SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OPINION
COHEN, Judge: The supplemental opinion resolves the issue left undecided by our opinion in
Background
In 1998, in a transaction separate from but similar to the Bender transaction, Times Mirror Co., Inc. (Times Mirror), exchanged all of the outstanding stock of Mosby, Inc. (Mosby), in the "Mosby transaction". Times Mirror used the "corporate joint venture" structure to effectuate both the Bender and Mosby transactions. However, in contrast to the Bender transaction, before Times Mirror transferred Mosby stock, Mosby distributed certain assets to Times Mirror.
Times Mirror treated the exchanges of the Bender and Mosby stock as tax-free reorganizations within the meaning of
Respondent's reasons for disallowing tax-free treatment of the Bender transaction are nearly identical to respondent's2006 Tax Ct. Memo LEXIS 13">*15 reasons for disallowing tax-free treatment of the Mosby transaction. As to the Mosby exchange only, respondent asserts an additional reason to disqualify that transaction as a reverse triangular merger. Respondent contends that Mosby's transfers of assets to Times Mirror prior to Times Mirror's transfers of Mosby stock present an alternative and independent ground for finding that the Mosby transaction did not meet the "substantially all" requirement of
In December 2004, the Bender transaction was tried. The parties agreed that, because of the similarities between the Bender and Mosby transactions and the issues for trial, a trial of the Bender transaction could obviate the need for or limit the scope of any trial of the Mosby transaction. The parties agreed that, if the Bender transaction fails to qualify as a tax-free reorganization because it is neither a reverse triangular merger nor a "B" reorganization, the Mosby transaction also fails to qualify as a tax- free reorganization. On September 27, 2005, the Court issued the Bender opinion, in which it found that the Bender transaction does not qualify as a tax-free reorganization within the meaning of
The parties agree that the Bender opinion governs the outcome of the Mosby issue at the trial level. They agree that any judicial determinations affecting the Bender opinion on appeal or remand will also apply to the Mosby transaction.
Times Mirror's adjusted basis in its Mosby stock as of October 9, 1998, was $ 166,307,272, which amount is greater than the amount determined in the statutory notice of deficiency, $ 161,290,641. Times Mirror realized $ 415,000,000 in 1998 on the exchange of its 100- percent common stock interest in Mosby, and the additional capital gain resulting from Times Mirror's disposition of the Mosby stock is $ 248,692,728.
Discussion
The parties have stipulated that, in accordance with the Bender opinion and their stipulations and agreement, the Court should find that the Mosby transaction does not qualify as a tax-free reorganization within the meaning of
Decision will be entered under