ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR FINAL APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT Re: Dkt. No. 258
SUSAN ILLSTON, District Judge.
On April 13, 2016, the Court held a hearing on Plaintiffs' motion for final approval of the class action settlement with defendants UMG Recordings, Inc. and Capitol Records, LLC (collectively "Defendants"). Having reviewed Plaintiffs' motion, the pleadings and other papers on file in this action, the objections to the settlement, and the statements of counsel and an objector at the hearing, the Court hereby finds that Plaintiffs' motion should be GRANTED and a final judgment entered thereon.
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ADJUDGED THAT:
1. For purposes of this Order, except as otherwise set forth herein, the Court adopts and incorporates the definitions contained in the Stipulation and Agreement of Settlement (the "Stipulation" or "Settlement").
2. The Court has jurisdiction over the parties to the Settlement and the subject matter of the litigation.
3. The Court hereby finally approves the Settlement and finds that the Settlement is fair, adequate and reasonable to the Class Members in all respects.
4. The Court finds that the persons identified in Ex. A attached hereto have timely and validly requested exclusion from the Settlement Class, or are permitted to be excluded notwithstanding an untimely request upon consent of the Parties, and are therefore not included in or bound by this Final Judgment and are not entitled to any recovery from the Fund or any other settlement proceeds obtained through this Settlement.
5. The Court has considered the nine objections filed by purported class members, as well as the statements made at the hearing by objector Anthony Gottlieb. The Court overrules the objections and finds that none of the objections demonstrate that the Settlement is not fair, adequate, and reasonable. The Court notes that only one of the objectors, George Clinton, filed a claim, and that at the hearing defense counsel stated that defendants would accept late claims filed by the objectors if those claims were otherwise valid.
6. The Court hereby dismisses on the merits and with prejudice the claims asserted in the Second Consolidated Amended Complaint and each of the Pending Actions, with Plaintiffs and Defendants to bear their own attorneys fees' and costs, except as provided for in the Settlement or otherwise ordered by this Court.
7. Plaintiffs, the Settlement Class, and each Class Member on behalf of themselves and each and all of their past, present, and future officers, directors, stockholders, principals, employees, independent contractors, advisors, agents, attorneys, financial or investment advisers, consultants, lenders, insurers, investment bankers, commercial bankers, representatives, affiliates, associates, parents, subsidiaries, joint ventures, general and limited partners and partnerships, heirs, executors, trustees, personal representatives, estates, administrators, trusts, predecessors, successors, assignors, and assigns shall be deemed to have, and by operation of the dismissal of the Action shall have, fully, finally and forever released relinquished, and discharged the Released Defendant Parties with respect to each and every Released Class Claim and shall forever be enjoined from prosecuting any of the Released Class Claims with respect to each and every Released Defendant Party and covenant not to sue any of the Released Defendant Parties with respect to any of the Released Class Claims.
8. Defendants, including the U.S. Labels, and including each of their unincorporated divisions and business units, and any and all of their past, present or future parents, associates, affiliates, subsidiaries or licensees, and each and all of their past, present and future officers, directors, stockholders, principals, employees, independent contractors, advisors, agents, attorneys, financial or investment advisers, consultants, lenders, insurers, investment bankers, commercial bankers, representatives, affiliates, associates, parents, subsidiaries, joint ventures, general and limited partners and partnerships, heirs, executors, trustees, personal representatives, estates, administrators, trusts, predecessors, successors, assignors and assigns, shall be deemed to have, and by operation of the dismissal of the Action shall have, fully, finally and forever released, relinquished and discharged the Released Plaintiff Parties with respect to each and every Released Defendant Claim and shall be forever enjoined from prosecuting any of the Released Defendant Claims with respect to each and every Released Plaintiff Party and covenant not to sue any of the Released Plaintiff Parties with respect to any of the Released Defendant Claims.
9. Nothing in the Settlement, this Order, and any judgment shall be offered or received as evidence of, or construed as or deemed to be evidence of, any presumption, concession, or admission of wrongdoing, negligence, fault, misrepresentation, omission, or liability, or the truth or validity of any claim or defense made by an opposing Party. See Settlement § XIII.B.
10. The Court finds that the Notice, Publication Notice, and other forms of notice disseminated to the Settlement Class through first class mail, print media, and online provided the best notice practicable under the circumstances, provided due and adequate notice of the Settlement and these proceedings, and fully satisfied the requirements of Rule 23(c)(2) and (e), due process, and 28 U.S.C. § 1715.
11. The plan for allocation of proceeds of the settlement ("Plan of Allocation") proposed under the Settlement is hereby APPROVED. The Court finds the proposed Plan of Allocation to be fair, reasonable, and adequate and in the best interests of the Class Members and the Settlement Class as a whole, and hereby directs the Parties and Claims Administrator to distribute the proceeds of the Settlement in accordance with the Settlement.
12. Without affecting the finality of the Judgment in any way, the Court hereby retains continuing and exclusive jurisdiction over: (a) the implementation of the Settlement and any distribution to Class Members pursuant to further orders of this Court; (b) the Defendants, until the Effective Date and each and every act agreed to be performed by the parties has been performed pursuant to the Settlement; (c) all Parties and Class Members for the purpose of enforcing and administering the Settlement, including the prohibition on asserting Released Class Claims or Released Defendant Claims pursuant to Section XI.B.7 of the Settlement; and (d) ruling upon the pending application by Class Counsel for attorneys' fees and expenses, and incentive fee awards.
13. In the event the Effective Date does not occur in accordance with the terms of the Settlement, then this Order and any judgment entered thereon shall be rendered null and void and shall be vacated, and in such event, all orders and judgments entered and releases delivered in connection herewith shall be null and void and the Parties shall be returned to their respective positions ex ante.
14. The Court will enter a final judgment in a separate document.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
EXHIBIT A
Requests for Exclusion
# GCG# Name Name (cont.) Affected Record(s) Name Name (cont.)
1 6 THE ESTATE OF SELENA QUINTANILLA-PEREZ
2 71 WU-TANG PRODUCTIONS, INC. 1005573 WU TANG PRODUCTIONS, INC.
1005574 WU-TANG PRODUCTIONS, INC.
1005576 WU-TANG PRODUCTIONS, INC.
3 72 AIMEE MANN
4 73 LINDA RONSTADT 1013685 LINDA RONSTADT
1037718 LINDA RONSTADT
1078271 LINDA RONSTADT
5 74 ERIK SCHRODY P/K/A EVERLAST
6 75 CYPRESS HILL
7 76 BUTTHOLE SURFERS 1077862 BUTTHOLE SURFERS
8 77 BLINK 182
9 78 ACE FREHLEY
10 79 LITA FORD
11 80 CHARLES LLOYD
12 81 THE DANDY WARHOLS 1036543 DANDY WARHOLS
1077567 THE DANDY WARHOLS
13 82 SUICIDAL TENDENCIES
14 83 CAROLE KING
15 84 SUBLIME
16 95 STRAY CATS 1015091 STRAY CATS DIAMOND & WILSON
17 96 30 SECONDS TO MARS 1037312 JARED LETO AND SHANNON LETO P/K/A 30 SECONDS TO MARS
18 104 YEAH YEAH YEAH'S
19 105 AUDIO SLAVE
20 106 TEMPLE OF THE DOG
21 107 CHRIS CORNELL 1036427 CHRIS CORNELL
22 108 TUPAC SHAKUR P/K/A 2 PAC 1004583 TUPAC SHAKUR
23 109 JUAN ESTEBAN ARISTIZABAL P/K/A JUANES 7809280 JUAN ESTEBAN ARISTIZABAL P/K/A "JUANES"
24 110 JUAN ESTEBAN ARISTIZABAL P/K/A JUANES AS A MEMBER OF EKHMOSIS
25 111 JOE WALSH 1009191 JOE WALSH
1076861 JOSEPH WALSH
26 119 THE JAMES GANG 1004338 THE JAMES GANG
27 120 BRIAN SETZER D/B/A BRIAN SETZER ORCHESTRA 1000145 MIDNITE TO SIX, INC.
28 121 THE PEDRO KNIGHT DECEDENTS TRUST
29 122 OMER PARDILLO-CID IN HIS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE
30 123 CELIA CRUZ
31 124 PEDRO KNIGHT
32 125 PINK FLOYD D/B/A PINK FLOYD MUSIC LIMITED AND
33 126 VI MUSIC
34 127 SEBASTIAN GROUP INC. D/B/A DIEGO VI MUSIC PUBLISHING
35 128 SEBASTIAN GROUP INC. D/B/A SEBASTIAN VI MUSIC
36 129 JUAN VIDAL NIEVES
37 130 CELINE DION
38 132 KEEP SWINGIN, INC.
39 136 PLAYER 1038371 PLAYER
40 137 NICK LACHEY 1010250 LACHEY, NICK
41 138 THE BLACK EYED PEAS
42 139 98 DEGREES
43 141 ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL 1002472 ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL, INC.
1036074 ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL
44 142 JILL SOBULE
45 147 JUAN LUIS GUERRA 1003390 GUERRA JUAN LUIS
46 148 UGLY KID JOE 1004662 UGLY KID JOE
47 149 BLUE OCTOBER
48 1000055 MICHAEL MCDONALD
49 1000122 MICHELLE PHILLIPS
1000123 MICHELLE PHILLIPS
50 1000171 MIKE CHAPMAN 1000173 MIKE CHAPMAN ENTERPRISES, INC.
51 1000179 MIKE CURB MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS INC 86 CURB MUSIC COMPANY
87 CURB PRODUCTIONS, INC.
88 MCPRODUCTIONS
89 CURB SONGS
90 MIKE CURB MUSIC
91 CURB RECORDING GROUP, INC.
92 CURB CONGREGATION SONGS
93 MIKE CURB CONGREGATION
1000180 MIKE CURB COMPANY, L.L.C.
1000181 MIKE CURB PROD INC RE BOBBY MARTIN
1000182 MIKE CURB PROD. TO PRODUCE RUTHI
1000183 MIKE CURB PRODNS INC FOR ERNIE PAYNE
1000184 MIKE CURB PRODS RE GLORY
1000185 MIKE CURB PRODS RE THE ALLEN S
1000186 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS
1000188 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS H.C
1000189 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS INC
1000190 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS INC.
1000191 MIKE CURB RCD RE AXE
1000192 MIKE CURB RCDS., INC-PIROUGE PROD-CHUCK POLLARD
1000193 MIKE CURB RECORDS
1000194 MIKE CURB RECORDS
1003533 HANK WILLIAM III
1007331 BILLY BURNETTE
1012142 CURB MUSIC CO
1012143 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS INC.
1012144 CURB PRODUCTIONS, INC., MIKE
1012154 MIKE CURB SIDEWALK PRODUCTIONS, INC.
1015598 THE CONGREGATION
1036522 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS, INC.
1036523 CURB RECORDS
1036578 DAVID CASSIDY MIKE CURB RECORDS, INC.
1037171 HERMAN RUSH/MIKE CURB
1037599 KINECTIC DIAMOND MUSIC
1037999 MIKE CURB MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS INC
1038000 MIKE CURB COMPANY, L.L.C.
1038001 MIKE CURB PROD RE ROGER WILLIAMS
1038002 MIKE CURB PROD INC.
1038003 MIKE CURB PROD INC
1038004 MIKE CURB PROD INC.
1038005 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS
1038006 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS
1038007 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS, INC. RE: SAWYER BROWN
1038008 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS, INC.
1038009 MIKE CURB RCD M ASHLEY PROD
1038010 MIKE CURB RCDS RE FRANKIE VALL
1038011 MIKE CURB RECORDS
1038012 MIKE CURB RECORDS
1038811 SMILE
1076507 MIKE CURB PRODUCTIONS
1076566 SMILE
1077208 CURB RECORDS CURB RECORDS, INC.
52 1000236 MILES DAVIS PROPERTIES LLC
1000235 MILES DAVIS
53 1000253 MILLS BROTHERS
54 1000749 DAVE NAVARRO
55 1000953 NICOLAS ENTERTAINMENT NEW LINE CINEMA
56 1001010 NO DOUBT 1038176 NO DOUBT
57 1001176 OLIVIA NEWTON-JOHN 1038221 OLIVIA NEWTON-JOHN
58 1001323 OVERBROOK ENTERTAINMENT
59 1001455 PAT BOONE 1007645 PAT BOONE
60 1001493 PATTI PAGE PRODUCTIONS, LLC
61 1001623 A PERFECT CIRCLE PARTNERSHIP
62 1002312 APPLE CORPS LIMITED 51 APPLE RECORDS INC (CALIFORNIA)
52 APPLE FILMS LIMITED
53 SUBAFILMS LIMITED
54 APPLE FILMS INC.
1036055 APPLE CORPS LIMITED
63 1002565 AXIS MUSIC GROUP LLC 1002563 AXIS MUSIC GROUP
1002568 AXIS MUSIC GROUP, LLC
64 1002733 BAROOGA BANDIT
65 1002796 BEASTIE BOYS, A PARTNERSHIP 1015549 THE BEASTIE BOYS
66 1002813 BECK HANSEN 1075678 BECK HANSEN
67 1003090 GLENN DANZIG
68 1003355 DAVID GROHL
69 1003438 GWEN STEFANI 1037127 GWEN STEFANI
70 1003521 HERBERT J HANCOCK HANCOCK MUSIC COMPANY 1003734 HERBIE HANCOCK
1037136 HANCOCK MUSIC CO.
1037169 HERBIE HANCOCK
71 1003760 HIDEOUT RECORDS & DISTRIBUTORS
72 1003813 AMY HOLLAND
73 1004040 INDEPENDENT PRODUCTIONS INC
74 1004264 JAGGED RECORDINGS LLC
75 1004445 JANET JACKSON 1004446 JANET JACKSON (CONTROL I)
1036210 BLACK DOLL, INC.
1036214 BLACK ICE PUBLISHING
1037308 JANET JACKSON
1037309 JANET JACKSON/JOSEPH
76 1004955P APA ROACH LLC/VIVA LA CUCARACHA MUSIC INC. 1001397 PAPA ROACH
77 1005078 WARNER BROS.ENTERTAINMENT, INC
78 1005184 WAYNE SHORTER 1075941 WAYNE SHORTER
79 1005367 WILLIAM J. BASIE TRUST 1039314 WILLIAM J BASIE TRUST
1078431 WILLIAM J. BASIE TRUST
80 1005511 ESTATE OF WOODY HERMAN 1005512 ESTATE OF WOODY HERMAN RE: ABE TURCHEN
1005513 ESTATE OF WOODY HERMAN
81 1005898 PEGGY LEE ASSOCIATES, LLC
82 1005900 PEGGY LEE MUSIC & MEDIA TRUST 1013472 PEGGY LEE RE: PEGGY LEE/ATTN: BILL RUDMA
83 1006386 Q PRODUCTIONS INC
84 1006970 RICHARD HAYMAN 1006969 RICHARD HAYMAN
85 1006983 RICHARD MARX DBA RICHARD MARX MUSIC
86 1007438 BLONDIE MUSIC INC
87 1007552 BOBBY ARVON-FIRST ARTIST
88 1007620 HONEY JAMES, INC.
89 1008058 CAFE TACUBA
90 1008307 CELIA CRUZ KNIGHT ESTATE
91 1008462 CHARLOTTE CAFFEY
92 1008527 CHET BAKER ESTATE, LLC.
93 1008558 CHINNICHAP INC 1008559 CHINNICHAP INC RE MIKE CHAPMAN FOR TANYA
94 1009249 ESTATE OF JJ CALE
95 1009343 JOHN R. CASH REVOCABLE TRUST 1009344 JOHN R. CASH REVOCABLE TRUST
96 1009783 KANYE WEST
97 1009789 KAREN CARPENTER TESTAMENTARY 1037532 KAREN CARPENTER TESTAMENTARY
98 1010060 KINETIC ART BUSINESS AMERICA
99 1010063 KING COLE PARTNERS LP 1037602 KING COLE PARTNERS LP
7807825 KING COLE PARTNERS LP
100 1010095 KITTY KALLEN 1010096 KITTY KALLEN
1075638 KITTY KALLEN
101 1011588 SOUNDGARDEN
102 1012805 DENNY DOHERTY PRODUCTIONS INC 1077652 DENNY DOHERTY PRODUCTIONS INC.
103 1012863 DEVICE
104 1012920 DICK HYMAN MUSIC INC. RE: DICK HYMAN
105 1013137 DONAVON FRANKENREITER
106 1013573 LESTER R AND CLAIRE BROWN REV TR
107 1013896 LOU ADLER 1013897 LOU ADLER DBA ODE SOUNDS & VISION
1037767 LOU ADLER DBA ODE SOUNDS & VISION
1037768 LOU ADLER
1037769 LOU ADLER
1037770 LOU ADLER PRODUCTION D/B/A ODE SOUNDS & VISUALS
108 1014831 MICHAEL CAMPBELL
109 1015017 STEVLAND MORRIS 1038913 STEVLAND MORRIS
110 1015244 SWEET CYANIDE MUSIC INC 143 BRET MICHAELS
144 RIKKI ROCKET
145 BOBBY DALL
146 BRUCE JOHANNESSON P/K/A C.C. DEVILLE
1006205 POISON SWEET CYANIDE MUSIC INC
111 1015682 THE JOHN E.A. PHILLIPS TRUST 1077816 THE JOHN E.A. PHILLIPS TRUST
1078030 THE JOHN E A PHILLIPS TRUST
112 1016088 TOM PETTY
113 1016103 THOMAS A WAITS P/K/A TOM WAITS
114 1016177 ESTATE OF TONY MARTIN 1039090 ESTATE OF TONY MARTIN
115 1016592 ELIEL LIND OSORIO P/K/A ELIEL 1036790 ELIEL LIND OSORIO P/K/A ELIEL
116 1016645 ELTON JOHN (COHEN TRIBUTE) WILLIAM A. BONG, LTD
117 1016841 ESTATE OF BENNY GOODMAN
118 1016889 ESTATE OF MARIA COLE 1014238 MARIA COLE DBA ALICE WAY MUSIC
119 1017132 FERGIE DUHAMEL F/K/A STACY FERGUSON P/K/A FERGIE
120 1017786 GEORGE STRAIT PRODUCTIONS, INC THE ERV WOOLSEY COMPANY
121 1036050 APOLLO RECORDS NEW LINE CINEMA
122 1036269 HONEY JAMES, INC.
123 1036437 CHRISTINA FLORES 1078153 CHRISTINA FLORES
124 1036930 FRANKIE LAINE 1036931 FRANKIE LAINE
125 1037006 GEORGE STRAIT
126 1037115 GUNS & ROSES 1037116 GUNS N' ROSES
127 1037173 HIDEOUT RECORD & DIST THE ROCKETS
128 1037174 HIDEOUT RECORDS
129 1037265 JEFFREY ISBELL PKA IZZY STRADLIN 1077278 JEFFREY ISBELL PKA IZZY STRADLIN
130 1037542 KATJA MOTION PICTURE CORP
131 1037685 LENNY KRAVITZ 1013523 LENNY KRAVITZ
1013524 LENNY KRAVITZ
1013525 LENNY KRAVITZ
1037684 LENNY KRAVITZ
1077720 LENNY KRAVITZ C/O PROVIDENT FI
132 1037709 LIBERTY RECORDS
133 1037919 MELISSA ETHERIDGE 1038035 MLE MUSIC
1038036 M.L.E. MUSIC, INC.
134 1037973 MICHAEL MCDONALD
135 1038113 NATALIE COLE 1000727 NATALIE COLE
1000729 NATALIE COLE
1000730 NATALIE COLE
1011870 NATALIE COLE
1038114 NATALIE COLE
1038115 NATALIE COLE
136 1038229 ONJ PRODUCTIONS
137 1038254 OWEN ELLIOT-KUGELL
138 1038299 PAUL WESTERBERG
139 1038491 RED HOT CHILI PEPPERS 112 ANTHONY KIEDIS
113 MICHAEL BALZARY P/K/A FLEA
114 CHAD SMITH
115 JOHN FRUSCIANTE
116 CLIFF MARTINEZ
117 JACK SHERMAN
140 1038542 RICHARD CARPENTER 7781346 RICHARD CARPENTER
141 1038624 ROCKETS, THE
142 1038738 SELENA SIT-WARNER BROS.
143 1038932 STUDIO K. LLC
144 1039082 TOM PETTY
145 1057301 BOB SEGER
146 1057501 CONCORD MUSIC GROUP, INC. 1076698 CONCORD MUSIC GROUP
1077209 HEADS UP INTERNATIONAL LTD DBA CONCORD MUSIC GROUP, INC.
1077640 CONCORD MUSIC GROUP INC
7812467 CONCORD MUSIC GROUP
147 1076221 KENNY EDWARDS
148 1076696 SONY PICTURES ENTERTAINMENT F/K/A COLUMBIA TRISTAR HOME ENT. INC 1011896 COLUMBIA PICTURES INDUSTRIES
1036839 ESP
1037353 JERRY GOLDSMITH
1037365 JESSE KAYE METRO GOLDWYN MAYER INC
1037818 MARC MAYA PRODUCTIONS FSO RICHARD RUDOLPH
1039156 TRI-STAR PRODUCTIONS
1075776 COLUMBIA PICTURES INDUSTRIES
1077113 SONY PICTURES ENTERTAINMENT
1078365 SONY PICTURES ENTERTAINMENT
149 1077336 NEW LINE PRODUCTIONS, INC.
150 1078105 ANDRE YOUNG P/K/A DR. DRE 1002123 ANDRE YOUNG P/K/A DR. DRE
1036016 ANDRE YOUNG P/K/A DR. DRE
151 1078420 WARNER CHAPPELL MUSIC INC 1008360 CHAPPELL MUSIC INC. UNICHAPPEL C/O WARNER/CHAPPEL
1036922 FOSTER FREES MUSIC, INC.
1038508 REFUGE PRODUCTIONS
1039278 WB MUSIC CORP.
1076224 CHAPPELL & CO
152 1078434 WILLIAM R MCLEAN