Filed: May 03, 2019
Latest Update: May 03, 2019
Summary: ORDER D.P. MARSHALL, JR. , District Judge . 1. Sears has established excusable neglect for his late answer. Pioneer Investment Services Company v. Brunswick Associates Ltd. Partnership, 507 U.S. 380 , 395 (1993); Union Pacific Railroad Company v. Progress Rail Services Corporation, 256 F.3d 781 , 782 (8th Cir. 2001). According to his son's affidavit, which is competent evidence about his father's health, Sears is an older man with a fa ding mind. He has had to move in with his son; h
Summary: ORDER D.P. MARSHALL, JR. , District Judge . 1. Sears has established excusable neglect for his late answer. Pioneer Investment Services Company v. Brunswick Associates Ltd. Partnership, 507 U.S. 380 , 395 (1993); Union Pacific Railroad Company v. Progress Rail Services Corporation, 256 F.3d 781 , 782 (8th Cir. 2001). According to his son's affidavit, which is competent evidence about his father's health, Sears is an older man with a fa ding mind. He has had to move in with his son; he..
More
ORDER
D.P. MARSHALL, JR., District Judge.
1. Sears has established excusable neglect for his late answer. Pioneer Investment Services Company v. Brunswick Associates Ltd. Partnership, 507 U.S. 380, 395 (1993); Union Pacific Railroad Company v. Progress Rail Services Corporation, 256 F.3d 781, 782 (8th Cir. 2001). According to his son's affidavit, which is competent evidence about his father's health, Sears is an older man with a fa ding mind. He has had to move in with his son; he has no memory of his ` car accident involving the Thompsons; and he forgets things he should remember. While launching the case has been delayed for a few months, and the Thompsons had to go to some trouble in achieving service, these circumstances are insufficient prejudice. Sears is ready to defend now, with the help of his son and insurer. Our law prefers decisions on the merits. Johnson v. Dayton Electric Manufacturing Company, 140 F.3d 781, 784-85 (8th Cir. 1998). The Clerk's default and the Court's Order on liability will be set aside.
2. Sears's filings to date do not establish his incompetence. But the parties need to address that issue soon. Motion to substitute a guardian of his estate, or joint report, due by 31 May 2019.
3. The Court received the attached letters from counsel during the briefing on the pending motions. Please do not send any more letters to chambers. File every substantive communication with the Court on the docket. And any moving party may reply within seven calendar days of any response.
* * *
Sears's motions, N o 10 & 12, are granted. The Court vacates the Clerk's default, N o 6, and the Order on liability, N o 8. The Thompsons' motion to strike, No 14, is denied.
So Ordered.
LASER LAW FIRM, P.A.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
415 N. MCKINLEY STREET, SUITE 760
LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS 72205
TELEPHONE; (501) 376-2981
KEVIN J. STATEN FACSIMILE: (501) 376-2417 E-mail. kstatem@laserlaw.com
www. laserlaw. com
April 16, 2019
Honorable D. Price Marshall, Jr.
U.S. Courthouse
600 W. Capitol Avenue, Room B155
Little Rock, AR 72201
Re: Thompson et al. v. Sears
Eastern District of Arkansas, Jonesboro Division
No 3:18-CV-00202. OPM
Dear Judge Marshall:
Allow me to make a status report on the above-referenced matter. Approximately two weeks ago, I filed a Motion to Reconsider in which I stated that a medical affidavit would be procured and forwarded to the Court.
I have contacted the relatives of Defendant Sears, who have advised that they are still trying to get in to see the Mr. Sears' doctor. Apparently, the doctor is "booked solid" with appointments and emergencies. They hope to have an affidavit signed in about a week.
I appreciate the Court's patience in this matter.
Respectfully,
Kevin Staten
KS/bds
cc: Mr. Larry Steele
steelelaw7622@sbcglobal.net
Larry J. Steele PLC
ATTORNEY AT LAW
225 West Elm Street, P.O. Box 561
WALNUT RIDGE, AR 72476-0561
e-mail: sleelelaw7622@sbcglobal.net
PHONE: (870) 886-5840 FAX: (870) 886-5873
VIA EMAIL
dpmchambers@ared.uscourts.gov
April 23, 2019
Honorable D. P. Marshall, Jr.
U.S. District Court
Eastern District of Arkansas
600 West Capitol Avenue, Room B 149
Little Rock. AR 72201
RE: Tiffany Nicole Thompson, et al. v. Carmon Sears
U.S. District Court No. 3:18-CV-00202
Dear Judge Marshall:
Mr. Staten's letter of April 16, 2019 disregards the fact that Mr. Staten's client. Auto-Owners Insurance, refused to accept service on behalf of their insured, Defendant. Carmon Sears. when given the opportunity. Mr. Staten's client also obstructed the process by refusing to provide an address where Mr. Scars could be served.
If Defendant Sears had mental problems, the diagnosis should have existed at the relevant time. Any diagnosis obtained at this time would have to be made retroactive and obviously would be self-serving.
Sincerely,
LJS/jas
cc: Mr. Kevin Staten (via email-kstaten@laserlaw.com)
LASER LAW FIRM, P.A.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
415 N. MCKINLEY STREET, SUITE 760
LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS 72205-3040
TELEPHONE: (501) 376-2981 E-mail: kstaten(@Jaserlaw.com
KEVIN STATEN FACSIMILE: (501) 376-2417 Direct Dial (501) 376-2981
www. laserlaw.com
April 23, 2019
Via Email Only: dpmchambers@ared.uscourts.gov
Honorable D. P. Marshall, Jr.
U.S. District Court
Eastern District of Arkansas
600 West Capitol Avenue, Room B149
Little Rock, AR 72201.
RE: Tiffany Nicole Thompson et al. v. Carmon Sears
U.S. District Court No. 3:18-CV-00202
Dear Judge Marshall:
In response to Mr. Steele's letter, I would point out that Auto Owners has no ability to accept service for Mr. Sears, and no duty to do so. The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure do not authorize service upon an insurance company, nor has Mr. Sears authorized Auto Owners to accept service for him.
Likewise, Auto Owners has no duty to provide an address where Mr. Sears can be served. What Auto Owners did, or didn't, do is irrelevant to the issues before the Court.
I spoke with Mr. Sears' son just now. He stated that he mailed medical records to me this morning from Oklahoma. I have the consent of Mr. Sears' son to submit these records to the Court upon receipt. I expect to have them in about two days.
Respectfully,
Kevin Staten
KS/bds
cc: Mr. Larry J. Steele
Steelelaw7622@sbcglobal.net