STATE OF FLORIDA

DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS

STATE OF FLORIDA, DEPARTMENT OF ) PROFESSIONAL REGULATION, FLORIDA ) CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY LICENSING ) BOARD, )

)

Petitioner, )

)

vs. ) CASE NO. 78-1230

)

IRA L. VARNUM, )

)

Respondent. )

)

RECOMMENDED ORDER

Pursuant to notice, the Division of Administrative Hearings, by its duly designated Hearing Officer, James E. Bradwell, held a public hearing in this case on November 16, 1978, in Fort Lauderdale, Florida.

APPEARANCES

For Petitioner: Barry Sinoff, Esquire

2400 Independent Square

Jacksonville, Florida 32202

For Respondent: Norman D. Zimmerman, Esquire

737 East Atlantic Boulevard Pompano Beach, Florida 33060

ISSUE

The Florida Construction Industry Licensing Board, Petitioner, by its Administrative Complaint filed May 18, 1978, seeks to revoke the Certified General Contractor's license issued to Ira L. Varnum based on allegations contained therein to the effect that he aided or abetted an uncertified or unregistered person to utilize his registration with an intent to evade the provisions of Chapter 468, Florida Statutes, which prohibits the use of a registrant's registration by an uncertified or unregistered person.

Additionally, the Petitioner seeks to assess an administrative fine in the amount of $500.00 against the Respondent, Ira L. Varnum, for failure to comply with the dictates of Chapter 468, Florida Statutes.

FINDINGS OF FACT

Based on my observation of the witnesses and their demeanor while testifying, the following relevant facts are found:

1. Ira L. Varnum, a Certified General Contractor, is the holder of license No. CG CA00832 and, during the times material, was a Certified General Contractor. William H. Bosely, the Chief Codes Enforcement Officer for

   Deerfield Beach, Florida, appeared during the course of the hearing and testified that he is the custodian of the permit applications in Deerfield Beach. Mr. Bosely issued permits to Ira L. Varnum to construct one-story, single-family residences on property located at 3275 and 3285 Southwest First Court, in West Deerfield Beach, Florida. (See Petitioner's Composite Exhibits Nos. 1 and 2.) As best as can be determined from the permits, the construction activity commenced during late December, 1977; and on January 25, 1978, Respondent, Ira L. Varnum, mailed a letter to the Deerfield Beach building department requesting that the construction activity for the properties here in question be "red-tagged" and requesting the building department to cease inspecting the construction of such properties. The properties were "red- tagged" based on these letters. (See Petitioner's Exhibits Nos. 3 and 4.)

   
   

2. Respondent, Ira L. Varnum, is the president of Structural Concrete Forming of Florida, Inc. Respondent Varnum testified that he entered into an agreement with his son-in-law, Angel Gonzales, James Monteleone and Frank Sepe, who were in a joint venture to construct approximately one hundred houses within a subdivision in West Deerfield Beach. According to Respondent, Structural Concrete Forming of Florida, Inc., was to be the contracting entity. Mr. Gonzales was to be the supervisor and Messrs. Sepe and Monteleone were to be the owners of the project, providing all funds necessary, and the profits derived from the building activity were to be equally divided into thirds. Mr. Gonzales, a developer residing in Boca Raton, testified that he simply contracted with his father-in-law, Respondent Varnum, to pull the building permits, and he agreed to "give his father-in-law something". According to Mr. Gonzales, he paid Respondent in cash $600.00 to pull the permits for the subject houses. Mr. Gonzales testified that Messrs. Sepe and Monteleone formed A-I-A Builders, Inc., to be the contracting entity for construction of the two houses which Respondent Varnum pulled the building permits for. According to Mr. Gonzales, Respondent Varnum visited the site on no more than two occasions after the concrete slab was poured for the erection of the homes. There is no dispute but that a controversy arose when Respondent Varnum was not permitted to order supplies and materials through Structural Concrete Forming of Florida, Inc., and for disbursement of all monies through that entity. The parties were unable to resolve their differences as to which firm would order and pay for the materials, and Respondent Varnum notified the building department of the City of Deerfield Beach that all construction activity of the subject projects would be halted forthwith until further notice. (Petitioner's Exhibits Nos. 3 and 4.)

   
   

3. Initially, the building department "red-tagged" the two projects but later decided, based on letters received from Messrs. Monteleone and Sepe and Attorney Richard R. Haas to the effect that the controversies between Respondent Varnum and Messrs. Monteleone and Sepe should be resolved either in the courts or between themselves amicably. The Department issued owner/builder permits to Mr. Monteleone and, thereafter, action resumed sometime during April, 1978.

   
   

4. By letter dated May 1, 1978, Mr. Monteleone advised the building department of the City of Deerfield Beach that "I have relieved Structural Concrete Forming, Inc., General Contractors, of all obligations pertaining to the development of one single family residence located on Lot 155, . . ." Additionally, Respondent Varnum testified that he received no monies from Mr. Gonzales, and that the agreement between him (Varnum), Gonzales, Sepe and Monteleone centered solely around their failure to permit Varnum's contracting entity, Structural Concrete Forming of Florida, Inc., to purchase, pay for and generally be responsible for the overall supervision and control of the two projects in question. In furtherance of this agreement, which was oral, Respondent Varnum testified that he received no monetary consideration. While

   this entire sequence of transactions appears to be suspicious, the undersigned, based on the evidence presented, is unable to rest a conclusion based on the disputed testimony of Messrs. Gonzales, Monteleone and Sepe that the Respondent engaged in the alleged unlawful conduct. While it is difficult to fully credit the version offered by Respondent Varnum, it is difficult to rationalize the versions testified by Messrs. Monteleone and Sepe to the effect that the Respondent had no obligations and yet a letter was sent to the building department advising that any and all obligations heretofore which were being performed by Structural Concrete Forming of Florida, Inc., were being released. In view thereof, I shall recommend that the complaint allegations filed herein be dismissed.

   
   

   CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

   
   

5. The Division of Administrative Hearings has jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties to this action.

   
   

6. The authority of the Petitioner, Florida Construction Industry Licensing Board, is derived from Chapter 468, Florida Statutes.

   
   

7. The parties were duly noticed pursuant to the notice provisions of Chapter 120, Florida Statutes.

   
   

8. Insufficient evidence was offered to establish that the Respondent, Ira

L. Varnum, unlawfully aided or abetted A-I-A Builders through Messrs. Monteleone, Sepe and Gonzales to evade the provisions of Chapter 468, Florida Statutes, by allowing them to use his registration certificate to pull permits or to otherwise use his registration certificate by an unlicensed person in a manner violative of Chapter 468, Florida Statutes.

RECOMMENDATION

Based on the foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of law, I hereby recommend that the complaint filed herein be dismissed in its entirety.

RECOMMENDED this 9th day of January, 1979, in Tallahassee, Florida.

JAMES E. BRADWELL, Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings Room 530, Carlton Building Tallahassee, Florida 32304

(904) 488-9675

COPIES FURNISHED:

Barry Sinoff, Esquire 2400 Independent Square

Jacksonville, Florida 32202

Norman D. Zimmerman, Esquire 737 East Atlantic Boulevard Pompano Beach, Florida 33060

Docket for Case No: 78-001230

Orders for Case No: 78-001230