JERRY A. FUNK, Bankruptcy Judge.
This case came before the Court upon Motion to Modify Confirmed Plan filed by Debtor (the "Motion to Modify") (Doc. 127). The Chapter 13 Trustee (the "Trustee") filed an Objection to the Motion to Modify. The Court conducted an evidentiary hearing on the matter on October 14, 2015 and elected to take the matter under advisement. Upon the evidence and the applicable law, the Court makes the following Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law.
On February 3, 2012, Debtor filed a Chapter 13 bankruptcy petition. At that time, Debtor was employed as a pilot by United Airlines. Along with his bankruptcy petition, Debtor filed a Statement of Current Monthly Income and Calculation of Commitment Period and Disposable Income ("Debtor's Form 22C"). Debtor's Form 22C reflected monthly income of $15,610.00 comprised of: 1) $9,900.00 in wages; 2) $650.00 in rent and other real property income; 3) $50.00 in interest, dividends and royalties; and 4) $5,010.00 in retirement income. Debtor's Form 22C reflected monthly disposable income of $5,125.49.
Despite the fact that Debtor had monthly disposable income of $5,125.49, he proposed a plan which provided for no payments to unsecured creditors in months 1-2 of the Plan, provided for payments of only $1,312.00 to unsecured creditors in months 3-23 of the Plan, and provided for payments of only $2,408.00 to unsecured creditors in months 24-60 of the Plan. Because Debtor's Plan provided to pay unsecured claims in full, the Trustee did not object to the Plan, notwithstanding the fact that it did not require Debtor to pay all of his disposable income into the Plan. On January 27, 2014, the Court entered Order Confirming Chapter 13 Plan Allowing Claims and Directing Distribution (the "Confirmation Order"), which mirrored the payments proposed in Debtor's Plan.
In February of 2015, Debtor became disabled as a result of a torn meniscus. Additionally, in July of 2015, Debtor had neck fusion surgery to repair a herniated disk. Because of these injuries, Debtor can no longer qualify as a pilot and is unable to maintain employment with United Airlines. As a result, Debtor no longer earns wages and, in lieu thereof, receives $2,900.00 monthly in disability income.
On April 30, 2015, Debtor filed an Amended Form 22C ("Debtor's Amended Form 22C"). Debtor's Amended Form 22C reflects monthly income of $9,320.00 comprised of $5,370.00 in retirement income and $3,950.00 in long term disability. According to Debtor's Amended Form 22C, Debtor has a negative monthly disposable income of $266.86. In other words, Debtor has no ability to pay anything to unsecured creditors. On April 23, 2015, Debtor filed a Modified Confirmed Chapter 13 plan by which he proposes to pay $1,466.04 per month for months 38 through 60 of the plan. The modified plan provides for no payments to unsecured creditors.
Section 1329(b)(1) of the Bankruptcy Code permits the debtor, any time after confirmation of a plan but before the completion of payments under the plan, to seek a decrease in the amount of payments on claims of a particular class provided for by the plan. 11 U.S.C. § 1329(b)(1). A debtor seeking to modify his plan to decrease his plan payments must show a substantial, unanticipated change in circumstances.
The Trustee does not dispute that Debtor's medical conditions have resulted in a decrease in his income or that he has a negative monthly disposable income. The Trustee does not assert that this change in Debtor's circumstances is either insubstantial or anticipated. Additionally, the Trustee admits that he did not object to Debtor not paying all of his disposable income into the Plan because the Plan proposed to pay 100% of the unsecured claims in the case. However, the Trustee points out that if Debtor had paid all of his disposable income into the Plan as required by §§ 707 and 1325 of the Bankruptcy Code, the unsecured claims would have been paid off in month 23 of the Plan. The Trustee asserts that because Debtor should have made larger payments when he could have afforded to do so, he should not now be allowed to reduce the distribution to unsecured creditors. The Trustee contends that Debtor should be required to pay 100% of the unsecured claims in the case.
"[A]ll participants in the bankruptcy case are barred by the doctrine of res judicata from asserting matters they could have raised in the bankruptcy proceedings before confirmation."