Elawyers Elawyers
Washington| Change

THE CONSERVANCY, INC., AND FLORIDA AUDUBON SOCIETY vs COLLIER DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AND DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION, 89-004159 (1989)

Court: Division of Administrative Hearings, Florida Number: 89-004159 Visitors: 9
Petitioner: THE CONSERVANCY, INC., AND FLORIDA AUDUBON SOCIETY
Respondent: COLLIER DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AND DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION
Judges: VERONICA E. DONNELLY
Agency: Department of Environmental Protection
Locations: Naples, Florida
Filed: Aug. 04, 1989
Status: Closed
Recommended Order on Tuesday, October 16, 1990.

Latest Update: Jan. 10, 2025

Docket for Case No: 89-004159
Issue Date Proceedings
Oct. 19, 1994 AGENCY APPEAL, ONCE THE RETENTION SCHEDULE OF -KEEP ONE YEAR AFTER CLOSURE- IS MET, CASE FILE IS RETURNED TO AGENCY GENERAL COUNSEL. -ac
Sep. 19, 1994 Final Order filed.
Jul. 12, 1994 Petitioners And Intervenors Response to CDC's Exceptions to Recommended Order filed.
Jul. 11, 1994 Petitioners' and Intervenor's Response to CDC'S Exceptions to Recommended Order filed.
Jul. 01, 1994 (Petitioner) Notice of Substitution of Counel filed.
May 27, 1994 (DEP) Order On Collier Development Corporation's Motion To Place Proceedings In Abeyance And Motion For Time To Respond To Exceptions; Order Denying Collier Development Corporation's Motion To Remand filed.
Jan. 12, 1994 Order Granting Request for Further Extension of Time to File Exceptions filed.
Nov. 09, 1993 Order Granting Request for Extension of Time to File Exceptions filed.
Oct. 26, 1993 Recommended Order On Remand sent out. CASE CLOSED. Hearing held January 16-19, 22-25, 29-31, 1990; February 1-2, 5-7; April 23, 25-27, 30; May 1; June 19-22, 29, and July 9-10, 1990.
Oct. 26, 1993 Case No/s 88-6212, 89-4159, 89-4407: unconsolidated.
Dec. 04, 1992 City of Naples' And Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay Inc.'s Reply to CDC'S Response filed.
Nov. 23, 1992 Notice of Response and Reliance of Florida Audubon Society on the City and Citizen's Filing of Notice of Supplemental Authority filed.
Nov. 23, 1992 CDC'S Response to FAS'S Argument on Notice of Supplemental Authority filed.
Nov. 10, 1992 (City of Naples) Notice of Supplemental Authority filed.
Nov. 05, 1992 Notice Of Non-Party Communication sent out. (any party so desiring may file a response to this communication within 15 days from the receipt of this notice)
Oct. 09, 1992 City of Naples' And Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay, Inc.'s Response to CDC's Memorandum filed.
Oct. 09, 1992 Collier Development Corporation's Reply Memorandum filed.
Sep. 15, 1992 Memorandum of Law of Petitioners the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society in Support of Their Proposed Recommended Order on Remand; Submissions of The Proposed Recommended Order on Remand of Petitioners The Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon
Sep. 15, 1992 Notice of Appearance of Co-Counsel for Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Sep. 15, 1992 Department of Environmental Regulation's New Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Sep. 15, 1992 Lely Cvic Association's Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Sep. 15, 1992 Memorandum of Law City of Naples and Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay;City of Naples and Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay, Inc. Proposed Findings of Fact; CDC'S New Proposed Recommended Order w/Appendix; Memorandum in Support of CDC 's New Proposed Recomm
Sep. 04, 1992 Stipulated Motion of Petitioner For An Extension of Time and Page Requirements filed.
Sep. 02, 1992 (Respondents) Notice of Filing w/Stipulation Motion of Petitioner ForAn Extension of the Time and Page Requirements filed.
Sep. 02, 1992 Order Granting Stipulated Motion for Extension of Time and Provding for the Filing of Memoranda sent out.
Aug. 18, 1992 Order of Clarification as to Previous Order Requiring Parties to FileNew Proposed Recommended Orders sent out.
Aug. 18, 1992 Order Denying Motion for Evidentiary Hearing sent out.
Aug. 07, 1992 Response of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society in Opposition to the CDC Motion for Evidentiary Hearing filed.
Aug. 05, 1992 CDC'S Response to Motion for Clarification filed.
Aug. 04, 1992 Response of The City of Naples and the Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay to CDC's Motion for Evidentiary Hearing filed.
Aug. 03, 1992 Floridfa Department of Environmental Regulation's Response to Motion for Evidentary Hearing filed.
Jul. 31, 1992 (Respondents) Motion for Evidentiary Hearing filed.
Jul. 29, 1992 Motion of City of Naples and Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay, Inc. for Clarification of Order Requiring Parties to File New Proposed Recommended Orders filed.
Jul. 20, 1992 Order Requiring Parties To File New Proposed Recommended Orders sent out. (parties shall file revised recommended order by no later than 9-8-92)
Jun. 10, 1992 CDC'S Reply to Responses to Its Renewed Motion filed.
Jun. 05, 1992 Notice of Telephonic Hearing filed. (From Kenneth G. Oertel)
May 28, 1992 (Petitioners0 Response and Objections of Petitioners Florida Audubon Society and the Conservancy, Inc. to the "CDC Renewed Motion to Consolidate" filed.
May 26, 1992 Motion of Petitioners Florida Audubon Society and the Conservancy, Inc. For An Additional Extension of Time to Respond to the "CDC Renewed Motion to Consolidate" filed.
May 26, 1992 Fl;orida Department of Environmental Regulation Response to Renewed Motin to Consolidate filed.
May 26, 1992 Response of City of Naples and Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay to CDC's Motin to Consolidate filed.
May 13, 1992 Motion of Petitioners Florida Audubon Society and the Conservancy, Inc. for an Extension of Time to Respond to the "CDC Renewed Motion to Consoldiate" filed.
May 13, 1992 Department of Environmental Regulation's Request for Additional Time to Respond filed.
May 08, 1992 Motion for Extension of Time to File Response filed. (From Kenneth G.Oertel)
May 08, 1992 Notice of Substitution of Counsel filed. (From Maria J. Chiaro)
May 01, 1992 CDC Renewed Motion to Consolidate (with DOAH Case No/s. 88-6212, 89-4159, 89-4407 & 89-5666DRI) filed.
May 01, 1992 (City of Naples & Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay) Motion to Set Status Conference filed.
Apr. 28, 1992 Order sent out. (Reassigning case to hearing officer W.F. Quattlebaum)
Apr. 28, 1992 Order sent out. (cases are reassigned to HO Quattlebaum)
Apr. 20, 1992 Response of Florida Audubon Society to the petition for prohibition or mandamus and appendix and the court order dated April 10, l992 filed.
Apr. 15, 1992 Notice of Dismissal(CDC dismisses the petition for Prohibition or Mandamus filed /petition sought disqualification of HO.-Hearing officer has GRANTED CDC's motions ) filed.
Apr. 14, 1992 Letter to DOAH from DCA filed. DCA Case No. 2-92-1333
Apr. 13, 1992 Order Granting Disqualification sent out. (motion granted and case is returned to the director of the division for reassignment to anotherhearing officer)
Apr. 13, 1992 BY ORDER OF THE COURT(Petitioner's motion for judicial notice is GRANTED-It is further ordered that respondent shall file a response to thepetitionfor writ of prohibition or mandamus) filed.
Mar. 16, 1992 CDC's Reply to Responses on Disqualification filed.
Mar. 06, 1992 Response of Florida Audubon Society in Oppositition CDC'S Motion for Disqualification of Hearing Officer Donnelly and Affidavit Supporting Disqualification of Hearing Officer Veronica Donnelly filed.
Mar. 02, 1992 Motion of Petitioner Florida Audubon Society For an Extension of The Time Within Which to Respond to, and Oppose, "CDC's Motion for Diqualification of Hearing Officer Veronica Donnelly" filed.
Feb. 28, 1992 The City of Naples and the Citizens to Preserve Naple Bay Response toCDC'S Motion for Diqualification of Hearing Officer Donnelly filed.
Feb. 19, 1992 (original) Affidavit Supporting Disqualification of Hearing Officer Veronia Donnelly filed. (From John Aurell)
Feb. 18, 1992 CDC'S Motion for Disqualification of Hearing Officer Donnelly filed.
Feb. 18, 1992 CC Affidavit Supporting Disqualification of Hearing Officer Veronica Donnelly filed. (From John K. Aurell)
Feb. 14, 1992 By Order of the Court(Second District-Petitioners' motion for rehearing is DENIED) filed.
Dec. 02, 1991 Letter to Richard T. Donelan, Jr. from Joseph Z. Fleming filed.
Nov. 26, 1991 Ltr. to Harry Chiles from JWY forwarding copies of pleadings filed with DOAH sent out.
Nov. 20, 1991 Ltr. to Harry Chiles from JWY forwarding copies of pleadings filed with DOAH sent out.
Nov. 18, 1991 Reply of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society in opposition to CDC's motion for rehearing filed.
Nov. 04, 1991 Motion for Rehearing filed.
Aug. 30, 1991 City of Naples' and Citizens to preserve Naples Bay's motion to dismiss filed.
Aug. 22, 1991 Motion of the conservancy, Inc. and Florida audubon society to strikethe CDC reply or, in the alternative, request that it be considered as further reason for dismissal of the petitions in the above-styled consolidated matters rec 'd.
Jul. 25, 1991 Response of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Scoiety to theDER's petition for review of non-final agency action filed.
Jul. 12, 1991 Notice of Substitution of Counsel filed.
Jul. 03, 1991 Motion of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society for an extension of time to file a response to the petition for review of non-final agency action filed.
Jul. 01, 1991 Motion of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society to consolidate the above-styled case with case no. 91-01573 filed.
Jun. 27, 1991 CDC Reply; Lee County's Response to Motion to Expedite filed.
Jun. 25, 1991 Order on Department's Motion For Stay filed. (From Timothy A. Smith)
Jun. 24, 1991 (2nd DCA) Response to Motion to Dismiss filed.
Jun. 20, 1991 (2nd DCA) CDC's Motion to Dismiss or Abate filed.
Jun. 19, 1991 Response of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society in Opposition to the Petition for Mandamus filed.
Jun. 19, 1991 Response of the Conservancy, Inc. and FL Audubon Society in Opposition to the Petition for Mandamus filed.
Jun. 18, 1991 2nd DCA Docketing Statement filed.
Jun. 17, 1991 Response to the City of Naples and Citizens to Preserve Naples Bsay, Inc. to Court's June 7, 1991 Order and Appendix filed. (Note: Original Appendix sent to Ann Cockeu at the Department of Legal Affairs.-ac)
Jun. 14, 1991 (Petitioner) Motion For Stay of Further Proceedings Pending Review filed. (From Patricia E. Comer)
Jun. 11, 1991 Petition for Review of Non-Final Agency Action filed.
May 24, 1991 Department of Environmental Regulation's Exceptions to Order Declining Remand filed.
May 24, 1991 Petition for Mandamus filed. Request for Oral Argument rec'd Appendix to Petitioners Petition for Mandamus rec'd
May 09, 1991 Order Declining Remand sent out.
Mar. 20, 1991 Order Allowing The Filing of Depositions, and Denial of Their Admission As Evidence sent out.
Jan. 18, 1991 Response of Petitioners to CDC Pleadings and Certification Request filed. (From Joseph Z. Fleming)
Jan. 10, 1991 Objections to Remand & attachments filed. (from Ken G. Oertel)
Jan. 09, 1991 CDC'S Response to Objections by Conservancy and Audubon filed. (from John Beranek)
Jan. 08, 1991 Order of Remand filed.
Jan. 02, 1991 (Petitioners) Objection to Filing filed. (From Kenneth G. Oertel)
Dec. 21, 1990 CDC'S Response to Objections of City filed. (From J. Beranek)
Dec. 21, 1990 Deposition of R. Bruce Taylor (2 Vols) filed.
Dec. 21, 1990 (Respondent) Notice of Filing filed. (From J. Beranek)
Dec. 21, 1990 Petitioners' Objections to the DER Secretary's "Order of Remand" and CDC's "Notice of Filing" Joinder in the "Objections to Remand of the City and Citizens" and Supplemental Objections filed.
Dec. 10, 1990 Notice of Filing w/exhibits 1-7 filed. (from J. A. Kurell)
Dec. 10, 1990 Objections to remand filed.
Oct. 16, 1990 Recommended Order sent out. CASE CLOSED. Hearing held Jan 16-19, 22-25, 29-31, 1990; Feb 1-2, 5-7, 1990; Apr 23, 25-27, 30, 1990; May 1; Jun 19-22, 29, 1990; Jul 9-10, 1990.
Oct. 02, 1990 CC (DER) Exhibit-5 filed. (From Patricia E. Comer) TAGGED
Sep. 28, 1990 TCI Exhibit 20 filed. (from Joseph Z. Fleming)
Jul. 30, 1990 Lely Civic Association, Inc. and East naples Civic Association, Inc.'s Proposed Recommended Order filed. (From Pamela S. Mac'Kie)
Jul. 27, 1990 Department of Environmental Regulation Proposed Recommended Order filed. (From Patricia E. Comer)
Jul. 27, 1990 (City of Naples & Citizens to Preserve Naples Bay) Response to Noticeof Filing of Collier Development Corporation filed.
Jul. 27, 1990 Final Argument, Proposed Findings of Fact, and Conclusions of Law of Intervenor, City of Naples, and Petitioner Citizens to Preserve NaplesBay filed.
Jul. 27, 1990 CDC's Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Jul. 27, 1990 Response of Petitioners to Notice of Filing of Collier Development Corp. filed.
Jul. 27, 1990 Proposed Recommended Order of Petitioners The Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society filed.
Jul. 25, 1990 Transcript (60 Vols) filed.
Jul. 20, 1990 Department of Environemtnal Regulation Notice of Filing & attachment filed. (From Patricia E. Comer)
Jul. 19, 1990 (Respondent) Notice of Filing w/Interrogatories to and Responses of Herbert L. Windom Regarding Intervenor City of Naples Exhibit 16 filed.(From Herbert L. Windom)
Jul. 12, 1990 CDC Notice of Filing w/exhibits (1 Book) filed. (From John K. Aurell)
Jul. 09, 1990 CASE STATUS: Hearing Held.
Jun. 29, 1990 CASE STATUS: Hearing Partially Held, continued to 7/9/90; 10:00am; Talla)
Jun. 27, 1990 CDC Notice of Regarding Field Work filed. (from John K. Aurell)
Jun. 26, 1990 City of Naples Exhibits 10, 14 & 15 ; & cover letter from K. Oertel filed.
Jun. 23, 1990 CASE STATUS: Hearing Partially Held, continued to 6/29/90; 10:30am; Talla
Jun. 08, 1990 Letter to Parties from B. Grant setting hearing sent out. (hearing isset for 6-19-90; 10:00; Naples)
May 31, 1990 Notice of Taking Deposition filed. (from Kenneth G. Oertel)
May 10, 1990 Vol II of Exhibits filed.
May 03, 1990 CC of Deposition of Kenneth L. Echternacht (entered as intervenor's exhibit #11 at hearing); & cover letter from K. Oertel filed. .
Apr. 23, 1990 CASE STATUS: HEARING CONTINUED TO 4/25/90; 10:00AM; NAPLES.
Apr. 10, 1990 Notice of Substitution of Counsel for Department of Enviromental Regulation filed. (from P. Comer).
Mar. 22, 1990 Amended Notice of Hearing (amended to reflect correct date in last paragraph of page 2) sent out. (hearing set for 4/23/90; 9:00am; Talla and 4/25-30/90, 5/1-3/90 & 6/18-29/90; Naples).
Mar. 21, 1990 Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for 4-23-90; 9:00; Talla; 4-25-90; 11:00; Naples; 4/26-27/90; 8:30; Naples; 4-30-90; 9:00; Naples; May 1-3, 1990; 8:30; Naples)
Mar. 13, 1990 (Petitioners) Notice of Filing by Petitioners & attachments filed.
Mar. 09, 1990 CASE STATUS: HEARING CONTINUED TO 4/23/90; 9:00AM; TALLA.
Mar. 08, 1990 CASE STATUS: HEARING CONTINUED TO 3/9/90; 9:00AM; TALLA.
Mar. 07, 1990 CASE STATUS: HEARING CONTINUED TO 3/8/90; 9:00AM; TALLA.
Mar. 06, 1990 CASE STATUS: HEARING CONTINUED TO 3/7/90; 9:00AM; TALLA.
Mar. 05, 1990 CASE STATUS: HEARING CONTINUED TO 3/6/90; 9:00AM; TALLA.
Mar. 02, 1990 CASE STATUS: Hearing Partially Held, continued to 3-5-90; 10:00; Naples)
Mar. 02, 1990 CASE STATUS: HEARING CONTINUED TO 3/5/90; 9:00AM; TALLA.
Mar. 01, 1990 CASE STATUS; HEARING CONTINUED TO 3/2/90; 8:30AM; TALLA.
Feb. 27, 1990 CASE STATUS: Hearing Partially Held, continued to 2-28-90; 8:30; Talla)
Feb. 26, 1990 CASE STATUS: Hearing Partially Held, continued to 2-29-90; 9:00; Talla)
Feb. 21, 1990 Notice of Substitution of Counsel For Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Feb. 21, 1990 Notice of Substitution of Counsel for Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Feb. 16, 1990 (Respondent) Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
Feb. 14, 1990 Petitioners' Notice of Re-Filing & Exhibits filed.
Jan. 29, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum & Affidavit filed.
Jan. 22, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum w/Affidavit & attachments filed.
Jan. 19, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum (25) filed.
Jan. 18, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum filed.
Jan. 16, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum & attachment (4) filed.
Jan. 12, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum filed.
Jan. 12, 1990 CDC'S Memorandum in Opposition to City's Motions for Protective Orderand to Quash Subpoena for Taylor Deposition filed.
Jan. 11, 1990 Motion to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum w/Exhibit-A filed.
Jan. 11, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum filed.
Jan. 10, 1990 Petitioners the Conservancy, Inc.'s and Florida Audubon Society's Witness and Evidence List and Request for and Extension of Time for Supplementing the Lists (Assuming That the Hearing Officer Were to Approve a Deadline for Submission of Lists) filed.
Jan. 10, 1990 Motion for Protective Order filed.
Jan. 10, 1990 CDC'S Memorandum in Opposition to City's Motion to Bifurcate filed.
Jan. 10, 1990 Motion for Protective Order filed.
Jan. 10, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum (5) filed.
Jan. 10, 1990 CDC'S Response to Cavallero's Motion for Protective Order filed.
Jan. 09, 1990 Notice of Deposition filed.
Jan. 09, 1990 Notice of Deposition & attachment filed.
Jan. 09, 1990 Notice of Deposition filed.
Jan. 08, 1990 Subpoena Ad Testificandum (12) filed.
Jan. 08, 1990 Respondent's Response to Order to Show Cause filed.
Jan. 08, 1990 Notice of Deposition filed.
Jan. 08, 1990 Notice of Substitution of Counsel for Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Jan. 05, 1990 Motion to Bifurcate Hearing filed.
Jan. 05, 1990 Amended Notice by The Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society of Taking Deposition filed.
Jan. 04, 1990 (City of Naples) Amended Notice of Deposition filed.
Dec. 29, 1989 Notice by the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society of TakingDeposition filed.
Dec. 29, 1989 Notice by the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society of TakingDeposition filed.
Dec. 27, 1989 Amended Notice of Deposition filed. (from J. Aurell).
Dec. 27, 1989 Letter to VED from J. Radey (re: document production) filed.
Dec. 27, 1989 CDC's Supplement to Response to Conservancy's Interrogatories to CDC rec'd
Dec. 26, 1989 Letter to VED from T. Tomasello (re: request for documents/& 1 att) filed.
Dec. 26, 1989 Letter to VED from T. Tomasello (re: Sabal Bay project) filed.
Dec. 26, 1989 CDC's Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion to Compel Discovery from Conservancy and Audubon filed.
Dec. 26, 1989 Motion of Petitioners for Protective Order as to Depositions Noticed by CDC of Current and Prior Directors of the Conservancy, Inc. filed.
Dec. 22, 1989 Ltr. to VED from J. Radey (re: Request to Produce Discovery) filed.
Dec. 22, 1989 Sierra Club Motion to Voluntarily Dismiss filed.
Dec. 21, 1989 (City of Naples) Notice of Depositions filed.
Dec. 21, 1989 CDC's Response to City's First Production Request; CDC's Memorandum in Opposition to City's Motion to Compel Document Production; Affidavitof Richard P. Henderlong (+ exh's) filed.
Dec. 20, 1989 CDC'S Preliminary Response to City's First Production Request filed.
Dec. 20, 1989 Response to Petitioners the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society in Opposition to CDC'S Motion to Compel Discovery w/Exhibits A-C filed.
Dec. 20, 1989 Reply of Petitioenrs to CDC'S Memorandum in Opposition to the Conservancy's Motion for Extension to Respond to Motion to Compel filed.
Dec. 20, 1989 CDC's Memorandum in Opposition to The City's Motion to Compel Entry (+ att's) filed.
Dec. 19, 1989 Motion to Compel Production of Documents filed.
Dec. 18, 1989 Notice of Status Conference filed.
Dec. 18, 1989 Amended Notice of Status Conference filed.
Dec. 18, 1989 CDC's Response to Notice of Status Conference filed.
Dec. 18, 1989 CDC's Memorandum in Opposition to the Conservancy's Motion for Extension to Respond to Motion to Compel filed.
Dec. 18, 1989 CDC's Response to Notice of Status Conference filed.
Dec. 15, 1989 (City of Naples) Motion to Compel Entry and Request for Oral Argumentfiled.
Dec. 14, 1989 Motion of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society for an Extension of Time Within Which to Respond to CDC'S Motion to Compel Discovery filed.
Dec. 13, 1989 City of Napels Charpter 119, Florida Statutes, Public Records Requestfor the Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Dec. 13, 1989 Notice of Deposition filed.
Dec. 12, 1989 City of Naples' First Request for Production of Documents filed.
Dec. 08, 1989 Request by City of Naples to Permit Entry Upon Sabal Bay Land filed.
Dec. 08, 1989 (Collier Development Corp) Partially Consented to Motion for Prehearing Order (+ attat. A) filed.
Dec. 07, 1989 Notice of Deposition - Livingston filed.
Dec. 07, 1989 Certificate of Counsel filed.
Dec. 06, 1989 CDC'S Motion to Compel Discovery w/exhibits 1-13 filed.
Dec. 06, 1989 Objections and Motion of Petitioners the Conservancy, Inc., Florida Audubon Society, and Dr. Robert Livingston to The Subpoena Duces Tecum and the Notices of Deposition filed.
Dec. 04, 1989 Lely Civic Association, Inc.'s Petition to Interven in Department of Environmental Regulation Licensing Proceeding filed.
Dec. 01, 1989 Notice of Deposition-Livingston filed.
Nov. 22, 1989 Subpoena Duces Tecum & Affidavit filed.
Nov. 21, 1989 Notice of Service of the Department of Environmental Regulation's Responses to the Conservancy's First Set of Interrogatories filed.
Nov. 15, 1989 Supplemental Objections and Answers to CDC'S Interrogatories Relatingto Certain Witnesses filed.
Nov. 13, 1989 Objections and Motion of Petitioners The Conservancy, Inc., Florida Audubon Society, Dr. Sam Snedaker, and Dr. Harold Wanless to the Subpoena Duces Tecum and The Notices of Depositions (+ exh A-C) filed.
Nov. 13, 1989 Notice by Petitioners The Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society of Taking Depositions of the Department of Enviromental Regulation filed.
Nov. 07, 1989 Notice by the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society of TakingDeposition filed.
Nov. 02, 1989 Petition of the City of Naples for Leave to Intervene filed.
Nov. 02, 1989 Notice of Deposition-Wanless filed.
Oct. 30, 1989 Objections of Petitioner Florida Audubon Society to CDC'S Second Interrogatories to Audubon filed.
Oct. 30, 1989 First Request of The Conservancy, Inc. for Production of Documents from the Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Oct. 26, 1989 Notice of Service of Answers to CDC'S Second Set of Interogatories filed.
Oct. 20, 1989 Order on Motion to Set Deadline sent out.
Oct. 20, 1989 CDC'S Request for Consolidation and Response to City of Naples' Response to Motion of Conservancy and Florida Audubon Requesting Consolidation filed.
Oct. 10, 1989 Objection of Florida Audbon Society and Bernard Yokel to the Notice of Request for Subpoena and the Subpoena Duces Tecum Without DepositionAttached filed.
Oct. 06, 1989 Order of Consolidation sent out. Consolidated case are: 88-6212, 88-6215, 89-4159, 89-4407 & 89-1841DRI.
Oct. 06, 1989 Response of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society to CDC's Motion to Set Deadline; CDC's Answers to Conservancy's Third Interrogatories filed.
Sep. 28, 1989 Notice of Request for Subpoena filed.
Sep. 27, 1989 Notice of Deposition-Yokel filed.
Sep. 26, 1989 Notice of Deposition - Audubon filed.
Sep. 25, 1989 CDC'S First Request for Admissions & attachments filed.
Sep. 25, 1989 CDC'S Motion to Set Deadline filed.
Sep. 25, 1989 Notice of Service of CDC'S Second Interrogatories to Audubon filed.
Sep. 12, 1989 Objections and Answers to CDC'S First Interrogatoreis to Florida Audubon Society filed.
Sep. 06, 1989 Amended Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for 1-16-90 thru 2-2-90; 9:00 am; Naples).
Aug. 30, 1989 Motion of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon SocietyRequestingThat Upon Transmittal to the Division of Administrative Hearings, TheAbove-Styled Matter be Consolidated With Pending Related DER Proceedings filed.
Aug. 30, 1989 Motion of the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society for Leaveto Intervene as Materially Affected Parties filed.
Aug. 30, 1989 Objections and Answers to CDC'S Second Itnerrogatories to the Conservancy, Inc. filed.
Aug. 24, 1989 Response of Collier Development Corporation to Motion to Reschedule Hearing and for Ultimate Consolidation of Cases filed.
Aug. 24, 1989 Response of Collier Development Corporation to Motion to Reschedule Hearing and for Ultimate Consoldiation of Cases filed.
Aug. 22, 1989 Supplemental Motion of Petitioners the Conservancy, Inc. and Florida Audubon Society for Postponement of the Hearing Now Scheduled in This Matter w/exhibits A&B filed.
Aug. 21, 1989 Motion of Petitioner the Conservancy, Inc. for Entry of an Order Resetting the Hearing in the Above-Styled Matter in View of the Need to Consolidate Additional Matters (for the Purposes of Ultimately Enavling the Hearing Officer to Obtain Jurisdiction o
Aug. 21, 1989 Order of Consolidation sent out. Consolidated case are: 88-6212, 88-6215, 89-4159 & 89-4407.
Aug. 21, 1989 Notice of Hearing (set for Sept 25- Oct 13, 1989; 9:00am; Naples) sent out.
Aug. 17, 1989 Notice by Petitioner the Conservancy, Inc. of Taking Depositions of the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Aug. 17, 1989 Notice by Petitioner the Conservancy, Inc. Of Taking Depositions of the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Aug. 16, 1989 Notice of Deposition-Conservancy filed.
Aug. 15, 1989 Notice of Related Cases and Motion to Consolidate by Respondent Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Aug. 15, 1989 Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for 10/13/89; 9:00am; Naples)
Aug. 15, 1989 Notice of Substitution of Counsel for Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Aug. 15, 1989 Order of Consolidation sent out. Consolidated case are: 88-6212, 88-6215 & 89-4159.
Aug. 07, 1989 Notice of Service of the Coonservancy's 3rd Set of Interrogs. to Collier Development Corp; Notice of Service of the Conservancy's 1st Set of Interrogs. to Respondent DER filed.
Aug. 07, 1989 Notice of Service of CDC's 1st Interrogs. to Audubon; Notice of Service of CDC's 3rd Interrogs. to Conservancy; Notice of Service of CDC's 3rd Interrogs. to Sierra Club filed.
Aug. 04, 1989 (DER) Notice of Related Cases and Motion to Consolidate by RespondentDepartment of Enviromental Regulation filed.
Jul. 24, 1989 Notice of Service of CDC's Second Interrogatories to Conservancy filed.
Jul. 17, 1989 Notice of Substitution of Counsel for Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
Jul. 17, 1989 Notice by Petitioner the Conservancy, Inc. Of Taking Depositions of the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation filed.
May 08, 1989 Amended Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for 10/13/89;8:30AM;Naples)
Apr. 11, 1989 CDC Response to TCI Motion for Continuance filed.
Apr. 03, 1989 Motion of Petitioner the Conservancy, Inc. for Rescheduling of the Hearing Now Scheduled for June 5 Through June 16, 1989 filed.
Mar. 28, 1989 CDC Answers and Objections to the Conservancy, Inc.'s Second Set of Interrogatories filed.
Mar. 13, 1989 Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for 6/5-16/89, 9:00a, Naples)
Feb. 09, 1989 (Petitioner's) Exhibits filed.
Feb. 06, 1989 Notice by Petitioner of Additional Efforts to Resolve Discovery Problems filed.
Feb. 06, 1989 Objections and Response to CDC'S First Request for Production of Documents ffrom the Conservancy, Inc. filed.
Feb. 06, 1989 Objections and Answers to CDC First Set of Interrogatories to the Conservancy, Inc. & attachments filed.
Feb. 03, 1989 CDC Answers and Objections to Interrogatories Propounded by Conservancy, Inc. filed.
Feb. 01, 1989 CDC Response to the First Request of the Conservancy, Inc. for Production of Documents from Collier Development Corporation filed.
Jan. 31, 1989 Response of the Conservancy, Inc. to the "CDC'S Motion to Compel and the "CDC'S Response to the Motion of the Conservancy for and Extensionof Time filed.
Jan. 30, 1989 Notice of Service of the Conservancy's Second Set of Interrogatories to Collier Development Corp. filed.
Jan. 26, 1989 Objections of the Conservancy, Inc to the Interrogatories and the Request for Production Filed by Collier Development Corp. filed.
Jan. 26, 1989 Motion of the Conservancy, Inc for an Extension of Time Within Which to Respond to Collier Development Corp.'s First Set of Interrogatoriesto the Conservancy, Inc and First Request for Production of Documentsfiled.
Jan. 25, 1989 CDC Motion to Compel filed.
Jan. 25, 1989 CDC Notice of Place of Production filed.
Jan. 25, 1989 CDC Response to Motion of the Conservancy, Inc. for an Extension of Time filed.
Jan. 25, 1989 CDC Response to Motion of the Conservancy, Inc. for an Extension of Time filed.
Jan. 10, 1989 DER/Applicant Response to Prehearing Order filed.
Jan. 10, 1989 Report of the Conservancy, Inc. in Response to the Order Dated December 21, 1988 & cover ltr filed.
Jan. 05, 1989 First Request of the Conservancy, Inc. for Production of Documents from Collier Development Corporation filed.
Dec. 30, 1988 New Certificate of Service filed.
Dec. 22, 1988 CDC'S First Request for Production of Documents from the Sierra Club filed.
Dec. 22, 1988 Notice of Service of CDC First Set of Interrogatoires to the Sierra Club filed.
Dec. 21, 1988 Order of Consolidation sent out. Consolidated case are: 88-6212 and88-6215.
Dec. 21, 1988 Initial Order sent out.
Dec. 21, 1988 Order of Consolidation sent out. Consolidated case are: 88-6212 and88-6215
Dec. 21, 1988 Order of Consolidation sent out. (consolidated cases are 88-6212 & 88-6215)
Dec. 21, 1988 Order of Consolidation sent out. Consolidated case are: 88-6212 and88-6215
Source:  Florida - Division of Administrative Hearings

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.
Ask a Question
Search for lawyers by practice areas.
Find a Lawyer