Petitioner: AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION
Respondent: THE HEALTH CENTER OF DAYTONA BEACH, INC.
Judges: ELLA JANE P. DAVIS
Agency: Agency for Health Care Administration
Locations: Daytona Beach, Florida
Filed: Jul. 20, 2006
Status: Closed
Settled and/or Dismissed prior to entry of RO/FO on Monday, August 28, 2006.
Latest Update: Nov. 17, 2024
- ft
ffeme
STATE OF FLORIDA 06 JU 20 p ~
AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION bn Py 4, 3
ADI; jslou 9
Hels nf Or
STATE OF FLO RIDA, AGENCY FOR
HEALTH CARE ADMINISTRATION,
Petitioner, a) (n° Iu U ae
vs. Case No. 2006004885
CERTIFIED MAIL #
THE HEALTH CENTER OF DAYTONA 7004 1160 0003 3739 1874
BEACH, INC.,
Respondent.
/
ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT
Petitioner, the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration (“AHCA”),
through undersigned counsel, files this Administrative Complaint against the above-named
Respondent (‘Respondent’) pursuant to Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes (2005),
and alleges:
NATURE OF THE ACTION
1. This is an action to impose an administrative fine in the amount of $1 9,655.00 (the
“fine amount”) against Respondent, pursuant to Section 408.040, Florida Statutes, and Florida
Administrative Code Rules 59C-1.013 and 59C-1.021.
2. For the calendar year 2005 (the “‘calendar year”), Respondent failed to comply
with the Medicaid condition upon its Certificate of Need (“CON”), a copy of which is attached
to this complaint as Exhibit A.
‘Unless otherwise noted, all statutes and rules hereinafier cited are to the indicated year’s
version of the stattate or rule because this is the controlling year in question.
Page 1 of 9
JURISDICTION AND VENUE
3. This tribunal has jurisdiction over Respondent, pursuant to Sections 120.569 and
120.57. Florida Statutes, and also Sections 408.031- 408.045, Florida’s ““Heailth Facility and
Services Development Act.”
4. Veraue is determined by Florida Administrative Code Rule 28-106.207.
PARTIES
5. Pursuant to Chapier 408, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 59C-1, Florida
Administrative Code, AHCA is the licensing and enforcing authority with regard to
community nursing home Jaws and rules.
6. Respondent is a corporation authorized under the laws of Florida to do business.
Respondent op erates a community nursing home located at 550 National Healthcare Drive,
Daytona Beach. Florida 32114 and is the licensee on the CON issued on October 14, 2004,
for the addition Of 60 community skilled nursing beds to the existing 60-bed Nursing
Home, with the Condition that a minimum of 35% of its 120-bed facility’s total annual
patient days shall be provided to Medicaid patients. The CON number is 9406; a copy of
the CON is attached to this complaint as Exhibit A.
COUNTI
Respondent failed to meet its Medicaid condition
Section 408.040, Florida Statutes
Florida Administrative Code Rule 59C-1.013
Florida Administrative Code Rule 59C-1.021
1. AHCA re-alleges paragraphs 1-6 above.
8. Respondent failed to comply with its Medicaid condition as reported to the
Agency in its Florida Nursing Home Utilization Report for the year 2005, a copy of which
Page 2 of 9
is attached to this Complaint as Exhibit B, and its facility report, a copy of which isatlached
to this complaint aS Exhibit C.
9. Respondent failed to comply with the condition set forth inits COIN, as required by
Section 408.040, Florida Statutes, and Rule S9C-1.013, Florida Administrative Code, which
provide, in part, aS follows:
408.040 Conditions and monitoring
(a) The agency may issue a certificate of need, or an exemption, predicated upon statements
of intent expressed by an applicant in the application for a certificate of need. Any conditions
imposed on & certificate of need or an exemption based on such statements of intent shall be stated on
the face of the certificate of need or in the exernption approval.
(b) The agency may consider, in addition to the other criteria specified ins. 408.035, a statement
of intent by the applicant that a specified percentage of the annual patient days at the facility will be
utilized by patients eligible for care under Title XIX of the Social Security Act. Any cerlificate of
need issued tO 4 nursing home in reliance upon an applicant's statements that a specified percentage
of annua] patient days will be utilized by residents eligible for care under Title XIX of the Social
Security Act must include a statement that such certification is a condition of issuance of the
certificate of need. The certificate-of-need program shall notify the Medicaid program office and the
Department of Elderly Affairs when it imposes conditions as authorized in this Paragraph in an area
in which a co7MMunity diversion pilot project is implemented.
()A certificate holder or an exemption holder may apply to the agency for a modification of
conditions izxzposed under paragraph (a) or paragraph (b). If the holder of acertificate of need or an
exemption demonstrates good cause why the certificate or exemption should be rnodified, the agency
shall reissue the certificate of need or exemption with such modifications as may be appropriate. The
agency shall by rule define the factors constituting good cause for modification.
(a) If the holder ofa certificate of need or an exemption fails to comply with a condition
upon which the issuance of the certificate or exemption was predicated, the azency May assess
an administrative fine against the certificate holder in an amount not to exceed $ 1,000 per failure
per day. Failure to annually report compliance with any condition upon which the issuance of the
certificate or ©Xemption was predicated constitutes noncompliance. In assessing the Penalty, the
agency shall take into account as mitigation the degree of noncompliance. Proceeds of such
penalties shall be deposited in the Public Medicaid Assistance Trust Fund.
th ok ok
59C-1.013 Monitoring Procedures
(4) Reporting Requirements Subsequent to Licensure or Commencement of Services, All holders
of a certificate of need that was issued predicated upon conditions expressecl on the face of the
certificate of need shall provide annual compliance reports to the agency, The reporting period shal]
be January 1 through December 31 of each year. The holder of a certificate Of need who began
operation after January 1 will Teport from the date operation began through December 31. The
compliance TePOTt shall be submitted no later than April 1 of the subsequent year.
(a) The compliance report will comtain information necessary for an assessment of compliance
with conditions on the certificate of need, utilizing measures, such as a percentage of patient days,
that are consistent with the siaied condition. The following information shal] be Provided in the
holder's annual compliance report: 1. The time period covered by the measures; 2. The measure for
assessing compliance with each of the conditions identified and described on the face of the
certificate of need; 3. The way in which the conditions were evaluated by applying the measures; 4.
The data sources used to generate information abowt the conditions that were measured: 5. The
person and position responsible for supplying the compliance report: 6. Ary other information
necessary for the agency to determine compliance with conditions: and 7, applicable, the reason or
reasons, with supporting data, why the certificate of need holder was unable to meet the conditions
set forth an tkae face of the Certificate of need.
(b) A change in the licensee for a facility or service does not affect the obligation for that facility
or service tO comtime to meel conditions imposed on a certificate of need and to provide annual
condition cOT21Pliance reports.
(c) ConClitions imposed on a certificate of need may be modified consistent with Rule 59C-
1.019, F.A-C- .
(5) Violation of Certificate of Need Conditions. Health care providers found by the agency to be
in noncompliance with conditions set forth in their certificate of need shall be fined as defined in
Rule 39C-1-021, FAC.
10. The foregoing violation warrants imposition of the above-mentioned fine
amount pursuant to Florida Administrative Code Rule 59C-].021, which provides, in
part:
59C-1-021 Penalties.
(a) General Provisions. The agency shall initiate administrative proceedings for revocation of a
certificate of need for violation of paragraphs 408.040(2)(a) and (b), F.S., or the assessment of
administrativ ©] fines for failure to comply with conditions placed on a certificate of need as specified
snder Rule SOC-1.013, F.A.C
ae ook
G3) penalties for Failure to Comply with Certificate of Need Conditions. The agency shall review
the annual] co7Mpliance report submitted by the health care providers who are licensed and operate the
facilities or SETVICES and other pertinent data to assess compliance with certificate of need conditions.
Providers who are not in compliance with certificate of need conditions shall be fined. For
community DUrsing homes or hospital-based skilled nursing units certified as such by Medicare, the
first compliarace Teport on the status of conditions must be submitied 30 calendar days following the
eighteenth month of operation or the first month where an 85 percent occupancy is achieved,
whichever comes first. The schedule of fines is as follows:
(a) Facilities failing to comply with any conditions set forth on the Certificate of Need will be
assessed a fitz€, not to exceed $1,000 per failure per day. In assessing the penalty the agency shall
take into account the degree of noncompliance. -
(b) The assessed fine shall be paid to the agency within 45 calendar days after written
notification of assessment by certified mail or within 30 calendar days after final agency action if an
administrative hearing has been requested. If a health care provider desires it may remit payment
according t0 4 payment schedule accepted by the agency. The health care provider must submit the
schedule of Payments to the agency within 30 calendar days after the date of receipt of the
notification of assessment or 2] calendar days after fina] agency action. The final balance will be due
no later than G months after the health care provider has been notified in writing by the agency of the
amount of the assessed fine or 6 months afier final agency action.
11. AHCA, i determining the penalty imposed, considered the degree of noncomphance.
WHEREFORE, AHCA demands the following relief: (1) enter factual and legal
findings as set forth in this Count; (2) impose the above-mentioned fine amount for the
violation: and (3) 1Mpose such other relief as this tribunal] may find appropriate.
Page 4 of 9
@ @
NOTICE
RESPONSZCENT is hereby notified that it has a right to request an administrative
hearing pursuant to Section 120.569, Florida Statutes. Specific options for administrative
caring m set out ain the attached Election of Rights (one page) and explained in the attached
aa tion of Risghts (one page). All requests for hearing shall be made to the Agency for
eth Care Admixustration and delivered to the Agency for Health Care Administration, 2727
Mahan Dr., Bldg- 3, MS #3, Tallahassee, Florida, 32308; Attention: Agency Clerk.
RESPONIPENT IS FURTHER NOTIFIED THAT IF THE REQUEST FOR
WEARING IS NOT RECEIVED BY THE AGENCY FOR HEALTH CARE
ADMINISTRATION WITHIN TWENTY-ONE (21) DAYS OF RECEIPT OF THIS
‘ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT, A FINAL ORDER WILL BE ENTERED.
Submitted as Of the date indicated on the below Certificate of Service.
———
Donna La Plante, Semor Attorney
Fla. Bar No. 0966193
Agency for Health Care Administration
2727 Mahan Drive, Bldg. 3, MS #3
Tallahassee, Florida 32308
Phone: (850) 922-5873
Fax: (850) 921-0158 or 413-9313
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
1HEREBY CERTIFY that a copy of the original Administrative Complaint,
Explanation of Rights form, and Election of Rights form have been sent by U.S. Certified Mail,
Return Receipt Requested (receipt # 7004 1160 0003 3739 1874) to Respondent, Atiention:
Administrator, at National Health Center of Daytona Beach, Inc., 550 National Healthcare
Drive, Daytona Beach, Florida 32114 on thi CHE of ine 2006.
4 Z ae
Donna £4 Planie, Senior Attorney
Q f
EXPLANATION OF RIGHTS oy Lom,
UNDER SEC. 120.569, FILORIDA STATUTES <0 a
(To be used with the attached Election of Rights form) 40g Pye, Ms .
Mel Oy “Po
. : OF 0.
In respons] to the allegations set forth in the Administrative Complaint Ba eat e
Agency for Healtka Care Administration (“AHCA” or “Agency”), Respondent must male ‘ode
of the following elections within twenty-one (21) days from the date of receipt of the .
Administrative Complaint and your Election of Rights in this matter must be received by
AHCA within twenty-one (21) days from the date you receive the Administrative Complaint.
Please make your election on the attached Election of Rights form and return it fully executed
to the address liste
UI QOE’996' 1S saajoaut yaloid ayy, ‘Yyoeag
euo}feq Jo TayUaD WTeaEY paq-y9 Buyspa arp 0} spaq Bursinu paypys Aypmunusod yg ppy :NOLLANMOSAC Loafowad
¥ -sLORLLSIGans y *DORLLSIC BisnjoA = ‘ALNNOD
‘TVG NOLLVNIAMAL GSSIATN
One
"700% ‘Zz equiajdag” aly NOLLVNIWWAL OLIZE VssauuaL, ‘omassayzinyyy
100z ‘Ez PEP “LVGANSSI yaaqs adayjoD 89M T2h
006’0c’e$ *LSO0 Loaloud ‘Duy ‘yaeag euopsec] jo JaquaD yeep ayy
“ENVOI'Idd¥
906 NGAON ©
(0/FL/01) Yonesytpoyy uoHTpuoD, :
‘paford spp ios paau aig saypia> uopeRstuppy azeD wpyeazy 10; AouaSy
ang ‘@poD aanensrmpy eprops ‘T-D¢6g reydeyD GN ‘(2661 ddng) saynyeyg epyoy ‘GpO-LE0'80F
su0y238) Joy Juaudojaaagq sadtarag pue Ape, yypeazy,, dy} Jo suoistaoid ary apup
Ye (YAN JO ALVOELLSS
&.
Ay by fiery
“0 3 ost fa
wy %, a oy by
“a NOLLVALLSININGY IVS HILIVaH WOA ADNADV
VaMOTs 40 ALVIS
Se ee
reat
ae seen
SS
enon wa,
Florida Nursin ig Fome Utilization
by District and Subdistrict
Ea
January 2005 ~- December 2005.
ee pe athena nite nee anny neato nt snerpemmntete nme carety en on
Beth, ee
srreratesehi tere patna roiy EO TT ERTIES pe
FLORIDA AGENCY FOR HEAITHT CAR
Agency For it Hee
mn Levine
ary
pe.
90/L0/) VOHV
Onl
if
Soot ‘Te MAAN - soot ‘T AMYONVE
STVLOL TYONNY
Oe eae)
(Gvieeuy
ve =
SO/TI-SO/10 STVLOL ATHALU VO
SAY Cia
YWEO'9S Y87'L6 ral ral
AOs sh L86¥1 Avs og SLO6E G06IzZ uo ao WIA JoyUsT ©)
BETTE BLGEL “WEV'GB. e8SaL OusIt ov oo 1 sua An
YEO ro — bS PEL ASESG LOE 00612 oD i) P| youd vuapdug ju vou]
MLGBS PLIGE WOL6R = ClPCE SELIE 6b 66 Jyjuary ZusInN puuayepurg
WOVE = 62691 %SBR9 = 60Z0F OOPES Oui OYI Jy puu du
ALLER TPCLT “S668 96EGE O08EP zl 02] OY puu Tursanyy BULA) Wo
YOCOS OlZ0l “826 veZOZ 00612 i) a) Hquyay sau y vy)
esas D0She YH EG colle OOSEP OUsOL vel Ozi
@: isp8t “z9SG EB8lP oOgeP 60801 oti ral
“obEI9 S8S19£ NLELI = SPGRS SEZLB OlS1Z ole GE 4a}Ua Loney yeyoY a duisanyy aval weaoy
WSs e168z YWIEOR = LEPSE OfSbr O860L eal taal puE Taq JG vapared) puungeg
YopR tL POLSE Y%OO68 Gbelz SZLEZ usgys Bs sy HL 90. YUO
%pLs9 7OS9E WLLSL yeves 08004 os7zi |0 261 to Lgady) DY) HO JuU}y
YCvGl CBRE WIZ SL66l 00617 ours foe 9 ost AMD aMuwIG - 1ojU9,) eotpayy VdUyLLA Kou UYyOY
EITI OBLIE —OLIG LPELS SPT ED Meese tres: ucsst JO LLL ce sour) Uap
“ESI9 9OSLL” %SEZG PIE? — 0990E sis py, = use 0 ay ve muujdug] Je sOpudT BawoYy UD | NUZLIOF
(vo/tr posofa) tayttar) Ul
YONLE 7GE9 YICLY SLZEZ oh99Z OILY aso = 0 pea te ou “Youay BuOHAEC] JOO) qeaPL YL]
ME GL C6862 YWesSS KLOLE OOREP OPOr vost jo uZl 2 tojuaZ & 826
YIOEL ESLPL “KEP'GG 1966L S002 90s osépy = |S gs oy Jud) HOWDY UEsAY UY] ¥PLIO a)
. 0 0 Oz = [papnyexs) “Loge HN Suusayo, [eLotUopy youd "| Aousy plai
%OGOL BLS6Z WezsG Lidly OO8Er Ovol oosoL jo ue vZi DED yyw eUOYDg «OEY
%lp'99 62492 *WOIG Lecop OOBEY Ovolt oesel fo vz ira sourjy Gegoq, pp
YLSSL TORRE *K9'SL gPEIS 00LS9 09st ooz91 fo Os! os Joya.) MUIJEY YE DY PUL UTEP] YouG LUoMeC] — OLE
MHZEGS TEPC YSOSG ROP O0sEr 5 Se OPOLT FOL oosol |o oz ir Qeumbyy — yg
O8'BS 9P6EZ %68'%6 9890F — OOEP eee OPOLL OPO! vosel fol Ge o£ Ajununuy:) 220 gst
lope pOORE WIL0G 1209 SELOS ae ggyzi BRLZI olszt jo ot 6f1 su
%LESE — EObL YStv6 1~902 «00612 ozss ess vors = fu i) iy) Sto
“DEER LILB1 S068 TECep = SPSeP 9EtZ1 © 9ECZ Zl. 0Lel! |o fcl cc cry
uISUTU A,
. 7 Ta a HYD PUL YYUILE SY pues EC
ous OpltzZ *eeS6 LOGI «= ONREY OPOTT Oost 10 Ue Ue HsqEY TY PUL LY wo! eo et a
MAIZE 18562 WOE HOP . OOREF Opoil 02601 00801 {0 vay ray saan ele
Pp PL YSIPYS
. -|
: 7 ; Aye je awe ‘a
lana00 SAVG dilo00 SAVd SAVd |IVLOL. O7a dds yess eli: med joowen
CIVDIN GIVI TVLOL INSILYd aad ‘ow9 «6-100 - TA ‘OW UY NYE spd P YT
[eau ee eanmw taninajaad cans Lpenuury
EALTH
ENTER
®
‘AYTONA BEAGH ©
VIA: 2™ Day Mail
March 27, 2006 pe be
Mr. Jeffery N. Gregg, Chief
Agency for Health Care Administration
Certificate of Need Office
Fort Knox Executive Center Le.
2727 Mahan Drive, Building Three Gk MAR 29 2006
Tallahassee, Fl. 32308 poe semen PEGE OF
6! e - GREGG, CHEE
PIEALT ERR
Re: The Health Center of Daytona Beach eae
FASHITYy REGULATION NY
CON #7299, Condition Compliance
Dear Mr. Gregg:
Please accept the following report as an assessment of compliance for the
referenced Certificate of Need condition, 35 percent of total annual patient days
shall be allocated to Medicaid patients, placed on the referenced CON.
If you have any additional questions and/or require additional information, please
do not hesitate to call 615-217-2324.
Sincerely,
The Health Center of Daytona Beach, Inc.
a
Steve A. Strawn
Director, Authorized Representative for the License Holder
Enclosure
THE HEALTH CENTER OF DAYTONA BEACH
CERTIFICATE OF NEED #7299
ASSESSMENT OF COMPLIANCE
The time period cow ered by the measures;
Please see attached typed summary chart (Exhibit A) for the time petiod covered. (Column A)
The measure for assessing compliance of the conditions identified and described:
The measure for assessing compliance of the condition identified is percent Medicaid of total
patient days, The formula is as follows:
Medicaid Total Days
% Medicaid of Total Patient Days = wwe nw neem n ee nc rune e
Total Patient Days
Corresponds to Summary Chart
Column A= Time Period Covered
Column B = Medicaid Total Days
Column C =Total Patient Days
Column D = % Medicaid of Total Patient Days
27.66% = 6,439
23,278
Conditioned jo be at minimum of 35% Medicaid of Total Patient Days
Actual percentage of Medicaid Days to Total Patient Days is 27.66%, which is les tham the
required 35%. the referenced CON is therefore in not in compliance with the measure Im the
strictest sense, but is in technical compliance with the spirit and inient of the condition. Please
see response to Question Nine.
The way in which the conditions were evaluated by applying the measures;
If the percent Medicaid of Total Patient Days is equal to or greater than the measure for
assessing compliance of the condition (see Question 2 for method), then compliancehas been
met. Please see attached Exhibit A.
Data was taken from @ computer generated sheet (Exhibit B) which are attached hereto, and
placed on the attached summary char. Two fine items, with headings Medicaid SNF and
Medicaid NF, were totaled together and are found on the separate summary chai (Exhibit A)
under the title MEDICAID PATIENT DAYS, per month. The date found under the char tile TOTAL
PATIENT DAYS (Exhibit A) can be found under the heading TOTAL DAYS on a monthly basis.
The acival data sources used to generate the information on the conditions that were
measured; .
Please see the attached computer generated data tables (Exhibit 8). Rows titled Medicaicdl SNF,
Medicaid NF and TOTAL DAYS have been summarized on a chart by month, and follow the
method sfated in Question 2 to report compliance.
The source of the data for the measure;
The Health Center of Daytona Beach, Inc., lessee and/or management entity of the reflerern ced
CON, internal report entitled "Census Summary of Patient Days" prepared by the facility
bookkeeper on a Monthly basis as part of a financial report which is patient specific. Data
recorded is based On revenue as patients are approved by payor source. Some revenue ray
be retroactive.
The reasonableness Of the measures and the confidence in the measures;
The measure is both reasonable and one which allows confidence in assessing compliaance
with the assigned condition. As can be seen from Question two (2), the measure is a
straightforward ratio of Medicaid Total Days to Total Patient Days. We are confident thatthis is a-
reasonable way to evaluate Percent Medicaid of Total Patient Days. .
Checks and balances are that payment is received on the turnaround documents and claim
forms. Data is done On 4 case by case basis. Hospital Cost Containment Reports are pepaared
off these reports. The report used also maiches our Medicaid and Medicare reports. Therefore
we feel the data is reasonable and accurate and one in which the confidence level is
extremely high.
The person and position responsible for defining the measures and supplying the compliance
report;
Steven A. Strawn, Direcior for The Health Center of Dayiona Beach, Inc., and the Authorized
Representative for the referenced license and Certificate of Need holder.
Any other information Necessary to determine compliance with conditions; and, None
If applicable, the reason or reasons, with supporting data, why the certificate of need holder
was unable to meet the conditions set forih on ihe face of the certificate of need.
The Health Center of Daytona Beach does not discriminate against patients on any goounds
including and not limited to payor source. The center works closely withthe area hospitals and
physicians to accommodate all referrals hey may have. Because of our high censusancdl our
limited number of beds (60) with 13 additional beds added 3/14/03, we frequently do not have
bed availability for patients regardless of payor source. However, we do work wih area
discharges planners jo assist them when they hove patients to place regardless of our
vacancies. The center has a higher than average Medicare and managed care census due to
the faci that it was the only Blue Cross provider on the eastside of the county, and stillis only
one of several options currently available. Our center had over 44.8% of our patients being
reimbursed by Medicare and managed care in 2005. Our facility is also the only five star
clinically based center in the eastern par of the county. In addition, the center ako offers
patients both in and out patient rehab services, which is very attractive to patients and tarnilies
seeking a nursing home bed. Because the majority of our patients come from hospitals, and
the majority of thos¢ admissions are Medicare patients, and given the fact that center must
treat Medicare as the primary payor source according to state Jaw, the center really has little
control of admissio™5- In addition, the center average length of stay is such that patients can
be discharged to less costly levels of care, before billing Medicaid. Please note that according
to the latest Florida’ Nursing Home Utilization by District and Subdistrict, July 2004 to June 20085,
p.73, the occupanc ¥ rate in District/Sub district. 4/4 was 87.95% compared to our centers 89.52%
occupancy rate. Based on licensed community beds of 3,394 and the average census of
87.95%, an average of 2,985 beds were occupied on any given day. Consequently, that
means that 409 beds were also unoccupied in the subdistrict during the same period of inne on
any given day. Clearly, for calendar year 2005, access to nursing home beds was notan issue
for this subdistrict. 117 addition, the east Volusia occupancy rates, in which the centerls located,
has an even lower occupancy rate average than the Subdistrict. Please keep in mind that in
addition to the hospital closing its skilled units within the last several reporting periods, Mariner
Health Care of peland and Holiday Care Center (inactive) closed in 2002 representing 240
beds. In addition, Emory L. Bennett Memorial Veterans NH of Florida, a 120 bed facility for
veterans has been excluded from the referenced numbers.
As the agency states in its publication entitled Florida Nursing Home Bed Need Projections by
District and Subdistrict, 10/07/05, “The. Legislature finds that the continued growth in the
Medicaid budget for nursing home care has constrained the ability of the state fo meet the
needs of its elderly residents through the use of less restrictive and less institutional methocis of
long-term care. it is therefore the intent of the Legislature to limit the increase In Medicaid
nursing home expenditures in order fo provide funds to invest in long-term care that is
community-based and provides supportive services in a manner that is both more cost-
effective and more In keeping with the wishes of the elderly residents of this state."(p.3, AHCA
FL Nursing Home Utilization, July 2004 - June 2005).
In summary, patient admissions are based on need and not payor source. Given that fact and
the clear Legislative directive to reduce reliance on nursing homes and suppor community
based services, it would seem the current state of census utilization would seem encouraging to
the agency. If access to a nursing home bed was truly an issue, you would not expect to see
two centers or 240 beds closing within the last several years in Volusia County. Furthermore, the
inability to serve Medicaid patients in the nursing home setting due to lack of demand allows
Medicaid budget dollars to be used in a fashion more in concer with current legislative
direction.
Lastly, this facility is located in a County which is part of the State of Florida, Department of Elcier
Affairs, Long-Term care Community Diversion Program. “The objective isto provide frail elderly
with safe, appropriate community based care alternatives in lieu of nursing home placement at
a cost less than Medicaid nursing home care.” (Department of Elder Affairs website) The CARES
unit at the Department of Elderly Affair determines the individuals that meet the criteria’ to
receive services. This program by its very nature, is designed to reduce the number of
admissions and therefore, patient days that nursing centers might have previously provided.
Please see attached documentation about the Long-Term Care Community Diversion Frogram.
Ifthe agency requires any additional information or support as to why the cénter has not met its
condition, please d° not hesitate to contact The Health Center of Daytona Beach, Inc.as we
would be glad to provide any backup available to document our operations and compliance
efforts.
—o I}
‘THE HEALTH CENTER OF DAYTONA BEACH
FISCAL YEAR 12/31/05
% OF
MEDICAID TOTAL MEDICAID
MONTH PATIENT DAYS — PATIENT DAYS PATIENT DAYS
sanuery 559 2,081 26.86
February 523 1,815 28,82
March 548 °41,911 28.68
April 486 1,902 25.55
May 528 1,854 28.48
June 456 1,828 24.95
July 614 1,876 27.40
August 536 2,055 26.08
September 565 1,880 30,05
October — 610 2,049 29.77
November 554 2,01 4 27,55
560 2,016 27.78
December ;
TOTAL 6,439 23,278 27.66
BLZEZ
aba
“se
EL
i
dad
eh
EL
-AON
6bOz zOz@eT
o @
6bae 20eLT
Otg BaLb
a a
656 OTSB
sa 06s
a ov
98 abe
oO a
0 Li
Qo Zz
g0E BaRE
[4]
{8 y (be
(Of =) (oez
t ge
TE Ooze
B93
EL
a
eL
$-390 © qqUOW
6
) (az)
E .
sf
Lz]
EL
Q
ek
§ -das
3281 TéETT
0 0
9L8T T6ETT
eTs faoe
[*) L
£16 6245
68 TEE
a ob
69 PRS
o 0
a ras
a z
4az BzaT
as
(eT) (ur
(82) (86T
Ss bz
TE Btz
eg
EL
a
EL
S$ -Ime = yquOW
3
(BE )
L
Cram
a9
EL
a
eh
§ -AeH
eu6T 20es
u u
zu6L cues
gue £29T
0 L
bes vaee
va sat
tr 6z
OI Loe
0 0
0 et
z@ 0
Sez sye
(SE } (e0T
5 a
Sb aot
Ez)
EL
a
EL
§ -2dy yauon
: £
ar
13
ft
oO
fe
§ -1eW
3
~qad
OSE
fe
E
SaAvd Wiud
OdN
dng
hyaed yOUPIstY
AN preotpay
ANS PTeotpay
W J2eg alvotpay
a2e) pabeury
@leDTIL
aotdsoy
aouRI SUT
BY) pTea Aprueg
Da you) predazg
ayeataa
isaaines quawdeg
tgasuag pu:
\PIOu/ow reqsuers,
]
sabireyosta
PToy/om suznqay
suoytss tupy
tansuap Say
TeaoL
aan
Ans
iqaag Aq Aypoudeo pow
-uep
YDRBq euOZAUG JO 1BQUTD YILHSLL BLL LuBZy tayuaD
1 VOHV
rasta
OGLE "ST: HORE NEG
AOS'LS 99PPZ WST'LG ISSth o0REP :
AETOR LEZST %R9°9R EBERLE o06iz bore, Orolt |0 0zI OZL S4UD papuayxg asuL9 1 spuL[poo yy LLU
ALF9L B19Pl SOLE SO06E — Q06IZ a0rs tee (lle ed IAN ANWID ASIAN, —_Zyy
M6BL9 E0CPI %ESSG ~260Z O06IZ oops” vie i" 08 09 isuq saqtag Asia, yy
HORSE GhLO ~ “BCTE ESBBI — oDvRS ore ren ne TI yoveg worked jo sven, EGY
YOURS PSZ6l %I9'IG SOIEE Scio oles OZLbI 0 vot O91 JajuaQ uoHETIqeysy pur Tussin ysasosgpry Lge
Io EbPBL = EEG 1000 ~—a0REF oogol” BOl6 06 66 asnoy Aoudoy py
YEE’ 6568 “YETVE 6 h9OT 0061z oovs OpoTL ju ray 0Z1 qaqu9D yeyoy pur Susi oBung poy SLUE
ws SSSEZ LOG «BLL IY = REP ovgol an 09 JOUDD MONENURYDY Sout sy ML PHONE — yyy
6L9 SOORZ WEG PBITP oOREr f sa Ovoll jo Oct vz1 JoUSD quYySY puu Tursmpy Ay15 vuUC
MSO €lS9e %OSRO goRES cee: ogo! [pROKee Sopot orolt fo zt vat ouary ueyavine ; O avOt
; g orsiz {OUR eaciz ase : - D UEILwUES povD He SPIQ — ZH
%It'SL S690E %S9'lG Z180P —OESbP oncor ee yerts nee ff ke s9]u,) UOYLITRYDY 7p BulsinNY MOL, wea GON
%MIEEL TLOSI %pO'0G —EOEIZ seiez see faces ; a a pue}oq jo uapauyy poomyeg — ¢zy
EP : y ie ;
rey 0. Sonat %ETGL BOSS ORNOL 08zt vot: fo 616 woaip ay wosMuyy Gay
, i 0 we «6S
YIeED EOVLE “ODE ZISBS opis o1ss1 o16s I 0 wl edt SO amino SO WaweHt SBelia 30.9 et us
MIPS) LEORE = METEG RSE ~—-d990E po EE ed rouvpl Opa] Lg
0962 ; . . ‘
“Ovo 0 “000 0 0 ; f tds |) 98 ay wuojAec] qe JayaQ adeayyeaEy Wwo2uOH] YZ
War's €6L9 %SER ESBEZ —-Spagz “ons9 o - (borer pesofs) ious aw kup — ygY
YRLbL “6TLEZ . YLL'DG —LELGE ooRep S1L9 0 tL €L ILL “Youay euolAug] Jo r9yU9Z yoy «gy 4 |
mwozg9 €19EL WEPGE 19661 -cz00z ieee Oporl jo vet od! JOINT MONENQUIDA MEE, eG
6Y agos = |¢ se 09 Ja] USLOINOY UEYIN, Epo] lett
WOl1L TLE %9L'96 IBEty —dOREP 00801 ‘S45 Uz JPePHPE) 19 HN sutnaA (eoU om Aaou— yfcy
WLL99 GSELZ ERPS ELZID «= 008 00801 jo OOLL avot : D val 021 cee ante SEH
%ps6o ESORE %ON'PR oRSES ee oeL Jouyy Legs pep
COS GOMEZ MOGYG «SOCTE baat oovst caso jo at out sana woNMUQeNeY pu pHOHL YouOG BuoNKUCL OLE
* ; ozl odd :
: 0'09 OPbbe REC 7890r oo8er 00801 ovoit {or oz ost Kyununso aouvnry JaquID ube —_gNG
“ECTS CELLE © ASP'OG BBESP —SELOS olszt aszi 0G ! D SOUUNTY Op Jo 21eD yOYY wy sa —-ague
YECRZ LLRs YUE LEEOT 00612 : : “oye tese " €1 GET aaytag saaaepug] Lue
YOL'b) OLC61 —AEZTG _O6ebb cpsey EERE a COI aL6tL 09 M9 JOM BED YAY UDID sdoysigy —_§ 4G
raped ech (EEL EEL YORog PUOUIQ WaWAY — ye
: ae A Ayunug wysnyo a
pate'ss satez © %OL'S6§ ST6Ty «= onRey [GREE DzEOT —O08OL S\opoll opott jo ozl — oz 29 UID MOHEALQUYO PUL IPOH SVQ pL, — ETZEL
YOCOL O1SR %I9T6 S9sor aoser |oweeeeselozeo1 ogo OPOIL Opolt jo oz. vet sould syed yG
: Ayunoy sapdepy
fae p vaHIsepqus
: . caseaeesl ee
ano00 SAVG dNo00 sava sava |dyloL Nor UvA TYLOL Daa das fRaS “Wao eL : AIT JO oN gry
GvDW GyOW TYLOL INGILVd cad ‘OW «6-UdY «OC NYE «(OWS «6-100 “IM Spagl pasuaoyy
' S007 ANNE - PONT ATTA
$0/90-P0/LO STYLOL ATHALUYNO
, SEOL-W-20-Sasz01 idjsoay wnjsy ojsewag L002 isnBny ‘| | 9p Wey sq
5 Lip wou
heGT: BEC R EBOO Ost Hoos:
584 7] (ers en) £Msaleq parsyysey -p y 2
cspuminnn oy idpoouunes Gpoumatey gy | AMEE 2d YPORP YLT
meee Ere sue eg ny CO YY IPF
A VI PEP ouahiep
POWAY YY Py 7 Ve
SYP SILLY,
70} PaSSauppy BQN “|.
(agey a2yups wou seysuey)
4equInN Spy -Z
ONT] = *Molaq ssauppe Auenyap saqua ‘ga, 4
Se, C] 4} Wey way yUsayIp ssauppe Ausalap 3] “g
ah VU. “syjuued aoeds 4) yuON au} Ua 10
70-b~ 9 ] i ed ‘soaidyew aif Jo yoeq ey) OF PueD si YSENY
Arsayjeq 10 a1eq “9 (atteny payufig } hq paqjaney“q . “NO 0} pueD ayy WUNJai LEO am JEU] OS
Sassalppy (Cy
usby Fy)
SSi8Aa! BY} UO SSaippe pue awieU INCA JUG mw
“peusep S| Aleajjaq papoyysay 4) p Way]
ayeidiuoo osjy “g pue ‘Z ‘, swoy ayduoD wy
Docket for Case No: 06-002645
Issue Date |
Proceedings |
Aug. 28, 2006 |
Order Closing File. CASE CLOSED.
|
Aug. 24, 2006 |
Joint Motion to Remand filed.
|
Aug. 03, 2006 |
Order of Pre-hearing Instructions.
|
Aug. 03, 2006 |
Notice of Hearing (hearing set for October 17, 2006; 9:30 a.m.; Daytona Beach, FL).
|
Jul. 25, 2006 |
Joint Response to Initial Order filed.
|
Jul. 21, 2006 |
Initial Order.
|
Jul. 20, 2006 |
Administrative Complaint filed.
|
Jul. 20, 2006 |
Request for Formal Administrative Hearing filed.
|
Jul. 20, 2006 |
Order of Dismissal Without Prejudice Pursuant to Section 120.54 and 120.569, Florida Statutes and Rules 28-106.111 and 28-106.201, Florida Administrative Code to Allow for Amendment and Resubmission of Petition filed.
|
Jul. 20, 2006 |
Motion for More Definite Statement and Amended Request for Formal Administrative Hearing filed.
|
Jul. 20, 2006 |
Notice (of Agency referral) filed.
|