EILEEN S. WILLETT, Magistrate Judge.
Pending before the Court are documents for in-camera inspection, Defendants' fully briefed Joint Motion Requesting Entry of Protective Order for Documents to be Produced regarding Defendant Burke (Doc. 172), and Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Defendants' Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Motion for Protective Order (Doc. 177). Further briefing is deemed unnecessary.
The Court has reviewed all proposed redactions of the documents presented for in-camera inspection and finds them to be appropriate for internal security of inmates and correctional staff within the Arizona Department of Corrections ("ADC"). The Court will order Defendants to release the redacted documents to Plaintiff's counsel.
The Court further finds that the entry of the proposed Protective Order is necessary and appropriate for the security issues inherent in the exchange of documents in this case. See Pell v. Procunier, 417 U.S. 817, 823 (1974) ("central to all other correctional goals is the institutional consideration of internal security within the correctional facilities themselves"). The Court will grant the Motion for Protective Order (Doc. 177) and issue the Protective Order as proposed.
Plaintiff requests that Defendants' Reply (Doc. 176) be stricken due to "impeaching assertions reproduced in Defendants' Reply." (Doc. 177). The Court has found the redactions proposed in the documents presented for in-camera inspection and the proposed protective order to be appropriate for ADC internal security based upon security challenges presented by any inmate, any informant, and all correctional staff under circumstances presented to the Court in the documents reviewed. Argument regarding Plaintiff's alleged conduct did not inform the Court's ruling. Though Defendants cite to further documents available for the Court's review in-camera supporting Defendants' assertions, such review is unnecessary. Defendants' Reply is authorized under LRCiv 7. 2(d). The Motion to Strike (Doc. 177) will be denied.
For good cause shown,