Elawyers Elawyers
Ohio| Change

Slayman v. FedEx Ground Package System, Inc., 3:05-cv-01127-HZ (Lead Case) (2016)

Court: District Court, D. Oregon Number: infdco20161024b57 Visitors: 8
Filed: Oct. 21, 2016
Latest Update: Oct. 21, 2016
Summary: ORDER GRANTING FINAL APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT, AWARDING CLASS COUNSEL ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS, AND APPROVING SERVICE AWARDS TO PLAINTIFFS MARCO A. HERN NDEZ , District Judge . This matter came before the Court on Plaintiffs' unopposed Motion for Final Approval of Class Action Settlement ("Final Approval Motion"). All defined terms herein shall have the same meaning as set forth in the Class Action Settlement Agreement ("Settlement"). The Court, having previously entered the Orde
More

ORDER GRANTING FINAL APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT, AWARDING CLASS COUNSEL ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS, AND APPROVING SERVICE AWARDS TO PLAINTIFFS

This matter came before the Court on Plaintiffs' unopposed Motion for Final Approval of Class Action Settlement ("Final Approval Motion"). All defined terms herein shall have the same meaning as set forth in the Class Action Settlement Agreement ("Settlement").

The Court, having previously entered the Order Preliminary Approving Class Action Settlement, Certifying Settlement Class and Subclasses, Approving Notice Procedures, and Setting Final Approval Hearing ("Preliminary Approval Order"), dated April 17, 2016, in which the Court preliminarily approved the proposed settlement set forth in the Settlement as being a fair, reasonable and adequate settlement that is in the best interests of the class, preliminarily certified the Berg Class; designated Class Representatives and Class Counsel; appointed a Settlement Administrator; approved the forms and methods of disseminating information about the Settlement, the Settlement Notice and Forms, and found them to constitute the best notice practicable under the circumstances and to fully satisfy the requirements of due process and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23; established procedures for Class Members to make claims, opt out or object to the Settlement; established deadlines for the filing of a motion for an award of attorney fees, costs, and service awards ("Motion for Fees, Costs, and Service Awards"); and scheduled a Final Approval Hearing for October 18, 2016, that was later postponed to October 20, 2016, for the Court to determine whether the Settlement should be finally approved and judgment entered thereon;

The Final Approval Hearing having been held on October 20, 2016, after notice to the Class, and the Court having fully considered Plaintiffs' Unopposed Motion for Final Approval of Class Action Settlement, For an Award of Attorney Fees, Expenses, and Services Award; and Memorandum in Support as well as the submissions in support thereof, and all papers filed with or submitted to the Court in connection with the proceedings in these actions, and good cause appearing therefor;

THE COURT HEREBY ORDERS AND FINDS AS FOLLOWS:

1. The Court has subject matter jurisdiction over these actions and all matters that relate to the Settlement.

2. The Settlement is finally approved as being a fair, reasonable, and adequate class action settlement. The Court further finds that the Settlement was the result of arm's-length negotiations conducted after Class Counsel adequately investigated the claims of the named Plaintiffs and the Class and became familiar with the strengths and weaknesses of the claims in the Litigation, and the risks attendant to continued prosecution of those claims. The assistance of an experienced mediator in the settlement process further supports the Court's conclusion that the Settlement is fair. The Settlement also offers substantial benefits to the Class. The Settlement fully satisfies the requirements set forth in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e)(1)(C), and the Parties are directed to consummate and implement the Settlement in accordance with its terms and provisions.

3. In addition to the classes and subclasses in Slayman v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 3:05-cv-01127-HZ ("Slayman") and Leighter v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 3:07-cv-00818-HZ ("Leighter"), which were previously certified by the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana as part of multi-district litigation proceedings under the caption In re FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc. Employment Practices Litig., 3:05-md-00527 (the "MDL Proceeding"), the Court confirms the certification, pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 23(a) & (b)(3) and for settlement purposes only, the following class and subclasses in Berg v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 3:14-cv-01663-HZ ("Berg") (collectively, the following class and subclasses are referred to herein as the "Berg Class"):

All persons who: 1) entered into a FedEx Ground or FedEx Home Delivery Form Operating Agreement (now known as OP-149 and Form OP-149-RES); 2) drove a vehicle on a full-time basis (meaning exclusive of time off for commonly excused employment absences) from July 27, 2009 through September 18, 2015, to provide package pick-up and delivery services pursuant to the Operating Agreement; and 3) were dispatched out of a terminal in the state of Oregon. All persons who: 1) entered into a FedEx Ground or FedEx Home Delivery Form Operating Agreement (now known as OP-149 and Form OP-149-RES); 2) drove a vehicle on a full-time basis (meaning exclusive of time off for commonly excused employment absences) to provide package pick-up and delivery services pursuant to the Operating Agreement; 3) were dispatched out of a terminal in the state of Oregon; and 4) who, at any time from July 27, 2009 through September 18, 2015, operated vehicles with a gross vehicle weight rating of less than 10,001 pounds. All persons who: 1) entered into a FedEx Ground or FedEx Home Delivery Form Operating Agreement (now known as OP-149 and Form OP-149-RES); 2) drove a vehicle on a full-time basis (meaning exclusive of time off for commonly excused employment absences) to provide package pick-up and delivery services pursuant to the Operating Agreement; 3) were dispatched out of a terminal in the state of Oregon; and 4) whose Operating Agreement was terminated at any time from July 27, 2009 through September 18, 2015.

4. Plaintiffs, and Class Counsel, have fairly and adequately represented the Class throughout the Litigation.

5. The Parties have fully implemented the procedures for notice to the Class pursuant to the Settlement and the Preliminary Approval Order.

6. The Court confirms that the form and content of the Settlement Notice (including the Detailed Notices) and the Claim Form, and the procedure set forth in the Settlement for providing notice of the Settlement to the Class, were in full compliance with the notice requirements of Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 23(c)(2)(B) and 23(e), fully, fairly, accurately, and adequately advised members of the Class of their rights under the Settlement, provided the best notice practicable under the circumstances, met the requirements of due process, and afforded Class Members with adequate time and an opportunity to file objections to the Settlement, submit Requests for Exclusion, and submit Claims to the Settlement Administrator.

7. The Court finds that no objections have been submitted by Class Members.

8. The Court finds that 4 class members submitted Requests for Exclusion from the Slayman and Leighter classes and no class members submitted Requests for Exclusions from the Berg class, so a total of 4 Class Members have validly submitted Requests for Exclusion. Those persons (listed on Exhibit A hereto) are excluded from the Class, and are not bound by the Settlement or any of the terms or provisions contained therein.

9. The Court further finds that the Claim Form was not unduly burdensome for Class Members to complete, the claims process set forth in the Settlement was reasonable and appropriate, and the plan to distribute the Class Settlement Fund to Eligible Class Members who submitted Valid Claims is in all respects fair, reasonable, and adequate, and is approved. The Settlement Administrator is authorized to proceed with the distribution plan as set forth in the Settlement, and that the class members listed on the attached Exhibit B are entitled to payment pursuant to the Distribution Plan.

10. All complaints filed by Plaintiffs in the Litigation are hereby dismissed with prejudice, without fees, costs, or disbursements to any Party except as provided in the Settlement and this Order.

11. As provided in the Settlement, the Settlement is in full settlement, compromise, release, and discharge of the Released Claims and each of them, and the Releasees have no further or other liability or obligation to any Class Member with respect to the Released Claims, except as expressly provided for in the Settlement. As provided in the Settlement, Class Members are also enjoined from asserting, filing, maintaining, or prosecuting any of the Released Claims in the future. The releases and the covenant not to sue set forth in the Settlement and reflected in this Order have the scopes provided for in the Settlement. Those persons who have validly submitted Requests for Exclusion are not bound by the releases or the covenant not to sue set forth in the Settlement and reflected in this Order.

12. The Court finds that the Parties and their attorneys have complied with the requirements of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 throughout the Litigation.

13. The Court awards to Class Counsel attorney fees in the amount of $4,635,000, and expenses in the amount of $104,100.37. Such awards, made in accordance with the Settlement, are fair and reasonable under the circumstances. In making its award of attorney fees and costs, the Court has considered the following factors: (a) the contingent nature of this action; (b) the time and expense incurred by Class Counsel; (c) the experience, reputation, and ability of Class Counsel and the skill they displayed in the Litigation; and (d) the results and benefits achieved for the Class. Payment of such attorney fees and costs is hereby ordered.

14. The Court awards the Settlement Administrator $48,264.87 to reimburse it for costs and expenses relating to the Notice, to the claim handling process, and to the payments to be made to Class Members.

15. The Court finds that service awards of $10,000 to each of the named Plaintiffs are fair and reasonable in light of the benefits they provided to the Class. Payment of such service awards is hereby ordered.

16. Neither the Settlement, nor any act performed or document executed pursuant to or in furtherance of the Settlement, is or may be deemed to be, may be offered or received as evidence in any action or proceeding, or may be used in any way as an admission, concession, or evidence of any liability (or lack thereof) or wrongdoing (or lack thereof) of any nature on the part of the Releasees, and will not be construed as, or deemed to be evidence of, an admission or concession that the Plaintiffs or Class Members have or have not suffered any damage.

17. Without affecting the finality of this Order, the Court hereby reserves continuing and exclusive jurisdiction over all matters related to the administration and consummation of the terms of the Settlement.

18. The Court shall enter a judgment consistent with this Order.

IT IS SO ORDERED.

EXHIBIT A

Slayman and Leighter Opt-Outs

Count Name Attention Address City State Zip 1 Johnson's Parcel Delivery, Inc. ATTN: Kirk E. Johnson 5535 Breitenstein Lane Klamath Falls OR 97601 2 Sanmark, Inc. ATTN: Mark E. Papenfuhs 18064 SW Loxley Dr Beaverton OR 97007 3 Victor E. Matoush 1717 Concord Way Medford OR 97504 4 Clifford E. Michael 910 SE 214th Ave Gresham OR 97030

Exhibit B

Class Members That Submitted Valid Claim Forms

Name 2 VESTS INC 3 RIVERS TRANSPORT LTD ADENOCORP INC AHLOO LTD ALAN CURTIS NIELSEN ALAN LANDON ALEXANDER LITINETSKY ALLEN LOGISTICS INC AMH INCORPORATED ANDREW JASON FLAIR ANTHONY-2ND VAN SWING HAAS ANTONIO STARKE ASHCRAFT INC B & B DELIVERIES LLC BAKERS HOME DELIVERY INC BEAN INCORPORATED BEC-N-CASE INC BETTY KENT BLACK DOG TRUCKING INCORPORATED BOCHSLER TRANSPORT INC BOOK ENTERPRISES INC BOX JOCKEY INC BRADY KAUTZ BRANDON CAIN BRANDON HAYES BRET BANGS BRETT A DAVIS BRIAN BECK INC BRIDGEWATER LOGISTICS INC BRINKER LOGISTIKOS LLC BROCK OLSON BRONSPAC INC BRUCE V STERMER BRYAN SMITH BUTLER DELIVERIES INC BWR DISTRIBUTION INC BYRON MARSH BYRON R HOOD C & R INDEPENDENT CONTRACTING INC C&C EXPRESS RUNNER INC CARRIAGE EXPRESS INC CARRIE LYNN DIX CASCADE DELIVERY INC CASTRO ENTERPRISES INC CECEL CO LLC CHAD D EVANS CHARLES WEBSTER CHASE DELIVERIES INC CHASTAIN INCORPORATED CHRIS KAUTZKY CHRIS MICHAEL BROWN CHRIS MOLLISON CHRISTOPHER STEVEN GALLOWAY CINDY SCOTT CLAUDETTE S AZOURI CLUTCH BUCKS INC CMK DELIVERIES COAST INC-2ND VAN COASTAL COURIER INC CRAIG STOREY CREATIVE LOGISTICS INC D AND K VENTURES INC DALE LEWIS DAN CARROLL DANELL OBRIST DAROLD BERUBE DARRELL CRAPSER DARRIN OPDYCKE DAVID A WOLF CONTRACTING INC DAVID BOSS DAVID BURRIS DAVID J MARTIN DAVID KERNDT DAVID PEREZ DAVID SCHUMACHER DAVID SILVEY DAVID SPICER DEAN MOORE DEE TODD STONE DEMOSS ENTERPRISES INC DENNIS ARTHUR DORGAN DENNIS GLOYD SALLEE DENNIS McHENRY DERIEUX DELIVERY INC DIANE MOULSEY DIXON FAMILY LLC DIXON FREIGHT INC DJ FREIGHT INC DMJ PRODUCTIONS INC DON F GONSALVES DON FOSTER DORNER ENTERPRISE INC DOUGLAS CORNEJO DUSTIN MINER E G & C G INC EDWARD C SLAYMAN JR EDWARD DONGILLI EDWARD SCOTT ROSENBERG EDWARDS TRUCKING INC ERIC HAMILTON ESTCOURT EXPRESS CONTRATORS INC FERYDOUN HEMATYAR FRANK CURDY FRANK W NEILSON FREE JACK INC FRONTIER DELIVERY INC FULTON FREIGHT INC G L M TRANSPORT INC G L PETERSON INC GARY WALKER GK TRANSPORTATION INC GLENN WOODS G-LINK LLC GOLDEN BRIDGES INC GOLDEN FLYER CORPORATION GOLDEN KITES INC GREGORY SLEEPER GROUNDGIRL INC GT LOGISTICS INC GWP ENTERPRISES INC HALL INVESTMENTS INC HALLS HELPING HAND INC HAMMONS & LONG INC HAUSER HAULING INC HAYLO TRENDS LLC HECTOR PADILLA HENDERSHOTT DELIVERY SERVICE INC HIGH DESERT DELIVERY INC HOLUB ENTERPRISES LLC HONEY FROM THE ROCK LLC HOODVIEW PACKAGE SERVICES INC HULL ENTERPRISES INC IMPERIAL TRANSPORT INC INFLYT INC INTREPID TRANSPORT INVICTUS TRANSPORTATION INC IRON HORSE CONTRACTING INC J WARREN INC JACK ZINDA JACOB GOLD JAMES D CONNOR JAMES DREILING JAMES OLNEY JAMES WRIGHT JASON LOWERY JEFF CATO JEFF EVANS INC JEFF HEATON JEFF M AKERS JEFFREY J FISHER JEN-EX INC JEREMIAH SERVICES INC JERRY YOST JOHN C RUDEEN JOHN CHESTER PARADISO JOHN DAVID JENKINS JOHN DONAT INC JOHN FAASSE JOHN GAILEY JOHN JAMES HOLZHEIMER JOHN P WILLIFORD JOHN TAGGART JON HECKMAN JONATHAN LEIGHTER JORYAS INC JOSEPH C SINSAY JOSHUA DONALD FANSLOW JOSHUA LEWIS JTCB INC K&S DELIVERIES KALEINANI EXPRESS INC KARLA CLARK KATHY L STEPHENS KAY RING SERVICES INC KBM GROUND DELIVERY CO KDS DELIVERIES KEN HUDACEK KEN MARSHALL TRUCKING INC KENNETH MARITN ZAKAR KENNETH W CHRUSOSKIE KENNS P&D SERVICE INC KENT A OSGOOD KEVIN PATRICK QUIRK KEYVAN TAHMASEB INC KIMBERLY L WIKTORSKI KING COURIER COMPANY KJM ENTERPRISES INC KRIS OVALL KURT I SHINN LANCE-4TH/ST CHRISTENSEN LARRIE PORTER LARSON EXPRESS LAURA DORGAN LD LUTZ LLC LEADERSHIP LLC LESLIE H LANGSTON LISA KAREN DAVIDSON LOMAX INC LORI ANN ROSS LSS DELIVERY INC LYLE SIMMONS M & T & S LLC M R EHLERT INC MACNAB PARCEL SERVICES INC MACS HOME DELIVERY INC MAHNKE ENTERPRISES MARK **SWING** McNEALY MARK ANTHONY PETOSA MARK KESSELL MARK LEINHOS MARVIN L CHRISTY Mc HOMEDELIVERY INC McKENNA DELIVERY INC MCT ENTERPRISES MICHAEL E JACKSON MICHAEL ESTEP INC MICHAEL HARSEN MICHAEL KENNELL MICHAEL PLUMMER MICHAEL RAY DESPAROIS MICHAEL TAYLOR MICHELE TIPPIN MICKLE ENTERPRISES INCORPORATED MIKE LISKA TRUCKING INC MKG DELIVERY INC MOTA INC MPDQ INC MYRON ROBINSON NAAM INC NATHANIEL KNIGHT NEUHARTH INC NOBLE TRANSPORT INC NORTH COAST TRANS INC 2ND VAN NW COLUMBIA VENTURES INC NW DELIVERY INC NW TRANSPACK INC ON THE RIGHT TRACK INC OTTER & JACKRABBIT SVC INC PACIFIC DELIVERY LLC PACK MULE DELIVERY SERVICES INC PATRICK CHORUBY PATRICK COMER PATRICK HALSTEAD PERRY ST JOHN PHILLIP BJARNSON QUALITY GROUND TRANSPORT INC R & S DELIVERY SERVICE INC R A DELIVERY SERVICE INC R BRYON FRENYEA RANDAL HART RANDALL ALBERT MORGAN RANDY HOLMER RANDY ROBINSON RAPID GAINES INC RAYMOND GREEN RCKMLRCO INC RDS INC RICH HOBSON RICHARD BRUCE LEY RICHARD C SMITH RICHARD GROSS RICHARD MORGAN RICHARD STACY RICK SARDEGNA RICK THURMAN RIGHT ON TIME INC ROBERT A FREEMAN ROBERT E ALBERT ROBERT FRENCH ROBERT HICKS ROBERT L DENTON ROBERT THOMPSON RODERICK LARIOS ROGERS N W ENTERPRISES INC ROLANDO BROWN RON GLIBERT SMITH RONALD EVANS RONALD ODELL COWAN RONALD R PLUMB ROYAL T INC RUNNING PRONGHORN SERVICES INC RYAN TRUCKING INC RYGAN INC SAMUEL J GARBI SARA HAZARD SARGHUM ENTERPRISES SCOOTERS Q S LOGISTICS CORP SCOTT A DAILEY SCOTT ANTHONY STEGLICH SCOTT B HOLLAR SCOTT G MEHAN SCOTT KENT SCOTT LUNT SEAN McNEIL SETEFANO TALALOTU SHADY CREEK RANCH INC SHAWN ALAN DAVIDSON SHEETS DISTRIBUTION INC SHERRY SUZAN VALADAS SKE LOGISTICS INC SOPHAL-2ND VAN KHUT SPRINT DELIVERY INC STANLEY LARSON STEVE BOLFIK STEVE SNELLEN STEVEN CHARLES HARRISON STEVEN D IVERSON STEVEN SMITH STILL WATERS ENTERPRISES LLC SYDBO ENTERPRISES INC TBERG TRANSPORT INC TEM EX INC TEN FINN CORP TERRY STEPHENS THE OUTPOST OF ENTERPRISE INC THE TERRAFIN GROUP INC THOMAS CANTELMO THOMAS EVANS FEDEX GROUND LLC THOMAS M Mc DEVITT THOMAS SACK THREE PEA'S INC TI 3 INC TIEBREAKER INC TIMMAH'S TRUCKIN SERVICE INC TIMOTHY ONEAL TODD M WILLIAMS INC TOM DANDO TONY RIDINGER TRA GLOBAL INC TRACI JEAN HUDACEK TRADEMARK INDUSTRIES LLC TRADEWINDS CARGO INVESTORS INC TRANSWEST TRIPLE E LLC TRONDER CORPORATION TRUSTED INVESTMENTS INC TSUCHIYA ENTERPRISES TUMALO EXPRESS INC TWIN RIVERS ENTERPRISES INC TWO GREY FOXES LLC VERN HAWARD VINCE STRAFFORD W R YOUNG INC WALL FREIGHT LLC WALLOWA-UNION FREIGHT INC WATSON EXPRESS INC WENSCO INC WESBEC DELIVERY SERVICE INC WESTSIDE DELIVERY INC WESTVIEW LOGISTICS INC WGL INC WHITE PACIFIC INC WILBERT I IMBRUGLIA JR WILD RIVERS PARCEL & PACKAGE SERVICES INC WILFREDO SALIGUMBA WILLIAM NORRIS WINMO INC X ONE DELIVERY SERVICES INC XLR8 INC YINKA ROWLAND YUDIE THIO ZELIG LOGISTICS INC-2ND VAN
Source:  Leagle

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.
Ask a Question
Search for lawyers by practice areas.
Find a Lawyer