CENTRIX FINANCIAL, LLC v. NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY OF PITTSBURGH, PA, Civil Action 09-cv-1542-PAB-CBS. (2015)
Court: District Court, D. Colorado
Number: infdco20150615647
Visitors: 12
Filed: Jun. 12, 2015
Latest Update: Jun. 12, 2015
Summary: ORDER REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AS TO ANDREW MACLEOD PHILIP A. BRIMMER , District Judge . This matter comes before the Court on Plaintiffs' Objections to Defendants' Deposition Designations [Docket No. 142]. The Court has reviewed the objections and rules as follows as to the deposition of Andrew MacLeod: DEPOSITION OF ANDREW MACLEOD - 9.12.2012 Item # Testimony Objection ruling 199.
Summary: ORDER REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AS TO ANDREW MACLEOD PHILIP A. BRIMMER , District Judge . This matter comes before the Court on Plaintiffs' Objections to Defendants' Deposition Designations [Docket No. 142]. The Court has reviewed the objections and rules as follows as to the deposition of Andrew MacLeod: DEPOSITION OF ANDREW MACLEOD - 9.12.2012 Item # Testimony Objection ruling 199. 1..
More
ORDER REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS' DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AS TO ANDREW MACLEOD
PHILIP A. BRIMMER, District Judge.
This matter comes before the Court on Plaintiffs' Objections to Defendants' Deposition Designations [Docket No. 142]. The Court has reviewed the objections and rules as follows as to the deposition of Andrew MacLeod:
DEPOSITION OF ANDREW MACLEOD - 9.12.2012
Item # Testimony Objection ruling
199. 13:2 - 13:15 Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Overruled
Knowledge
200. 15:2 - 16:19 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Overruled
Lay Witness Opinion
201. 26:3 - 26:16 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible 26:3 to 26:12 -
Lay Witness Opinion Overruled
202. 28:17 - 28:24 Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Overruled
Knowledge
203. 30:4 - 30:19 Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Sustained
Knowledge
204. 36:2 - 36:20 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Sustained -
Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation; speculation
Incomplete hypothetical
205. 37:6 - 37:15 Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Sustained
Knowledge; Rule 611(a): Vague
206. 42:12 - 43:9 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained -
Lay Witness Opinion relevance,
speculation.
Also, no
substantive
answer given.
207. 43:11 - 44:3 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained -
Lay Witness Opinion; Rule 611(a): Vague foundation
208. 44:5 - 45:19 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained.
Lay Witness Opinion Also, foundation
209. 46:12 - 46:23 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
210. 47:22 - 48:20 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained.
Lay Witness Opinion Also,
speculation.
211. 49:11 - 50:2 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion; Rule 602: Sustained.
Foundation; Incomplete hypothetical Also,
speculation.
212. 50:20 - 51:15 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained.
Lay Witness Opinion Also,
speculation.
213. 51:16 - 51:24 Rule 602: Best evidence Sustained -
Rule 701
214. 52:2 - 52:6 Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Sustained
Knowledge; Rule 701: Legal
Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Witness Opinion
215. 54:12 - 54:23 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation
216. 55:10 - 56:20 Rule 602: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
217. 58:9 - 60:4 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained.
Lay Witness Opinion; Incomplete hypothesis Also,
speculation.
218. 61:3 - 63:2 Rule 602: Foundation; Rule 701: Legal 61:3-68:13 -
Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Witness Overruled.
Opinion; Rule 611(a): Assumes facts not in 61:15-63:2 -
evidence Sustained.
219. 69:22 - 70:19 Rule 602: Foundation; Speculation/Lacks Sustained
Personal Knowledge; Rule 701: Legal
Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Witness Opinion
220. 70:21 - 71:8 Rule 611(a): Misstates Evidence Sustained
221. 71:10 - 71:23 Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Sustained
Knowledge; Foundation
222. 72:4 - 72:10 Rule 602: Foundation Overruled
223. 72:24 - 73:4 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
224. 73:16 - 74:9 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
225. 74:18 - 75:11 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
226. 75:22 - 76:12 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
227. 77:13 - 78:24 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
228. 80:12 - 80:15 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
229. 81:2 - 81:12 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation
230. 81:24 - 82:5 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation
231. 83:1 - 83:13 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation
232. 84:3 - 85:24 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation
233. 86:23 - 87:3 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation
234. 88:17 - 89:12 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
235. 92:9 - 92:18 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation
236. 93:1 - 93:17 Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Sustained
Knowledge; Foundation
237. 95:11 - 96:11 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
238. 97:7 - 97:15 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
Lay Witness Opinion
239. 99:9 - 99:23 Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Overruled
Knowledge; Foundation
240. 100:17 - Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks Personal Overruled
101:8 Knowledge; Foundation
241. 103:2 - 104:9 Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Overruled
Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks
Personal Knowledge
242. 106:19 - Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Sustained
108:1 Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks
Personal Knowledge
243. 108:19- Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Sustained
108:24 Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks
Personal Knowledge
244. 109:18 - Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Sustained
110:12 Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks
Personal Knowledge
245. 112:4 - Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Sustained
112:23 Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks
Personal Knowledge
246. 122:5 - Rule 701: Legal Conclusion; Rule 602: Sustained
122:20 Speculation/Lacks Personal Knowledge
247. 123:22 - Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Sustained
124:4 Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks
Personal Knowledge; Rule 611(a): Assumes
facts not in evidence
248. 125:10 - Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Sustained -
125:20 Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks speculation
Personal Knowledge
249. 126:10 - Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Lay Overruled
126:24 Witness Opinion; Rule 602: Speculation/Lacks
Personal Knowledge
250. 130:11 - Rule 701: Legal Conclusion/Impermissible Sustained
130:24 Lay Witness Testimony; Rule 602:
Speculation/Lacks Personal Knowledge
251. 172:18 - Rule 611: Compound Question Sustained
172:24
Source: Leagle
