Elawyers Elawyers
Ohio| Change

Nissan Motor Acceptance Corporation v. Robert Allen Nissan of Helena, Inc., CV-19-16-H-CCL. (2019)

Court: District Court, D. Montana Number: infdco20190328d37 Visitors: 15
Filed: Mar. 27, 2019
Latest Update: Mar. 27, 2019
Summary: ORDER & PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION CHARLES C. LOVELL , District Judge . Plaintiff Nissan Motor Acceptance Corporation ("NMAC") filed the above-captioned action against defendants Robert Allen Nissan of Helena, Inc. and Robert T. Allen (collectively referred to as "Defendant") for breach of contract, claim and delivery, injunctive relief, specific performance, breach of sign lease agreement, breach of lease plan agreement, and breach of guaranty (the "Action"). NMAC and Defendant entered into a
More

ORDER & PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

Plaintiff Nissan Motor Acceptance Corporation ("NMAC") filed the above-captioned action against defendants Robert Allen Nissan of Helena, Inc. and Robert T. Allen (collectively referred to as "Defendant") for breach of contract, claim and delivery, injunctive relief, specific performance, breach of sign lease agreement, breach of lease plan agreement, and breach of guaranty (the "Action"). NMAC and Defendant entered into a Forbearance Agreement and Release dated as of March 22, 2019 ("Forbearance Agreement") pursuant to which Defendant is to perform certain terms and conditions. Defendant and NMAC have executed and filed a Joint Request to Vacate Hearing and to Enter Stipulated Preliminary Injunction Order (Doc. 27). The parties also filed a Stipulation of Parties to Preliminary Injunction (Doc. 28) and a proposed order (Doc. 29). Defendant and NMAC have agreed that a Preliminary Injunction Order shall be issued by this Court pursuant to the terms and conditions contained within their Stipulation and proposed order.

Having reviewed the stipulation, and for good cause shown, the Court enters the following Findings and Conclusions.

1. NMAC has established that it is entitled to the issuance of a preliminary injunction. Unless Defendant is enjoined there is a danger that the vehicles identified on the attached Exhibit A, the other vehicles and personal property described in the attached Exhibit B and the proceeds from the sale of any such vehicle or other personal property (collectively the "Collateral"), may become unavailable to replevy and may become substantially impaired in value before the Court can consider NMAC's motion for an order of delivery or hold a trial on the merits.

2. Defendant has sold and continues to sell NMAC's vehicle Collateral out-of-trust and to use the proceeds of the vehicle and non-vehicle Collateral for purposes other than repaying NMAC the amounts owed to it. As long as Defendant can continue to sell vehicles out of trust, NMAC's security interest is being irreparably harmed by the diversion or withholding of the sales proceeds necessary to satisfy NMAC's liens. The injury to NMAC is irreparable because its source of repayment, the Collateral, is being diminished each day that Defendant is not enjoined. The sales proceeds of the vehicle Collateral represent cash collateral which could easily be applied to satisfy Defendant's obligations to NMAC under the loan documents and security agreements entered into by the parties.

3. A preliminary injunction is proper in this case because NMAC's security interest in the cash Collateral is easily and quickly lost as Defendant can spend the sales proceeds for other purposes. At the same time, the vehicles are depreciating in value. Defendant has already demonstrated its unwillingness to meet its obligations to NMAC under the loan documents by refusing to surrender the vehicles and by selling vehicles out of trust.

4. NMAC has established the likelihood that it will prevail on the merits of its claim based upon Defendant's defaults under the loan documents, NMAC's security interest in the collateral, and because Defendant has sold vehicles "out of trust" by keeping the proceeds and failing to pay them to NMAC.

5. NMAC has established the probable validity of its security interest in, and claim to possession of, the vehicles identified on the attached Exhibit A and all of Defendant's furniture, fixtures, machinery, supplies and other equipment, all motor vehicles, tractors, trailers, implements, service parts and accessories and other inventory of every kind, all accounts, contract rights, chattel paper and general intangibles as described in the attached Exhibit B, that Defendant is in default on its loan obligations owing to NMAC under the loan documents as set forth in NMAC's moving papers.

The parties having stipulated that Plaintiff is not required to provide security and to entry of the Preliminary Injunction, the Court enters this Preliminary Injunction without requiring Plaintiff to provide security. Accordingly,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Defendant may sell or lease the Collateral in the ordinary course of business only as provided in this order:

1. At the time of any sale or lease of any vehicle, Defendant shall immediately notify NMAC of such sale or lease via email to the following email address: Jeffry.Griffin@nissan-usa.com, by promptly delivering or faxing to NMAC a true copy of the written contract of such retail sale or lease at 8900 Freeport Parkway, Irving, Texas 75063 (fax: 972 607-8236) and by notifying NMAC's representative on site at 3135 Prospect Ave, Helena, MT 59601.

2. Defendant shall turn over possession to NMAC and NMAC shall maintain physical custody of titles and manufacturers certificates of origin ("MCO") for all vehicles in which NMAC has a lien or security interest, whether or not financed by NMAC;

3. Defendant shall not make delivery of a vehicle identified on the attached Exhibit A unless it has received either ( 1) full payment for such vehicle or (2) written approval of consumer financing. Within the earlier often (10) calendar days of sale or one business day from Defendant's receipt of any of the sale proceeds (excluding down payments for sales that do not close) for any sale or lease of a vehicle, including any vehicle identified on Exhibit A that has been sold or leased on or before the date of this Order for which Defendant received proceeds before or after the date of this Order, Defendant shall immediately and forthwith remit to NMAC by check delivered to NMAC's representative on site at 3135 Prospect Ave, Helena, MT 59601 or by wire transfer or direct payment to NMAC's bank in accordance with the wire instructions provided to Defendant by NMAC all amounts received by Defendant up to the amount advanced by NMAC to Defendant to acquire the vehicle (the "Advanced Price"). Defendant may not pay such amounts to NMAC via electronic funds transfer ("EIPP"). Any proceeds in excess of the Advanced Price on a particular vehicle may be retained by Defendant to use towards its operating expenses. NMAC's security interest continues to attach to the proceeds in excess of the Advanced Price to the extent they are not used to cover operating expenses;

4. Within one business day from Defendant's receipt of any of the "cash" proceeds (excluding down payments for sales that do not close) of such sale or lease of a vehicle not identified on the attached Exhibit A (a "Non-Floored Vehicle"), Defendant shall immediately and forthwith remit to NMAC by check delivered to NMAC's representative on site at 3135 Prospect Ave, Helena, MT 5960 I or by wire transfer or direct payment to NMAC's bank in accordance with the wire instructions provided to Defendant by NMAC funds received by Defendant in the amount of 50% of Defendant net sale price of the Non-Floored Vehicle after payment of taxes, registration, and licensing. Defendant may not pay such amounts to NMAC via EIPP;

5. Should Defendant receive any vehicle as a "trade-in" for the payment of a vehicle or a Non-Floored Vehicle, Defendant shall notify NMAC within one business day of receiving the trade-in by email to the following email address: Jeffry.Griffin@nissan-usa.com and by notifying NMAC's representative on site at 3135 Prospect Ave, Helena, MT 59601. Furthermore, Defendant shall promptly pay or satisfy any liens or amounts owing against the trade-in vehicle. Defendant may subsequently sell the trade-in as a Non-Floored Vehicle in accordance with paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 4 above;

6. Trades or transfers of vehicles by Defendant with other dealers ("Dealer Trades") are prohibited unless expressly consented to in writing by NMAC;

7. Defendant shall limit the use of Demonstrator Vehicles to customer test drives of no more than 24 hours in duration. Defendant shall continue to have the right to use Demonstrator Vehicles for dealer purposes.

8. Defendant may sell parts, accessories, or related supplies ("Parts") in the ordinary course of its service department's business but Defendant shall use the proceeds from the cost of the Parts sold to pay Defendant's invoice cost on account of part's sales, in the form of checks or other immediately available funds to NMAC. Defendant shall submit to NMAC a written accounting upon its request of the following: (1) Parts sold the previous week; and (2) Parts ordered as replacements the previous week.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendant is restrained from removing any of the Collateral in such manner as to make it less available to seizure by levying officer and/or impairing the value of the subject colalteral.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendant shall permit NMAC and its authorized agents and employees to enter upon Defendant's sales lot and business offices located at 3135 Prospect Ave, Helena, MT 5960 I during business operating hours. NMAC shall be authorized to hold possession of keys overnight to all vehicles, to be present while all mail and other package deliveries are opened and to review the cash receipts journals on a daily basis. NMAC is authorized to conduct audits and inspections of the Collateral and Defendant's books and records, including making photocopies thereof. Defendant shall deliver copies of all bank statements and daily website bank statements, contracts in transit and lien payoff schedules to NMAC within one business day of receipt by Defendant of such statements each day.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendant must ensure that its managers, members and employees comply with all its agreements with NMAC.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Preliminary Injunction and Order to Show Cause Hearing currently set for March 28, 2019, and the Court's March 25, 2019 Order (Doc. 26) are VACATED.

This Order shall remain in effect until modified by further order of this Court, a subsequent order of a Bankruptcy Court or provisions of Title 11, or modified by written agreement signed by the parties, filed with and approved by this Court. So ordered.

Exhibit A

Robert Allen Nissan of Helena, Inc. — Inventory

VIN Make Model Year 5J6RM4H98GL003723 HONDA CR-V 16 JN8AZ2NE4E9063166 INFINITI QX80 14 5NPD84LF2HH080417 HYUNDAI ELANTRA 17 5N1AZ2MS1KN104161 NISSAN MURANO 19 2G1125S36J9111011 CHEVROLE IMPALA 18 1G11E5SA2GF118415 CHEVROLE MALIBU 16 1N4BL4DV2KQ24422 NISSAN ALTIMA 19 1N4BL4DV7KC124514 NISSAN ALTIMA 19 3C6UR5FL8GG129493 RAM 2500 16 1N4BL4CV0KC130785 NISSAN ALTIMA 19 1GC4K0C80DF173498 CHEVROLE SILVERADO 13 1N4BL3AP2HC193877 NISSAN ALTIMA 17 3N1AB7AP0JY209753 NISSAN SENTRA 18 JM1BM1V72F1219702 MAZDA3 TOURING 15 3N1AB7AP1KY236896 NISSAN SENTRA 19 3N1AB7AP2KY239080 NISSAN SENTRA 19 3N1AB7AP8KY2475S6 NISSAN SENTRA 19 3N1AB7AP6GY249991 NISSAN SENTRA 16 1N4AL3AP6GC250835 NISSAN ALTIMA 16 JN1BJ1CR3JW254177 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 18 3N1AB7AP3KY254784 NISSAN SENTRA 19 3N1AB7AP9KY254868 NISSAN SENTRA 19 3N1AB7AP4KY255605 NISSAN SENTRA 19 1GT12UE87GF264781 GMC SIERRA 16 1C6RR7MT8G5272148 RAM 1500 16 JN1BJ1CR2JW288272 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 18 JN1BJ1CR4JW292095 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 18 3FA6P0G77DR298373 FORD FUSION 13 JN8AT2MV7JW303423 NISSAN ROGUE 18 1N4BL4DWBKN307501 NISSAN ALTIMA 19 JN1BJ1CRXKW312612 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 19 JN1BJ1CR1KW313891 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 19 JN1BJ1CR9KW317B17 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 19 JN1BJ1CR5KW317930 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 19 JN1BJ1CR5KW318205 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 19 JN1BJ1CR1KW318332 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 19 3N1CB7AP0HY322315 NISSAN SENTRA 17 3N1CE2CP0JL356538 NISSAN VERSA HBK 18 1N4AL3AP0EN361981 NISSAN ALTIMA 14 1N4AA6AV9KC364679 NISSAN MAXIMA 19 1N4AA6AV7KC365023 NISSAN MAXIMA 19 1N4AA6AV1KC367639 NISSAN MAXIMA 19 JN8AT2MV1KW379298 NISSAN ROGUE 19 JN8AT2MV3KW380646 NISSAN ROGUE 19 JN8AT2MV2KW382579 NISSAN ROGUE 19 JN8AT2MVXKW384242 NISSAN ROGUE 19 JN8AT2MV1KW3B8535 NISSAN ROGUE 19 JN8AT2MV3KW390416 NISSAN ROGUE 19 1N4AA6AP5JC406958 NISSAN MAXIMA 18 1N4AA6AP1JC409484 NISSAN MAXIMA 18 JN1BV7ARXFM410700 INFINITI Q50 15 1N4AA6AP1GC413804 NISSAN MAXIMA 16 1N4AA6AP0HC419000 NISSAN MAXIMA 17 1GNSKCKC7GR420945 CHEVROLE TAHOE 16 1N4AA6AP0GC438726 NISSAN MAXIMA 16 1N4AL3AP2FC456605 NISSAN ALTIMA 15 1N6AA1E52KN502068 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1F45HN502368 NISSAN TITAN 17 1N6AA1EJ7KN503391 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E56KN503675 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1EJ6KN503737 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E55KN503828 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E51KN503986 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E55KN504445 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E5XKN504697 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E53KN504900 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E52KN505245 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E5XJN506738 NISSAN TITAN 18 1N6AA1E50KN507429 NISSAN TITAN 19 JN8AY2NC2H9507795 NISSAN ARMADA 17 1N6AA1E51KN508492 NISSAN TITAN 19 JN8AY2NC2KX509453 NISSAN ARMADA 19 1N6AA1E56KN509556 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E5XJN510093 NISSAN TITAN 18 1N6AA1E5XKN510385 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E55KN510570 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6BA1F44KN510618 NISSAN TITAN XD 19 1N6BA1F40KN510731 NISSAN TITAN XD 19 1N6BA1F44KN510912 NISSAN TITAN XD 19 JN8AY2NC0KX511038 NISSAN ARMADA 19 1N6AA1F43JN512046 NISSAN TITAN 18 1N6AA1E51JN512394 NISSAN TITAN 18 1N6AA1E5XJN512748 NISSAN TITAN 18 1N6AA1E56JN512925 NISSAN TITAN 18 1N6AA1EJ2KN513522 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E5XJN513530 NISSAN TITAN 18 3N1CP5CU0JL513793 NISSAN KICKS 18 1N6BA1F45KN513902 NISSAN TITAN XD 19 1N6AA1E53KN514472 NISSAN TITAN 19 2C4RC1DG3HR516382 CHRYSLER PACIFICA 17 1N6AA1EJ0KN516936 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1EJ1KN517075 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6AA1E52KN517640 NISSAN TITAN 19 1N6BA1F47JN518582 NISSAN TITAN XD 18 1NGAA1F42JN519716 NISSAN TITAN 18 3N1CP5CU4JL520746 NISSAN KICKS 18 1N6BA1F43JN521673 NISSAN TITAN XD 18 1N6AA1F46JN522196 NISSAN TITAN 18 3N1CP5CU1JL525452 NISSAN KICKS 18 1N6BA1F40JN538172 NISSAN TITAN XD 18 1N6BA1F39JN538517 NISSAN TITAN XD 18 3N1CP5CU4JL539359 NISSAN KICKS 18 1N6BA1F33JN539601 NISSAN TITAN XD 18 3N1CP5CUXJL540709 NISSAN KICKS 18 1N6BA1F45JN543058 NISSAN TITAN XD 18 1N6AA1E53JN548216 NISSAN TITAN 18 1C4PJMDX5JD554400 JEEP CHEROKEE 18 JN8AY2NC7J9556013 NISSAN ARMADA 18 1C4HJWFG9DL589481 JEEP WRANGLER 13 JN1BJ1CR3JW600292 NISSAN ROGUE SPOR 18 1C6RR7MT7HS632947 RAM 1500 17 3N1AB7AP5HL666288 NISSAN SENTRA 17 5N1DR2MM5HC667037 NISSAN PATHFINDER 17 3C4PDDGG9HT704161 DODGE JOURNEY 17 1N6AD0FV0KN706321 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 1N6AD0EV5KN706378 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 1N6AD0EV5FN712736 NISSAN CREW CAB 15 1N6AD0EV0KN718017 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 1N6AD0EV0KN718079 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 1N6AD0EV2KN718844 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 1N6AD0EV6KN720628 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 1N6AD0EV0KN721578 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 5N1AT2MV7KC722950 NISSAN ROGUE 19 1N6AD0EV8JN725392 NISSAN CREW CAB 18 1N6AD0EV0KN725825 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 1N6AD0EV9KN734149 NISSAN CREW CAB 19 5N1AT2MV2KC748601 NISSAN ROGUE 19 5N1AT2MV7KC7S4202 NISSAN ROGUE 19 JNSAY2NE2K9757305 NISSAN ARMADA 19 1N6AD0EV8JN759428 NISSAN CREW CAB 18 3C6RR7KT4HG793105 RAM 1500 17 3N1CN7AP0KL803S78 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N1CN7AP3KL805213 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N1CN7AP6KL805772 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N1CN7AP1KL809681 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 5N1AT2MV8HC813170 NISSAN ROGUE 17 3N1CN7AP0KL813978 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N1CN7AP6KL815301 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N1CN7AP6KL815704 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N2CN7AP4KL817497 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N1CN7AP5KL819436 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N2CN7AP8KL819852 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 3N1CN7AP8KL822542 NISSAN VERSA SED 19 1FTFW1EF5HFA01195 FORD F-150 17 1FTEW1EG3FFC64089 FORD F150 15 1FTEW1EF2FKF10077 FORD F-150 15

Exhibit B

2.4.1 Property, including all automobiles, trucks and other motor vehicles (including service loan cars, daily rentals, demonstrators and display vehicles), and all parts accessories, attachments, components and furnishings whether or not attached to Property, including all goods hereafter acquired in replacement or substitution of the foregoing; 2.4.2 All other goods, including without limitation, all inventory, machinery, equipment, tools, appliances, trucks, motor vehicles and office furniture and fixtures; 2.4.3 All accounts, accounts receivable, chattel paper, security agreements, instruments, contract rights, leases of property, all rentals due or to become due under any lease of any property, all other rentals, policies and certificates of insurance, deposit accounts, investment property, dealer reserve accounts, manufacturer's statements of origin (MSO's) or certificates of title or ownership relating to vehicles, bills of sale, receipts, journals, records, files, books and ledger sheets, records indicating, summarizing or evidencing Debtor's business operations or financial condition and all computer programs, disk or tape files, printouts, runs or other computer-prepared information and the equipment containing such information, documents and general intangibles, including all monies and credits now due or to become due to Debtor from, and all claims against, vendors of inventory or other lending institutions; 2.4.4 All other assets of Debtor, with the exception of real property, but including fixtures; and 2.4.5 All cash and non-cash proceeds of the foregoing.
Source:  Leagle

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.
Ask a Question
Search for lawyers by practice areas.
Find a Lawyer