Filed: Feb. 17, 2015
Latest Update: Feb. 17, 2015
Summary: STIPULATION REGARDING EXCLUDABLE TIME PERIODS UNDER SPEEDY TRIAL ACT; [PROPOSED] FINDINGS AND ORDER WILLIAM B. SHUBB, District Judge. The United States of America through its undersigned counsel, Heiko P. Coppola, Assistant United States Attorney, together with counsel for defendant Andranik Martirosyan, John R. Manning, Esq., hereby stipulate the following: 1. This matter is set for status conference on February 23, 2015. 2. By this stipulation, Mr. Martirosyan now moves to continue the s
Summary: STIPULATION REGARDING EXCLUDABLE TIME PERIODS UNDER SPEEDY TRIAL ACT; [PROPOSED] FINDINGS AND ORDER WILLIAM B. SHUBB, District Judge. The United States of America through its undersigned counsel, Heiko P. Coppola, Assistant United States Attorney, together with counsel for defendant Andranik Martirosyan, John R. Manning, Esq., hereby stipulate the following: 1. This matter is set for status conference on February 23, 2015. 2. By this stipulation, Mr. Martirosyan now moves to continue the st..
More
STIPULATION REGARDING EXCLUDABLE TIME PERIODS UNDER SPEEDY TRIAL ACT; [PROPOSED] FINDINGS AND ORDER
WILLIAM B. SHUBB, District Judge.
The United States of America through its undersigned counsel, Heiko P. Coppola, Assistant United States Attorney, together with counsel for defendant Andranik Martirosyan, John R. Manning, Esq., hereby stipulate the following:
1. This matter is set for status conference on February 23, 2015.
2. By this stipulation, Mr. Martirosyan now moves to continue the status conference until April 27, 2015 at 9:30 a.m.
3. The parties agree and stipulate, and request the Court find the following:
a. Mr. Martisosyan was originally scheduled to be arraigned on July 10, 2012. Due to serious health issues, Mr. Martirosyan was not arraigned until November 28, 2012. The Defense represents Mr. Martirosyan remains in very fragile health.
b. The Government has provided defense Counsel with over 700 pages of discovery.
c. The Defense is seeking a continuance in order to review the material provided by the Government and conduct, as necessary, investigation. (It should be noted, Mr. Martirosyan speaks very limited English and the services of an Armenian language interpreter are necessary to effectively communicate with the defendant.)
d. The defense represents Mr. Martirosyan is gravely ill. His health has been spiraling downward for several years. The downward progression began approximately seven years ago when he was in a car accident and suffered a significant head injury. Presently, he suffers from severe cardiac issues (he had heart surgery just prior to charges being filed in this matter), diabetes, and loss of vision (related to his diabetes — he has had eye surgery during the pendency of this case and may need additional surgery but is unlikely to receive such surgery due to his other health issues). He is in significant pain, but because of his cardiac issues and other health concerns, he is limited in what he can take for his pain. Mr. Martirosyan is frequently disoriented and suffers from memory loss and anger issues. In addition to receiving medical treatment for his physical health issues, Mr. Martirosyan is also receiving treatment from the psychiatric staff for his mental and emotion health concerns.
e. The parties were (and are) considering asking the court to order a competency evaluation. However, Mr. Martirosyan's physical health is extremely compromised. Mr. Martirosyan is virtually bed ridden; he leaves his family house only for MD appointments; and, he is being cared for and is under the watchful eye of at least one family member at all times. I have visited Mr. Martirosyan at his family's home on multiple occasions as he is unable to meet with me at my office. During these visits, Mr. Martirsoyan cannot sit (he lays on the couch — where he spends almost all of his time); he requires the use of oxygen; he appears to be in considerable discomfort; has visible tremors; memory issues; and, he is not alert, relatively speaking, for more than a few minutes at a time.
f. The defense has recently turned over approximately 1600 pages of medical records regarding the defendant. The most recent "batch" of records, consisting of approximately two hundred pages, was turned over recently. The government needs additional time to review of the provided material. Finally, the defense is aware there are additional medical records not yet produced by Kaiser (defendant's treating physicians). The defense is working with Kaiser to ensure the requested, but not yet provided, records are produced as soon as possible. (The records sought relate to Mr. Martisoryan's mental health.) The government needs time to review the material provided by the defense (as well as the recently produced material). The defense needs additional time to facilitate the production of the remaining relevant medical records and ultimately provide the noted records to the government for their review.
g. Counsel for Mr. Martirosyan believes a continuance in this case is necessary to allow the government time to review the material and because the defendant is not physically able to assist in his own defense by meeting with counsel, discussing the case and/or reviewing the discovery.
h. The defendant's prognosis remains uncertain. This continuance is additionally sought, in part, to determine if Mr. Martirosyan's health will stabilize sufficiently to move forward.
i. The Government does not object to the continuance.
j. Based on the above-stated findings, the ends of justice served by granting the requested continuance outweigh the best interests of the public and the defendant in a speedy trial within the original date prescribed by the Speedy Trial Act.
k. For the purpose of computing time under the Speedy Trial Act, 18 United States Code Section 3161(h)(7)(A) within which trial must commence, the time period of February 23, 2015 to April 27, 2015, inclusive, is deemed excludable pursuant to 18 United States Code Section 3161(h)(7)(A) and (B) (iv), corresponding to Local Code T-4 because it results from a continuance granted by the Court at defendant's request on the basis of the Court's finding that the ends of justice served by taking such action outweigh the best interest of the public and the defendant in a speedy trial. The parties agree and further stipulate the defendant is currently "physically unable to stand trial" for purposes of excludable time under 3161(h)(4).
4. Nothing in this stipulation and order shall preclude a finding that other provisions of the Speedy Trial Act dictate that additional time periods are excludable from the period within which a trial must commence.
IT IS SO STIPULATED.
Dated: February 17, 2015. Benjamin B. Wagner
United States Attorney
by: /s/Heiko P. Coppola
HEIKO P. COPPOLA
Assistant U.S. Attorney
ORDER
IT IS SO FOUND AND ORDERED.
