IRENE M. KEELEY, District Judge.
On October 18, 2017, the Court conducted an evidentiary hearing by telephone regarding the plaintiff's Emergency Motion for the Appointment of a Receiver (Dkt. No. 3), Supplemental Motion for the Appointment of a Receiver (Dkt. No. 20), and Renewed Motion for the Appointment of a Receiver (Dkt. No. 24). For the reasons stated on the record, as well as the reasons that follow, the Court
The plaintiff, U.S. Bank National Association, as Trustee for the benefit of the Holders of COMM 2013-CCRE12 Mortgage Trust Commercial Mortgage Pass-Through Certificates ("U.S. Bank"), is the holder of a $15,470,000 loan made to the defendant, Mountain Blue Hotel Group, LLC ("Mountain Blue"), in 2013 (Dkt. Nos. 3-4; 3-5; 3-6). Mountain Blue's obligations under the promissory note are secured by a deed of trust (Dkt. No. 3-7). That deed of trust encompasses real property comprising the "Hilton Garden Inn Morgantown" located at Suncrest Towne Centre, 201 Memorial Highway, Morgantown, West Virginia ("Property").
District courts possess inherent equitable powers under federal common law that include authority to appoint a receiver.
Standing alone, a contractual provision for a court-appointed receiver provides strong support for such an appointment if the contractual predicates are satisfied.
Here, U.S. Bank provided sufficient evidence to satisfy the Court that the contracts at issue, as well as the relevant equitable factors, warrant the appointment of a receiver. First, Mountain Blue's failure to pay franchise fees to Hilton Garden Inns Franchise LLC ("Hilton") constituted a material default that permitted Hilton to cancel Mountain Blue's franchise agreement (Dkt. Nos. 3-9; 3-10; 3-12). A material default under the franchise agreement constitutes an event of default under the loan agreement (Dkt. No. 3-5 at 35-37). Further, Mountain Blue's failure to pay state taxes and local hotel taxes, as well as its inability to pay operating and other expenses as they became due, constituted additional events of default under the loan agreement (Dkt. No. 3-5 at 35). Each of these events of default permit U.S. Bank to demand full payment, seek foreclosure, and apply for the appointment of a receiver under the deed of trust (Dkt. No. 3-7 at 13-14). Thus, U.S. Bank is within its contractual rights to seek the appointment of a receiver.
Second, current circumstances at the Property weigh heavily in favor of appointing a receiver. The value of the Property, and thus its adequacy to satisfy Mountain Blue's debt to U.S. Bank, is directly tied to its continued operation as a hotel under the Hilton franchise agreement. Evidence admitted at the evidentiary hearing established that Mountain Blue recently failed to pay additional fees owed to Hilton, again putting the franchise agreement at risk of termination (Dkt. No. 27-5). Additionally, Mountain Blue's failure to oppose the Monongalia County Commission's tax complaint against it resulted in a default judgment, imposing a lien on the Property for the amount of $144,315.63 (Dkt. No. 19-2). Moreover, under the loan documents, the Property is U.S. Bank's primary source of recovery. Absent the appointment of a receiver to manage the Property and prevent its value from being adversely affected by the inability to operate as a Hilton franchisee, U.S. Bank has no adequate legal remedy.
Finally, the appointment of a receiver will effectively protect U.S. Bank's interest in the Property. A receiver will be able to use money advanced by U.S. Bank to remain current with Mountain Blue's obligations to Hilton, meet payroll requirements, and pay operating and other expenses as they become due. U.S. Bank's interest in protecting the value of the Property clearly outweighs Mountain Blue's interest in avoiding the appointment of a receiver. In fact, Mountain Blue agreed in the loan documents that a receivership would be appropriate under these circumstances (Dkt. Nos. 3-5 at 35-38; 3-7 at 14-15).
In conclusion, for the reasons discussed, the Court
It is so
The Clerk shall transmit copies of this Order to counsel of record.