GENERAL STEEL DOMESTIC SALES, LLC v. CHUMLEY, 10-cv-01398-PAB-KLM. (2012)
Court: District Court, D. Colorado
Number: infdco20120712891
Visitors: 1
Filed: Jul. 11, 2012
Latest Update: Jul. 11, 2012
Summary: ORDER REGARDING THE PARTIES' OBJECTIONS TO DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION TESTIMONY OF DAVID NARDOZZI PHILIP A. BRIMMER, District Judge. This matter comes before the Court on Defendants' Objections to Designated Deposition Testimony of David Nardozzi [Docket No. 221] and Plaintiff's Objections to Defendants' Counter Designations to Deposition Testimony of David Nardozzi [Docket No. 256]. The Court rules as follows on defendants' objections [Docket No. 221]: Item # Testimony Object
Summary: ORDER REGARDING THE PARTIES' OBJECTIONS TO DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION TESTIMONY OF DAVID NARDOZZI PHILIP A. BRIMMER, District Judge. This matter comes before the Court on Defendants' Objections to Designated Deposition Testimony of David Nardozzi [Docket No. 221] and Plaintiff's Objections to Defendants' Counter Designations to Deposition Testimony of David Nardozzi [Docket No. 256]. The Court rules as follows on defendants' objections [Docket No. 221]: Item # Testimony Objecti..
More
ORDER REGARDING THE PARTIES' OBJECTIONS TO DESIGNATIONS OF DEPOSITION TESTIMONY OF DAVID NARDOZZI
PHILIP A. BRIMMER, District Judge.
This matter comes before the Court on Defendants' Objections to Designated Deposition Testimony of David Nardozzi [Docket No. 221] and Plaintiff's Objections to Defendants' Counter Designations to Deposition Testimony of David Nardozzi [Docket No. 256].
The Court rules as follows on defendants' objections [Docket No. 221]:
Item # Testimony Objection Ruling
1 7:7-10 Leading Overruled
2 7:11-14 Compound; vague Overruled
3 7:15-18 No question posed Overruled
4 10:1-7 Assumes facts not in Overruled
evidence; lack of
foundation
5 10:12-13 Assumes facts not in Overruled
evidence; lack of
foundation
6 11:13-19 No questions posed Overruled
7 13:7-14:10 Compound; answer is Sustained, unresponsive and
not responsive irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
8 14:11-13,21- Compound; vague; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
25;15:1-3 leading; answer is not ruling of July 3, 2012
responsive
9 15:11-13 Leading; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
mischaracterizes the ruling of July 3, 2012
testimony
10 15:15-16:14 Leading; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
mischaracterizes the ruling of July 3, 2012
testimony
11 16:15-18 Leading; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
mischaracterizes the ruling of July 3, 2012
testimony
12 17:10-25 Leading; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation; vague; calls ruling of July 3, 2012
for hearsay
13 23:10-24:5 Vague; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
14 24:6-11 Leading; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
15 24:12-13 Leading Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
16 24:14-25:3 Answer is not Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
responsive ruling of July 3, 2012
17 25:4-9 Leading; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
mischaracterizes the ruling of July 3, 2012
testimony; calls for
hearsay
18 25:16-26:3 Vague; leading; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
mischaracterizes the ruling of July 3, 2012
testimony
19 27:17-19 Leading; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
20 29:8-14 Leading Overruled
21 29:21-30:18 Leading; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
22 33:9-10 Leading Overruled
23 33:14-16 Leading Overruled
24 34:20-222 Mischaracterizes the Overruled
testimony
25 35:22-36:2 Leading; Overruled
mischaracterizes the
testimony; vague
26 36:3-7 Leading Overruled
27 37:14-17 Leading; vague; calls for Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
hearsay; lack of ruling of July 3, 2012
foundation
28 37:18-38:2 Vague; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
29 38:3-5 Lack of foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
30 38:6-8 Leading; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
mischaracterizes the ruling of July 3, 2012
testimony
31 38:11-13 Lack of foundation; calls Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
for hearsay ruling of July 3, 2012
32 38:17-21 Leading; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
33 38:22-39:7 Leading; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
34 40:25-41:17 Leading; compound Overruled
35 42:1-43:15 Answer not responsive Overruled
36 44:9-17 Leading Overruled
37 49:6-51:19 Vague; answer is not Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
responsive ruling of July 3, 2012
38 51:25-52:1 Mischaracterizes the Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
testimony ruling of July 3, 2012
39 52:6-24 Answer is not Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
responsive ruling of July 3, 2012
40 53:1-16 Answer is not Sustained
responsive
41 53:17-25 Lack of foundation Overruled
42 54:10-12 Lack of foundation Overruled
43 54:16-56:4 Leading; vague Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
44 56:5-7 Lack of foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
45 57:13, 22-25; Leading; answer is not Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
58:1-59:8 responsive ruling of July 3, 2012
46 60:5-61:9, 17-24 Answer is not Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
responsive ruling of July 3, 2012
47 64:13-66:9 Lack of foundation; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
mischaracterizes the ruling of July 3, 2012
testimony; answer is not
responsive
48 66:10-67:6 Leading; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
49 67:15-69:18 Leading; Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
mischaracterizes the ruling of July 3, 2012
testimony; answer is not
responsive
50 69:19-20 Lack of foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
51 69:21-24 Leading; calls for Overruled
hearsay
52 69:25-71:9 Leading, calls for Overruled
hearsay
53 71:18-25 No question posed; Sustained
answer is not
responsive
54 72:23-73:1 Leading; Sustained as leading
mischaracterizes the
testimony
55 73:7-74:4 Lack of foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
56 76:23-77:1 Lack of foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
57 77:2-77:7 Lack of foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
58 77:12-77:17 Leading Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
59 78:8-17 Lack of foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
60 78:18-20;79:13- Leading; answer is not Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
80:25 responsive ruling of July 3, 2012
61 84:21-85:2 No questions posed Sustained
62 85:14-16 Leading Overruled
63 86:20-88:12 Lack of foundation; Overruled as to 86:20-87:4;
answer is not Sustained as nonresponsive
responsive as to 87:5-88:12
64 88:13-22 Compound; leading; Overruled
lack of foundation
65 93:22-23-95:14 Lack of foundation; calls Overruled
for hearsay
66 96:12-20 Answer is not Overruled
responsive
67 97:22-98:10 Lack of foundation Overruled
68 101:12-17 Leading; Overruled
mischaracterizes the
testimony
69 102:25-104:4 Leading; calls for Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
hearsay ruling of July 3, 2012
70 121:23-122:7 Leading; lack of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
foundation ruling of July 3, 2012
71 128:1-3 Vague Overruled
72 128:14-21 Lack of foundation Overruled
73 129:22-130:11 Leading; lack of Overruled
foundation; answer is
not responsive
The Court rules as follows on plaintiff's objections [Docket No. 256]:
Item # Testimony Objection Ruling
1 15:17 Argument by counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
2 29:25 Argument of counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
3 35:24 Argument of counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
4 38:23 Argument of counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
5 54:13 Argument of counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
6 54:18 Argument of counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
7 66:12 Argument of counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
8 73:2 Argument of counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
9 85:17 Argument of counsel Overruled since this is a trial
to court
10 143:1-16 FRCP 106 Overruled
11 148:5-12 Relevance Overruled
12 148:23-149:2 Relevance Overruled
13 160:9-10 Argumentative Overruled
14 174:14-175:1 Vague, foundation Overruled
15 210:10-212:9 Relevance Overruled
16 226:13-231:8 Relevance Overruled
17 233:14-234:14 Incomplete, 234:13-14 Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
should not be read ruling of July 3, 2012
18 237:21-24 Beyond the scope of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
designation, relevance ruling of July 3, 2012
19 238:4-241:21 Beyond the scope of Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
designation, relevance ruling of July 3, 2012
20 246:17-247:20 Foundation and Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
relevance ruling of July 3, 2012
21 254:2-255:19 Hearsay, foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
22 259:1-21 Relevance, foundation Irrelevant pursuant to Court's
ruling of July 3, 2012
Source: Leagle
