Filed: Mar. 05, 2012
Latest Update: Mar. 05, 2012
Summary: OPINION AND ORDER JOHN E. STEELE, District Judge. This matter comes before the Court on a Motion to Dismiss (Doc. #8) filed on August 22, 2011, by plaintiff Jillian Mitchenall (Mitchenall or plaintiff). Mitchenall seeks to dismiss Speedy's Airboat Tours, Inc.'s Petition for Exoneration From or Limitation of Liability for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Petitioner Speedy's Airboat Tours, Inc. (Speedy's Airboat or petitioner)filed a response in opposition on September 6, 2011. (Doc. #10.)
Summary: OPINION AND ORDER JOHN E. STEELE, District Judge. This matter comes before the Court on a Motion to Dismiss (Doc. #8) filed on August 22, 2011, by plaintiff Jillian Mitchenall (Mitchenall or plaintiff). Mitchenall seeks to dismiss Speedy's Airboat Tours, Inc.'s Petition for Exoneration From or Limitation of Liability for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Petitioner Speedy's Airboat Tours, Inc. (Speedy's Airboat or petitioner)filed a response in opposition on September 6, 2011. (Doc. #10.) F..
More
OPINION AND ORDER
JOHN E. STEELE, District Judge.
This matter comes before the Court on a Motion to Dismiss (Doc. #8) filed on August 22, 2011, by plaintiff Jillian Mitchenall (Mitchenall or plaintiff). Mitchenall seeks to dismiss Speedy's Airboat Tours, Inc.'s Petition for Exoneration From or Limitation of Liability for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Petitioner Speedy's Airboat Tours, Inc. (Speedy's Airboat or petitioner)filed a response in opposition on September 6, 2011. (Doc. #10.) For the reasons discussed below, the motion to dismiss is denied.
The Complaint for Exoneration From or Limitation of Liability (the Complaint)(Doc. #1) alleges that Speedy's Airboat is the owner of a 16-foot Bobby Jones/Cottonmoust airboat which, on or about March 3, 2011, was operating near Everglades City in Collier County, Florida when it collided with mangroves. As a result of the collision, two passengers of the airboat were injured. Speedy's Airboat contends it is entitled to exoneration from liability, or alternatively, that liability should be limited to the $7,500.00 value of Speedy's Airboat's interest in the vessel. Mitchenall alleges that the accident occurred in the Everglades at certain specific coordinates in an area known as Sally Slough (Doc. #8, ¶ 3), and "[b]y information and belief, this accident occurred in very shallow water in an area only big enough for one airboat to pass." (Doc. #8, ¶ 4.) Based on this, Mitchenall asserts that the accident did not occur on "navigable waters" and therefore the court lacks subject matter jurisdiction.
This Court has discussed admiralty jurisdiction and navigable waters within the Everglades in In re Everglades Island Boat Tours, LLC, 484 F.Supp.2d 1259 (M.D. Fla. April 23, 2007). The factual matters presented at this stage of the proceedings establish that the accident occurred in navigable waters. See Affidavit of Phillip T. Johnson, owner and President of Speedy's Airboat Tours, Inc. (Doc. #10-1.) Therein, he attests that during the voyage at issue, the airboat traveled from Speedy Boat's dock "on the Barron River through various different waterways, channels and bodies of water to access Sally Slough." (Id. at ¶ 9.) Johnson attests that the Sally Slough is connected to the Barron River, which connects directly to the Chokoloskee Bay and the Gulf of Mexico. Johnson attests that the Sally Slough is used by Speedy's Airboats for sightseeing tours through the Everglades. Attached to his affidavit are two maps that demonstrate the approximate position of the incident. (Doc. #10-2.) This case is thus factually dissimilar to In re Complaint of Bridges Enterprises, Inc., No. 02-60270-CIV, 2003 WL 23305261 (S.D. Fla. Oct. 14, 2003) and Lykes Bros. Inc. v. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, 821 F.Supp. 1457 (M.D. Fla. 1993). Accordingly, the Court concludes that petitioner has established admiralty jurisdiction at this stage of the proceedings.
Accordingly, it is now
ORDERED:
The Motion to Dismiss (Doc. #8) is DENIED.
DONE AND ORDERED.