Filed: Jun. 11, 2014
Latest Update: Jun. 11, 2014
Summary: ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL (Re: Docket Nos. 2395, 2410, 2471, 2556, 2557, 2558, 2564, 2610, 2624, 2633, 2664, 2825, 2835, 2836, 2838, 2871, 2872, 2873, 2974, 2975, 2976, 2977, 2991, 2993, 3037, 3039) PAUL S. GREWAL, Magistrate Judge. This court has decried sealing practices in this and related cases on multiple occasions. 1 In recent filings, however, the parties have become more judicious in deciding what information they choose to defend as confidential. Old dogs, it turns out, can learn new
Summary: ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL (Re: Docket Nos. 2395, 2410, 2471, 2556, 2557, 2558, 2564, 2610, 2624, 2633, 2664, 2825, 2835, 2836, 2838, 2871, 2872, 2873, 2974, 2975, 2976, 2977, 2991, 2993, 3037, 3039) PAUL S. GREWAL, Magistrate Judge. This court has decried sealing practices in this and related cases on multiple occasions. 1 In recent filings, however, the parties have become more judicious in deciding what information they choose to defend as confidential. Old dogs, it turns out, can learn new ..
More
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL (Re: Docket Nos. 2395, 2410, 2471, 2556, 2557, 2558, 2564, 2610, 2624, 2633, 2664, 2825, 2835, 2836, 2838, 2871, 2872, 2873, 2974, 2975, 2976, 2977, 2991, 2993, 3037, 3039)
PAUL S. GREWAL, Magistrate Judge.
This court has decried sealing practices in this and related cases on multiple occasions.1 In recent filings, however, the parties have become more judicious in deciding what information they choose to defend as confidential. Old dogs, it turns out, can learn new tricks. Yet there remains a backlog of sealing requests from prior motions to be addressed. It is to these motions, which were filed before the parties made any real progress in reforming their sealing practices, that the court now turns.
In 26 separate administrative motions the parties seek to seal 134 documents. "Historically, courts have recognized a `general right to inspect and copy public records and documents, including judicial records and documents.'"2 Accordingly, when considering a sealing request, "a `strong presumption in favor of access' is the starting point."3 Parties seeking to seal judicial records relating to dispositive motions bear the burden of overcoming the presumption with "compelling reasons" that outweigh the general history of access and the public policies favoring disclosure.4
However, "while protecting the public's interest in access to the courts, we must remain mindful of the parties' right to access those same courts upon terms which will not unduly harm their competitive interest."5 Records attached to nondispositive motions therefore are not subject to the strong presumption of access.6 Because the documents attached to nondispositive motions "are often unrelated, or only tangentially related, to the underlying cause of action," parties moving to seal must meet the lower "good cause" standard of Rule 26(c).7 As with dispositive motions, the standard applicable to nondispositive motions requires a "particularized showing"8 that "specific prejudice or harm will result" if the information is disclosed.9 "Broad allegations of harm, unsubstantiated by specific examples of articulated reasoning" will not suffice.10 A protective order sealing the documents during discovery may reflect the court's previous determination that good cause exists to keep the documents sealed,11 but a blanket protective order that allows the parties to designate confidential documents does not provide sufficient judicial scrutiny to determine whether each particular document should remain sealed.12
In addition to making particularized showings of good cause, parties moving to seal documents must comply with the procedures established by Civ. L.R. 79-5. Pursuant to Civ. L.R. 79-5(b), a sealing order is appropriate only upon a request that establishes the document is "sealable," or "privileged or protectable as a trade secret or otherwise entitled to protection under the law." "The request must be narrowly tailored to seek sealing only of sealable material, and must conform with Civil L.R. 79-5(d)."13 "Within 4 days of the filing of the Administrative Motion to File Under Seal, the Designating Party must file a declaration as required by subsection 79-5(d)(1)(A) establishing that all of the designated material is sealable."14
Motion Document to be Sealed Result Reason/Explanation
to Seal
2395 Samsung's Opposition To UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Apple's Motion To to confidential
Compel Further Discovery business information
And For Sanctions
2395 Pease Declaration ISO UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Samsung's Opposition To to confidential
Apple's Motion To business information
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions
2395 Exhibit A to the Pease UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Opposition To business information
Apple's Motion To
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions
Infringement Contention
2395 Exhibit B to the Pease UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Opposition To business information
Apple's Motion To
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions
2395 Exhibit C to the Pease UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Opposition To business information
Apple's Motion To
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions
2395 Exhibit D to the Pease UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Opposition To business information
Apple's Motion To
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions
2395 Exhibit E to the Pease UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Opposition To business information
Apple's Motion To
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions
2395 Exhibit F to the Pease UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Opposition To business information
Apple's Motion To
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions
2410 Apple's Reply ISO Motion UNSEALED No supporting
To Compel Further declaration was filed
Discovery And For
Sanctions
2410 Exhibit A to the Mueller UNSEALED No supporting
Declaration ISO Apple's declaration was filed
Reply ISO Motion To
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions
2471 Apple's Response To UNSEALED No supporting
Samsung's Motion For declaration was filed;
Leave To File not narrowly tailored
Supplemental Declaration to confidential
Of Thomas D. Pease business information
2556 Samsung's Supplemental SEALED UNSEALED Sealed portions
Brief In Support Of 6:3, 9-11, 13-20 4:6-8 reflect narrow
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s 4:14-5:25 tailoring to protect
Motion To Compel 8:1-4 confidential business
Further Discovery And For information.
Sanctions For Violations Unsealed portions do
Of Protective Order not or lack a
supporting
declaration.
2556 Ahn Declaration ISO SEALED UNSEALED Sealed portions
Samsung's Supplemental 2:26-28 2:16-25 reflect narrow
Brief In Support Of tailoring to protect
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s 244:4-3: confidential business
Motion To Compel 5:6-9 information.
Further Discovery And For 5:27-6:1 Unsealed portions do
Sanctions For Violations not or lack a
Of Protective Order supporting
declaration.
2556 Korea Declaration ISO SEALED UNSEALED Sealed portions
Samsung's Supplemental 5:17-19 2:1-4, 21 reflect narrow
Brief In Support Of 5:21-6:18 5:5-6, 17 tailoring to protect
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s confidential business
Motion To Compel 4:7-8 information.
Further Discovery And For 4:27-5:13 Unsealed portions do
Sanctions For Violations not or lack a
Of Protective Order supporting
declaration.
2556 Exhibit 1 to the Korea UNSEALED No supporting
Declaration ISO declaration was filed.
Samsung's Supplemental
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit 2 to the Korea UNSEALED No supporting
Declaration ISO declaration was filed.
Samsung's Supplemental
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit 3 to the Korea UNSEALED No supporting
Declaration ISO declaration was filed.
Samsung's Supplemental
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit 4 to the Korea SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Samsung's Supplemental information
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit 5 to the Korea SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Samsung's Supplemental information
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 McGowan Declaration ISO UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Samsung's Supplemental to confidential
Brief In Support Of business information
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Kwak Declaration ISO UNSEALED, except 2:10-12. Sealed portions
Samsung's Supplemental reflect narrow
Brief In Support Of tailoring to protect
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s confidential business
Motion To Compel information.
Further Discovery And For Unsealed portions
Sanctions For Violations lack a supporting
Of Protective Order declaration.
2556 Shim Declaration ISO UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Samsung's Supplemental to confidential
Brief In Support Of business information
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Kang Declaration ISO SEALED UNSEALED Sealed portions
Samsung's Supplemental reflect narrow
Brief In Support Of 2:7-10 2:10-15 tailoring to protect
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s 2:15-18 2:19-3:15 confidential business
Motion To Compel 3:17-19, 21-22, information.
Further Discovery And For 26-27 Unsealed portions do
Sanctions For Violations 4:2-4 not or lack a
Of Protective Order supporting
declaration.
2556 Exhibit A to the Kang SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Samsung's Supplemental information
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit C to the Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Supplemental confidentiality claimed
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit F to the Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Supplemental confidentiality claimed
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit N to the Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Supplemental confidentiality claimed
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit 0 to the Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Supplemental confidentiality claimed
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit P to the Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Supplemental confidentiality claimed
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit Q to the Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Supplemental confidentiality claimed
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order s
2556 Exhibit R to the Becher UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Supplemental business information
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit S to the Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Supplemental confidentiality claimed
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Exhibit X to the Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Supplemental confidentiality claimed
Brief In Support Of
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2556 Camesasca Declaration UNSEALED Declaration filed
ISO Samsung's indicating no
Supplemental Brief In confidentiality claimed
Support Of Opposition To
Apple Inc.'s Motion To
Compel Further Discovery
And For Sanctions For
Violations Of Protective
Order
2556 Vanzetti Declaration ISO UNSEALED Declaration filed
Samsung's Supplemental indicating no
Brief In Support Of confidentiality claimed
Opposition To Apple Inc.'s
Motion To Compel
Further Discovery And For
Sanctions For Violations
Of Protective Order
2557 Apple Inc.'s Supplemental UNSEALED, except 5:4-7 Sealed portions
Brief in Support of Its reflect narrow
Motion for Sanctions tailoring to protect
confidential business
information.
Unsealed portions do
not.
2557 Selwyn Declaration ISO UNSEALED Declaration filed
Apple Inc.'s Supplemental indicating no
Brief in Support of Its confidentiality claimed
Motion for Sanctions or no supporting
declaration was filed
2557 Exhibit 1 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 2 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 3 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 4 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 6 of the Selwyn SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO Apple confidential business
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 8 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 9 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 10 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 11 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 12 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 13 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 14 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 15 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 16 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 17 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 18 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 19 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 20 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2557 Exhibit 21 of the Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple to confidential
Inc.'s Supplemental Brief business information
in Support of Its Motion
for Sanctions
2558 Koppelman Declaration UNSEALED No supporting
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte declaration was filed
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 1 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 2 of the SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Koppelman Declaration confidential business
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 3 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 4 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 5 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 6 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 7 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 8 of the SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Koppelman Declaration confidential business
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 9 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 10 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 11 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 12 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia Corporation and business information
Nokia Inc.'s Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 13 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 14 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 15 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 16 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte business information
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 17 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 18 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 19 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 20 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 21 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia Corporation and
Nokia Inc.'s Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 22 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 23 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2558 Exhibit 25 of the UNSEALED No supporting
Koppelman Declaration declaration was filed
ISO Nokia's Ex-Parte
Administrative Motion to
File Documents Under Seal
2610 Becher Declaration in UNSEALED No supporting
Support of Administrative declaration was filed
Motion to File Documents
Under Seal
2610 Samsung's Motion for UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Leave to Take Discovery to protect confidential
business information
2624 Apple Inc.'s Opposition to UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Samsung's Motion for to confidential
Leave to Take Discovery business information
2633 Samsung's Reply in UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Support of its Motion for to confidential
Leave to Take Discovery business information
2664 Becher Declaration in UNSEALED No supporting
Support of Samsung's declaration was filed
Administrative Motion to
Seal
2664 Samsung's Notice Related UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
to In Camera Submission to confidential
business information
2825 Apple Inc.'s Response to UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Samsung's Brief to confidential
Regarding Attorney-Client business information
Privilege and Work-Product
Production in
Response to Order of
November 8, 2013
2835 Samsung's Response to SEALED UNSEALED Sealed portions
November 8, 2013 Order to 3:13 12:18-23 reflect narrow
Show Cause Why tailoring to protect
Sanctions Are Not 17:2-14 15:1-8, 10-16:3, confidential business
Warranted n.6 information.
16:7, 12-15, Unsealed portions do
n.7, 17-17:1 not.
17:21-18:18
2835 Exhibit 31 of the Becher UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Response to business information
November 2, 2013 Order to
Show Cause Why
Sanctions Are Not
Warranted
2835 Exhibit 32 of the Becher UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Response to business information
November 2, 2013 Order to
Show Cause Why
Sanctions Are Not
Warranted
2835 Exhibit 33 of the Becher UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Response to business information
November 2, 2013 Order to
Show Cause Why
Sanctions Are Not
Warranted
2835 Exhibit 39 of the Becher UNSEALED, except 257-262 Sealed portions
Declaration ISO (Transcript of Record at 87-92) reflect narrow
Samsung's Response to tailoring to protect
November 2, 2013 Order to confidential business
Show Cause Why information.
Sanctions Are Not Unsealed portions do
Warranted not.
2835 Exhibit 40 of the Becher UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Response to business information
November 2, 2013 Order to
Show Cause Why
Sanctions Are Not
Warranted
2835 Exhibit 41 of the Becher SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Samsung's Response to information
November 2, 2013 Order to
Show Cause Why
Sanctions Are Not
Warranted
2835 Exhibit 42 of the Becher SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Declaration ISO confidential business
Samsung's Response to information
November 2, 2013 Order to
Show Cause Why
Sanctions Are Not
Warranted
2836 Nokia's Brief ISO UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Sanctions Against to confidential
Samsung and Quinn business information
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 1 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO business information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 2 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO business information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 3 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO business information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 4 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO business information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 5 of the UNSEALED, except 58:4-59:25 Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO business information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 6 of the SEALED Narrowly tailored to
Koppelman Declaration confidential business
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 7 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO business information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 8 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO business information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 9 of the UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Koppelman Declaration to confidential
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO business information
Sanctions Against
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 11 of the UNSEALED Declaration filed
Koppelman Declaration indicating no
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO confidentiality
Sanctions Against claimed
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2836 Exhibit 12 of the UNSEALED Declaration filed
Koppelman Declaration indicating no
ISO Nokia's Brief ISO confidentiality
Sanctions Against claimed
Samsung and Quinn
Emmanuel
2838 Apple's Brief Regarding UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Appropriate Sanctions for to confidential
Samsung's Protective business information
Order Violations
2838 Exhibit 22 to Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple's to confidential
Brief Regarding business information
Appropriate Sanctions for
Samsung's Protective
Order Violations
2838 Exhibit 23 to Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple's to confidential
Brief Regarding business information
Appropriate Sanctions for
Samsung's Protective
Order Violations
2838 Exhibit 24 to Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple's to confidential
Brief Regarding business information
Appropriate Sanctions for
Samsung's Protective
Order Violations
2838 Exhibit 25 to Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple's to confidential
Brief Regarding business information
Appropriate Sanctions for
Samsung's Protective
Order Violations
2838 Exhibit 26 to Selwyn UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Apple's to confidential
Brief Regarding business information
Appropriate Sanctions for
Samsung's Protective
Order Violations
2871 Samsung's Supplemental UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Response to confidential
business information
2871 Exhibit 1 to Becher UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO to confidential
Samsung's Supplemental business information
Response
2872 Nokia's Supplemental UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Brief to confidential
business information.
2872 Exhibit 1 to Koppelman UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored
Declaration ISO Nokia's to confidential
Supplemental Brief business information
2873 Apple's Post-Hearing UNSEALED except 4:15-17, Sealed portions
Brief in Support of 4:24-5:6 reflect narrow
Sanctions tailoring to protect
confidential business
information.
Unsealed portions do
not.
2974 Apples February 17, 2014 UNSEALED Motion denied at
Letter Brief Feb. 27 hearing (see
Docket No. 2997)
2975 NishiNo supporting UNSEALED Motion denied at
declaration ISO of Apple's Feb. 27 hearing (see
Motion to File Under Seal Docket No. 2997)
2975 NishiNo supporting UNSEALED Motion denied at
declaration ISO of Feb. 27 hearing (see
Samsung's Motion to File Docket No. 2997)
Under Seal
2976 Kolovos Sealing UNSEALED Motion denied at
Declaration Feb. 27 hearing (see
Docket No. 2997)
2977 Samsung's Opposition to UNSEALED Motion denied at
Administrative Motion to Feb. 27 hearing (see
Seal Docket No. 2997)
2991 Kolovos Sealing UNSEALED Motion denied at
Declaration Feb. 27 hearing (see
Docket No. 2997)
2993 Samsung's Opposition to UNSEALED Motion denied at
Administrative Motion to Feb. 27 hearing (see
Seal Docket No. 2997)
3037 Samsung's Motion for UNSEALED Notice filed from
Authorization to Submit Apple indicating no
Deposition Transcripts of sealing necessary; No
Paul Melin and Eeva supporting
Hakoranta to The ITC declaration was filed
by Nokia
3037 Becher Declaration ISO UNSEALED Declaration filed
Samsung's Motion for indicating no
Authorization to Submit confidentiality
Deposition Transcripts of claimed or no
Paul Melin and Eeva supporting
Hakoranta to The ITC declaration was filed
3037 Exhibit 1 to Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Motion for confidentiality
Authorization to Submit claimed or no
Deposition Transcripts of supporting
Paul Melin and Eeva declaration was filed
Hakoranta to The ITC
3037 Exhibit 2 to Becher UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO indicating no
Samsung's Motion for confidentiality
Authorization to Submit claimed or no
Deposition Transcripts of supporting
Paul Melin and Eeva declaration was filed
Hakoranta to The ITC
3039 Nokia's Reply to UNSEALED Declaration filed
Samsung's Opposition to indicating no
Nokia's Motion to Compel confidentiality
Information for claimed
Remediation
3039 Exhibit 1 to Koppelman UNSEALED Declaration filed
Declaration ISO Reply to indicating no
Samsung's Opposition to confidentiality
Nokia's Motion to Compel claimed or not
Information for narrowly tailored to
Remediation confidential business
information
IT IS SO ORDERED.
