Hershfield v. Griffith, (1874)
Court: Supreme Court of the United States
Number:
Visitors: 8
Judges: Bradley
Filed: May 18, 1874
Latest Update: Feb. 21, 2020
Summary: 85 U.S. 657 (1873) 18 Wall. 657 HERSHFIELD v. GRIFFITH. Supreme Court of United States. *658 Mr. Lyman Trumbull, for the appellant. Messrs. J. Hubley Ashton and N. Wilson, contra. Mr. Justice BRADLEY delivered the opinion of the court. The only point made in this case is, that being one of equity jurisdiction it was tried by jury as an action at law. This being so it would seem that, under the seventh article of amendments to the Constitution, it should have been removed by writ of error and not
Summary: 85 U.S. 657 (1873) 18 Wall. 657 HERSHFIELD v. GRIFFITH. Supreme Court of United States. *658 Mr. Lyman Trumbull, for the appellant. Messrs. J. Hubley Ashton and N. Wilson, contra. Mr. Justice BRADLEY delivered the opinion of the court. The only point made in this case is, that being one of equity jurisdiction it was tried by jury as an action at law. This being so it would seem that, under the seventh article of amendments to the Constitution, it should have been removed by writ of error and not ..
More
85 U.S. 657 (1873)
18 Wall. 657
HERSHFIELD
v.
GRIFFITH.
Supreme Court of United States.
Mr. Lyman Trumbull, for the appellant.
Messrs. J. Hubley Ashton and N. Wilson, contra.
Mr. Justice BRADLEY delivered the opinion of the court.
The only point made in this case is, that being one of equity jurisdiction it was tried by jury as an action at law. This being so it would seem that, under the seventh article of amendments to the Constitution, it should have been removed by writ of error and not by appeal. But that aside, we have just decided in Hornbuckle v. Toombs that equitable as well as legal relief may be pursued by the form of action prescribed by the Territorial legislature. There is no complaint that this was not done, or that substantial justice was not administered between the parties.
JUDGMENT AFFIRMED.
Dissenting, Justices CLIFFORD, DAVIS, and STRONG.
Source: CourtListener
