1013 and 1047-1048. Thus,
the Agency cannot reject or modify them. Further, Odyssey is, in essence, asking the Agency to
overturn the ALJ’s ruling on an evidentiary issue, which the Agency cannot do. See Barfield v.
Dep’t of Health, 805 So.2d 1008 (Fla. Ist DCA 2002) (an agency does not have substantive
jurisdiction to reverse or modify an ALJ’s conclusion of law on an evidentiary issue). Therefore
Qdyssey’s First Exception is denied. .
In its Second Exception, Odyssey took exception to the finding of fact in Paragraph 110
of the Recommended Order, arguing that the finding was not supported by competent,
substantial evidence. However, contrary to Odyssey’s argument, the finding of fact in Paragraph
110 of the Recommended Order was based on competent, substantial evidence. See, e.g.,
Transcript, Volume 1, Pages 55-57, 64 and 139-144; Transcript, Volume 3, Pages 461-462; and
Regency Exhibits 2, 20 and 76. Thus, the Agency is prohibited from rejecting or modifying it.
See § 120.57(1)(D), Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Second Exception is denied.
In its Third Exception, Odyssey took exception to the findings of fact in Paragraph 166 of
the Recommended Order, arguing that the findings were not based on competent, substantial
record evidence. However, contrary to Odyssey’s argument, the findings of fact in Paragraph
166 of the Recommended Order were based on competent, substantial evidence. See, ¢.g.,
Transcript, Volume 14, Pages 1715-1716; and Odyssey Exhibit 43. Thus, they cannot be
disturbed by the Agency. See § 120.57(1)(D, Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Third
Exception is denied.
In its Fourth Exception, Odyssey took exception to the finding of fact in Paragraph 172 of
the Recommended Order, arguing that the finding was not supported by competent, substantial
record evidence. Odyssey is, in essence, asking the Agency to re-weigh the evidence in order to
reach ultimate findings that are more favorable to its position, which the Agency cannot do. See
§ 120.57(1)(), Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Paragraph 172 of the Recommended Order was an ultimate
finding of fact’ made by the ALJ after weighing the competent, substantial evidence presented in
this case. See, e.g., Paragraph 169 of the Recommended Order; Transcript, Volume 7, Pages
764-765 and 773-777; Transcript, Volume 8, Pages 1036-1037; Transcript, Volume 11, Pages
1412-1415; -and Regency Exhibits 56, 61 and 62. The Agency does not have any grounds to
reject or modify that ultimate finding of fact. See § 120.57(1)(D, Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore,
Odyssey’s Fourth Exception is denied.
In its Fifth Exception, Odyssey took exception to the findings of fact in Paragraph 203 of
the Recommended Order, arguing that the findings of fact were not based on competent,
substantial evidence. However, contrary to Odyssey’s argument, the findings of fact in
Paragraph 203 of the Recommended Order were based on competent, substantial evidence. See,
e.g., Transcript, Volume 1, Pages 85-86 and 178-179; Transcript, Volume 3, Pages 417-418;
Transcript, Volume 6, Pages 715-716 and 718; Transcript, Volume 7, Pages 768-769 and 771-
' The “ultimate facts” mentioned above
are those “necessary to determine issues in [a] case” or the “final facts” derived
from the “evidentiary facts supporting them.” Id. (citing Black's Law Dictionary
1522 (6th ed. 1990)). Ultimate facts are also regularly described as “mixed
questions” of law and fact, see, e.g., Antonucci v. Unemp. App. Comm’n, 793
So.2d 1116, 1117 (Fla. 4th DCA 2001), and must generally be made by the fact
finder in an administrative proceeding because they are “necessary for proper
review of administrative orders.” Tedder, 697 So.2d at 902; see also San Roman
y. Unemp. App. Comm’n, 711 So.2d 93 (Fla. 4th DCA 1998) (finding that
whether “good cause” exists for unemployment compensation claimant to
voluntarily leave work frequently involves mixed question of law and fact, and
is an ultimate fact best left to the fact-finder); Heifetz v. Dep’t of Bus. Reg., Div.
of Alcoholic Beverages & Tobacco , 475 So.2d 1277 (Fla. ist DCA 1985)
(finding that “negligent supervision and lack of diligence are essentially ultimate
findings of fact clearly within the realm of the hearing officer's fact-finding
discretion.”) (citations omitted).
Costin v. Fla. A&M Univ. Bad. of Trustees, 972 So.2d 1084 (Fla. Sth DCA 2008).
772; and Regency Exhibits 59-60. Thus, the Agency cannot reject or modify them. See §
120.57(1)(), Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Fifth Exception is denied.
In its Sixth Exception, Odyssey took exception to the finding of fact in Paragraph 250 of
the Recommended Order wherein the ALJ found that the proposed office locations of Regency
would enhance access to a greater degree than the ones proposed by Odyssey, arguing that the
finding was not supported by competent, substantial record evidence. However, contrary to
Odyssey’s assertion, the finding of fact in Paragraph 250 was based on competent, substantial
evidence (See Transcript, Volume 1, Pages 85-86 and 178-179; Transcript, Volume 3, Pages
417-418 and 432; Transcript, Volume 6, Pages 715-716 and 718; Transcript, Volume 7, Pages
763, 764, 768-769 and 771-772; Regency Exhibits 7, 56 and 59-60), and thus cannot be
disturbed by the Agency. See § 120.57(1)(), Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Sixth
Exception is denied.
In its Seventh Exception, Odyssey took exception to the finding of fact in Paragraph 276"
of the Recommended Order, arguing that the ALJ’s statement that “[hJaving an office in a
particular county such as Walton County, would most likely establish and promote a presence in
the area” was not based on competent, substantial evidence. However, despite Odyssey’s
argument to the contrary, the finding of fact in Paragraph 276 of the Recommended Order was a
reasonable inference based on competent, substantial evidence. See, e.g., Transcript, Volume 1,
Pages 85-86 and 178-179; Transcript, Volume 6, Pages 715-716, 718 and 729; and Regency
Exhibits 59-60. Thus, the Agency is prohibited from rejecting or modifying it. See §
120.57(1)(), Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Seventh Exception is denied.
? The exception refers to Paragraph 277 of the Recommended Order. However, it is obvious from Odyssey’s
argument that the finding of fact it is taking exception to is located in Paragraph 276 of the Recommended Order.
In its Eighth Exception, Odyssey took exception to the finding of fact in Paragraph 288 of
the Recommended Order wherein the ALJ found Regency had proposed a better nurse to patient
ratio for its hospice program than Odyssey or United, arguing that the finding was not supported
by competent, substantial record evidence. However, contrary to Odyssey’s argument, the
finding of fact in Paragraph 288 of the Recommended Order was based on competent, substantial
evidence. See Transcript; Volume 6, Pages 740-741; Transcript, Volume 9, Page 1149;
Transcript, Volume 12, Page 1609; and Regency Exhibit 7. Thus, the Agency cannot alter it.
See § 120.57(1)(D, Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Eighth Exception is denied.
In its Ninth Exception, Odyssey took exception to the finding of fact in Paragraph 292 of
the Recommended Order wherein the ALJ found that Odyssey and United’s approach to opening
offices on a staggered basis was “not necessarily appropriate given the need for an [sic]
additional hospice services over a four-county area,” arguing that the finding of fact was not
supported by competent, substantial record evidence. However, contrary to Odyssey’s argument,
the finding of fact in Paragraph 292 of the Recommended Order was based on competent,
substantial evidence. See, e.g., Transcript, Volume 1, Pages 85-86 and 178-179; Transcript,
Volume 3, Pages 417-418; Transcript, Volume 6, Pages 715-716 and 7 18; Transcript, Volume 7,
Pages 768-769 and 771-772; and Regency Exhibits 59-60. Thus, the Agency cannot reject or
~modify it. See § 120.57(1)\/, Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Ninth Exception is
denied.
In its Tenth Exception, Odyssey took exception to the finding of fact in Paragraph 293 of
the Recommended Order, arguing that the finding was not supported by competent, substantial
record evidence. However, contrary to Odyssey’s assertion, the finding of fact in Paragraph 293
was based on competent, substantial evidence (See Transcript, Volume 6, Page 716; Transcript,
Volume 7, Pages 764-765; Transcript, Volume 8, Pages 1036-1037; Transcript, Volume 11,
Pages 1412-1415; and Regency Exhibit 56), and thus cannot be disturbed by the Agency. See §
120.57(1)(), Fla. Stat.; Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Tenth Exception is denied.
In its Eleventh Exception, Odyssey took exception to the finding of fact in Paragraph 297
of the Recommended Order, arguing that the finding was not ‘supported ‘by competent,
substantial evidence. Paragraph 297 of the Recommended Order was an ultimate finding of fact
made by the ALJ after weighing the competent, substantial evidence presented in this case. See,
¢.g,, the rulings on Odyssey’s First — Tenth Exceptions supra. Odyssey is, in essence, asking the
Agency to re-weigh the evidence in order to reach a finding that is more favorable to Odyssey,
which the Agency cannot do. See Heifetz. Therefore, Odyssey’s Eleventh Exception is denied.
In its Twelfth, Thirteenth, Fourteenth, Fifteenth and Sixteenth Exceptions, Odyssey took
exception to the conclusions of law in Paragraphs 331, 333, 334, 344 and 346 of the
Recommended Order, arguing that the conclusions of law were findings of fact that were not
supported by competent, substantial record evidence. The Agency asserts that Paragraphs 331,
333, 334, 344 and 346 of the Recommended Order are conclusions of law. While there is some
question as to whether the Agency has substantive jurisdiction over the conclusions of law in
these paragraphs,’ the Agency does not need to reach that point because, even if the Agency has
_ substantive jurisdiction over the conclusions of law in Paragraph 331, 333, 334, 344 and 346 of
the Recommended Order, it could not substitute conclusions of law that are as or more
reasonable than those of the ALJ. See § 120.57(1)(), Fla. Stat. Additionally, as noted by
Regency in its response to Odyssey’s exceptions, this matter was already resolved by a previous
Agency final order. See In Re: Letters of Intent and CON application of Regency Hospice of
3 See, e.g., Deep Lagoon Boat Club, Ltd. v. Sheridan, 784 So.2d 1140, 1142 (Fla. 2d DCA 2001) (stating an agency does not
have substantive jurisdiction to decide whether the doctrine of collateral estoppel applies to a particular case).
Northwest Florida, LLC now known as Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc., Rendition
No.. AHCA-07-0044-S-OLC (January 12, 2007). Therefore, Odyssey’s Twelfth, Thirteenth,
Fourteenth, Fifteenth and Sixteenth Exceptions are denied.
FINDINGS OF FACT
The Agency hereby adopts the findings of fact set forth in the Recommended Order.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW"
The Agency adopts the conclusions of law set forth in the Recommended Order.
ORDER
Based upon the foregoing, Regency’s CON application No. 9971 is approved, and
_Odyssey’s CON application No. 9954 and United’s CON application No. 9955 are denied.
DONE and ORDERED this / fd day of bugus t , 2008, in Tallahassee, Florida.
four (ase SECRETARY
AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION
NOTICE OF RIGHT TO JUDICIAL REVIEW
A PARTY WHO IS ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY THIS FINAL ORDER IS ENTITLED
TO A JUDICIAL REVIEW WHICH SHALL BE INSTITUTED BY FILING ONE COPY
‘OF A NOTICE OF APPEAL WITH THE AGENCY CLERK OF AHCA, AND A
SECOND COPY ALONG WITH THE FILING FEE AS PRESCRIBED BY LAW, WITH
THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL IN THE APPELLATE DISTRICT WHERE THE
AGENCY MAINTAINS ITS HEADQUARTERS OR WHERE A PARTY RESIDES.
REVIEW PROCEEDINGS SHALL BE CONDUCTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
FLORIDA APPELLATE RULES. THE NOTICE OF APPEAL MUST BE FILED
WITHIN 30 DAYS OF RENDITION OF THE ORDER TO BE REVIEWED.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that:a true and correct copy of the foregoing Final Order has
been furnished by U.S. Mail, or . the method indicated, to the persons named below on this
/ g day of Aug as , 2008.
id
XQ
RICHARD J. SHOOP, Agency Clerk
Agency for Health Care Administration
2727 Mahan Drive, MS#3
Tallahassee, Florida 32308-5403
(850) 922-5873
COPIES FURNISHED TO:
Charles A. Stampelos
Administrative Law Judge
Division of Administrative Hearings
The DeSoto Building
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060
Mark A. Emanuele, Esquire
Panza, Maurer & Maynard, P.A.
3600 North Federal Highway, Third Floor
Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33308
Jay Adams, Esquire
Broad and Cassel
215 South Monroe Street, Suite 400
Tallahassee, Florida 32301
Geoffrey D. Smith, Esquire
Smith & Associates, P.A.
2873 Remington Green Circle
Tallahassee, Florida 32308
Sandra E. Allen, Esquire
Assistant General Counsel
Agency for Health Care Administration
2727 Mahan Drive, MS #3
Tallahassee, Florida 32308
Elizabeth Dudek
Health Quality Assurance
Jan Mills
Facilities Intake Unit
Docket for Case No: 07-001878CON
Issue Date |
Proceedings |
Aug. 19, 2008 |
Final Order filed.
|
Apr. 30, 2008 |
Recommended Order (hearing held November, 2007). CASE CLOSED.
|
Apr. 30, 2008 |
Recommended Order cover letter identifying the hearing record referred to the Agency.
|
Apr. 18, 2008 |
Regency`s Responsive Memorandum of Law filed.
|
Apr. 04, 2008 |
Order (motion to strike is denied).
|
Apr. 03, 2008 |
Petitioner, Odyssey HealthCare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Response to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Motion to Strike Odyssey`s Unauthorized Reply filed.
|
Mar. 31, 2008 |
Motion to Strike Odyssey`s Unauthorized "Reply" filed.
|
Mar. 28, 2008 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Reply to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, LLC`s Memorandum of Law filed.
|
Mar. 18, 2008 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Submittal of Case Law in Support of its Proposed Recommended Order and Memorandums of Law (documents unavailable for viewing) filed.
|
Mar. 18, 2008 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Memorandum of Law in Support of its Position that Petitioner, Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Amendment to its Application was an Impermissible Amendment filed.
|
Mar. 18, 2008 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Memorandum of Law in Support of its Position that Petitioner, Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc., was an Invalid Entity at the Time its Application was filed filed.
|
Mar. 18, 2008 |
Proposed Recommended Order of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Mar. 17, 2008 |
United Healthcare`s Proposed Recommended Order filed.
|
Mar. 17, 2008 |
Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida`s Memorandum of Law in Support of Proposed Proposed Recommended Order filed.
|
Mar. 17, 2008 |
(Proposed) Recommended Order filed by Regency.
|
Mar. 17, 2008 |
Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida`s Notice of Filing Proposed Recommended Order filed.
|
Mar. 17, 2008 |
AHCA`s Joinder in Regency Proposed Recommended Order and Memorandum of Law filed.
|
Mar. 17, 2008 |
Odyssey HealthCare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Memorandum of Law in Support of its Position that Petitioner, Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Amendment to its Application was an Impermissible Amendment filed.
|
Mar. 17, 2008 |
Odyssey HealthCare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Memorandum of Law in Support of its Position that Petitioner, Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc., was an Invalid Entity at the Time its Application was Filed.
|
Mar. 17, 2008 |
Proposed Recommended Order of Odyssey HealthCare of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Mar. 07, 2008 |
Order (Agreed Motion to Expand PRO Page Limit and Extension of Filing Deadline is granted, page limit is expanded to 80 pages).
|
Mar. 06, 2008 |
Agreed Motion to Expand PRO Page Limit and Extension of Filing Deadline filed.
|
Feb. 29, 2008 |
Order Granting Motion to Expand PRO Page Limit (page limit is expanded to 50 pages)
|
Feb. 28, 2008 |
Agreed Motion to Expand Pro Page Limit filed.
|
Feb. 20, 2008 |
Order Granting Extension of Time (PROs and memoranda of law to be filed by March 13, 2008).
|
Feb. 20, 2008 |
Odyssey HealthCare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Motion for a Ten-Day Extension of Time in which to File Proposed Recommended Orders and Memoranda of Law filed.
|
Jan. 10, 2008 |
Amended Order (proposed recommended orders and memoranda of law shall be filed by March 3, 2008).
|
Jan. 10, 2008 |
Transcript (volumes 1-14) filed. |
Dec. 13, 2007 |
Transcript (Motion Hearing taken on November 26, 2007) filed. |
Dec. 13, 2007 |
Order (proposed orders and memoranda of law shall be filed by February 29, 2008).
|
Nov. 27, 2007 |
CASE STATUS: Hearing Held. |
Nov. 27, 2007 |
Order (motions to relinquish jurisdiction are denied without prejudice).
|
Nov. 27, 2007 |
Joint Pre-hearing Stipulation filed.
|
Nov. 26, 2007 |
CASE STATUS: Motion Hearing Held. |
Nov. 19, 2007 |
Regency`s Amended Notice of Taking Telephone Depositions Duces Tecum filed.
|
Nov. 19, 2007 |
Regency`s Hospice of Northwest Florida and the Agency for Health Care Administration`s Response to Odyssey`s and United`s Motions for Summary Recommended Order filed.
|
Nov. 19, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Taking Telephone Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Nov. 13, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Taking Telephone Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Nov. 13, 2007 |
Order (on or before November 19, 2007, the non-moving parties may file responses and include any other relevant information that a responding party desires to file).
|
Nov. 13, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Taking Telephone Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Nov. 13, 2007 |
Re-Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Nov. 09, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Nov. 09, 2007 |
Re-Notice of Taking Depositions (As to Location Only) (S. Whittington, G. Church and J. Pace) filed.
|
Nov. 09, 2007 |
Petitioner United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.`s Joinder in Odyssey`s Motion Seeking Dismissal of Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc., filed.
|
Nov. 09, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Taking Depositions Duces Tecum filed.
|
Nov. 08, 2007 |
Petitioner Odyssey HealthCare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Motion for Summary Recommended Order Seeking Dismissal of Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida and Request for Telephonic Hearing filed.
|
Nov. 01, 2007 |
Notice of Taking Deposition (of S. Whittington) filed.
|
Oct. 31, 2007 |
Notice of Taking Deposition filed.
|
Oct. 30, 2007 |
AHCA`s Response to Petitioner United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.`s First Request for the Production of Documents from the Agency for Health Care Administration filed.
|
Oct. 29, 2007 |
AHCA`s Notice of Service of Answers to United Hospice of West Florida`s First Set of Interrogatories to AHCA filed.
|
Oct. 29, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey HealthCare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Responses to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Request for Admissions filed.
|
Oct. 26, 2007 |
Petitioner United Hospice of West Florida, Inc`s Response to Regency`s First Request for Admissions filed.
|
Oct. 24, 2007 |
Petitioner Odyssey HealthCare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Request for Copies to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Oct. 23, 2007 |
Order (Odyssey`s Motion to Amend Odyssey`s Witness List is granted).
|
Oct. 22, 2007 |
Regency`s Response in Opposition to Odyssey`s Motion to Amend Odyssey`s Witness List filed.
|
Oct. 22, 2007 |
Regency`s Responses to United`s First Request for Production of Documents filed.
|
Oct. 19, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Response to United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.`s First Request for Production of Documents filed.
|
Oct. 17, 2007 |
Motion to Amend Odyssey`s Witness List filed.
|
Oct. 16, 2007 |
Regency`s Amended Notice of Taking Depositions Duces Tecum filed.
|
Oct. 16, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Oct. 15, 2007 |
CASE STATUS: Pre-Hearing Conference Held. |
Oct. 15, 2007 |
Amended Notice of Hearing (hearing set for November 27 through 30, December 3 through 5 and 10 through 14, 2007; 9:00 a.m.; Tallahassee, FL; amended as to dates).
|
Oct. 15, 2007 |
Intervenor, Hospice of the Palm Coast, Inc.`s, Proposed Protective Order filed.
|
Oct. 15, 2007 |
Intervenor, Hospice of the Palm Coast, Inc.`s, Notice of Filing Proposed Protective Order filed.
|
Oct. 12, 2007 |
Regency`s Responses to Odyssey`s Third Request for Production of Documents filed.
|
Oct. 12, 2007 |
Regency`s Responses to Odyssey`s Fourth Request for Production of Documents filed.
|
Oct. 11, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Withdrawal of Third Request for Production of Documents to Odyssey filed.
|
Oct. 11, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Withdrawal of Third Request for Production of Documents to United filed.
|
Oct. 10, 2007 |
Regency`s Hospice of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Third Request for Production of Documents on an Expedited Basis to Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Oct. 10, 2007 |
Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Third Request for Production of Documents on an Expedited Basis to United Hospice of West Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Oct. 08, 2007 |
Petitioner United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.`s Response to Odyssey`s First Request for Admissions filed.
|
Oct. 05, 2007 |
Regency`s Response to Odyssey`s First Request for Admissions filed.
|
Oct. 03, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Oct. 02, 2007 |
Regency`s Amended Notice of Taking Deposition filed.
|
Oct. 02, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Taking Depositions filed.
|
Oct. 02, 2007 |
Amended Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Sep. 28, 2007 |
Regency`s First Request for Admissions to oddyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, INC. filed.
|
Sep. 28, 2007 |
Regency`s First Request for Admissions to United Hospice of West Florida, INC. filed.
|
Sep. 26, 2007 |
Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum (of P. Greenberg) filed.
|
Sep. 26, 2007 |
Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
|
Sep. 21, 2007 |
Petitioner United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.`s First Request for the Production of Documents from Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc., filed.
|
Sep. 21, 2007 |
Petitioner United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.`s First Request for the Production of Documetns from Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc., filed.
|
Sep. 21, 2007 |
Petitioner United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.`s First Request for the Production of Documents from the Agency for Health Care Administration filed.
|
Sep. 21, 2007 |
Notice of Service of United Hospice of West Florida, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories to the Agency for Health Care Administration filed.
|
Sep. 20, 2007 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Amended Witness List filed.
|
Sep. 18, 2007 |
Order Granting Continuance and Re-scheduling Hearing (hearing set for November 13 through 15, December 3 through 5 and 10 through 14, 2007; 9:00 a.m.; Tallahassee, FL).
|
Sep. 17, 2007 |
Agreed Motion for Continuance filed.
|
Sep. 17, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Third Request for Production of Documents to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Sep. 14, 2007 |
Undeliverable envelope returned from the Post Office.
|
Sep. 14, 2007 |
Undeliverable envelope returned from the Post Office.
|
Sep. 14, 2007 |
Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Second Request for Production of Documents to Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Sep. 14, 2007 |
Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida Inc.` Second Request for Production of Documents to United Hospice of West Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Sep. 11, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Third Request for Production of Documents to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Sep. 10, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Request for Admissions to United Hospice of West Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Sep. 05, 2007 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Request for Admissions to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Aug. 31, 2007 |
Order (motion to compel is denied in light of Regency`s response and it`s second amended answers to the first set of interrogatories).
|
Aug. 31, 2007 |
Amended Notice of Hearing (hearing set for November 5 through 8, 13 through 15, 26 through 30 and December 3 through 5, 2007; 9:00 a.m.; Tallahassee, FL; amended as to dates).
|
Aug. 30, 2007 |
Regency`s Second Amended Answers to Odyssey`s First Set of Interrogatoreis (unexecuted) filed.
|
Aug. 30, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Filing Regency`s Second Amended Answers to Odyssey`s First Interrogatories filed.
|
Aug. 30, 2007 |
Regency`s Response to Odyssey`s Motion to Compel Better Responses to Odyssey`s First Interrogatories to Regency filed.
|
Aug. 29, 2007 |
United`s Response to Odyssey`s First Request for Production filed.
|
Aug. 29, 2007 |
United`s Response to Odyssey`s Interrogatories filed.
|
Aug. 27, 2007 |
Order of Consolidation (DOAH Case Nos. 07-001657 |
Aug. 27, 2007 |
Notice of Voluntary Dismissal filed.
|
Aug. 23, 2007 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Motion to Compel a Better Response to Odyssey of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Interrogatories to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Aug. 22, 2007 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Motion to Compel Better Answers to Interrogatories filed.
|
Aug. 20, 2007 |
Order Granting Motion to Compel.
|
Aug. 20, 2007 |
AHCA`s Notice of Service of Answers to Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Second Set of Interrogatories to Agency for Health Care Administration filed.
|
Aug. 17, 2007 |
Notice of Serving Answers and Objections to Odyssey`s First Set of Interrogatories filed.
|
Aug. 10, 2007 |
Odyssey Health Care of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Motion to Compel Production of Documents to Odyssey Healthcare Inc.`s First Request for Production of Documents and Answers filed.
|
Aug. 08, 2007 |
Odyssey Preliminary Witness List (filed in Case No. 07-001658CON).
|
Aug. 06, 2007 |
Notice of Filing Responses to Interrogatories.
|
Aug. 06, 2007 |
Response to Request for Production of Documents filed.
|
Aug. 02, 2007 |
Amended Notice of Hearing (hearing set for November 1, 2, 5 through 9, 13 through 15 and 26 through 29, 2007; 9:00 a.m.; Tallahassee, FL; amended as to dates of hearing).
|
Jul. 30, 2007 |
Regency`s Responses to Odyssey`s Second Request for Production of Documents filed.
|
Jul. 30, 2007 |
Regency`s Final Witness List filed.
|
Jul. 27, 2007 |
United Healthcare`s Preliminary Witness List filed.
|
Jul. 27, 2007 |
The Agency for Health Care Administration`s Final Witness List filed.
|
Jul. 24, 2007 |
Regency`s Preliminary Witness List filed.
|
Jul. 24, 2007 |
Agency for Health Care Administration`s Response to Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Second Request for Admissions to AHCA filed.
|
Jul. 23, 2007 |
Protective Order.
|
Jul. 20, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Second Set of Interrogatories To Agency For Health Care Administration filed.
|
Jul. 19, 2007 |
Regency`s Responses to Odyssey`s First Request for Production of Documents filed.
|
Jul. 19, 2007 |
The Agency for Health Care Administration`s Response to the Motion of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Motion for a Protective Order filed.
|
Jul. 19, 2007 |
Amended Notice of Transfer.
|
Jul. 18, 2007 |
Notice of Transfer.
|
Jul. 17, 2007 |
Order Granting Extension (parties have until July 23, 2007 to file their witness lists).
|
Jul. 16, 2007 |
Regency`s Notice of Filing Answers to Odyssey`s First Interrogatories.
|
Jul. 13, 2007 |
Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time filed.
|
Jul. 12, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Executed Amended Answers to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories (Case No. 07-1658) filed.
|
Jul. 10, 2007 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Motion for Protective Order filed.
|
Jul. 03, 2007 |
Notice of Service Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Second Request for Admissions to the Agency for Health Care Administration filed.
|
Jun. 28, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Second Request for Production of Documents to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Jun. 27, 2007 |
Agency for Health Care Administration`s Response to Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Request for Admissions to AHCA filed.
|
Jun. 27, 2007 |
AHCA`s Notice of Service of Answers to Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories to AHCA filed.
|
Jun. 26, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s Unexecuted Responses to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories filed.
|
Jun. 26, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida Inc.`s Responses to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Request for Production of Documents filed.
|
Jun. 19, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida Inc.`s First Request for Production of Documents to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Jun. 19, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida Inc.`s First Request for Production of Documents to United Hospice of West Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Jun. 19, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida Inc.`s First Request for Production of Documents to Covenant Hospice, Inc. filed.
|
Jun. 19, 2007 |
Notice of Service Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories to Covenant Hospice, Inc. filed.
|
Jun. 15, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories to Regency Hospice of Northwest Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Jun. 15, 2007 |
Notice of Service of Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories to United Hospice of West Florida, Inc. filed.
|
Jun. 13, 2007 |
Amended Notice of Hearing (hearing set for November 1, 2, 5 through 9, 13 through 16 and 19 through 21, 2007; 9:00 a.m.; Tallahassee, FL; amended as to dates of hearing).
|
Jun. 12, 2007 |
Notice of Service Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories to Agency for Health Care Administration filed.
|
Jun. 12, 2007 |
Odyssey Healthcare of Northwest Florida, Inc.`s First Request for Admissions to the Agency for Health Care Administration filed.
|
Jun. 12, 2007 |
Order of Pre-hearing Instructions.
|
Jun. 12, 2007 |
Order Granting Continuance and Re-scheduling Hearing (hearing set for November 1, 2, 5 through 9, 12 through 16 and 19 through 21, 2007; 9:00 a.m.; Tallahassee, FL).
|
Jun. 11, 2007 |
Order (Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time in which to File Proposed Order of Pre-Hearing Instructions is granted).
|
Jun. 08, 2007 |
Proposed Order of Pre-hearing Instructions filed.
|
Jun. 08, 2007 |
Agreed Motion for Continuance filed.
|
Jun. 06, 2007 |
Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time in Which to File Proposed Order of Pre-Hearing Instructions filed.
|
May 30, 2007 |
Order (granting request for parties to file proposed order of prehearing instructions on or before June 3, 2007).
|
May 15, 2007 |
Response to Request for Prehearing Instructions filed.
|
May 04, 2007 |
Order of Consolidation (DOAH Case No. 07-1878CON was added to consolidated batch).
|
May 03, 2007 |
Motion for Consolidation filed.
|
Apr. 30, 2007 |
Initial Order.
|
Apr. 26, 2007 |
Petition Challenging Co-Batched Applicants filed.
|
Apr. 26, 2007 |
Notice (of Agency referral) filed.
|
Orders for Case No: 07-001878CON
Issue Date |
Document |
Summary |
Aug. 14, 2008 |
Agency Final Order
|
|
Apr. 30, 2008 |
Recommended Order
|
On balance and in this comparative review hearing, Regency proved that its proposed hospice program in AHCA Service Area 1 should be approved over the other two applicants.
|