TRUSTEES OF THE SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA PIPE TRADES HEALTH AND WELFARE TRUST FUND v. C H STONE PLUMBING CO. INC., CV 13-1339 GAF (SPx). (2014)
Court: District Court, C.D. California
Number: infdco20140514a19
Visitors: 6
Filed: May 13, 2014
Latest Update: May 13, 2014
Summary: CIVIL MINUTES — GENERAL GARY ALLEN FEESS, District Judge. Proceedings: (In Chambers) RULING ON EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS The following sets forth the Court's ruling on objections to testimony submitted in declaration form. A. PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS Declaration of David Dean Page: Line Objection Ruling 7:15-16 Hearsay SUSTAINED if offered for truth of matter asserted. Court will admit it for the limited purpose of impe
Summary: CIVIL MINUTES — GENERAL GARY ALLEN FEESS, District Judge. Proceedings: (In Chambers) RULING ON EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS The following sets forth the Court's ruling on objections to testimony submitted in declaration form. A. PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS Declaration of David Dean Page: Line Objection Ruling 7:15-16 Hearsay SUSTAINED if offered for truth of matter asserted. Court will admit it for the limited purpose of impea..
More
CIVIL MINUTES — GENERAL
GARY ALLEN FEESS, District Judge.
Proceedings: (In Chambers)
RULING ON EVIDENTIARY OBJECTIONS
The following sets forth the Court's ruling on objections to testimony submitted in declaration form.
A. PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTIONS
Declaration of David Dean
Page: Line Objection Ruling
7:15-16 Hearsay SUSTAINED if offered for truth of matter
asserted. Court will admit it for the limited
purpose of impeachment as a purported
inconsistent statement with respect to
Campos's testimony.
7:16-17 Hearsay SUSTAINED.
10:2-4 Hearsay; improper legal The evidence will be received for the
conclusion limited purpose of establishing Dean's state
of mind to the extent it is relevant.
SUSTAINED as to all other purposes.
B. DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
Declaration of Jeffrey Goss
Page: Line Objection Ruling
6:1-2 No Foundation To the extent that the testimony is based on
information provided by Campos, it would
be admissible as a prior consistent statement
by Campos regarding what he knew at the
time. The Court would admit it for that
limited purpose. For other purposes the
objection is SUSTAINED.
Declaration of Michael Jung
Page: Line Objection Ruling
2:23-27 Best evidence; hearsay OVERRULED. The evidence establishes
context regarding Exhibit 42, which is the
best evidence of its content.
4:21-24 Best evidence; hearsay; OVERRULED. The objections go to
relevance weight and not admissibility.
4:24-28 Foundation; hearsay; OVERRULED.
conclusion; best
evidence
4:28-5:3 Best evidence; hearsay OVERRULED.
5:3-8 Best evidence. SUSTAINED.
Declaration of Mike Layton
Page: Line Objection Ruling
4:24-27 Conclusion and lacks OVERRULED.
foundation
Declaration of Angela Panomchai
Page: Line Objection Ruling
4:3-8 Best evidence. OVERRULED.
4:19-22 Foundation OVERRULED. The declarant's description
of her work history and job duties
establishes a sufficient foundation.
4:22-5:3 Foundation OVERRULED. The declarant's description
of her work history and job duties
establishes a sufficient foundation.
5:26-28 Foundation; conclusion OVERRULED. The declarant's description
of her work history and job duties
establishes a sufficient foundation.
8:24-26 Foundation; conclusion OVERRULED. The declarant's description
of her work history and job duties
establishes a sufficient foundation.
8:1-7 Relevance OVERRULED.
9:10-12 Speculation OVERRULED.
9:21-23 Opinion; relevance OVERRULED.
10:24-27 Conclusion; foundation OVERRULED.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Source: Leagle
