PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD Case #: A16-654 LICENSE #:I-CGC1512764 Petitioner, vs NATHAN DUTCHER Respondent, ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT COMES NOW, the Petitioner, Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board, hereinafter referred to as “Petitioner”, and files this Administrative Complaint against NATHAN DUTCHER, hereinafter referred to as “Respondent”, and alleges: 1. Petitioner seeks to suspend, revoke or take other disciplinary action against the Respondent as licensee and against his license to practice contracting pursuant to Chapter 75-489, Laws of Florida, as amended. 2. Respondent is a General Contractor, having been issued license |-CGC1512764 (CGC1512764.) Respondent's address of record is 654 100th Ave N., St Petersburg, FL 33702. 3. At all times, material Respondent was the qualifying contractor for Point Residential LLC. 4. On March 28, 2016 the Respondent entered into a written contract with the Complainant for demolition and remodel of her mobile home, to include new floors, kitchen, bathroom, all fixtures, walls, baseboards, counters, and the construction of a new utility shed for a total cost of $29,550.00. Complainant stated that Respondent did not obtain required permits and that she paid him one payment of $16,000.00 before she realized what a disaster it was and paid him no more. He left her home in a terrible, unfinished condition COUNT ONE Paragraph 1 to 6 restated as if in full. 5. The City of Oldsmar Building Department has confirmed that there is no record that the Defendant obtained required permits. 6. Respondent failed to obtain a building permit prior to the start of construction as required in violation of Section 104, Florida Building Code 5" Edition (2014) - Building; Section 489.127 (1)(h), Florida Statutes; Section 489.129 (1)(0), Florida Statutes; Section 24(2)(n), Chapter 75- 489, Laws of Florida, as amended; and Pinellas County Code, Section 22-14. oe Se Oo SSSsK 12600 Belcher Road, Suite 102 Largo, Florida 33773 « Phone 727-582-3100 e Fax 727-453-3523 Web Site: www.pcclb.com PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD WHEREFORE, Petitioner requests that an order be issued imposing one or more of the following penalties: suspension or revocation of Respondent's license, imposition of an administrative fine, financial restitution to the consumer for financial harm directly related to the violation, and assessment of costs related to the investigation and prosecution of the case, and any other relief that is deemed appropriate. Signed thissapdey Aa 2017. Gay kan¢aster, Interim Executive Director eee SS ee _S)sKS 12600 Belcher Road, Suite 102 ¢ Largo, Florida 33773 « Phone 727-582-3100 « Fax 727-453-3523 Web Site: www.pcclb.com {POJOUOH JON Ajuee pA diysuew Jo 100g WWE UIEGO Oo} eunjiey payoeny joe jUu0D x PeAledey JON esuodsey JO}OeBUOD Pa (v94Z1S1999-1) 977 TWILNAGISSY LNIOd Waa N3HOLNG NVHLVN ‘SIWVN YOLOVULNOD rea a0 SHEqOY :‘YOLVOILSSANI 9102 ‘vl 3desg :Jiva M3IA3xY ASV9 ASNVD 31sVEdOwd VERIFIED RETURN OF SERVICE State of FLORIDA County of PINELLAS Court —_— LOOM A Plaintiff: RLJ2016010677 PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD vs. Defendant: NATHAN DUTCHER and POINT RESIDENTIAL LLC For: PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD 12600 Belcher Rd. #102 Largo, FL 33773 Received by Robert L. Jones, Incon the 22nd day of July, 2016 at 3:16 pm to be served on NATHAN DUTCHER, POINT RESIDENTIAL LLC, 434 3RD AVE N, ST PETERSBURG, FL |, Kenneth Di Benedetto, do hereby affirm that on the 25th day of July, 2016 at 7:20 pm, I: INDIVIDUALLY/PERSONALLYserved by delivering a true copy of the CITATION DATED JUNE 9, 2016, FORMAL COMPLAINT FORM, CONTRACTOR'S RESPONSE TO ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINTwith the date and hour of service endorsed thereon by me, to: NATHAN DUTCHERat the address of: 1013 BRASS LANE, HOLIDAY, FL 34691 and informed said person of the contents therein, in compliance with state statutes. | certify that | am over the age of 18, and that | am not a party to nor interested in the outcome of the above entitled suit. Under penaity of perjury, | declare that | have read the foregoing and that the facts stated in it are true (F.S. 92.525). Kenneth Di PPS9097 “ Robert L. Jones, Inc Po Box 6415 Clearwater, FL 33758-6415 (727) 442-9269 Our Job Serial Number: RLJ-2016010677 Copyright © 1982-2011 Database Services, inc. - Process Server's Toolbox V6.5m Contractor Information Sheet License # |-CGC1512764 Status A Name Nathan Dutcher Address 654 100th Ave N City State Zip St Petersburg, FL 33702 Phone 813-770-2786 Basis Original Date 05/18/2007 Date Renewed 08/10/2015 Class 16 - General Contractor GENERAL State Lic No CGC1512764/ 2016 Comments need good address 6-2015 Business Names Point Residential LLC Case Information Case # Inv Init Status 7 : Letter Date Sent Dispositior — 16-65 dest PRA Complaint Let #1 06/09/2016 Complaint (against a licensed contractor) Complainant Myers, Karen Phone 727-787-3584 (Failure to Obtain Permit / Possible Aiding & Abetting / Misconduct, On March 28, 2016 the Defendant entered into a written contract with the Complainant to demo and remodel her mobile home to include new floors, kitchen, bathroom, all fixtures, walls, baseboards, counters and the construction of a new utility shed for a total cost of $29,550.00. The Complainant alleges that he hired unlicensed and unskilled workers from craigslist to perform the work unsupervised, and that there were problems with every facet of the job and they left her home in shambles. She stated that he charged her additional fees for work that cost less than half of what he charged and ruined the walls and floor materials and tried to patch it rather than do it right. She stated that he never obtained permits for any of the work. She paid him one payment of $16,000.00 before she realized what a disaster he was and paid him no more. He left her home is a messy, unfinished condition. The City of Oldsmar Bldg Dept has confirmed that there is no record that the Defendant obtained a required permit for the work. Defendant denies all allegations except not pulling permit. Contractor Information Sheet License # |-CGC1512764 Status A Name Nathan Dutcher Address 654 100th Ave N City State Zip St Petersburg, FL 33702 Phone 813-770-2786 Basis Original Date 05/18/2007 Date Renewed 08/10/2015 Class 16 - General Contractor GENERAL State Lic No CGC1512764/ 2016 Comments need good address 6-2015 Case # 12-263 Business Names Point Residential LLC Case Information Inv Init Status — Letter Date Sent Dispositior DWB FP Let #1 02/22/2012 Complaint (against a licensed contractor) Complainant Rocha, Anthony Phone 727-687-5717 2/22/12---Mr.Rocha, the complainant, says he contracted with Nathan Dutcher (Point Residential LLC CGC1512764) to perform some repairs. There was no contract supplied with this complaint against Mr. Dutcher. The work is allegedly Fascia and Soffit work. The total price was $2500, and a $1250 deposit was given to Point Residential LLC on 12/14/11 (check # 1387, supplied). Mr. Rocha states there were many false start dates that passed. Finally, on 1/10/12, Mr. Dutcher showed up. The complaint sounds like he had a sub contractor with him. Allegedly, some minor work was performed by Mr. Dutcher of putting up some fascia with 8 screws. It appears Mr. Rocha then fired Mr. Dutcher, hired another contractor, Jeffrey Christopher Neal (I- CGC062069) to perform the work at a cost of $2450. Mr. Neal pulled the required permit. Mr. Rocha also alleges he gave Mr. Dutcher, an unspecified amount of money for supplies. It appears Mr. Dutcher s registration in Pinellas County was expired at the time of this project. It had expired 10/1/11, as it has not been renewed. It was in expired status the date the check was written (12/14/11). Mr. Rocha wants his $1250 deposit back from Mr. Dutcher. Contractor Information Sheet License # |-CGC1512764 Status A Name Nathan Dutcher Address 654 100th Ave N City State Zip St Petersburg, FL 33702 Phone 813-770-2786 Basis Original Date 05/18/2007 Date Renewed 08/10/2015 Class 16 - General Contractor GENERAL State Lic No CGC1512764/ 2016 Comments need good address 6-2015 Case # 12-1321 Business Names Point Residential LLC Case Information Letter ~—~Date Sent _Dispositior Inv Init Status | DWB Complaint Let #1 08/17/2012 Complaint (against a licensed contractor) Complainant Horshy, Tami Phone 813-781-7347 8/17/12---The complainant, Tami L. Horsky, is filing this complaint for Stacey Hudspeth Ms. Horsky states: On 6/16/12 on Craigs List, she responded to an ad for a 4 point inspection that is required for insurance coverage on Ms. Hudspeth s SFR at 6499 18th St N St Pete. Mr. Dutcher told her the cost is $100. On 6/14/2012, the inspection was performed. While at that address, Mr. Dutcher mentioned to Ms. Hudspeth that she should have a Wind Mitigation report done which will save her more on the insurance. He told Ms. Hudspeth the cost is $50 since he is already there. She paid the $50 in cash. The report was sent by e mail on 6/14/12, with a note saying the Wind Mitigation report will follow by US Mail . Ms. Horsky says that report never came. On 6/25/12 an e mail was received saying that Mr. Dutcher charges $125.00 for that report. And since the additional $75.00 was not received, his office did not send the report. The complainant says the verbal agreement was for the two reports to be $150.00. Mr. Dutcher allegedly wants an additional $75.00 + an additional $25.00 for the 4 point inspection, or a total of $275.00 for the two reports. He has been paid $150.00. There was a problem with the 4 point inspection report. When notified of the problem, its alleged Mr. Dutcher refused to correct the report unless the additional money is paid to him. The complainat feels victimized, and that this is a con. The reports, at this point, are not as important as informing others of Mr. Dutchers business practices. 9/11/12---The Probable Cause Committee found no PC, as this is a contract dispute that would need to be resolved in civil court. Case closed. PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD INVESTIGATOR NARRATIVE By: Paul Roberts Case No: A16-654 Contractor Name: Nathan Dutcher Company Name: Point Residential LLC Complainant/Homeowner Name: Karen Myers Work site address: 394 Cobia Way Oldsmar, FL 34677 Contract Date: 3/28/2016 Description of Work: Mobile Home Renovation Contract Amount: $29550 Violations: Failure to Obtain Permit / Possible Aiding & Abetting / Misconduct. On March 28, 2016 the Defendant entered into a written contract with the Complainant to demo and remodel her mobile home to include new floors, kitchen, bathroom, all fixtures, walls, baseboards, counters and the construction of a new utility shed for a total cost of $29,550.00. The Complainant alleges that he hired unlicensed and unskilled workers from craigslist to perform the work unsupervised, and that there were problems with every facet of the job and they left her home in shambles. She stated that he charged her additional fees for work that cost less than half of what he charged and ruined the walls and floor materials and tried to patch it rather than do it right. She stated that he never obtained permits for any of the work. She paid him one payment of $16,000.00 before she realized what a disaster he was and paid him no more. He left her home is a terrible, unfinished condition. The City of Oldsmar Bidg Dept. has confirmed that there is no record that the Defendant obtained a required permit for the work. Defendant denies all allegations and stated that he performed good work but the Complainant brought in other contractors and she was difficult to work with. He avoided the lack of permit issue. SE) 3 fe 12600 Belcher Road, Suite 102 ¢ Largo, Florida 33773 « Phone 727-582-3100 e Fax 727-453-3523 Web Site: www.pcclb.com PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD INVESTIGATIVE REPORT By: Paul Roberts Case #: A16-654 COMPLAINANT INFORMATION Name: Karen Myers Address: 394 Cobia Way Oldsmar, FL 34677 Phone: 727-787-3584 Complaint Date: May 25, 2016 CONTRACTOR INFORMATION Name: Nathan Dutcher Company Name: Point Residential LLC Address: 654 100th Ave N. St Petersburg, FL 33702 Phone: 813-770-2786 License Type: General PCCLB License: |-CGC1512764 State License/Registration: CGC1512764 PERMIT REQUIRED: Y IF REQUIRED, WAS PERMIT ISSUED: N PERMIT #: PERMIT DATE: LICENSE ACTIVE WITH DBPR: Y LICENSE # IN CONTRACT: Y LICENSE ACTIVE WITH PCCLB AT TIME OF CONTRACT: Y LICENSE CURRENTLY ACTIVE WITH PCCLB: Y i re 12600 Belcher Road, Suite 102 ¢ Largo, Florida 33773 « Phone 727-582-3100 e Fax 727-453-3523 Web Site: www.pcclb.com Roberts, Paul SSS From: Ulloa, Catherine Sent: Friday, June 10, 2016 10:21 AM To: Roberts, Paul Ce: PlanRedev Subject: RE: Permit Question Y looked up the contractor in our system and only 1 permit was pulled for that license holder it was fo ampa Rd #324. If you have any other questions please feel free to contact me. Thank you, Catherine Ulloa City of Oldsmar Licensing and Permit Clerk 100 State Street W Oldsmar, FL 34677 Phone:813-749-1124 Fax: 813-855-2730 E-mail: Culloa@myoldsmar.com From: Roberts, Paul [mailto:paroberts@co.pinellas.fl.us] Sent: Thursday, June 09, 2016 2:28 PM To: Ulloa, Catherine Subject: Permit Question Hi Catherine, I’m working a case that in part involves the contractor claiming to have pulled a permit in your jurisdiction. Could you please tell me if a permit was pulled for a mobile home demo and remodel, and construction of new shed at 394 Cobia Way Oldsmar on or about 3/28/2016? The contractor is Nathan Dutcher DNA Point Residential LLC. Thanks! PR Paul Roberts Investigator Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board 12600 belcher Rd Suite 102 Largo FL 33773 (727) 582-3100 . PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD SI FORMAL COMPLAINT FORM Ref#t: i NAME: Karen C Myers SS: 394 Cobia Way Oldsmar Fi 34677 Number City State PHONE: 727.787.3584 Construction Address if Different: Complaint is against: Nathan Dutcher, License # CGC1512764 Company Name: Point Residential Contractor or person in charge: (if known) Address: 654 100th Ave N St Petersburg, Fl 33702 Phone: 813.770.2786 Date of contract: 03/28/2016 THE SPECIFIC COMPLAINT IS: (Attach additional sheets as necessary) (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE LEGIBLY) Nathan Dutcher was hired to do repairs and new construction of a shed on my mobile home. Original estimate was for $29.550 with a deposit paid to him for $16,000. On the first day of work he brought in a crew that he found on craigslist that were not licensed or insured for the demo of the floors and to put in new sub floors. These people were not supervised and proceeded to tear out and throw away wood baseboards, tearing and damaging newly painted walls. The main bathroom was not finished because it had black mold. Everything was taken out, tub, toilet and sink to replace the sub flooring. They returned the next day to haul off the carpet, baseboards and trash. Nathan and his brother took out the kitchen cabinets and did the sub flooring there. The following week another crew from craigslist showed up to work on the bathroom, again unsupervised, unlicensed and uninsured. Attach copies of all appropriate documents: contracts, checks, (both sides) liens, permits, etc. Laer (My S/d }2eie (Signature) (Date) eee 12600 Beicher Road, Suite 102 © Largo, Florida 33773 e Phone 727-582-3100 e Fax 727-453-3523 Website: www.pccib.com Their job was to finish the bathroom. They started the dry wall which was hung poorly, making huge holes for the shower and tub faucet. They installed the tub without securing it properly. They did not hook up the plumbing nor check or replace any of the plumbing to look for leaks. They did not return. Craigslist crew #3 came and worked on the bathroom. They also did such a poor job Nathan fired them. Apparently he did not pay them either because the one man showed up several days later looking for his money. | believe at this point we are into week 3. The bathroom at this point is completely torn out. He hired a contractor to do the tile (which | provided) and the contractor would not take Nathans dirty money. So | had to pay him. He also had to go into the wall from the bedroom to do all the repairs to the shower/tub... secure it and replumb. | had to purchase new cabinets ,plumbing parts and fixtures since crew #1 threw everything away. As of today the bathroom Is still not finished. No sink, no toilet, no shower. Nathan did such a poor job, not showing up, not supervising that | started to take away the unstarted jobs from him. He was to install new windows. | bought the windows myself and will hire a new contractor to install them for half of what he was going to charge me. He had no intention of installing them, he never went before the HOA for approval nor did he ever pull permits. He never got permission from the HOA to replace the one window with a door... nor permit. The kitchen... he took out all the cabinets and replaced the sub flooring. He put the cabinets back... some drawers barley open and the breakfast bar was torn out and not finished. No kick plates. The sink area was to have new wood put in as there are giant holes in the walls and floor, which was not done either. Nathan ordered granite for me with only showing me samples online. Any good contractor would have me pick out the slabs in person. He had someone from Orlando area come and install the granite. Again, he was not here to supervise. The granite was the wrong color and wrong size in the kitchen. The 2 bathroom pieces were the wrong size and the wrong colors. The granite men took the 2 bathroom slabs back out and said they would replace them. I never saw them again and when | talked to them they said | had to pay them again for the new granite. They also told me Nathan told them he could use them at another house. So | expect to be repaid for them so | can buy new, either that or this is theft. Now | have a kitchen that is still torn up with granite | hate and does not fit. | have no sinks in the bathrooms. | had to have someone come in and install the faucets in the kitchen sink as Nathan never showed up to install them. | also had to have someone else come install the kitchen appliances as Nathan never came back to do that either. Nathan said he would repair and patch walls damaged. This was not done. He said he would reinstall water heater. This was never touched, not evento replace the sub flooring under it as he was suppose to do the entire house. This was a critical area that was neglected. Nathan agreed to put down vinyl flooring. He charged me $3850. Then he said he did not want to do it himself and he would need to hire someone. So my son agreed to do it for him for $1700. He proceeded to lay the flooring and then Nathan refused to pay him. Nathan told me to pay him, which | did not do. Nathan hired him and Nathan should pay him out of the $16,000 he was given. The agreement for my son to do the work was between my son and Nathan. | asked Nathan why he did not finish the kick plates on the kitchen cabinets and he told me that was the flooring guys job. The kick plates were not part of any agreement with my son when he agreed to do the flooring. | asked Nathan about the base boards. | expect him to replace them since he allowed the craigs list crew #1 to tear them out and throw them away. Nathan said he would not pay for them nor would he install them. He has not been back in 3 weeks. | called him to come finish and he told me he had no time and no money for this job any more. He also said he only made $2000 on this job and he lost 3 weeks of his life. He has clearly abandoned me and the job. We are living in a torn up house, myself a senior on disability, an adult student and an 18 month old baby. Since Nathan clearly abandoned the job and me | will have to hire someone else to finish all the jobs he did not finish and my family has to live in chaos. He refuses to refund me any part of the $16,000 that he was given and now | don’t have the money to do the jobs that needed to be done here to make my new home livable. There is not one job that Nathan was hired for that was finished. He refused to take my calls these last few weeks and did not return my calls. Clearly job abandonment when he said he had no more time for this job nor any more money for this job. Every other day he revised his estimate. | believe that he misallocated the funds. He took me for a foolish old woman. The jobs that were taken away from him when he wasn’t showing up and | saw his indifference was the shed, the windows, the sub panel, the back door & the back splash in kitchen. | invite your inspectors /investigators to come and look at the unfinished work and how he has left this house for us to live in chaos. https://banking.achievacu.com/My Accounts V2/PrintCheckImage/764.. @2000 Artetic Chests 1-000-276-7821 wwe peltefletneens com | Ns soecnvans 1646 # otf Vidi ls 3 o 72 _3 “vy Q z a m 2 z a. be FS lofl 5/20/2016 2:52 PX a QMINERES! IPXVERITIAI Li” LL. rr" Sees AE SURI Selicarxn | yp PEs Ces es Client Initials Page 1 of 1 Point Residential LLC Service Agreement Point Residential Contact Information Customer Contact Information Point Residential LLC CGC 1512764 ‘Nathan Dutcher ath point tial.con ET | 813-770-2786 mC Products/Services Subfiooring, re attach aluilies_——SssCSSSid install back door Fuh aT MM Discounts Fotais: —— oe oval and A- Anes Appr Authorization — payment made to Point Residential [LC Ciient initiais Page i of i Point Residential Contact Information Point Residential LLC CGC 1512764 ! agree to the terms & conditions of the service ee Date Client Initials Page 1 of 1 Point Residential Contact Information Point Residential LLC CGC 1512764 Client initials Page 1 of 1 Point Residential Contact Information Customer Contact Information Point Residential LLC CGC 1512764 813-770-2786 eo lana re MAL Client Initials Page 1 of 1 Prin bala thong jus pemben [sete dpuone Cok wrayer oO jk lever 9 Crumber uk Cmsld bwek (rot bur nk [ erted~ed lw NW Deuter Lft my itdon Sen/e_ Kk tahoity rt 6 Hom buacbsdala been ek Thee _ ~ Ger ne, heuSe Loaks hot wires Expose vn peeatin bell lath - Leable. PB Peds Nuun bath - Lh Ut finerhed brlein Wi Wagin balls — toda M plurabena | Crud olan ( O gle earth foot peer eereserenemererenens 10 . a me ers, ms Property Appraiser General Information Page | of 4 Interactive Map of this parcel Sales Query Back to Query Results New Search Tax Collector Home Page Contact Us WM 16-28-16-34803-000-3940 Compact Property Record Card Portability Data Current as of June Email Print Radius Improvement Value Calculator 9,20 16 Search per F.S. 553.844 |Ownership/Mailing Address Change 7 |____ Mailing Address | SC Adress ce prc derigl 394 COBIA WAY 394 COBIA WAY ee } OLDSMAR FL 34677-2400 | Property Use: 0260 (Mobile Home, with improvement - individual lot owners in a Living Units: subdivision) 1 [click here to hide] Legal Description GULL-AIRE VILLAGE LOT 394 Mortgage Letter File for Homestead Exemption [ Homestead: ] omestead Use Percentage: 0.00% [ Government: | on-Homestead Use Percentage: 100.00% lassified Agricultural: No Parcel Information Latest Notice of Proposed Property Taxes (TRIM Notice Evacuation Zone on mecca Sales Census Tract/} (NOT the same as a FEMA _ Recording Comparison |= Book/Page 19161/1976 [Sales Query [12103027319 077/040 2015 Final Value Information Just/Market Assessed Value/ County Taxable Municipal Value SOH Cap Taxable Value Taxable Value $65,359 $52,739 $25,000 $27,739 $0 [click here to hide] Value History as Certified (yellow indicates correction on file) Homestead Just/Market Assessed Value/ County School Municipal Ye Soe oS! ee Taxable Exemption Value SOH Cap Taxable Value Value Taxable Value 2015 Yes $65,359 $52,739 $25,000 $27,739 $0 http://www.pepao.org/general.php?pn=162816348030003940 6/9/2016 Property Appraiser General Information 2014 Yes $53,653 2013 Yes $51,547 2012 Yes $51,321 2011 Yes $56,687 2010 Yes $58,157 2009 Yes $67,460 2008 Yes $76,400 2007 Yes $89,800 2006 Yes $79,700 2005 Yes $67,700 2004 Yes $59,300 2003 Yes $55,000 2002 Yes $51,900 2001 Yes $47,000 2000 No $53,800 1999 No $46,900 1998 No $41,300 1997 Yes $40,500 $40,400 2015 Tax Information Click Here for 2015 Tax Bill Tax Collector Mails 2015 Tax Bills October 31 2015 Final Millage Rate 2015 Est Taxes w/o Cap or Exemptions Tax District: OM $52,320 $51,547 $51,321 $56,687 $58,157 $67,460 $76,400 $89,800 $79,700 $51,200 $49,700 $48,800 $47,700 $47,000 $53,800 $46,900 $41,100 $40,500 $40,400 $25,000 $27,320 $25,000 $26,547 $25,000 $26,321 $25,000 $31,687 $25,000 $33,157 $25,000 $42,460 $26,400 $51,400 $64,800 $54,700 $26,200 $24,700 $23,800 $22,700 $22,000 $53,800 $46,900 $16,100 $15,500 $15,400 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Page 2 of 4 Ranked Sales (what are Ranked Sales?) See all QM VA Sale Dat 20.0669}| 13 Apr 2016 $1,311.55 07 Dec A significant change in taxable value may occur 2006 when sold due to changes in the market or the 02 May removal of exemptions. Click here for more 2005 information. Seawall: No 25 Sep 2000 16 Nov 1999 29 Oct 1999 transactions e Book/Page 19161 / 1976 @ 15518 / 1720 @ 14281 / 2082 11063 / 1279 @ 10724 / 2006 & 10708 / 0079 & 2015 Land Information Frontage: None Price $126,000 $145,000 $65,000 $59,000 $53,000 $13,500 View: Land Use Land Size Unit Value Units Total Adjustments Adjusted Value Method Mobile Home (02) 57x113 43500.00 1.0000 1.0000 $43,500 LT [click here to hide] 2015 Building 1 Structural Elements Back to Top http://www.pepao.org/general.php?pn=162816348030003940 Site Address: 394 COBIA WAY 6/9/2016 Property Appraiser General Information Page 3 of 4 Quality: Average Square Footage: 2139.00 ———T7 Foundation: Piers © UTU 1 Floor System: Wood | e 1) Exterior Wall: Frame Siding Roof Frame: Gable Or Hip Roof Cover: Mh Roof Over (Metal/Membrane) 53 BAS Stories: 1 Living units: 1 Floor Finish: Carpet/Hardtile/Hardwo Interior Finish: Drywall/Plaster/Panel CPF 2 Fixtures: 6 2 Year Built: 1980 | |e i Effective Age: 36 Heating: Central Duct Open plot in New Window Cooling: Cooling (Central) Building 1 Sub Area Information 2 Description Living Area Ft Gross Area Ft? Factor E Utility Unfinished 0 120 = 0.25 Base 1,719 1,719 1.00 Carport 0 252 = 0.25 Open Porch 0 48 0.21 Total Living SF: 1,719 Total Gross SF: 2,139 Total Effectiv [click here to hide] 2015 Extra Features Description Value/Unit Units Total Value as New Depreciated Va No Extra Features on Record click here to hide] Permit Data Permit information is received from the County and Cities. This data may be incomplete and may exclude permits that do not result in field reviews (for example for water heater replacement permits). We are required to list all improvements, which may include unpermitted construction. Any questions regarding permits, or the status of non-permitted improvements, should be directed to the permitting office in which the structure is located. Estimated Value 070259 HEAT/AIR 11 Apr 2007 $5,000 a ss | | http://www. pepao.org/general.php?pn=1 628 16348030003940 6/9/2016 Property Appraiser General Information Page 4 of 4 Interactive Map of this parcel Map Sales Back to Query Ne Tax Collector Home Contact Legend Query Results Search Page Us http://www.pcpao.org/general.php?pn=162816348030003940 6/9/2016 Results 1 to 1 of 1 Last Name: DUTCHER; First Name: NATHAN; City: ST PETERSBURG; State: FL; LL NAME NATHAN ELLIOTT DUTCHER NATHAN E DUTCHER NATHAN DUTCHER NATHAN BUTCHER NATHAN COLE NATHAN DUTCHOR NATHAN ELLIOTT DUTCHER DOB: 1/9/1981 Age: 35 Gender - Male “View Sources (~14) = SSN SSN: XXX-XX-2557 v SSN: XXX-Xx-6575 x ™ SSN not recently reported for subject. SSN: XXX-XX-2557 ™ SSN potentially randomly issued by the SSA. LexID: 717. DL: D326625810090 132 DL State: FL Issue Date: Apr 03 Exp Date: Jan 18 ADDRESS PHONE(S) 1013 BRASS LN HOLIDAY, FL 34691-5048 PASCO COUNTY 1992 - Jun 2016 434 33RD AVE N SAINT PETERSBURG, FL 704-1 PIN' COUNTY Nov 2014 - Apr 2016 654 100TH AVE N APT 201 SAINT PETERSBURG, FL 702-2251, PIN! Mar 2014 - Jun 2015 NTY 6117 COLE DR APT 33634 TAMPA, FL 33634-5013. HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY Aug 2004 - Jun 2014 is invalid. Page 1 of 2 INDICATORS criminal motor vehicles property people at work 813-770-2786 - EDT POSSIBLE CELL PHONE ™ phone number and zip code combination METRO PCS, INC. TAMPA, FL 13- - EDT POSSIBLE CELL PHONE ™ phone number and Zip code combination is invalid. AERIAL COMMUNICATION TAMPA, FL 4723 W ANITA BLVD TAMPA, FL 33611-1117, Hi Ri HH COUNTY May 2003 - May 2011 is invalid. 813-598-5339 - EDT POSSIBLE CELL PHONE ™ phone number and zip code combination AERIAL COMMUNICATION TAMPA, FL 918-766-3766 - EDT POSSIBLE NON-DA ™ phone number may be disconnected. ™ phone number and zip code combination is invalid. I phone and address are geographically distant (greater than 10 miles). TACONIC TEL CORP NASSAU, FL https://secure.accurint.com/app/bps/misc 6/23/2016 Results 1 to 6 of 6 Last Name: DUTCHER; First Name: NATHAN; State: FL; ALL NAME NATHAN ELLIOTT DUTCHER NATHAN E DUTCHER NATHAN DUTCHER NATHAN BUTCHER NATHAN DUTCHOR NATHAN ELLIOTT DUTCHER DOB: 1/9/1981 Age: 35 Gender - Male “View Sources (~14) SSN SSN: XXX-XX-2557 Vv SSN: XXX-xx-6575 x ™ SSN not recently reported for subject. SSN: XXX-XX-2557 ™ SSN potentially randomly issued by the SSA. LexID: 717564132 DL: 0326625810090 DL State: FL Issue Date: Apr 03 Exp Date: Jan 18 6117 COLE DR APT 33634 Page 1 of 3 ADDRESS INDICATORS 1013 BRASS LN HOLIDAY 91-5048 PASCO COUNTY 1992 - Jul 2016 PHONE(S) 434 33RD AVE N SAINT PETERSBURG, FL 33704-1304, PINELLAS COUNTY Nov 2014 - Apr 2016 motor vehicles &é people at work 654 100TH AVE N APT 201 INT PETER RG, FL 33702-2251, PINELLAS COUNTY Mar 2014 - Jun 2015 813-770-2786 - EDT POSSIBLE CELL PHONE ™ phone number and zip code combination is invalid. METRO PCS, INC. TAMPA, FL 813-598-5339 - EDT POSSIBLE CELL PHONE ™ phone number and zip code combination TAMPA, FL 33634-5013. HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY Aug 2004 - Jun 2014 is invalid. AERIAL COMMUNICATION TAMPA, FL 4723 W ANITA BLVD 813-598-5339 - EDT TAMPA, FL 33611-1117, POSSIBLE CELL PHONE ™ phone number and zip code combination is invalid. AERIAL COMMUNICATION TAMPA, FL 518-766-3766 - EDT POSSIBLE NON-DA ™ phone number may be disconnected. I phone number and zip code combination is invalid. phone and address are geographically distant (greater than 10 miles). TACONIC TEL CORP NASSAU, FL HILLSBOR iH. INTY May 2003 - May 2011 https://secure.accurint.com/app/bps/misc 7/19/2016 PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD June 09, 2016 CASE #:A16-654 CERTIFIED MAIL LICENSE #:Il-CGC1512764 Nathan Dutcher Point Residential LLC 654 100th Ave N. St Petersburg, FL 33702 Dear Mr. Dutcher: The enclosed complaint has been filed against you. Please use the attached form in response to the complaint and return it to my office within ten (10) working days. Please be advised that it is in your best interest to provide this board with a timely response. When a contractor fails to respond toa complaint, the probable cause committee finds automatic probable cause, and this matter is sent to the Executive Director to proceed with an Administrative Complaint. All complaints filed against you, your response(s), and Board action taken will be part of your permanent file with the Board and open to public inspection under the Laws of Florida. Therefore, it is in your best interests to resolve such complaints at the earliest possible time. If you are a State Certified or Registered Contractor and should be found in violation of this complaint, the Board action and recommendations will be forwarded to the Department of Business and Professional Regulation for disciplinary action. If investigation by the Board reveals grounds for disciplinary action, you will be afforded a hearing on the charges against you and will be notified of such proceedings in advance. Your prompt attention to this complaint will be to your advantage. All responses MUST be in writing. Sincerely, Paul Roberts PCCLB Investigator Enc cc: Karen Myers —————e -es.—Osa—sS—S—o—T oS 12600 Belcher Road, Suite 102 ¢ Largo, Florida 33773 e Phone 727-582-3100 e Fax 727-453-3523 Web Site: www.pcclb.com PINELLAS COUNTY oy ae CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD jy) 3 >»; 7015 3010 0001 2518 2444 ed cat June 09, 2016 Please SED THS Ard CASE #:A16-654 CERTIFIED MAL ‘ LICENSE #:I-CGC1512764 Dear Mr. Dutcher: The enclosed complaint has been filed against you. Please use the attached form in response to the complaint and return it to my office within ten (10) working days. Please be advised that it is in your best interest to provide this board with a timely response. When a contractor fails to respond to a complaint, the probable cause committee finds automatic probable cause, and this matter is sent to the Executive Director to proceed with an Administrative Complaint. All complaints filed against you, your response(s), and Board action taken will be part of your permanent file with the Board and open to public inspection under the Laws of Florida. Therefore, it is in your best interests to resolve such complaints at the earliest possible time. If you are a State Certified or Registered Contractor and should be found in violation of this complaint, the Boar: action and recommendations will be forwarded to the Department of Business and Professional Regulation for disciplinary action. If investigation by the Board reveals grounds for disciplinary action, you will be afforded a hearing on the charges against you and will be notified of such proceedings in advance. Your prompt attention to this complaint will be to your advantage. All responses MUST be in writing. Sincerely, pe Paul Roberts Yo y 73 l 7 PCCLB Investigator Enc cc: Karen Myers ————— ae ee ee ee 12600 Belcher Road, Suite 102 ¢ Largo, Florida 33773 « Phone 727-582-3100 « Fax 727-453-3523 Web Site: www.pcclb.com ee ROBERT L JONES INC, PINELLAS COUNTY CONSTRUCTION LICENSING BOARD FORMAL COMPLAINT FORM Company Name: Point Residential sss Contractor or person in charge: (if known) Address: 654 100th Ave N eeeeeeeeeeSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSeSeeee St Petersburg, Fl 33702 Phone: 813.770.2786 Date of contract: 03/28/2016 _—— THE SPECIFIC COMPLAINT IS: (Attach additional sheets as (PLEASE PRINT OR TYPE LEGIBLY) Nathan Dutcher was hired to do repairs and new construction of a shed on my mobile home. Original estimate was for $29.550 with a deposit paid to him for $16,000. On the first day of the demo of the floors and to put in new sub - These people, RT ws crocs to tecr oct ce tee ee esos: a tearing and damaging newly painted walls. The main bathroom was not finished because it had black mold. Everything was taken out, tub, toilet and sink to replace the sub flooring. They retumed the next day to haul off the carpet, baseboards and trash. Nathan and his brother took out the kitchen cabinets and did the sub flooring there. The following week another crew from craigslist showed up to work on the bathroom, again unsupervised, unlicensed and uninsured. Attach copies of all appropriate documents: contracts, checks, (both sides) liens, permits, etc. 4) A {