CHRISTOPHER L. RAY, Magistrate Judge.
Jimmie Alexander died after a delay in treatment of a blood clot while a detainee at Chatham County Detention Center (CCDC). Doc. 26-1. After complaining of pain in his leg the evening of May 22, 2016, he was seen by medical staff but was not immediately admitted to the infirmary. Defendants argue that he was moved to an observation room in "receiving and discharge," because there were no infirmary beds available. See Depo. Mark Dambach, LPN at 104-132. Alexander was not seen until 3:00 p.m. the next day, when the Corizon Health physician evaluated him and determined he required emergency care. See Depo. Guy Augustin, M.D. at 161-166. Despite being rushed to the emergency room for surgery the evening of May 23, 2016, Alexander died of complications arising post-surgery. See Depo. Anthony Avino, M.D. at 30-35, 52, 77 & 103. Plaintiffs contend that, because Alexander was not admitted to the infirmary where he could be seen by on-duty medical providers, his treatment was delayed by 15 hours until he could be seen by the Corizon Health physician. They further contend that infirmary beds must have opened up during the 15 hours he was not being seen by a medical provider in the observation room, and that Alexander should have been admitted when they opened.
Based on deposition testimony, plaintiffs believe that the admissions and discharges to the infirmary were memorialized in writing. Doc. 43 at 5-6. The nighttime RN on duty on May 22, 2016, testified that Corizon Health providers regularly kept a "discharge book" reflecting "the time [patients] came in, and the time they left" while she worked at the CCDC. See Depo. Montine Stokes, RN at 40-42. Plaintiffs have been on the hunt for the discharge book since, seeking it from Corizon Health (which has since stopped providing medical services to CCDC), the Sheriff and Chatham County (who contracts out medical services at CCDC and thus has no access to medical records), and Correct Health (a non-party which took over the contract to provide medical services to CCDC). In their discovery responses, these respondents again and again made clear that they did not have the infirmary discharge book. Doc. 43 at Exhs. 9, 12, 15 & 17 (responses by the Sheriff and County); Exhs. 18, 20 & 23 (responses by Corizon Health); Exhs. 16 & 26 (affidavit of "no records" by non-party Correct Health).
Plaintiffs thus have moved to compel production of the long-sought infirmary discharge logs. Doc. 43. The relief they seek in bringing their motion, however, is unclear. They explain:
Doc. 43 at 13. A motion to compel, of course, is not the appropriate vehicle to seek redundant discovery responses or an affidavit to support responses already submitted under the assurance of Fed. R. Civ. P. 11.
Given respondents' unambiguous responses in both discovery and their responses to this motion, it is clear that all disclaim having "possession, custody, or control" over the infirmary discharge logs, if they ever existed. So, there is nothing to compel. The motion (doc. 43) must be
One final matter. While the Court appreciates the reason plaintiffs had for believing the infirmary discharge logs exist(ed), it is skeptical of their reasons for bringing a motion to compel. After all, counsel for respondents had represented, repeatedly, in writing and subject to Rule 11, that they did not have the logs. Correct Health contends that the motion to compel was frivolous, and that under the mandatory fee-shifting provision of Rule 37 they are entitled to an award of costs. Doc. 56; see Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(5)(B) ("If the motion is denied, the court. . . must, after giving an opportunity to be heard, require the movant, the attorney filing the motion, or both to pay the party or deponent who opposed the motion its reasonable expenses incurred in opposing the motion, including attorney's fees.").
Plaintiffs have not responded to Correct Health's request for fees. They are, however, entitled to an opportunity to be heard. Id. Plaintiffs are therefore