MAXINE M. CHESNEY, District Judge.
Before the Court are two motions, each filed February 5, 2018, by defendant Amazon.com, LLC ("Amazon"): (1) "Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff's Second Amended Class Action Complaint"; and (2) "Motion to Strike Class Allegations." The motions have been fully briefed. Having read and considered the papers filed in support of and in opposition to the motions, the Court hereby rules as follows.
1. The First Cause of Action, titled "Failure to Provide Regular Pay/Minimum Wages," is subject to dismissal, as plaintiff fails to "allege facts showing that there was a given week in which [she] was entitled to but denied minimum wages or [regular] wages."
2. The Second Cause of Action, titled "Failure to Provide Overtime Premium Pay," is subject to dismissal, as plaintiff fails to "allege facts showing that there was a given week in which [she] was entitled to but denied . . . overtime wages."
3. The Third Cause of Action, titled "Failure to Provide Meal Periods and/or Meal Period Premium Pay," is subject to dismissal, as plaintiff fails to allege sufficient facts to support a finding that Amazon failed to "provide" her a meal period or periods.
4. The Fourth Cause of Action, titled "Failure to Provide Rest Periods and Rest Period Premium Pay," is, for the reasons stated above with respect to the Third Cause of Action, subject to dismissal.
5. The Fifth Cause of Action, titled "Failure to Reimburse for Necessary Expenditures Incurred," is not subject to dismissal, in light of plaintiff's allegation that she was "required to carry and use [her] personal cell phone[] for scheduling purposes and maintaining communication with dispatch and the warehouse — all without any reimbursement of any kind." (
6. The Sixth Cause of Action, titled "Failure to Provide Accurate Wage Statements [and] Keep Accurate Payroll Records," is, as pleaded, derivative of the First through Fifth Causes of Action, and, consequently, is, for the reasons stated above, subject to dismissal to the extent based on the First through Fourth Causes of Action and not subject to dismissal to the extent based on the Fifth Cause of Action.
7. The Seventh Cause of Action, titled "Failure to Timely Pay Wages Owed," is subject to dismissal, as plaintiff does not allege facts to support a finding that Amazon's asserted failure to timely pay wages due plaintiff upon termination of her employment was "willful."
8. The Eighth Cause of Action, titled "Failure to Provide Adequate Contracting Compensation," is subject to dismissal, as said claim is based on "[t]hreadbare recitals of the elements of [the] cause of action, supported by mere conclusory statements,"
9. The Ninth Cause of Action, titled "Violation of California's Unfair Competition Law," is, as pleaded, derivative of the First through Eighth Causes of Action, and, consequently is:
a. subject to dismissal to the extent based on the First through Fourth Causes of Action;
b. not subject to dismissal to the extent based on the Fifth Cause of Action;
c. subject to dismissal only to the extent based on the portion of the Sixth Cause of Action that is subject to dismissal;
d. subject to dismissal to the extent based on the Seventh and Eighth Causes of Action.
In her opposition, plaintiff requests leave to amend, which request will be granted, as it does not appear plaintiff cannot cure at least some of the deficiencies identified above.
In light of the Court's dismissal of the majority of the claims asserted in the operative pleading, and plaintiff's opportunity to amend her dismissed claims, the Court will deny Amazon's motion to strike the class allegations, without prejudice to refiling after plaintiff has amended, or, alternatively, decides not to do so.
For the reasons stated above:
1. Amazon's motion to dismiss is hereby GRANTED in part and DENIED in part, as follows:
a. The First through Fourth, Seventh, and Eighth Causes of Action are DISMISSED in their entirety;
b. The Sixth Cause of Action is DISMISSED to the extent it is based on the First through Fourth Causes of Action;
c. The Ninth Cause of Action is DISMISSED to the extent it is based on the First through Fourth, Seventh and Eighth Causes of Action, and to the extent it is based on the portion of the Sixth Cause of Action that is subject to dismissal;
2. Plaintiff's request for leave to amend is hereby GRANTED, and plaintiff shall file a Third Amended Complaint no later than April 27, 2018. If plaintiff does not file a Third Amended Complaint within the time provided, the instant action will proceed on the remaining claims in the SAC.
3. Amazon's motion to strike is hereby DENIED without prejudice.
4. The Case Management Conference is hereby CONTINUED from April 27, 2018, to June 29, 2018, at 10:30 a.m. A Joint Case Management Statement shall be filed no later than June 22, 2018.