RICHARD G. ANDREWS, District Judge.
Defendants in these three cases have filed motions to dismiss. (D.I. 8).
I have read the patent, looked at independent claim 12, and looked at the very tiny pictures of the T8 LED tube lights. Claim 12 is addressed to a an "energy-efficient lighting apparatus." (So is claim 1, which among other things, includes a "ballast cover" as a part of the "energy-efficient lighting apparatus." Plaintiff purports to explain what a ballast cover is. (See D.I. 12, p.2 n.3). Defendants respond that the explanation contains "obvious factual inaccuracy." (D.I. 14, p. 7). It is not obvious to me, and, in any event, seems like a poor candidate for resolution on a motion to dismiss.). I gather that Plaintiff is saying that claim 12 covers LED tube lights. I (preliminarily) take the "for retrofit . . . "to be a non-limiting statement of intent. Defendants argue that the balance of claim 12 cannot describe a tube light, but the terminology of the patent claim (while perhaps clear to a POSITA) is not presently clear to me. It is plausible that claim 12 covers LED tube lights. Therefore, I believe that the Complaints comply with Rule 18
I am nevertheless concerned about whether I am allowing what might be frivolous litigation to go forward. Plaintiff is ready and able to provide claim charts.
1. Plaintiff should provide detailed claim charts to each of the three Defendants charting its infringement theories for all asserted claims against at least one of each Defendant's accused T8 LED tube lights.
2. The parties are directed to meet-and-confer after the claim charts are filed. Among other things, the parties shall discuss whether they can jointly agree upon a way to present the case to me for early resolution.
3. A rule 16 scheduling conference will be set for February 9, 2016, at 9 a.m. There will be a separate order in regard to the scheduling conference.
4. The parties should submit a joint status report three business days before the Rule 16 scheduling conference regarding any agreements or proposals for a means for early resolution of these cases.