DSM IP Assets, B.V. v. Lallemand Specialties, Inc., 16-cv-497-wmc. (2018)
Court: District Court, E.D. Wisconsin
Number: infdco20180507b15
Visitors: 16
Filed: May 04, 2018
Latest Update: May 04, 2018
Summary: ORDER WILLIAM M. CONLEY , District Judge . On the parties' deposition designations, counter-designations and objections as to Ryan Skinner, the court rules as follows: Lallemand's DSM's Court DSM's Lallemand's Objections Lallemand's Court Designations Objections Ruling Counter- to Counter Ruling Designa
Summary: ORDER WILLIAM M. CONLEY , District Judge . On the parties' deposition designations, counter-designations and objections as to Ryan Skinner, the court rules as follows: Lallemand's DSM's Court DSM's Lallemand's Objections Lallemand's Court Designations Objections Ruling Counter- to Counter Ruling Designat..
More
ORDER
WILLIAM M. CONLEY, District Judge.
On the parties' deposition designations, counter-designations and objections as to Ryan Skinner, the court rules as follows:
Lallemand's DSM's Court DSM's Lallemand's Objections Lallemand's Court
Designations Objections Ruling Counter- to Counter Ruling
Designations DSM's Designations
Counter-
Designations
11:7-11:8 11:12-12:22 Irrelevant (FRE 402); Overruled.
Waste of Time (FRE
403)
18:12-18:16 18:9-18:11 Sustain:
23:9-23:17; Irrelevant (FRE 402); 23:16, 19-22;
23:19-24:4 Prejudicial/Confusing/ 24:1-4.
Misleading (FRE 403); Overruled
Lack of Personal as to
Knowledge (FRE 602); remainder.
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702)
26:11-26:19 27:3-27:15 Irrelevant (FRE 402); Sustain:
Prejudicial/Confusing/ 27:8-15.
Misleading (FRE 403); Overruled
Lack of Personal as to
Knowledge (FRE 602); remainder.
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702);
Includes Attorney
Objection (FRE 611(a))
35:10-35:11 MIL #3, FRE Sustain. 35:12 Attorney Objection Sustain.
403, 702
35:13-35:14 MIL #3, FRE Sustain. 35:15 Strike.
403, 702
35:16-36:9 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 52:18-53:11 [53:9-11] Lack of Overruled.
403, 702 Personal Knowledge
(FRE 602); Seeks
Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702)
53:17-54:3 [53:21-54:3] Lack of Overruled.
Personal Knowledge
(FRE 602); Seeks
Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702)
54:5-54:9 Improper Counter- Sustain.
Designation as Beyond
the Scope;
Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702);
Includes Attorney
Objection (FRE 611(a))
54:17-55:11 Improper Counter- Sustain.
Designation as Beyond
the Scope;
Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Hypothetical;
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702);
Includes Attorney
Objection (FRE 611(a))
56:6-58:6 Improper Counter- Sustain.
Designation as Beyond
the Scope;
Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Hypothetical;
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702);
Includes Attorney
Objection (FRE 611(a))
59:11-59:14 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
63:13-60:15 MIL #3, FRE Sustain.
403, 702
60:17-60:19 MIL #3, FRE Sustain.
403, 702
60:21-61:1 MIL #3, FRE Overruled 61:8-61:12
403, 702
61:13-61:15 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
61:17-61:18 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
61:20-61:21 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
62:1-62:2 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
62:4-62:7 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 62:8-62:14
403, 702
62:15-63:1 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 63:2-64:10
403, 702
64:19-65:1 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
65:5-65:7 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
65:10-66:4 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
67:12-68:1 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 68:2 Attorney Objection Sustain.
403, 702
68:3 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 68:5-8
403, 702
69:13-69:20 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 69:21-70:13 Strike 70:2-7
403, 702
70:22-71:8 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 73:22-75:3 Lack of Personal Sustain.
403, 702 Knowledge (FRE 602);
75:15-76:10; Hypothetical; Sustain:
76:12-76:19 Seeks Improper Expert 75:21; 76:7,
Opinion (FRE 701/702); 15.
Includes Attorney Overruled
Objection (FRE 611(a)) as to
remainder.
78:2-78:6 Irrelevant (FRE 402); Sustain.
Prejudicial/Confusing/
Misleading (FRE 403);
Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702);
Includes Attorney
Objection (FRE 611(a))
80:5-80:7 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
80:16-81:2 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
82:3-85:10 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
86:13-87:5 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
87:12-88:3 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
88:19-89:1 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
89:7-90:10 MIL #3, FRE Overruled.
403, 702
90:17-91:4 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 91:5-93:2 [92:3-9] [92:18-93:2] Overruled.
403, 702 Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702)
93:3-93:11 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 93:12-94:1 Improper Counter- Sustain:
403, 702 Designation as Beyond 93:15, 21.
the Scope Overruled
as to
Irrelevant (FRE 402); remainder.
Prejudicial/Confusing/
Misleading (FRE 403);
Includes Attorney
Objection (FRE 611(a))
94:19-94:21 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 94:3-94:17 Improper Counter- Sustain:
403, 702 Designation as Beyond 94:6, 14.
the Scope Overruled
Prejudicial/Confusing/ as to
Misleading (FRE 403); remainder.
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702);
Includes Attorney
Objections (FRE 611(a))
95:11-97:11 MIL #3, FRE Overruled. 97:17-100:4 Improper Counter- Overruled.
403, 702 Designation as Beyond
the Scope
Irrelevant (FRE 402);
Prejudicial/Confusing/
Misleading (FRE 403)
100:17- Improper Counter- Sustain:
102:2 Designation as Beyond 101:14;
the Scope Overruled
Irrelevant (FRE 402); as to
Prejudicial/Confusing/ remainder.
Misleading (FRE 403);
Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702);
Includes Attorney
Objections (FRE 611(a))
104:21- Improper Counter- 109:8-11 Overruled.
104:22; Designation as Beyond
1105:5- the Scope
105:10; Irrelevant (FRE 402);
108:15-109:7 Prejudicial/Confusing/
Misleading (FRE 403)
109:16-111:2 Improper Counter- Sustain:
Designation as Beyond 109:21.
the Scope Overruled
Irrelevant (FRE 402); as to
Prejudicial/Confusing/ remainder.
Misleading (FRE 403);
Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702);
Includes Attorney
Objections (FRE 611(a))
113:22-116:4 Improper Counter- 116:5-15 Sustain:
Designation as Beyond 113:22-116:4.
the Scope
Irrelevant (FRE 402); Strike:
Prejudicial/Confusing/ 116:5-15.
Misleading (FRE 403);
Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702)
119:22-120:12 Improper Counter- Sustain.
Designation as Beyond
the Scope
Irrelevant (FRE 402);
Prejudicial/Confusing/
Misleading (FRE 403);
Lack of Personal
Knowledge (FRE 602);
Seeks Improper Expert
Opinion (FRE 701/702)
Source: Leagle
