Filed: Feb. 07, 2020
Latest Update: Feb. 07, 2020
Summary: STIPULATED MOTION AND ORDER REGARDING ANSWER DEADLINES AND CASE SCHEDULE RICARDO S. MARTINEZ , Chief District Judge . I. INTRODUCTION Pursuant to LCR 7(d)(1) and LCR 10(g), Plaintiff Amazon.com, Inc. ("Amazon"), Defendants Cash Network, LLC, Rasheed Ali, and Peter Bradford (collectively "Cash Network Defendants"), and Defendants First Impression Interactive, Inc., Jeffrey Giles, and Dale Brown (collectively "First Impression Defendants") 1 move the Court to extend the deadlines set in the
Summary: STIPULATED MOTION AND ORDER REGARDING ANSWER DEADLINES AND CASE SCHEDULE RICARDO S. MARTINEZ , Chief District Judge . I. INTRODUCTION Pursuant to LCR 7(d)(1) and LCR 10(g), Plaintiff Amazon.com, Inc. ("Amazon"), Defendants Cash Network, LLC, Rasheed Ali, and Peter Bradford (collectively "Cash Network Defendants"), and Defendants First Impression Interactive, Inc., Jeffrey Giles, and Dale Brown (collectively "First Impression Defendants") 1 move the Court to extend the deadlines set in the ..
More
STIPULATED MOTION AND ORDER REGARDING ANSWER DEADLINES AND CASE SCHEDULE
RICARDO S. MARTINEZ, Chief District Judge.
I. INTRODUCTION
Pursuant to LCR 7(d)(1) and LCR 10(g), Plaintiff Amazon.com, Inc. ("Amazon"), Defendants Cash Network, LLC, Rasheed Ali, and Peter Bradford (collectively "Cash Network Defendants"), and Defendants First Impression Interactive, Inc., Jeffrey Giles, and Dale Brown (collectively "First Impression Defendants")1 move the Court to extend the deadlines set in the Court's Order Setting Trial Date and Related Dates ("Scheduling Order") (Dkt. #40). After the Scheduling Order was entered, Amazon filed its First Amended Complaint ("FAC") (Dkt. #52), which added seven new defendants to the case. Since filing the FAC, Amazon diligently served the international defendants and has continued discovery. The parties also spent considerable time discussing settlement, but have not yet reached a resolution. The parties now request a roughly four-month extension to the Scheduling Order to conduct discovery and prepare the case for trial. The parties have not previously sought an extension of the Scheduling Order.
II. BACKGROUND
Amazon filed its Complaint on April 10, 2019 against Roy Oron ("Oron") and the First Impression Defendants (Dkt. #1). Amazon voluntarily dismissed Jeffrey Giles and Dale Brown soon after filing the case (Dkt. #22). On May 24, 2019, Amazon moved for authorization for alternative service on Oron (Dkt. #15), which the Court granted on June 6, 2019 (Dkt. #19). Amazon promptly completed service on Oron (Dkt. #21).
On July 5, 2019, Oron moved to dismiss the case for lack of personal jurisdiction (Dkt. #27). Despite not receiving a stay from the Court in connection with the motion, Oron refused to participate in any of the requirements set forth in the Court's initial scheduling order (Dkt. #5), and refused to respond to Amazon's discovery requests. On September 19, 2019, the Court denied Oron's motion to dismiss (Dkt. #42). On the same day, Oron's attorney filed a motion to withdraw (Dkt. #41), which the Court granted on November 1, 2019 (Dkt. # 54).
Separate from Oron, Amazon worked with First Impression to complete the prediscovery requirements, such as exchanging initial disclosures and completing the Joint Status Report (Dkt. #29). Amazon then pursued discovery of First Impression, and Amazon served ten subpoenas on third parties.
On October 8, 2019, and based on the discovery Amazon conducted, Amazon moved for leave to file its FAC (Dkt. #45). The Court granted Amazon's motion on October 25, 2019 (Dkt. #51), and Amazon promptly filed the FAC on October 31, 2019 (Dkt. #52). Among other things, the FAC added seven new defendants: Clickomy, Ltd., Maayan Marzan, Jeffrey Giles, Dale Brown, Cash Network, LLC, Rasheed Ali, and Peter Bradford.
On November 5, 2019, Amazon moved for authorization for alternative service of process on Defendants Maayan Marzan and Clickomy Ltd. (Dkt. #55). On November 21, 2019, the Court granted Amazon's motion (Dkt. # 59), and Amazon completed service on November 26, 2019 (Dkt. #60).
Defendants Oron and Clickomy Ltd. have failed to appear or otherwise respond to the FAC. Accordingly, on February 5, 2020, Amazon filed a Motion for Default against Oron and Clickomy Ltd. (Dkt. #62).
Defendant Marzan has not yet appeared in the case, but counsel for Marzan has been in contact with counsel for Amazon regarding a possible settlement. Those discussions are ongoing.
The First Impression Defendants and the Cash Network Defendants have not answered the FAC (in part) because they have been engaged in settlement discussions with Amazon. Though the parties continue those discussions, no agreement has been reached. The parties, therefore, wish to adjust the case schedule in order to proceed with the litigation.
III. STIPULATED REQUEST
Good cause exists to extend the Scheduling Order by roughly four months. This is the first time the parties have requested an extension of the Scheduling Order. After the Court entered the Scheduling Order, seven new defendants have been added to this litigation. Two of the new defendants are located internationally, and required alternative service. Amazon also conducted significant third-party discovery in order to identify the additional defendants and gather evidence to support its case.
The current Scheduling Order (Dkt. #40) does not provide sufficient time for the parties to pursue their claims and defenses. For example, the current expert disclosure deadline is June 10, 2020, and the deadline for completion of discovery is August 10, 2020. Some of the newly added defendants anticipate filing Rule 12 motions in response to the FAC. In particular, the Cash Network Defendants contend this Court lacks jurisdiction over them and intend to assert those defenses in a Rule 12 Motion to be filed. The Parties will not have sufficient time after the anticipated Rule 12 motions to complete discovery by the current case deadlines.
Accordingly, Amazon, the Cash Network Defendants, and the First Impression Defendants jointly request the following action:
1. That the Cash Network Defendants and the First Impression Defendants be ordered to file an answer or other responsive motion to the FAC on March 6, 2020; and
2. That the Court amend the Scheduling Order as shown below:
Current Date New Date
JURY TRIAL DATE December 7, 2020 April 5, 2021
Disclosure of expert testimony under June 10, 2020 October 9, 2020
FRCP 26(a)(2)
Deadline for filing motions related July 10, 2020 November 9, 2020
to discovery
Discovery completed by August 10, 2020 December 9, 2020
All dispositive motions must be filed September 8, 2020 January 11, 2021
by and noted on the motion calendar
no later than the fourth Friday
thereafter
Mediation per LCR 39.1(c)(3), if October 23, 2020 February 26, 2021
requested by the parties, held no
later than
All motions in limine must be filed November 9, 2020 March 8, 2021
by and noted on the motion calendar
no later than the third Friday
thereafter
Agreed pretrial order due November 25, 2020 March 24, 2021
Trial briefs, proposed voir dire December 2, 2020 March 31, 2021
questions, jury instructions, neutral
statement of the case, and trial
exhibits due
DAVIS WRIGHT TREMAINE LLP BYRNES KELLER CROMWELL LLP
By s/James H. Wendell By s/Jofrey M. McWilliam
Bonnie E. MacNaughton, WSBA #36110 Bradley S. Keller, WSBA #10665
James H. Wendell, WSBA #46489 Jofrey M. McWilliam, WSBA #28441
Sara A. Fairchild, WSBA #54419 1000 Second Avenue, 38th Floor
920 Fifth Avenue, Suite 3300 Seattle, WA 98104
Seattle, WA 98104 Phone: 206-622-2000
Tel: (206) 622-3150 Fax: 206-622-2522
Fax: (206) 757-7700 Email: bkeller@byrneskeller.com
Email: bonniemacnaughton@dwt.com jmcwilliam@byrneskeller.com
jamiewendell@dwt.com
sarafairchild@dwt.com ARONBERG GOLDGEHN DAVIS &
GARMISA
Attorneys for Plaintiff Amazon.com, Inc.
By s/Nathan H. Lichtenstein
Nathan H. Lichtenstein (admitted pro
hac vice)
330 North Wabash Avenue, Suite 1700
Chicago, IL 60611
Phone: 312-828-9600
Email: nlichtenstein@agdglaw.com
Attorneys for Defendants First Impression
Interactive, Inc., Jeffrey Giles, and Dale
Brown
LOWE GRAHAM JONES
By s/Mark P. Walters
Mark P. Walters, WSBA# 30819
701 Fifth Avenue, Suite 4800
Seattle, WA 98104
Telephone: (206) 381-3300
Email: walters@lowegrahamjones.com
Attorneys for Defendants Cash Network,
LLC, Rasheed Ali, and Peter Bradford
ORDER
Given the stipulation above, and for good cause, the Court issues the following revised deadlines:
1) the Cash Network Defendants and the First Impression Defendants are to file an answer or other responsive motion to the FAC no later than March 6, 2020, and
2) the scheduling order is modified as set forth below.
Current Date New Date
JURY TRIAL DATE December 7, 2020 April 5, 2021
Disclosure of expert testimony under June 10, 2020 October 9, 2020
FRCP 26(a)(2)
Deadline for filing motions related July 10, 2020 November 9, 2020
to discovery
Discovery completed by August 10, 2020 December 9, 2020
All dispositive motions must be filed September 8, 2020 January 5, 2021
by and noted on the motion calendar
no later than the fourth Friday
thereafter
Mediation per LCR 39.1(c)(3), if October 23, 2020 February 26, 2021
requested by the parties, held no
later than
All motions in limine must be filed November 9, 2020 March 8, 2021
by and noted on the motion calendar
no later than the third Friday
thereafter
Agreed pretrial order due November 25, 2020 March 24, 2021
Trial briefs, proposed voir dire December 2, 2020 March 31, 2021
questions, jury instructions, neutral
statement of the case, and trial
exhibits due