MOTION FOR JUDGMENT FOR ATTORNEY'S FEES AND RECOVERY OF COURT COSTS
ELAINE E. BUCKLO, District Judge.
Plaintiffs, LOCAL NO. 1 S.E.I.U. PENSION TRUST FUND and LOCAL NO. 1 S.E.I.U. HEALTH FUND, bring this motion to recover attorneys' fees and court costs from Defendant, REALTY & MORTGAGE BUILDING SERVICES CO., an Illinois Corporation, pursuant to FED. R. CIV. P. 54(d) and the provisions of a collective bargaining agreement enforceable under section 301 of the Taft-Hartley Act, 29 U.S.C. § 185(a).
1) On June 19, 2017, Plaintiffs filed the instant action under ERISA, 29 U.S.C. §§ 502(a)(3), 502(g)(2), and 515 to collect from Defendant the balance remaining due and owing of $15,522.09 on the Settlement Agreement entered into between the Funds and the Defendant.
2) The Defendant's failure to pay the balance of $15,522.09 led to the filing of the instant suit. Attached as Exhibit 1 is a copy of the Settlement Agreement entered into between the parties in the instant action.
3) Subsequent to the filing of the instant action and commencement of the litigation, the Defendant, REALTY & MORTGAGE BUILDING SERVICES CO., filed a third-party complaint against the Chicago Housing Authority, claiming therein that the Chicago Housing Authority was obligated to reimburse Defendant, REALTY & MORTGAGE BUILDING SERVICES CO., for the monies claimed due and owing to the Plaintiff Funds.
4) Over more than one year subsequent to the filing of the instant action, and numerous court status calls and hearings on various motions filed by the parties, only then did the Plaintiffs receive payment in full of the delinquent contributions claimed to be due and owing to the Funds, i.e., the balance of the monies due under the Settlement Agreement, which monies were deposited with the Plaintiff Funds by the third-party defendant, Chicago Housing Authority.
5) Plaintiffs have unnecessarily incurred the expense of attorneys' fees in the amount of $10,481.25, which claimed amount is supported by contemporaneous records maintained by Plaintiffs' Counsel, Robert B. Greenberg, and others in his law firm who worked on the litigation along with Mr. Greenberg. See Exhibit 2 attached hereto.
6) That the Plaintiffs incurred court costs totaling $460.00, which were composed of $400.00 initial filing fee charged by the court, and $60.00 for service of summons charged by the Stern Process & Investigation Company.
7) As provided in the ERISA Statute, Chapter 29, Section 1132(G)(2)(D), the attorneys are entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees and costs in the action which are to be paid by defendant. Although there is no specific judgment entered in the instant action, in fact, payment in full was made during the pendency of the lawsuit, negating the Court's finding a judgment against the Defendant, but, in recognition of the fact that all the issues were decided in favor of the Plaintiff, the attorneys' fees and court costs should be awarded.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray that the Court enter judgment in favor of Plaintiffs and against the Defendant in the amount of $10,866.25 as and for recovery of attorneys' fees and court costs.
Exhibit 1
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED by and between SEIU Local Union No. 1 Health and Welfare Fund and SEIU Local Union No. 1 Pension Fund (hereinafter the "Funds") and Realty and Mortgage Building Services Co. (hereinafter "Realty"), and without any admission herein of liability or wrongdoing, the parties have agreed to settlement of the Funds' claims for delinquent contributions for the period ending January 31, 2016.
1. The Funds claim that Realty is a successor to certain Chicago Housing Authority contracts for various buildings previously managed by East Lake Management and Development Corp., Habitat Realty and Management Company, Inc., and or any other management companies previously hired by Chicago Housing Authority for the various buildings as listed on the Memorandum of Agreement attached hereto, which contracts commenced on or about October 1, 2015, and Realty denies that it is delinquent for payments due the Funds.
2. Realty disputes that it is a successor to the East Lake Management and Development Corp., Habitat Realty and Management Company, Inc., and or any other management companies previously hired by Chicago Housing Authority for the various buildings as listed on the Memorandum of Agreement attached hereto, and Realty denies that it is delinquent for payments due the Funds.
3. Realty hereby agrees to pay to the Funds $36,502.48 in monthly payments of $3,041.88 commencing on March 10, 2016, in addition to its normal payments due on that date, and each month thereafter, through and including February 10, 2017.
4. Realty further agrees to pay the contributions due for the months of December 2015, January 2016 and February 2016, on or before March 10, 2016, for all buildings it manages as covered by the Memorandum of Agreement attached hereto.
5. In consideration of the payments and obligations set forth above, the Funds for themselves and on behalf of their various respective trustees, agents, successors, assigns, attorneys, employees, administrators, and legal representatives, hereby fully, finally, and unconditionally release and forever discharge Realty, and its officers, directors, members, shareholders, agents, attorneys, employees, representatives, affiliates, subsidiaries, successors and assigns, in both its personal and fiduciary capacities, from any and all actions, causes of action, suits, arbitrations, debts, dues, demands, sums of money, executions, liabilities, claims and demands, whether known or unknown, liquidated or unliquidated, absolute or contingent, in law or equity, which were filed or could have been filed with any federal, state, local or private court, agency, arbitrator or any other entity, including claims related to the period (October 1, 2015, through January 31, 2016), or claims otherwise based directly upon any contractual obligation whatsoever to the Funds relating to the obligation of Realty to pay contributions to the Funds, plus attorneys' fees or any other fees, costs, expenses, or damages incurred therein, up to and including January 31, 2016. The Funds' release does not release any claims, known or unknown, subsequent to Januar), 31, 2016, or any discrepancies disclosed by an audit of Realty's books and records after December 1, 2015.
6. In consideration of the obligations set forth above, Realty, its officers, directors, shareholders, affiliates, subsidiaries, agents, attorneys, employees, representatives, successors and assigns, in their personal and fiduciary capacities, hereby fully, finally and unconditionally release and forever discharge the Funds, their trustees, officers, respective agents, assigns, attorneys, employees, administrators and legal representatives from any and all actions, causes of action, suits, arbitrations, debts, dues, sums of money, executions, liabilities, liens, damages, grievances, injuries, actions or rights of action of any nature whatsoever, known or unknown, liquidated or unliquidated, absolute or contingent, in law or in equity, which were filed or could have been filed with any federal, state, local or private court, agency, arbitrator or any entity, including but not necessarily limited to claims made relating to the audit period referenced in paragraph 1 of this Settlement Agreement (October 1, 2015) or claims otherwise based directly or indirectly upon any contractual obligations whatsoever to the Funds relating to the obligation of Realty to pay contributions to the Funds, or any other fees, costs, expenses, or damages incurred therein, up to and including the date of this Settlement Agreement and Release.
7. This Agreement constitutes the full and complete understanding between the parties concerning its subject matter, and supersedes any and all prior agreements or understandings with respect to its subject matter.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties or their duly authorized agents have duly executed this Settlement Agreement as of the day and year provided below.
SEIU Local Union No. 1 Health and Welfare
Fund and SEIU Local Union No. 1 Pension
Fund
By: _____________________________ Dated: 3-1-2016
Realty and Mortgage Building Services co.
By: _____________________________ Dated: 3/1/16
Exhibit 2
A B C D E F G H
1 Matter Date Timekeepe Bill Hours Rate Amount Narrative
2 GEN 01/14/2016 RBG 27527 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Review regarding status.
3 GEN 01/15/2016 RBG 27527 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Review and exchange emails.
4 GEN 01/27/2016 RBG 27527 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review. Conference with Tom Posey. Telephone
call to Efram Elias regarding status.
5 GEN 01/28/2016 LJE 27527 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty — Conference with Rick, JV, TB, Efram, Maria.
GEN 01/28/2016 RBG 27527 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review proposed settlement memorandum of
6 agreement and response to Efram Elias.
7 GEN 01/29/2016 LJE 27527 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty — Telephone call with JV.
8 GEN 01/29/2016 LJE 27527 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty — Telephone call with JV.
9 GEN 01/29/2016 RBG 27527 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Review and email to Efram Elias. Conference with attorney Posey.
10 GEN 02/01/2016 RBG 27640 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty & Mortgage — Conference with Elberts regarding action against Realty & Mortgage
and review McCormack Baron contract.
11 GEN 02/01/2016 LJE 27640 0.75 225.00 168.75 Realty Mortgage — Review emails and CBA. Conference with Robert Greenberg.
12 GEN 02/02/2016 LJE 27640 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — JV and RBG.
13 GEN 02/02/2016 RBG 27640 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty Mortgage — Telephone conference with Jim Vanek and Lee Elberts regarding
McCormak and Realty Mortgage litigation.
14 GEN 02/04/2016 RBG 27640 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone conference with attorneya Tom Posey regarding status.
15 GEN 02/05/2016 RBG 27640 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review and set up meeting. Email to Tom Posey.
16 GEN 02/10/2016 RBG 27640 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty & Mortgage — Review and conferences with Vanek and Efram Elias.
17 GEN 02/11/2016 RBG 27640 2.50 225.00 562.50 Realty & Mortgage — Conference with Vanek, Pizarro and Elias regarding pending action
and settlement.
18 GEN 02/16/2016 RBG 27640 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review and telephone conference with Vanek regarding status.
19 GEN 02/17/2016 RBG 27640 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review regarding status settlement.
20 GEN 02/22/2016 LJE 27640 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Telephone call with JV.
21 GEN 02/23/2016 RBG 27640 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty & Mortgage — Preparation of settlement agreement.
22 GEN 02/29/2016 RBG 27640 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review regarding signed CBA and status settlement agreement.
Telephone call to attorney Posey.
23 GEN 03/14/2016 RBG 27788 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review regarding Jim Vanek's email.
24 GEN 03/21/2016 LJE 27788 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review regarding Vanek missives and preparation of report for
Trustees.
25 GEN 04/04/2016 RBG 27877 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review status and emails from Liz Del Cid and JimVanek.
26 GEN 04/05/2016 RBG 27877 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Signed agreement emailed to Posey, Vanek and Del Cid.
27 GEN 04/07/2016 RBG 27877 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review miscellaneous emails regarding status.
28 GEN 04/11/2016 RBG 27877 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review and call to Vanek regarding status.
29 GEN 06/13/2016 RBG 28109 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review re: status.
30 GEN 06/27/2016 RBG 28109 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review & report for Trustees.
31 GEN 06/27/2016 RBG 28109 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage Co. — Review & report for Trustees.
32 GEN 07/26/2016 RBG 28224 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review re: status settlement & payments. Email
to Grizel.
33 GEN 08/10/2016 RBG 28319 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Review regarding status received from Grizel.
34 GEN 09/12/2016 RBG 28442 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Review and report for Trustees.
35 GEN 11/30/2016 RBG 28662 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Conference with M. Raimondi. Review and email to attorneys Posey
and Vanek.
36 GEN 11/30/2016 RBG 28662 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review & report for Trustees.
37 GEN 12/06/2016 RBG 28818 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone conference with attorney Posey regarding claim.
38 GEN 12/09/2016 RBG 28818 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Review regarding status payments delinquent.
39 GEN 12/15/2016 RBG 28818 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Review re: status.
40 GEN 02/01/2017 RBG 29038 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review and call to Michele Raimondi regarding status of monthly
payments.
41 GEN 02/06/2017 RBG 29038 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Review regarding status.
42 GEN 02/09/2017 RBG 29038 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Review with Fund office regarding status and email to Tom Posey and
Jim Vanek regarding default.
43 GEN 03/01/2017 RBG 29194 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Review re: status. Calls to Vanek and Posey.
44 GEN 03/01/2017 RBG 29194 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Review regarding status and joinder in litigation. (2/9/17)
45 GEN 03/08/2017 RBG 29194 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review and telephone call to attorney Posey.
46 GEN 03/16/2017 RBG 29194 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review and email to Vanek.
47 GEN 03/27/2017 RBG 29194 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone call to Vanek regarding enforcement of settlement.
48 GEN 04/10/2017 RBG 29309 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Telephone call to Vanek regarding settlement agreement default and
conference with Vanek re: possible lawsuit
49 GEN 04/26/2017 RBG 29309 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty Mortgage — Facts Investigation, Review regarding lawsuit to enforce settlement
agreement
50 GEN 04/27/2017 RBG 29309 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Dictate, review & email to attorney Posey
51 GEN 05/01/2017 RBG 29408 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review & report for Trustess (04/07/2017)
52 GEN 05/11/2017 RBG 29408 2.00 225.00 450.00 Realty & Mortgage Building — Preparation complaint & email to Vanet
53 GEN 06/07/2017 RBG 29565 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review & report for trustee's
54 GEN 06/16/2017 RBG 29565 2.00 225.00 450.00 Realty & Mortgage — Revised complaint, preparation & filing
55 GEN 07/05/2017 RBG 29842 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Court appearance for filing return of summons
56 GEN 07/11/2017 RBG 29842 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review regarding court's order & compliance
26CF regarding mandatory discovery order
57 GEN 07/19/2017 RBG 29842 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Telephone conference with attorney Bob Slobig
58 GEN 08/01/2017 RBG 29843 0.50 225.00 112.50 Reality & Mortgage — Review answer and motion (5/15/2017)
59 GEN 08/01/2017 LJE 29843 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Dictate email to JV
60 GEN 08/03/2017 RBG 29843 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review regarding court's order
61 GEN 08/07/2017 RBG 29843 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Facts Investigation, review docket regarding scheduling 26f
62 GEN 08/14/2017 RBG 29843 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review & response to Vaneke email-Conference with Elberts
regarding status
63 GEN 08/14/2017 LJE 29843 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty Mortgage — Conference with Robert B. Greenberg & Alexander Rosenthal
64 GEN 09/14/2017 RBG 29932 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Facts Investigation, Court's order resetting status date
65 GEN 09/20/2017 RBG 29932 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Management — Review and report for trustees
66 GEN 09/27/2017 RBG 29932 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone conference defense counsel and conference with Maria
Pizzavo
67 GEN 09/28/2017 RBG 29932 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty & Mortgage — Court appearance status and scheduling call
68 GEN 11/08/2017 RBG 30132 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review & telephone conference with CHA attorney Brian Harrington
regarding settlement
69 GEN 11/13/2017 RBG 30132 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review & report for trustees
70 GEN 11/15/2017 RBG 30132 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone conference with attorney Slobig regarding status
71 GEN 11/28/2017 RBG 30132 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review regarding settlement, court's order and email to attorney
72 GEN 12/27/2017 RBG 30278 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review regarding status and calls to atty. Slobig & CHA attorney
Harrington
73 GEN 01/15/2018 RBG 30378 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone call from & to Ryan Harrington
74 GEN 01/16/2018 RBG 30378 1.50 225.00 337.50 Realty & Mortgage — Court appearance, status call, review regarding claim & verification
conference with CHA attorney Ryan Harrington
75 GEN 02/01/2018 RBG 30472 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone call to attorney Slobig regarding status settlement
76 GEN 02/15/2018 RBG 30472 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review regarding status & courts order resetting to 3-14-18
77 GEN 02/22/2018 RBG 30472 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty Mortgage — Telephone call to attorney Slobig regarding status settlement
78 GEN 03/14/2018 RBG 30620 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty & Mortgage — Court appearance, status call & email documents to CHH attorney
79 GEN 03/14/2018 RBG 30620 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage Co — Review & report for trustees
80 GEN 03/26/2018 RBG 30620 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review regarding emailed reports, conference with Kali and email to
attorney Harrington
81 GEN 04/10/2018 RBG 30673 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone call to Ryan Harrington at CHA regarding settlement
82 GEN 04/12/2018 RBG 30673 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review regarding Harrington e-mail
83 GEN 05/03/2018 RBG 30827 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone call to CHA attorney Harington regarding status
84 GEN 05/08/2018 RBG 30827 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone call to Harrington at CHA regarding status
85 GEN 05/10/2018 RBG 30827 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Telephone call to attorney Harrington regarding settlement
86 GEN 05/14/2018 RBG 30827 0.25 225.00 56.25 Reality & Mortgage — Telephone call to attorney Slobig regarding status settlement
87 GEN 05/21/2018 RBG 30827 0.50 225.00 112.50 Realty & Mortgage — Review regarding settlement per attorney Harington's e-mail
88 GEN 05/23/2018 RBG 30827 1.25 225.00 281.25 Realty & Mortgage — Status conference, discussion with attorney Ryan Harrington
regarding payments being made & to what buildings
89 GEN 06/13/2018 RBG 30974 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review 3rd party motion for summary judgement
90 GEN 06/19/2018 RBG 30974 0.25 225.00 56.25 Realty & Mortgage — Review & report for trustees
91 GEN 7/25/2018 RBG 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty & Mortgage — Motion to dismiss Summary Judgement
92 GEN 8/1/2018 RBG 1.00 225.00 225.00 Realty & Mortgage — Preparation of motion for costs & attorney's fees.
93 Total 45.25 10181.25