Elawyers Elawyers
Ohio| Change

IHS OF DANA, INC. vs AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION, 96-005436CON (1996)

Court: Division of Administrative Hearings, Florida Number: 96-005436CON Visitors: 12
Petitioner: IHS OF DANA, INC.
Respondent: AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION
Judges: DAVID M. MALONEY
Agency: Agency for Health Care Administration
Locations: Tallahassee, Florida
Filed: Nov. 15, 1996
Status: Closed
Recommended Order on Tuesday, February 17, 1998.

Latest Update: May 09, 2024

Docket for Case No: 96-005436CON
Issue Date Proceedings
Jan. 19, 1999 Agency Final Order received
Mar. 18, 1998 (R. Bruce McKibben) Notice of Appearance received.
Mar. 09, 1998 Case No/s: unconsolidated. 96-005434
Mar. 05, 1998 Final Order received.
Feb. 24, 1998 Order sent out.
Feb. 24, 1998 Order (all cases are closed) sent out.
Feb. 17, 1998 Recommended Order sent out. CASE CLOSED. Hearing held October 14, 16, 17, 22, and 23, 1997.
Jan. 12, 1998 Joint Proposed Recommended Order of Agency for Health Care Administration and Arbor Health Care Company received.
Jan. 12, 1998 Petitioner, Life Care Health Resources, Inc`s Proposed Recommended Order; Beverly Savana Cay Manor, Inc`s Proposed Recommended Order received.
Dec. 04, 1997 Order sent out. (Joint Motion for Extension of Time to file PRO`s is Granted)
Dec. 03, 1997 Joint Motion for Extension of Time to File Proposed Recommended Order received.
Nov. 20, 1997 Notice of Filing; (Volumes I-5 of 5) DOAH Court Reporter Final Hearing Transcript received.
Oct. 30, 1997 Order Closing File, CASE 96-3220 ONLY CLOSED sent out.
Oct. 30, 1997 Case No/s: unconsolidated. 96-003220
Oct. 28, 1997 Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s Notice of Voluntary Dismissal received.
Oct. 28, 1997 Case No/s: unconsolidated. 96-005433
Oct. 27, 1997 Health Care and Retirement Corporation of America`s Notice of Voluntary Dismissal received.
Oct. 20, 1997 Notice of Filing; Excerpt of Proceedings Testimony of Taffey Bisbee ; Excerpt of Proceedings Testimony of James S. Weigard received.
Oct. 15, 1997 Order Closing File Case No. 96-5431 ONLY sent out.
Oct. 15, 1997 Case No/s: unconsolidated. 96-005431
Oct. 15, 1997 Order Closing File Case No. 96-5439 ONLY sent out.
Oct. 15, 1997 Case No/s: unconsolidated. 96-005439
Oct. 14, 1997 Final Order received.
Oct. 10, 1997 American Medical Associates, Inc`s Notice of Voluntary Dismissal received.
Oct. 09, 1997 (Joint) Stipulation and Settlement Agreement received.
Oct. 08, 1997 Order sent out. (DOAH No Longer Has Jurisdiction Over the Agency`s Initial Approval of the Tri-County CON)
Oct. 07, 1997 Order sent out. (Integrated Health Services at Gainesville is no Longer Party to Case)
Oct. 06, 1997 Tri-County`s Motion to Sever Its CON Application; Supplement to Prehearing Stiuplation received.
Oct. 06, 1997 (Intervenor) Notice of Voluntary Dismissal (filed via facsimile) received.
Oct. 03, 1997 (Signed by R. McKibben, J. Jauser, J. Wharton, J. Adams, W. Watkins, R. Patterson) Prehearing Stipulation received.
Oct. 03, 1997 Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s Unopposed Motion for Postponement received.
Sep. 30, 1997 American Medical Associates, Inc`s Response to Tri-County`s Motion to Dismiss (filed via facsimile) received.
Sep. 30, 1997 Order Closing File, CASE NO 96-5700 CLOSED sent out.
Sep. 30, 1997 Case No/s: unconsolidated. 96-005700
Sep. 29, 1997 Tri-County`s Motion to Dismiss American Medical Associates, Inc. received.
Sep. 29, 1997 (Tri County) Request for Oral Argument received.
Sep. 26, 1997 (National) Notice of Voluntary Dismissal received.
Sep. 26, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Amended Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions received.
Sep. 24, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions received.
Sep. 22, 1997 Order sent out. (96-005434 severed from consolidated group; Hearing for 96-5434 set for Jan. 20-23, 1998)
Sep. 19, 1997 Tri-County Witness and Exhibit Lists received.
Sep. 18, 1997 Amended Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing to begin on 10/6/97; 10:00am; Tallahassee)
Sep. 18, 1997 (Life Care Health Resources, Inc.) Amended Joint Notice of Taking Depositions received.
Sep. 17, 1997 Agreed Upon Motion to Set Aside First Week Reserved for Hearing received.
Sep. 12, 1997 (Respondent) Response to Hernando Health Care, Inc`s Motion to Sever received.
Sep. 12, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Notice of Cancelling Telephonic Depositions received.
Sep. 11, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Motion for Order Assessing Sanctions Against Integrated Health Services of Dana, Inc. received.
Sep. 11, 1997 (Petitioner) Motion to Continue Case No. 96-5434 in the Event Motion to Sever is Granted received.
Sep. 11, 1997 Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s Notice of Voluntary Dismissal received.
Sep. 09, 1997 Response by National Healthcare L.P. to Motion to Sever by Hernando Health Care, Inc. received.
Sep. 09, 1997 Life Care Health Resources, Inc`s Response to Motion to Sever received.
Sep. 08, 1997 Joint Notice of Taking Depositions received.
Sep. 08, 1997 (Arbor Health Care Company) Response to Hernando Health Care, Inc`s Motion to Sever received.
Sep. 05, 1997 Order sent out. (Arbor Health Care Company `s Motion to Compel Response to Discovery by Integrated Health Services of Dana, Inc. is Granted)
Sep. 05, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Amended Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions; Arbor Health Care Company`s Notice Canceling Telephonic Depositions received.
Sep. 05, 1997 Hernando Health Care, Inc`s Motion to Sever received.
Sep. 04, 1997 Life Care Health Resources, Inc`s Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions received.
Sep. 03, 1997 Life Care Health Resources, Inc`s Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions received.
Aug. 28, 1997 Case No/s: unconsolidated. 97-000053
Aug. 28, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Notice of Withdrawal of Motion to Compel Against National Healthcare, L.P. received.
Aug. 26, 1997 Putnam`s Notice of Withdrawing Application and Voluntary Dismissal received.
Aug. 25, 1997 Life Care Health Resources, Inc`s Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions received.
Aug. 22, 1997 (3) Arbor Health Care Company`s Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions; Arbor Health Care Company`s Amended Notice of Taking Telephonic Deposition; received.
Aug. 21, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Notice of Taking Telephonic Deposition received.
Aug. 21, 1997 Life Care Health Resources, Inc. Amended Final Witness and Exhibit List received.
Aug. 20, 1997 Letter to DMM from Brian Doster (RE: request to forego ruling upon the pending motion to compel) received.
Aug. 20, 1997 Health Care and Retirement Corporation of America Witness and Exhibit Lists; American Medical Associates, Inc`s, Witness and Exhibit Lists received.
Aug. 19, 1997 (From J. Wharton) Notice of Service of Answers; Arbor Health Care Company`s Response to Mariner Health Care of Port Orange`s First Request for Production of Documents received.
Aug. 19, 1997 (2) Petitioner, Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s Compliance With Order of Prehearing Instructions (filed via facsimile) received.
Aug. 18, 1997 Life Care Health Resources, Inc. Final Witness and Exhibit List received.
Aug. 15, 1997 (National Healthcare, L.P. d/b/a Hernando County) Notice of Change of Address received.
Aug. 15, 1997 Respondent Arbor Health Care Company`s Disclosure of Witnesses and Documents received.
Aug. 15, 1997 Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s Exhibit List; Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s Witness List; Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s Exhibit List; Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s Witness List received.
Aug. 15, 1997 Tri-County Witness and Exhibit Lists received.
Aug. 14, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon IHS of Dana, Inc. received.
Aug. 14, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Set of Interrogatories to to National Healthcare, L.P.; Arbor Health Care Company`s Motion to Compel Response to Discovery by Integrated Health Services of Dana, Inreceivedc`d.
Aug. 14, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Motion to Compel Production of Documents and Response to Interrogatories by National Healthcare received.
Aug. 06, 1997 Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s Written Responses and Objections to Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents received.
Aug. 06, 1997 Notice of Service of Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s Answers to Arbor Health Care Company`s First Set of Interrogatories received.
Aug. 06, 1997 Notice of Service of Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s Answers to Arbor Health Care Company`s First Set of Interrogatories received.
Aug. 06, 1997 Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s Written Responses and Objections to Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents received.
Aug. 05, 1997 Putnam`s Second Request for Production of Documents to Arbor received.
Aug. 01, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents Upon National Healthcare, L.P. received.
Aug. 01, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents Upon Hernando Healthcare, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents Upon Beverly Savana Cay Manor, Inc. received.
Aug. 01, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents Upon Unicare Health Facilities, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents Upon Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc. received.
Aug. 01, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents Upon IHS of Dana, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents Upon Health Care and Retirement Corporation of America received.
Aug. 01, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents Upon Putnam Hospital, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s Third Request for Production of Documents Upon Life Care Health Resources, Inc. received.
Jul. 23, 1997 Amended Notice of Hearing As to Dates sent out. (hearing set for 9/29/97; 10:00am; Tallahassee; There will be no hearing on 10/3/97)
Jun. 16, 1997 Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s Response to Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s Second Request for Production of Documents received.
Jun. 16, 1997 Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s Answers to Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Set of Interrogatories received.
Jun. 16, 1997 Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s Response to Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents received.
Jun. 06, 1997 (American Medical Associates, Inc.) Response to First Request for Production of Documents by Integrated Health Services; Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories received.
May 21, 1997 Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s Response to Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents received.
May 21, 1997 Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s Answers to Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Set of Interrogatories received.
May 08, 1997 (AMA) Response to Second Request for Production of Documents received.
May 05, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s Second Request for Production of Documents to Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc. received.
May 01, 1997 Letter to DMM from Sheila Ross (RE: request for subpoenas) received.
Apr. 28, 1997 Life Care Health Resources, Inc`s Response and Objections to Arbor`s Second Request for Production of Documents received.
Apr. 21, 1997 Letter to DMM from J. Hauser Re: Date for filing witness and exhibit lists received.
Apr. 07, 1997 Hernando Healthcare, Inc`s Response and Objections to Arbor Health Care Company`s First Set of Interrogatories received.
Apr. 07, 1997 Hernando Healthcare, Inc`s Response and Objections to Arbor Health Care Company`s Request for Production received.
Apr. 07, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents to Unicare Health Facilities, Inc. received.
Apr. 07, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s Notice of Service of Interrogatories to Unicare Health Facilities, Inc. received.
Apr. 04, 1997 Putnam`s Exhibit and Witness List received.
Apr. 03, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc.,`s Notice of Service of First Set of Interrogatories to Arbor Health Care Company received.
Apr. 03, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents to Arbor Health Care Company received.
Apr. 03, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents to American Medical Associates, Inc received
Apr. 03, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s Notice of Service of First Set of Interrogatories to American Medical Associates, Inc. received.
Apr. 03, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents to Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc. received.
Apr. 03, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc.,`s Notice of Service of First Set of Interrogatories to Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc. received.
Apr. 03, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s Notice of Service of First Set of Interrogatories to Beverly Savana Cay Manor, Inc. received.
Apr. 03, 1997 Integrated Health Services at Gainesville, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents to Beverly Savana Cay Manor, Inc. received.
Apr. 02, 1997 Order Continuing and Rescheduling Formal Hearing sent out. (hearing rescheduled for Sept. 29 - Oct. 24, 1997; 10:00am; Tallahassee)
Apr. 01, 1997 (Respondent) Notice of Hearing received.
Mar. 28, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents upon Life Care Health Resources, Inc. received.
Mar. 28, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Second Request for Production of Documents upon American Medical Associate, Inc. received.
Mar. 25, 1997 (From A. Clark) Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories; Response to First Request for Production of Documents received.
Mar. 21, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Health Care and Retirement Corporation of America received.
Mar. 21, 1997 (From J. Wharton) Notice of Service of Interrogatories received.
Mar. 18, 1997 (From G. Sternstein) Notice of Service of Interrogatories received.
Mar. 17, 1997 Unicare Health Facilities, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Arbor Health Care Company; Notice of Service of First Set of Interrogatories received.
Mar. 17, 1997 (Petitioner) Notice of Service of First Set of Interrogatories; Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Arbor Health Care Company received.
Mar. 10, 1997 Putnam`s Notice of Service of Interrogatories to Arbor; Putnam`s First Request for Production of Documents to Arbor received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon American Medical Associates, Inc. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Beverly Savana Cay Manor, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Life Care Health Resources, Inc. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon IHS of Dana, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Health Facilities, Inc. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Putnam Hospital, Inc. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 (John Wharton) Notice of Service of Interrogatories; Arbor Health Care company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon National Healthcare, L.P. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Hernando Healthcare, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Vantage Healthcare Corporation received.
Mar. 07, 1997 (John Wharton) 10/Notice of Service of Interrogatories; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Unicare Health Facilities, Inc received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Mariner Health Care of Port Orange, Inc. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Unicare Health Facilities, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Hernando Healthcare, Inc. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Notice of Service of Interrogatories (11 sets); Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents upon IHS of Dana, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents upon Putnam Hospital, Inc. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Request for Production of Documents Upon Vantage Healthcare Corporation; Arbor Health Care Company`s Request for Production of Documents Upon National Healthcare, L.P. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon American Medical Association, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Beverly Savana Cay Manor, Inc. received.
Mar. 07, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Health Facilities, Inc.; Arbor Health Care Company`s First Request for Production of Documents Upon Health Resources, Inc. received.
Mar. 06, 1997 Notice of Joinder in Arbor Health Care Company`s Motion for Continuance, Notice of Conflict received.
Mar. 04, 1997 Putnam`s Response Opposing Arbor`s Motion for Continuance received.
Mar. 03, 1997 (James Hauser) Notice of Appearance received.
Mar. 03, 1997 Written Opposition to Arbor`s Motion for Continuance Filed By Health Facilities, Inc. d/b/a Tri-County Nursing Home; (Tri-County) Request for Oral Argument received.
Feb. 28, 1997 Letter to DMM from Mitchell Friedman (RE: opposed to continuance) received.
Feb. 27, 1997 Response to Correspondence of Tri-County Nursing Home received.
Feb. 20, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Motion to Continue and Reschedule Formal Hearing received.
Feb. 13, 1997 Order of Consolidation sent out. (Consolidated cases are: 96-3220, 96-3221, 96-5431 through 96-5440, 96-5700, 97-0052 & 97-0053)
Feb. 04, 1997 Order sent out. (motions for continuance are denied)
Jan. 29, 1997 Putnam`s Response Opposing NHC`s Motion for Continuance received.
Jan. 28, 1997 Arbor Health Care Company`s Response to National Healthcare, L.P.`s Motion for Continuance received.
Jan. 28, 1997 (Respondent) Notice of Substitution of Counsel In Case No. 96-5431 Through 96-5440 and 96-5700 received.
Jan. 21, 1997 National Healthcare, L. P.`s Motion for Continuance and Request for Hearing to Reset Final Hearing Date received.
Jan. 02, 1997 (AHCA) Notice of Related Petitions received. (for 96-3220, 96-3221, 96-5431 through 96-5440, 96-5700, 97-0052 & 96-0053)
Dec. 31, 1996 Order Continuing and Rescheduling Formal Hearing sent out. (hearing reset for May 19 - June 13, 1997; 10:00am; Tallahassee)
Dec. 24, 1996 National Healthcare, L.P.`s Response In Support of Motion for Continuance received.
Dec. 20, 1996 Putnam`s Response to Motion for Continuance (filed via facsimile) received.
Dec. 17, 1996 (Petitioner) Motion for Continuance received.
Dec. 16, 1996 Amended Order of Consolidation sent out. (for 96-3220, 96-3221, 96-5431 through 96-5440 and 96-5700)
Dec. 13, 1996 Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for Jan. 13 - Feb. 7, 1997; 10:00am; Tallahassee)
Dec. 13, 1996 Order of Consolidation sent out. (Consolidated cases are: 96-3220, 96-3221, 96-5431, 96-5432, 96-5433, 96-5434, 96-5435, 96-5436, 96-5437,96-5438, 96-5439, 96-5440 & 96-5700)
Nov. 21, 1996 Prehearing Order and Order of Consolidation sent out. (Consolidated cases are: 96-3220, 96-3221, 96-5431 through 96-5440)
Nov. 20, 1996 Notification card sent out.
Nov. 15, 1996 Notice of Related Petitions (96-3220, 96-3221 and 96-5431 through 96-5440); Notice; Petition for Formal Administrative Hearing received.
Apr. 08, 1996 National Healthcare, L.P.`s Response to Request to Produce by Arbor Health Care Company received.
Apr. 07, 1996 Hernando Healthcare, Inc`s Response and Objections to Arbor Health Care Company`s Request for Production received.
Apr. 07, 1996 Hernando Healthcare, Inc`s Response and Objections to Arbor Health Care Company`s First Set of Interrogatories received.
Hernando Healthcare, Inc`s Response and Objections to Arbor Health Care Company`s First Set of Interrogatories received.
Final Order received.
Hernando Healthcare, Inc`s Response and Objections to Arbor Health Care Company`s Request for Production received.
Life Care Health Resources, Inc`s Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions received.
Life Care Health Resources, Inc`s Notice of Taking Telephonic Depositions received.
Tri-County Witness and Exhibit Lists received.
Source:  Florida - Division of Administrative Hearings

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.
Ask a Question
Search for lawyers by practice areas.
Find a Lawyer