[PROPOSED; CORRECTED] OMNIBUS ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART DOLBY'S MOTION TO FILE DOCUMENTS UNDER SEAL
YVONNE GONZALEZ ROGERS, District Judge.
[PROPOSED] OMNIBUS ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO SEAL
On October 23, 2019, this Court ordered that counsel for the parties file a proposed order as to what each party is seeking to have sealed, in light of the Court's comments at the October 23, 2019 hearing on summary judgment and Daubert motions.
Plaintiffs Dolby Laboratories Licensing Corporation and Dolby International AB (together, "Dolby") have reconsidered the information that is properly sealed in this proceeding which can be restricted to (i) pricing information in the parties' license agreements, (ii) confidential source code and proprietary materials regarding Dolby's technologies, and (iii) confidential information relating to third-party licensees of Dolby. Dolby hereby submits this omnibus order granting the motions to seal that it now seeks in light of the Court's guidance at the October 23, 2019 summary judgment hearing.
On August 13, 2019, in connection with its Motion for Summary Judgment, Dolby filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal pursuant to Civil Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5 requesting to seal certain documents in this action and redact confidential references to certain of those documents in Dolby's motion papers. Dkt. No. 152.
On August 13, 2019, in connection with its Motion to Exclude/Strike Expert Testimony of Adobe Experts Steven Kursh, Schuyler Quackenbush, and Christian Tregillis, Dolby filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal pursuant to Civil Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5 requesting to seal certain documents in this action and redact confidential references to certain of those documents in Dolby's motion papers. Dkt. No. 158.
On August 13, 2019, in connection with its Daubert Motion, Defendant Adobe Inc. ("Adobe") filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal pursuant to Civil Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5. On August 19, 2019, pursuant to Civil Local Rule 79-5(e), Dolby filed a response to Adobe's motion requesting to seal several exhibits filed by Adobe that contain confidential information of Dolby. Dkt. No. 165.
On September 3, 2019, in connection with their Opposition to Defendant Adobe Inc.'s Daubert Motion, Dolby filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal pursuant to Civil Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5 requesting to seal certain documents and to redact references to Dolby's confidential information in Dolby's Opposition to Defendant Adobe Inc.'s Daubert Motion. Dkt. No. 169.
On September 3, 2019, in connection with its Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment, Adobe filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal pursuant to Civil Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5. On September 9, 2019, pursuant to Civil Local Rule 79-5(e), Dolby filed a response to Adobe's motion requesting to seal several exhibits filed by Adobe that contain confidential information of Dolby. Dkt. No. 177.
On September 24, 2019, in connection with their Reply in Further Support of Summary Judgment and Opposition to Adobe's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment, Dolby filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal pursuant to Civil Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5 requesting to seal certain documents and redact confidential references to certain of those documents in Dolby's motion papers. Dkt. No. 185.
On October 4, 2019, in connection with its Reply in Support of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment, Adobe filed an Administrative Motion to File Documents Under Seal pursuant to Civil Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5. On October 8, 2019, pursuant to Civil Local Rule 79-5(e), Dolby filed a response to Adobe's motion requesting to seal several exhibits filed by Adobe that contain confidential information of Dolby. Dkt. No. 202.
On October 18, 2019, in connection with its notice of erratum and request to supplement record on Dolby's motion for summary judgment, Adobe filed an Administrative Motion to File Documents Under Seal pursuant to Civil Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5. On October 22, 2019, pursuant to Civil Local Rule 79-5(e), Dolby filed a response to Adobe's motion requesting to seal Exhibit 1 to that motion that contained confidential information of Dolby. Dkt. No. 210.
In support of the above motions to seal, Dolby submitted declarations of Mary Wand and Samuel Diamant. Dkt. No. 152-1; Dkt. No. 152-2; Dkt. No. 158-1; Dkt. No. 165-2; Dkt. No. 165-3; Dkt. No. 169-1; Dkt. No. 169-2; Dkt. No. 177-1; Dkt. No. 210-1.
Having considered the motions to seal (Dkt. Nos. 152, 158, 165, 169, 177, 185, 202, 210) and declarations (Dkt. Nos. 152-1, 152-2, 158-1, 165-2, 165-3, 169-1, 169-2, 177-1, 210-1) identified above, as modified through the proposed order below, and with good cause appearing therefor,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AS FOLLOWS:
Document or Evidence Offered in Order
Reference to be Support of Sealing
Sealed
Specific pricing terms Dkt. No. 152-1, Wand Granted as to section 2;
of the Subscription Decl. ¶¶ 6-10; denied as to section 4.
Letter (Redactions at Dkt. No. 152-2,
PDF page 2, Sections 2 Diamant Decl. ¶¶ 3, 6
and 4)
(Dkt. No. 152-9,
Correll Decl. Ex. A).
Specific pricing terms Dkt. No. 152-1, Wand Granted.
of the 2012 System Decl. ¶¶ 4, 5, 8-10;
Agreement Dkt. No. 152-2,
(Redactions at PDF Diamant Decl. ¶¶ 3, 6
pages 12-17)
(Dkt. No. 152-10,
Correll Decl. Ex. D).
Specific pricing terms Dkt. No. 152-1, Wand Granted.
in ADOBE_00020570 Decl. ¶¶ 6-10;
(Redactions at PDF Dkt. No. 152-2,
page 2 under "rate" Diamant Decl. ¶¶ 3, 6-7
"qty" and "royalty
due" columns)
(Dkt. No. 152-11,
Correll Decl. Ex. E).
Specific pricing terms Dkt. No. 158-1,
in the Expert Report of Diamant Decl. ¶ 4. Granted except as to PDF
Steven R. Kursh pages 46 and 54.
(Redactions at PDF
pages 31, 34, 40, 41,
42, 44, 46, 54, 70,
74, 79)
(Dkt. No. 158-5,
Correll Decl. Ex. A).
Specific pricing terms Dkt. No. 158-1,
in Expert Rebuttal Diamant Decl. ¶ 4.
Report of Steven R. Granted.
Kursh (Redactions at
PDF pages 31-32)
(Dkt. No. 158-6,
Correll Decl., Ex. B).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 158-1,
source code Diamant Decl. ¶ 4. Granted.
information in the
Expert Report of Dr.
Schuyler
Quackenbush, dated
June 13, 2019 [SEAL —
No Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 158-8,
Correll Decl., Ex. D).
Specific pricing terms Dkt. No. 158-1,
and third party Diamant Decl. ¶ 4. Granted.
information in Expert
Rebuttal Report of
Christian Tregillis,
CPA, ABV, CFF, CLP,
dated July 15, 2019
(Redactions at PDF
pages 5-6, 8-11, 14-31,
43-53, 60, 62-68, 70-74,
79, 81-83)
(Dkt. No. 158-10,
Correll Decl., Ex. F).
Specific pricing terms Dkt. No. 158-1,
in excerpts from the Diamant Decl. ¶ 4. Granted.
transcript of the
Deposition of Christian
Tregillis (Redactions at
PDF pages 13)
(Dkt. No. 158-11,
Correll Decl., Ex. G).
Specific pricing teams Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand
and third party Decl. ¶¶ 8-9; Granted.
information in excepts Dkt. No. 165-3,
of the deposition of Diamant Decl. ¶ 7
Paul Meyer
(Redactions at PDF
pages 3, 6, 8, 9, 10)
(Dkt. No. 161-6,
Callagy Decl. Ex. A).
Specific reference to Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand
source code issues in Decl. ¶¶ 10-11 Denied.
excerpts of the
deposition of John
Strawn of July 26,
2019 (Redactions at
PDF page 3)
(Dkt. No. 161-7,
Callagy Decl. Ex. B).
Specific pricing terms Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand Granted.
and third party Decl. ¶¶ 13-14;
information in Expert Dkt. No. 165-3,
Report of Paul Meyer Diamant Decl. ¶ 7
of June 13, 2019
(Redactions at PDF
pages 16-18. 22-26,
29-31, 33-42, 50-53,
55. 59-62, 70-75, 80)
(Dkt. No. 161-12,
Callagy Decl. Ex. E).
Specific pricing terns Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand
in Supplemental Decl. ¶¶ 13-14 Granted.
Expert Report of Paul
Meyer of June 27,
2019 (Redactions at
PDF pages 7-9, 11, 13-18,
20)
(Dkt. No. 161-14,
Callagy Decl. Ex. F).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand
source code Decl. ¶¶ 15-16 Granted.
information in Expert
Rebuttal Report of
John Strawn of July
15, 2019 [SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 161-16,
Callagy Decl. Ex. G).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand Granted.
source code Decl. ¶¶ 15-16
information in Expert
Report of Schuyler
Quackenbush of June
13, 2019 [SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 161-18,
Callagy Decl. Ex. H).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand Granted.
information in Expert Decl. ¶¶ 17-18
Report of Steven
Kursh of June 13, 2019
(Redactions at PDF
pages 31, 34, 40-42,
44, 46, 70)
(Dkt. No. 161-20,
Callagy Decl. Ex. I).
Specific pricing and Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand
third party information Decl. ¶¶ 17-18 Granted.
in Expert Rebuttal
Report of Lorin Hitt of
July 15, 2019
(Redactions at PDF
pages 14-15, 34)
(Dkt. No. 161-22,
Callagy Decl. Ex. J).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand
information in Decl. ¶ 6 Granted.
September 26, 2012
System License
Agreement
(Redactions at PDF
pages 5-7)
(Dkt. No. 161-24,
Callagy Decl. Ex. K).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand Granted.
information in Decl. ¶ 6
September 26, 2012
Dolby Codec Program
Addendum
(Redactions at PDF
pages 5-7)
(Dkt. No. 161-26,
Callagy Decl. Ex. L).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand Granted.
information in Decl. ¶ 6
September 27, 2013
Professional Pricing
Letter (Redactions at
PDF page 2, Section 2)
(Dkt. No. 161-28,
Callagy Decl. Ex. M).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand
information in Decl. ¶ 6 Granted as to section 2;
September 27, 2013 denied as to section 4.
Creative Cloud Pricing
Letter (Redactions at
PDF page 2, Sections 2
& 4)
(Dkt. No. 161-30,
Callagy Decl. Ex. N).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 165-2, Wand
information in April 1, Decl. ¶ 6 Granted.
2003 Digital Audio
System License
Agreement
(Redactions at PDF
page 20)
(Dkt. No. 161-32,
Callagy Decl. Ex. O).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 169-1, Granted.
information in excerpts Diamant Decl. ¶ 4;
from the transcript of Dkt. No. 169-2, Wand
the Deposition of Decl. ¶¶ 13 - 14.
Christian Tregillis,
taken on July 29, 2019
(Redactions at PDF
pages 5-6)
(Dkt. No. 169-6,
Correll Decl. Ex. W).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 169-1,
information in 2012 Diamant Decl. ¶ 3; Granted.
System Agreement Dkt. No. 169-2, Wand
(Redactions at PDF Decl. ¶ 6.
pages 12-17)
(Dkt. No. 169-7,
Correll Decl. Ex. X).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 169-1,
information in excerpts Diamant Decl. ¶ 4; Granted.
from the transcript of Dkt. No. 169-2, Wand
the Deposition of Paul Decl. ¶¶ 13 - 14.
Meyer, taken on July
25, 2019 (Redactions
at PDF pages 4-6)
(Dkt. No. 169-8,
Correll Decl. Ex. Y).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in 2003 L3 Decl. ¶ 7
Agreement
(Redactions at PDF
page 20)
(Dkt. No. 174-4,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 1)
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in 2012 Decl. ¶ 7
System Agreement
(Redactions at PDF
12-17)
(Dkt. No. 174-5,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 2).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶¶ 8-9 Granted.
7 to the deposition of
Pamela Miller
(Redactions at PDF 4,
6, 8)
(Dkt. No. 174-7,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 4).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in 2012 Decl. ¶ 7 Granted.
Professional Pricing
Letter (Redactions at
PDF page 2, Section 2)
(Dkt. No. 174-9,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 6).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in 2012 Decl. ¶ 7
Dolby Codec Program
Addendum
(Redactions at PDF
pages 5-7)
(Dkt. No. 174-10,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 7).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶¶ 8-9 Granted.
2 to the deposition of
Cole Rathje
(Redactions at PDF
pages 4, 6)
(Dkt. No. 174-13,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 10).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶¶ 8-9
50 to the deposition of
Cristian Mueller
(Redactions at PDF
page 6)
(Dkt. No. 174-22,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 19).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶¶ 8-9
70 to the deposition of
Garen Ingleby (Redaction
at PDF 2)
(Dkt. No. 174-33,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 30).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
source code deposit Decl. ¶¶ 12-13 Granted.
copies in AC-3 Fixed
Data
Registration to the
Copyright Office [SEAL,
No Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 174-38,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 35).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
source code deposit Decl. ¶¶ 12-13
copies in BSI
Registration to the
Copyright Office [SEAL,
No Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 174-39,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 36).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
source code deposit Decl. ¶¶ 12-13 Granted.
copies in AC-3
Mantissa Unpacking
Registration to the
Copyright
Office [SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 174-40,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 37).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
source code deposit Decl. ¶¶ 12-13
copies in AC-3 Mantissa
Unpacking Subroutine
Registration to the
Copyright Office [SEAL,
No Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 174-41, Callagy
Decl. Ex. 38).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
source code Decl. ¶¶ 14-15 Granted.
information in
Excerpts of July 15,
2019 Expert Report of
Dr. John Strawn
[SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 174-43,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 40).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Denied.
source code Decl. ¶¶ 14-15
information in July 15,
2019 Expert Report of
Schuyler Quackenbush
[SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 174-46,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 43).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted as to section 2;
information in the Decl. ¶ 7 denied as to section 4.
2013 Subscription
Letter (Redactions at
PDF page 2, Sections 2
and 4)
(Dkt. No. 174-49,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 46).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in the Decl. ¶ 7 Granted.
2012 Professional
Pricing Letter
(Redactions at PDF
page 2, Section 2)
(Dkt. No. 174-50,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 47).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶¶ 8-9
169 to the deposition
of Hung Chang
(Redactions at PDF
pages 2, 3, 15-20)
(Dkt. No. 174-58,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 55).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶¶ 8-9
58 to the deposition of
Bill Roberts
(Redactions at PDF
pages 2, 3, 5)
(Dkt. No. 174-60,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 57).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶¶ 8-9 Granted.
72 to the deposition of
Garen Ingleby
(Redactions at PDF
pages 2, 6-9)
(Dkt. No. 174-61,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 58).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶¶ 8-9 Granted.
61 to the deposition of
Garen Ingleby
(Redactions at PDF
page 2)
(Dkt. No. 174-64,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 61).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in Decl. ¶¶ 8-9 Granted.
DOLBY_00017628
(Redactions at PDF
page 2)
(Dkt. No. 174-66,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 63).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Denied.
technical information Decl. ¶¶ 8-9
in Exhibit 244 to the
deposition of Rob
Andersen [SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 174-67,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 64).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in excerpts Decl. ¶ 11 Granted.
from the Deposition
Transcript of Carolyn
Kohn (February 1,
2019) (Redactions at
PDF pages 24-25)
(Dkt. No. 185-11,
Morris Decl. Ex. D).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in Decl. ¶¶ 9 Granted.
Dolby_00000418
(Redactions at PDF
page 3)
(Dkt. No. 185-20,
Morris Decl. Ex. M).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in the Decl. ¶¶ 9 Granted.
2013 Professional
Pricing Letter
(Redactions at PDF
page 2, Section 2)
(Dkt. No. 185-21,
Morris Decl. Ex. N).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted as to section 2;
information in the Decl. ¶¶ 9 denied as to section 4.
Subscription Letter
(Redactions at PDF
page 2, Sections 2 and
4)
(Dkt. No. 185-22,
Morris Decl. Ex. O).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in Decl. ¶ 9
Dolby_00008622
(Redactions at page 2)
(Dkt. No. 185-23,
Morris Decl. Ex. P).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand Granted.
information in Decl. ¶¶ 9
ADOBE_00436949
(Redaction at page 2)
(Dkt. No. 185-35,
Morris Decl. Ex. CC).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
source code Decl. ¶ 14 Granted.
information from
excerpts from the
expert report of John
Strawn [SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 185-37,
Morris Decl. Ex. EE).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
technical and third Decl. ¶ 14 Granted.
party information in
ADOBE_00024829-94
[SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 185-42,
Morris Decl. Ex.
MM).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
source code Decl. ¶¶ 14-15 Denied.
information in excerpts
from the Deposition
Transcript of Schuyler
Quackenbush, Ph.D.
[SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 185-45,
Morris Decl. Ex. PP).
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in Decl. ¶ 9 Granted.
ADOBE 00003458
(Redactions at PDF
page 2)
(Dkt. No. 199-3,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 67)
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
information in excerpts Decl. ¶ 11 Granted.
from the Deposition
Transcript of Carolyn
Kohn (Redactions at
PDF page 4)
(Dkt. No. 199-5,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 69).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
source code Decl. ¶¶ 14-15 Denied except as to
information in rebuttal paragraphs 83 and 84.
Report of Ron Schnell
[SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 199-10,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 76).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
source code Decl. ¶ 11
information in excerpts
from the deposition of Denied. Without all of the
Steve Vernon [SEAL, exhibits discussed in the
No Redactions] relevant deposition excerpts,
the request is vague and
(Dkt. No. 199-11, ambiguous.
Callagy Decl. Ex. 78).
Highly confidential Dkt. No. 177-1, Wand
source code Decl. ¶ 9 Granted.
information in Exhibit
217 to the deposition
of Steve Vernon
[SEAL, No
Redactions]
(Dkt. No. 199-12,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 79).
References to the supra
above-referenced Granted in part and denied
documents and in part, consistent with the
information in the above-referenced
parties' Summary decisions.
Judgment and Daubert
filings:
Dkt. No. 152-7,
Redactions at PDF
page 8;
Dkt. No. 152-8,
Redactions at PDF
page 3
Dkt. No. 161-4,
Redactions at PDF
pages 21, 24, 25
Dkt. No. 169-5,
Redactions at PDF
pages 18, 19, 21-24
Dkt. No. 173-3,
Redactions at PDF
pages 9, 24-28, 31
Dkt. No. 173-7,
Redactions at PDF
pages 3, 11-13
Dkt. No. 173-9,
Redactions at PDF
pages 6-10
Dkt. No. 185-5,
Redactions at PDF
pages 8-9, 13
Dkt. No. 185-7,
Redactions at PDF
pages 3, 10-11, 13
Specific pricing Dkt. No. 210-1, Wand
information in Exhibit Decl. ¶ 5 Granted except as to
184 to the Deposition section 4 on PDF pages 6
of Hung Chang and 7.
(Redactions at PDF
pages 3, 6-7)
(Dkt. No. 205-3, 205-4
Farris Decl. Ex. 1).
Dolby has withdrawn its motion to seal as to the following documents. For that reason, Dolby's motions to seal the following documents are DENIED AS MOOT:
Document or Evidence Offered in Order
Reference to be Support of Sealing
Sealed
Excerpts from the Denied.
transcript of the
Deposition of Steven
R. Kursh, Ph.D., taken
on July 26, 2019
(Dkt. No. 158-7,
Correll Decl., Ex. C).
Excerpts from the
transcript of the Denied.
Deposition of Schuyler
Quackenbush, Ph.D.,
taken July 23, 2019
(Dkt. No. 158-9,
Correll Decl., Ex. E).
Excerpts of the Denied.
deposition of Lorin
Hitt of July 31, 2019
(Dkt. No. 161-9,
Callagy Decl. Ex. C).
Excerpts from the Denied.
deposition of Cristian
Mueller
(Dkt. No. 174-8,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 5).
Exhibit 62 to the
deposition of Garen Denied.
Ingleby
(Dkt. No. 174-11,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 8).
Excerpts from the Denied.
deposition of Pamela
Miller
(Dkt. No. 174-15,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 12).
Exhibit 1 to the Denied.
deposition of Patrick
Rossi
(Dkt. No. 174-16,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 13).
Exhibit 7 to the Denied.
deposition of Patrick
Rossi
(Dkt. No. 174-17,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 14).
DOLBY_00010024 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 174-18,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 15).
Exhibit 38 to the
deposition of Cristian Denied.
Mueller
(Dkt. No. 174-20,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 17).
Exhibit 47 to the Denied.
deposition of Cristian
Mueller
(Dkt. No. 174-21,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 18).
Exhibit 51 to the Denied.
deposition of Cristian
Mueller
(Dkt. No. 174-23,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 20).
Exhibit 4 to the Denied.
deposition of Cole
Rathje
(Dkt. No. 174-24,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 21).
Excerpts from the Denied.
deposition of Conroy
Shun
(Dkt. No. 174-25,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 22).
Excerpts from the Denied.
deposition of Cole
Rathje
(Dkt. No. 174-26,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 23).
Exhibit 153 to the Denied.
deposition of Kyle
Vaughn
(Dkt. No. 174-27,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 24).
Excerpts from the
deposition of Kyle
Vaughn
(Dkt. No. 174-28,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 25).
Excerpts from the
deposition of Patrick Denied.
Rossi
(Dkt. No. 174-29,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 26).
Excerpts from the
deposition of Garen Denied.
Ingleby
(Dkt. No. 174-30,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 27).
Excerpts from the Denied.
deposition of Winona Ou
(Dkt. No. 174-31,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 28).
Exhibit 68 to the
deposition of Garen Denied.
Ingleby
(Dkt. No. 174-32,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 29).
Exhibit 119 to the Denied.
deposition of John
Mardesich
(Dkt. No. 174-42,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 39).
Excerpts from the Denied.
deposition of Dr. John
Straws
(Dkt. No. 174-44,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 41).
Exhibit 121 to the Denied.
deposition of John
Mardesich
(Dkt. No. 174-45,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 42).
Excerpts from the Denied.
deposition of Schuyler
Quackenbush
(Dkt. No. 174-48,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 45).
Exhibit 152 to the Denied.
deposition of Kyle
Vaughn
(Dkt. No. 174-62,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 59).
Schedule 13 to the Denied.
Expert Report of Paul
Meyer
(Dkt. No. 174-63,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 60).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Pamela Miller
(Dkt. No. 185-8,
Morris Decl. Ex. A).
Excerpts from the
Deposition Transcript Denied.
of Joe Perry
(Dkt. No. 185-9,
Morris Decl. Ex. B).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Carolyn Kohn
(December 12, 2018)
(Dkt. No. 185-10,
Morris Decl. Ex. C).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Patrick Rossi
(Dkt. No. 185-12,
Morris Decl. Ex. E).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Garen Ingleby
(Dkt. No. 185-13,
Morris Decl. Ex. F).
Excerpts from the
Deposition Transcript Denied.
of Cristian Mueller
(Dkt. No. 185-14,
Morris Decl. Ex. G).
ADOBE_00539118 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-15,
Morris Decl. Ex. H).
ADOBE_00539119 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-16,
Morris Decl. Ex. I).
ADOBE_00484905-06 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-17,
Morris Decl. Ex. J).
Excerpts from the
Deposition Transcript Denied.
of Winona Ou
(Dkt. No. 185-18,
Morris Decl. Ex. K).
Dolby_00011831-37 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-19,
Morris Decl. Ex. L).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Adriana Souza
(Dkt. No. 185-24,
Morris Decl. Ex. Q).
ADOBE_00490963-64 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-25,
Morris Decl. Ex. S).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Hung Chang
(Dkt. No. 185-26,
Morris Decl. Ex. T).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Conroy Shum
(Dkt. No. 185-27,
Morris Decl. Ex. U).
ADOBE_00513174 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-28,
Morris Decl. Ex. V).
ADOBE_00058814 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-29,
Morris Decl. Ex. W).
ADOBE_00513155 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-30,
Morris Decl. Ex. X).
ADOBE_00513181 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-31,
Morris Decl. Ex. Y).
Dolby_00038441 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-32,
Morris Decl. Ex. Z).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Brandy Ichishita
(Dkt. No. 185-33,
Morris Decl. Ex. AA).
ADOBE_00498321 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-34,
Morris Decl. Ex. BB).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Kyle Vaughn
(Dkt. No. 185-36,
Morris Decl. Ex. DD).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Charles Van Winkle
(Dkt. No. 185-38,
Morris Decl. Ex. FF).
Excerpts from the
Deposition Transcript Denied.
of Colin Stefani
(Dkt. No. 185-39,
Morris Decl. Ex. GG).
ADOBE_00539110-11 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-40,
Morris Decl. Ex.
KK).
ADOBE_00139718-20 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-41,
Morris Decl. Ex. LL).
ADOBE_00139721-35 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 185-43,
Morris Decl. Ex. NN).
Excerpts from the
Deposition Transcript Denied.
of John Mardesich
(Dkt. No. 185-44,
Morris Decl. Ex. OO).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of Adriana Souza
(Dkt. No. 199-4,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 68).
ADOBE_00004552 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 199-6,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 71).
ADOBE_00004648 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 199-7,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 72).
Dolby_00002677 Denied.
(Dkt. No. 199-8,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 73).
Excerpts from the Denied.
Deposition Transcript
of John Mardesich
(Dkt. No. 199-9,
Callagy Decl. Ex. 74).
The Court emphasizes that all decisions made herein are made in the context of the summary judgment and Daubert motions. To the extent requests are denied, the Court finds that an insufficient showing has been made to justify sealing. The decisions are not binding with respect to how documents or information will be treated at trial. Such issues will be discussed at the pre-trial conference. Further, Dolby shall file the documents ordered unsealed, or redacted versions of documents ordered partially sealed, in accordance with this order, no later than Monday, December 23, 2019.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
