58 Swansea Mall Drive, LLC v. Gator Swansea Property, LLC, 15-cv-13538. (2018)
Court: District Court, D. Massachusetts
Number: infdco20180215780
Visitors: 9
Filed: Jan. 29, 2018
Latest Update: Jan. 29, 2018
Summary: DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS AND COUNTER-COUNTER DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AND REQUEST FOR RULING ON OBJECTIONS RICHARD G. STEARNS , District Judge . Defendant, Gator Swansea Property, LLC ("Gator"), by and through undersigned counsel, hereby submits its objections and counter-counter deposition designations to the counter deposition designations submitted by Plaintiff, 58 Swansea Mall Drive, LLC ("58 Swansea"). Gator also submits this request for rulings on its
Summary: DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS AND COUNTER-COUNTER DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AND REQUEST FOR RULING ON OBJECTIONS RICHARD G. STEARNS , District Judge . Defendant, Gator Swansea Property, LLC ("Gator"), by and through undersigned counsel, hereby submits its objections and counter-counter deposition designations to the counter deposition designations submitted by Plaintiff, 58 Swansea Mall Drive, LLC ("58 Swansea"). Gator also submits this request for rulings on its o..
More
DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS AND COUNTER-COUNTER DESIGNATIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COUNTER DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AND REQUEST FOR RULING ON OBJECTIONS
RICHARD G. STEARNS, District Judge.
Defendant, Gator Swansea Property, LLC ("Gator"), by and through undersigned counsel, hereby submits its objections and counter-counter deposition designations to the counter deposition designations submitted by Plaintiff, 58 Swansea Mall Drive, LLC ("58 Swansea"). Gator also submits this request for rulings on its objections to the counter deposition designations of Plaintiff, 58 Swansea Mall Drive, LLC, as set forth in herein. Gator has attached hereto, as Exhibits A through E, pertinent pages from the deposition transcripts marking objected-to testimony and stating the grounds for each objection.1
Gator's Objections and Counter-Counter Designations to 58 Swansea's Counter-Designation
Jack Corwin 3-27-17
58 Swansea's Counter-Designations Gator's Objection
95:18-96:10 Non-Responsive
Gator's Counter-Counter-Designations
97:15-98:11
106:16-107:2
114:20-115:5
118:5-10
128:3-130:10
173:12-15
174:7-176:4
189:1-6
202:20-203:1
Jack Corwin 3-28-17
58 Swansea's Counter-Designations Gator's Objections
None None
Gator's Counter-Counter-Designations
271:2-11
285:10-13
286:20-25
294:11-16
314:4-25
315:1-6
320:25
321:1-13
322:7-25
334:25-336:12
627:20-629:1
Coulton Brooks 11-14-16
58 Swansea's Counter-Designations Gator's Objections
67:7-24 Speculation
73:25-74:13 Improper Expert Testimony
74:18-75:22 Calls for Legal Conclusion
79:19-80:16 Improper Expert Testimony — already decided
80:18-81:3 Improper Expert Testimony, Speculation Improper
81:4-23 Expert Testimony — already decided
Calls for Legal Conclusion, Speculation — already
decided
107:21-108:9 Calls for Legal Conclusion
116:4-11 Improper Expert Testimony
124:17-125:6 Improper Expert Testimony,
Calls for Legal Conclusions, Speculation —
already decided
Gator's Counter-Counter-Designations
125:7-126:9
Coulton Brooks 2-16-17
58 Swansea's Counter-Designations Gator's Objections
244:7-9 Improper Expert Testimony
245:14-18 Calls for Legal Conclusion
245:11-14 Calls for Legal Conclusion
246:8-12 Improper Expert Testimony,
Calls for Legal Conclusion
252:7-14 Speculation
253:5-9 Speculation
253:17-22 Speculation, Hearsay
282:14-283:5 Speculation
288:9-23 Speculation
Gator's Counter-Counter-Designations
263:13-15
281:6-15
Gabe Wilson 11-1716
58 Swansea's Counter-Designation Gator's Objections
52:6-53:3 Speculation
69:13-16 Calls for Legal Conclusion, Speculation
136:24-137:14 Incomplete w/o Exhibit, Hearsay
146:16 Incomplete/Incomprehensible Designation
185:1-12 Speculation
185:14-25 Improper Expert Testimony,
Speculation, Relevance
187:7-20 Speculation, Relevance
187:7-9 Hearsay
189:17-25 Improper Expert Testimony, Speculation
202:1-10 Speculation
216:5-15 Speculation
Gator's Counter-Counter-Designations
77:19-24
193:17-19
Mike Marcone 2-24-17
58 Swansea's Counter-Designations Gator's Objections
79:15-21 Hearsay; Lack of Foundation — already decided
80:9-15 Speculation; Non-responsive — already decided
98:21-99:12 Speculation; Non-responsive
109:23-110:21 Hearsay
120:9-122:2 Hearsay; Speculation; Lack of Foundation
135:5-21 Hearsay; Lack of Foundation; Speculation
138:9-18 Speculation; Lack of Foundation
145:13-23 Improper Exhibit Testimony;
Lack of Foundation — sustained as to 19-23 (already
sustained as to remaining lines)
157:20-158:12 Improper Exhibit Testimony; Hearsay
161:8-20 Improper Expert Opinion; Speculation; Lack of
Foundation
215:8-18 Speculation
Gator's Counter-Counter-Designations
34:10-17
40:2-14
59:8-21
60:19-61:14
102:11-103:4
103:11-24
120:5-8
122:13-17
136:7-13
150:23-153:2
169:11-15
170:17-171:4
171:10-13
217:8-220:14
220:24-221:9
221:11-222:19
227:5-228:4
228:10-16
239:21-25
FootNotes
1. Gator has used the following legend to identify the abbreviated objections stated in the attached (all other objections are fully stated):
H Hearsay
S Speculation
LF Lack of Foundation
N-R Non-responsive
LC Calls for Legal Conclusion
Source: Leagle
