Elawyers Elawyers
Ohio| Change

SIERRA CLUB, INC., AND MANASOTA-88 INC. vs HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY AND DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS, 90-006639GM (1990)

Court: Division of Administrative Hearings, Florida Number: 90-006639GM Visitors: 1
Petitioner: SIERRA CLUB, INC., AND MANASOTA-88 INC.
Respondent: HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY AND DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS
Judges: ROBERT E. MEALE
Agency: Department of Community Affairs
Locations: Tampa, Florida
Filed: Oct. 19, 1990
Status: Closed
Recommended Order on Tuesday, December 8, 1992.

Latest Update: Jul. 05, 2024

Docket for Case No: 90-006639GM
Issue Date Proceedings
Apr. 01, 1998 (Admin Commission) Notice of Commission Meeting filed.
Sep. 16, 1994 Notice of Voluntary Dismissal (from David L. Smith) filed.
Aug. 24, 1994 Motion to strike the Department of Community Affairs' response to motion to supplement the record filed.
Jun. 10, 1994 Notice of Substitution of Counsel for Department of Community Affairs filed.
May 18, 1994 Department of Community Affairs Reply To Big Bend Area Group's MotionTo Strike filed.
May 06, 1994 Department of Community Affairs Request for An Extension of Time to Respond to BBAG's Motion to Strike filed.
Apr. 19, 1994 Live Oak's motion for extension of time to file respone to Sierra Club, Inc.'s motion to quash appeal filed.
Apr. 06, 1994 Department of Community Affairs Response to Big Bend Area Group's Motion for Stay Pending Appeal filed.
Apr. 01, 1994 AGENCY APPEAL, ONCE THE RETENTION SCHEDULE OF -KEEP ONE YEAR AFTER CLOSURE- IS MET, CASE FILE IS RETURNED TO AGENCY GENERAL COUNSEL. -ac
Apr. 01, 1994 AGENCY APPEAL, ONCE THE RETENTION SCHEDULE OF -KEEP ONE YEAR AFTER CLOSURE- IS MET, CASE FILE IS RETURNED TO AGENCY GENERAL COUNSEL. -ac
Mar. 31, 1994 (Admin Comm) Order filed.
Mar. 23, 1994 Hillsborough County's Response to BBAG's Motion for Stay Pending Appeal filed.
Mar. 23, 1994 Department of Community Affairs Request for an Extension of Time to Respond to BBAG'S Motion for Stay Pending Appeal filed.
Feb. 28, 1994 (Live Oak Realty, N.V.,) Directions to the Clerk filed.
Jan. 18, 1994 AGENCY APPEAL, ONCE THE RETENTION SCHEDULE OF -KEEP ONE YEAR AFTER CLOSURE- IS MET, CASE FILE IS RETURNED TO AGENCY GENERAL COUNSEL. -ac
Dec. 17, 1993 Final Order filed.
Aug. 24, 1993 Hillsborough County's Motion to Set Hearing Date and Response to Sierra Club, Inc.'s Motion to Set Hearing Date filed.
Dec. 08, 1992 Recommended Order sent out. CASE CLOSED. Hearing held 9/23-27/91.
Nov. 12, 1992 Letter to REM from David Lisle Smith (re: request for copy of Final Order) filed.
Nov. 02, 1992 Request for Copy of RO filed. (From Thomas Reese)
Sep. 21, 1992 Map 18 (indvertently excluded from materials supplied as Sierra Club Exhibit-1) filed.
Jun. 26, 1992 Order sent out. (motion denied)
Jun. 22, 1992 Sierra Club, Inc.'s Motion for Rehearing of Motion to Strike May 28 Letter filed.
Jun. 17, 1992 Order sent out. (Sierra Club, Inc.'s Motion to Strike County's May 28 Letter is DENIED)
Jun. 05, 1992 Sierra Club, Inc.'s Motion to Strike County's May 28 Letter filed.
Jan. 22, 1992 Second Errata to Sierra Club, Inc.'s Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Jan. 02, 1992 Corrected Pages for Proposed Recommended Order of Hillsborough County; & Cover Letter to REM from J. Dingfelder filed.
Dec. 30, 1991 Proposed Recommended Order of Hillsborough County ; Appendix ; Disk ; & Cover letter from J. Dingfelder filed.
Dec. 26, 1991 CC Letter to Neal A. Snyder et al from Michael P. Donaldson (re: filing date of PRO) filed.
Dec. 26, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.'s Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Dec. 24, 1991 Errata to Sierra Club, Inc.'s Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Dec. 24, 1991 Petitioner, Department of Community Affairs' Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Dec. 24, 1991 Proposed Recommended Order of Hillsborough County filed.
Dec. 24, 1991 Intervenor's Big Bend Area Group, Inc. Proposed Recommended Final Order filed.
Dec. 24, 1991 Intervenor's Big Bend Area Group, Inc. Proposed Recommended Final Order filed.
Dec. 23, 1991 Several Pages to Update Hillsborough County Comprehensive Plan (Sierra Club Exhibit-1) filed.
Dec. 23, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.'s Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Nov. 15, 1991 Letter to REM from John J. Dingfelder (re: no objection to Motion fora thirty day extension) filed.
Nov. 08, 1991 (Petitioner) Motion for Extension of Time to File Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Nov. 01, 1991 CC Letter to Thomas Reese from John J. Dingfelder (re: ltr to Neal Sivyer dated October 25, 1991) filed.
Oct. 30, 1991 Statutes and Regulations filed. (From John J. Dingfelder)
Oct. 28, 1991 CC Letter to Neil Sivyer from Thomas W. Reese (re: PRO) filed.
Oct. 28, 1991 Transcript (Vols 1&2 of day 4) & Vols 1&2 of day 5) filed.
Oct. 24, 1991 Transcript (Vols 1-6) filed.
Oct. 18, 1991 Hillsborough Countyt's Exhibit 14 (Sierra Club ltr dated January 19, 1990) filed.
Oct. 14, 1991 (one box) Hillsborough's Exhibits 1-7,12,19-34,36,38-58 w/cover ltr filed.
Oct. 07, 1991 CC Letter to Peggy Huffman from Neal A. Sivyer (re: Big Bend Area Group Wishes to Transcribe the entrie hearing) filed.
Oct. 07, 1991 CC Governor's Task Force Report filed.
Sep. 27, 1991 CASE STATUS: Hearing Held.
Sep. 23, 1991 Response to Sierra Club, Inc.`s Motion to Amend; Bbag`s Objections to the Documents of the Sierra Club filed. (From Neal A. Sivyer)
Sep. 23, 1991 Hillsborough County Amended Expedite List filed. (From John J. Dingfelder)
Sep. 20, 1991 Hillsborough County`s Motion to Disqualify Sierra Club, Inc.`s Counsel of Record; Hillsborough County`s Motion in Opposition to Sierra Club, Inc.`s Motion For Leave to Amend Second Amended Complaint filed. (From John J. Dingfelder)
Sep. 20, 1991 Sierra Club Response to Motion to Exclude Witness; Sierra Club Inc.'sResponse to Motion in Limine; Notice to Produce Documents at Final Hearing filed. (From Thomas Reese)
Sep. 19, 1991 Hillsborough County Amended Witness List filed. (From John J. Dingfelder)
Sep. 19, 1991 Motion to Exclude Witness; Motion for Disclosure of Ex Parte Communications filed. (From David L. Smith)
Sep. 18, 1991 Order Denying Motion to Determine Standard of Review sent out.
Sep. 17, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.'s Motion for Leave to Amend Second Amended Complaint w/Atts; Witness List; Sierra Club, Inc.'s Exhibit List and Objections to Other Parties Exhibits filed.
Sep. 17, 1991 Joint Pre-Trial Stipulation; Second Amended BBAG Witness List; Witness and Exhibit Lists filed.
Sep. 16, 1991 (BBAG) Motion to Determine Standard of Review; Motion in Limine; Notice of Taking Deposition DT filed.
Sep. 16, 1991 (Intervenors) Notice of Withdrawal as a Party filed.
Sep. 16, 1991 (Respondent) Notice of Taking Deposition DT; Motion in Limine; Motion to Determine Standard of Review filed.
Sep. 16, 1991 (Intervenors) Sierra Club, Inc.`s Motion for Protective Order; Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum filed.
Sep. 13, 1991 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum w/Exhibit-A; Notice of Taking Deposition Decus Tecum filed. (From Neal A. Sivyer)
Sep. 12, 1991 Witness List filed. (From Neal A. Sivyer)
Sep. 11, 1991 Letter to John J. Dingfelder from Thomas W. Reese (re: pending Sierra Club`s Public Record and Discovery Requests) filed.
Sep. 11, 1991 CC Letter to Neal A. Sivyer from Thomas W. Reese (re: ltr dated August 14, 1991) filed.
Sep. 10, 1991 Joint Motion For Telephonic Pre-Hearing Conference filed.
Sep. 09, 1991 Notice of Taking Deposition Duces Tecum (3) filed. (From Neal A. Sivyer)
Sep. 09, 1991 Department of Community Affairs Response to Sierra Club, Inc.`s Fourth Request for Admissions & attachments filed. (From Stephanie P. Donaldson)
Sep. 06, 1991 Joint Motion For Telephonic Pre-Hearing Conference filed.
Sep. 06, 1991 Order Denying Request for Prehearing Conference and Denying In Part and Granting in Part County's Motion for Protective Order sent out.
Aug. 28, 1991 Page 2 of the Hillsborough County`s Amended Response to Sierra Club`s Fourth Set of Reequest for Admissions filed. (From John J. Dingfelder)
Aug. 26, 1991 Hillsborough County`s Motion For Protective Order w/Exhibit-A filed. (From John J. Dingfelder)
Aug. 21, 1991 Intervenor BBag's Request for Production of Documents; Notice of Service of Interrogatories; Witness Interrogatories to Sierra Club, Inc. filed.
Aug. 16, 1991 (Sierra Club) Notice of Deposition filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
Aug. 12, 1991 Order on Second Amended Motion to Intervene and Discovery Dispute Between Hillsborough County and Sierra Club, Inc. sent out. (Big Bend Area Group 2nd amended petition to intervene granted).
Aug. 12, 1991 CC Letter to Thomas Reese from Mcihael P. Donaldson (re: discovery requests) filed.
Aug. 12, 1991 (Sierra Club) Notice of Deposition filed.
Aug. 12, 1991 (Sierra Club) Notice of Deposition filed.
Aug. 08, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.'s Fourth Set of Requests For Admission to Hillsborough County and Departmnet of Community Affairs filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
Aug. 07, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Response to Hillsborough County`s Motion for Protective Order filed. (From Thomas Reese)
Aug. 05, 1991 Notice of Deposition filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
Aug. 05, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Motion to Impose Sanctions Against Hillsborough County For Failure to comply With Order Concerning Answering Requests for Admission & attachments filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
Aug. 05, 1991 Notice of Deposition filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
Aug. 02, 1991 Hillsborough County`s Motion For Protective Order w/Exhibit-A filed. (From John J. Dingfelder)
Aug. 01, 1991 Corrected Page 30 w/Ltr to John Dingfelder from Thomas W. Reese (re: County's Response to Sierra Club's Fourth Set of Request for Admissions filed.
Jul. 31, 1991 Big Bend Area Group, Inc.`s Reply to Sierra Club, Inc.`s Response to Second Amended Motion to Intervene filed. (From David L. Smith)
Jul. 31, 1991 Big Bend ARea Group, Inc.`s Reply to Sierra Club, Inc.`s Response to Second Amended Motion to Intervene filed. (From David Lisle Smith)
Jul. 29, 1991 Notice of Service of Manaota-88, Inc.`s First Set of Interrogatories and Request for Production of Documents (#1-4) filed. (from Thomas W. Reese)
Jul. 29, 1991 Notice of Deposition filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
Jul. 26, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Response to Big Bend Area Group, Inc.`s Second Amended Motion to Intervene filed. (From Thomas Reese)
Jul. 22, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Motion to Determine Sufficiency of County`s Interrogatory Answers w/Exhibits 1-6 filed. (From Thomas Reese)
Jul. 17, 1991 (Sierra Club) Notice of Deposition filed.
Jul. 15, 1991 Big Bend Group, Inc.'s Second Amended Motion for Leave to Intervene as Petitioner-In-Intervention and Response and Request for Clarification filed.
Jun. 25, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Notice of Service of Responses to the County`s Second Set of Interrogatories and Request for Production filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
Jun. 21, 1991 (Petitioner) Notice of Substitution of Counsel filed. (From Michael P. Donaldson)
Jun. 20, 1991 Order on Requests to Intervene, to Resolve Discovery Disputes and to Clarify sent out.
Jun. 11, 1991 Letter to REM from John J. Dingfelder (re: Clarification of Order) filed.
Jun. 06, 1991 Hillsborough County`s Notice of Service of Amended Response filed. (from Bonnie E. Allen)
Jun. 05, 1991 Respondent Hillsborough County`s Reply to Sierra Club Inc.`s Response to County`s Motion For Leave to File Additional Interrogatories filed. (From Bonnie E. Allen)
Jun. 05, 1991 Notice of Substitution of Counsel filed. (From Bonnie E. Allen)
Jun. 03, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Response to County`s Motion For Leave to File Additional Interrogatories filed. (From Thomas Reese)
Jun. 03, 1991 Big Bend Area Group, Inc.'s Memorandum of Law in Support of Its Amended Motion For Leave to Intervene and In Opposition to Sierra Club, Inc.'s Response in Opposition to Big Bend Area Group, Inc.'s Amended Motion For Leave to Intervene filed. (From David
May 29, 1991 Hillsborough Countys Notice of Service filed.
May 28, 1991 CC Letter to Bonnie E. Allen from T W. Reese (re: May 20, 1991 ltr concerning misindetified discovery requests) filed.
May 28, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc. Response in Opposition to Big Bend Area Group, Inc.`s Amended Motion For Leave to Intervene filed. (From T. W. Reese)
May 24, 1991 Respondent Hillsborough County's Motion For Leave to File Additional Interrogatories; Hillsborough County's Second Set of Interrogatories and Requests For Production; Notice of Service of Respondent Hillsborough County's Second Set of Interrogatories an
May 21, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Response to "Motion For Protective Order or, In the Alternative, Inc Limine filed. (From Thomas Reese)
May 20, 1991 Corrected Page 30 & cover ltr filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
May 17, 1991 Big Bend Area Group, Inc.'s Amended Motion for Leave to Intervene as Petitioner-in-Intervention filed.
May 16, 1991 Big Bend Area Group, Inc.`s Amended Motion For Leave to Intervene as Petitioner-in-Intervention filed. (from David L. Smith)
May 15, 1991 Hillsborough County`s Motion For Protective Order Or, in The Alternative, In Limine w/(TAGGED) Exhibits A-C filed. (From Bonnie E. Allen)
May 01, 1991 Order Denying Motion to Intervene (for Big Bend Area Group, Inc) sentout.
Apr. 25, 1991 Notice of Service of Interrogatories filed. (From Thomas W. Reese)
Apr. 24, 1991 Big Bend Area Group, Inc.'s Memorandum of Law in Suport of Its Motionto Intervene and In Opposition to Sierra Club, Inc.'s Response in Oposition filed. (From David Lisle Smith)
Apr. 18, 1991 Respondent Hillsborough County`s Second Amended Response to Sierra Club, Inc.`s Second Set of Requests For Admissions filed. (From Bonnie E. Allen)
Apr. 17, 1991 Hillsborough County`s Notice of Service filed. (From Bonnie E. Allen)
Apr. 17, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Response in Opposition to Motion For Leave to Intervene by Big Bend Area Group, Inc. filed. (from Thomas W. Reese)
Apr. 15, 1991 Big Bend Area Group, Inc.`s Motion For Leave to Intervene as Petitioner-in-Intervention filed. (From David Lisle Smith)
Apr. 15, 1991 Big Bend Area Group, Inc.`s Motion For Leave to Intervene as Petitioner-in-Intervention filed. (From David Lisle Smith)
Apr. 15, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Fourth Set of Requests For Admission to Hillsborough County (#1-303) (PartI) filed. (from Thomas Reese)
Apr. 10, 1991 Sierra Club's Response to Williams Accquisition Holding Company, Inc.'s Amended Motion to Intervene filed.
Apr. 09, 1991 Order Denying Motion to Strike or in the Alternative, for Protective Order sent out.
Apr. 08, 1991 Sierra Club`s Response to Hillsborough County`s Motion to Strike, Or In the Alternative, For Protective Order, and Sierra Club`s Motion For Leave to File Additional Interrogatories filed. (from Thomas W. Reese)
Apr. 08, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Reply to Hillsborough County`s Response to Sierra Club, Inc.`s Motion to Determine the Sufficiency of Objections filed. (from Thomas W. Reese)
Apr. 08, 1991 Order Denying Motion to Intervene sent out.
Apr. 08, 1991 Order on Objections to Requests for Admissions sent out.
Apr. 05, 1991 Williams Acquisition Holding Company, Inc.'s Response to Sierra Club,Inc.'s Reponse in Opposition to The Motion to Intervene filed.
Apr. 05, 1991 Respondent Hillsborough Countys Motion to Strike or, In The Alternative, for Protective Order filed.
Apr. 04, 1991 Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for Sept 23-27, 1991; 9:00am; Tampa)
Apr. 04, 1991 Letter to REM from T. Reese (Re: Enclosed Pages 2 and 3 of Exhibit Band Last page of The Motion) filed.
Apr. 02, 1991 Hillsborough Countys Response to Sierra Club, Inc.'s Motion to Determine The Sufficiency of Objections filed.
Apr. 01, 1991 (Intervenors) Notice of Service of Interrogatories filed.
Mar. 29, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.'s Motion to Set Final Hearing filed.
Mar. 29, 1991 Respondent Hillsborough Countys Motion to Schedule Final Hearing filed.
Mar. 25, 1991 Motion to Determine The Sufficiency of Hillsborough Countys Objections to Sierra Club, Inc.s Second Set of Requests for Admission (#1-32) and Request for Attorneys Fees filed.
Mar. 21, 1991 Hillsborough Countys Notice of Service filed.
Mar. 15, 1991 Sierra Club, Inc.'s Response in Opposition to the Motion to Interveneby the Williams Acquisition Holding Co., Inc. filed.
Mar. 12, 1991 (Petitioner) Motion to Intervene (for Williams Acquisition Holding Company, Inc.) filed.
Feb. 11, 1991 Department of Community Affairs' Response to Request for Admissions filed. (From David J. Russ)
Feb. 08, 1991 Hillsborough County`s Notice of Service & cover ltr filed. (From Bonnie E. Allen)
Feb. 04, 1991 Order to Show Cause sent out.
Jan. 16, 1991 Stipulated Order of Voluntary Dismissal (Petition in Intervention by Tom Traina is dismissed) sent out.
Jan. 14, 1991 Letter to REM from Thomas W. Reese (re: New Hearing Date) filed.
Jan. 14, 1991 (unsigned) Stipualted Order of Voluntary Dismissal & Settlement Agreement filed. (From Bonnie E. Allen)
Jan. 07, 1991 (Sierra) Notice of Service of Interrogatories; Sierra Club, Inc.`s Second Set of Requests For Admission to Hillsborough County and Department of Community Affairs (#1-32) filed. (from Thomas Reese)
Jan. 02, 1991 (Sierra Club) Notice of Service of Interrogatories filed.
Dec. 31, 1990 (Respondent) Amended Notice of Appearance; & cover letter from B. Allen filed.
Dec. 21, 1990 (Sierra Club, Inc) Notice of Deposition filed.
Dec. 13, 1990 Letter to REM from B. E. Allen (re: County's Appeal) filed.
Dec. 10, 1990 Order Granting Request to Vacate Stay sent out.
Dec. 10, 1990 (Intervenor) Notice of Filing; Intervenor Tom Traina Responce to Hillsborough County`s First Set of Interrogatories filed. (from T. Traina)
Dec. 10, 1990 Intervenor tom Traina Production of Documents to Hillsborough County w/exhibits D&E filed.
Dec. 07, 1990 Letter to REM from B. E. Allen (re: Order denying Hillsborough County's Motion For Reconsideration) filed.
Dec. 07, 1990 Sierra Club, Inc.`s Response to Hollborough County`s Motion For Reconsideration filed. (From T. W. Reese)
Dec. 06, 1990 Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration sent out.
Dec. 03, 1990 Respondent Hillsborough County`s Motion For Reconsideration w/exhibits A&B + Cover ltr filed. (from B. E. Allen)
Nov. 26, 1990 Sierra Club's Response to Hillsborough County's Request for Production of Documents filed.
Nov. 26, 1990 Sierra Club's Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories filed.
Nov. 26, 1990 (Hillsborough County) Notice of Appearance & cover letter from B. Allen filed.
Nov. 19, 1990 Notice of filing; & cover letter from B. Allen filed.
Nov. 09, 1990 Manasota-88, Inc.'s Response to Hillsborough County's Request for Production of Documents filed.
Nov. 09, 1990 Manasota-88, Inc.'s Notice of Service of Interrogatory Answers filed.
Nov. 07, 1990 Tampa Bay Regional Planning Council`s Notice of service of Answers to Interrogatories filed. (From Linda M. Hallas)
Nov. 05, 1990 Tampa Bay Retional Planning Council`s Response to First Request to Produce By Hillsborough County filed. (From Linda M. Hallas)
Oct. 31, 1990 (Respondent) Notice of filing filed. (From Emeline C. Action)
Oct. 30, 1990 Order Granting Leave to File Second Amended Petition in Intervention and Consolidating Cases for Hearing sent out. Consolidated case are: 89-5157GM and 90-6639GM
Oct. 30, 1990 Order Granting Leave to File Second Amended Petition in Intervention and Consolidating Cases for Hearing sent out. Consolidated case are:89-5157GM and 90-6639GM
Oct. 25, 1990 PPF's sent out.
Oct. 19, 1990 Agency referral letter; Petition for Hearing; Agency action letter; Notice of Intent, may include other supporting documents filed.
Source:  Florida - Division of Administrative Hearings

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.
Ask a Question
Search for lawyers by practice areas.
Find a Lawyer