U.S. v. MANGARELLA, 3:06-CR-00151. (2012)
Court: District Court, W.D. North Carolina
Number: infdco20120319713
Visitors: 27
Filed: Mar. 15, 2012
Latest Update: Mar. 15, 2012
Summary: ORDER FRANK D. WHITNEY, District Judge. THIS MATTER is before the Court upon a letter from Defendant (Doc. No. 608) regarding the criminal assessment and restitution imposed by the Court. The U.S. Attorney's Response (Doc. No. 609) was also received by the Court and considered. Defendant contends that he is not required to pay restitution until sixty (60) days after his release from prison. He states that a box (Box D) was checked on the final judgment (Doc. No. 573) that says monthly paymen
Summary: ORDER FRANK D. WHITNEY, District Judge. THIS MATTER is before the Court upon a letter from Defendant (Doc. No. 608) regarding the criminal assessment and restitution imposed by the Court. The U.S. Attorney's Response (Doc. No. 609) was also received by the Court and considered. Defendant contends that he is not required to pay restitution until sixty (60) days after his release from prison. He states that a box (Box D) was checked on the final judgment (Doc. No. 573) that says monthly payment..
More
ORDER
FRANK D. WHITNEY, District Judge.
THIS MATTER is before the Court upon a letter from Defendant (Doc. No. 608) regarding the criminal assessment and restitution imposed by the Court. The U.S. Attorney's Response (Doc. No. 609) was also received by the Court and considered.
Defendant contends that he is not required to pay restitution until sixty (60) days after his release from prison. He states that a box (Box D) was checked on the final judgment (Doc. No. 573) that says monthly payments of fifty (50) dollars are due each month beginning sixty (60) days after Defendant's release. Defendant is correct; however, as Defendant concedes, another box on the judgment (Box B) says that payments are to begin immediately. Box B also states, however, that it is combined with the ruling in Box D. Therefore, payments must begin immediately and Defendant must pay fifty (50) dollars per month beginning sixty (60) days after his release from prison. See MERRIAM-WEBSTER DICTIONARY (Online Edition) (defining "combined" as "to become one" and "to act together").
Furthermore, the Court's oral sentence specified that restitution payments are to be made subject to the Bureau of Prisons Inmate Financial Responsibility Program ("IFRP") (See Resentencing Hr'g Tr. 51). Defendant currently participates in this program and seventy-five (75) dollars have been paid in restitution from it. Defendant is not required to participate in this program and may end his participation at any time; however, by ending his participation in the program, Defendant may also lose corresponding benefits. Defendant may not stop making restitution payments, yet still participate in IFRP. See 28 C.F.R. § 545.11(d).
Therefore, Defendant's request is DENIED. Defendant is to continue to make restitution payments subject to IFRP and is also to make payments of fifty (50) dollars a month beginning sixty (60) days after his release from prison.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Source: Leagle