NATIONAL PASTEURIZED EGGS, INC. v. MICHAEL FOODS, INC., 10-cv-646-wmc (2012)
Court: District Court, E.D. Wisconsin
Number: infdco20120605d56
Visitors: 2
Filed: May 30, 2012
Latest Update: May 30, 2012
Summary: ORDER WILLIAM M. CONLEY, District Judge. Having reviewed the parties' deposition designations and objections thereto, the court makes the following rulings. The approved designations may be presented to the jury unless the witness is available to testify in person. 1) Leon John Davidson, Apr. 6, 2012 (dkt. #277): MFI Initial National National MFI Court's Ruling Designations Objections Counterdesignations Counterobjections
Summary: ORDER WILLIAM M. CONLEY, District Judge. Having reviewed the parties' deposition designations and objections thereto, the court makes the following rulings. The approved designations may be presented to the jury unless the witness is available to testify in person. 1) Leon John Davidson, Apr. 6, 2012 (dkt. #277): MFI Initial National National MFI Court's Ruling Designations Objections Counterdesignations Counterobjections 7..
More
ORDER
WILLIAM M. CONLEY, District Judge.
Having reviewed the parties' deposition designations and objections thereto, the court makes the following rulings. The approved designations may be presented to the jury unless the witness is available to testify in person.
1) Leon John Davidson, Apr. 6, 2012 (dkt. #277):
MFI Initial National National MFI Court's Ruling
Designations Objections Counterdesignations Counterobjections
7:1-7:2 (See National Initial
7:5-7 Designations)
9:14-21 (See National Initial
Designations)
10:25-11:2 12:6-13:5
11:17-19 (See National Initial
Designations)
32:20-33:2 (See National Initial
Designations)
33:20-34:6 34:16-35:17
34:10-15 (See National Initial
Designations)
35:18-22 (See National Initial
Designations)
37:1-38:8 39:6-42:1
42:2-9 42:10-13
44:2-10
(See National Initial
Designations)
44:11-16 (See National Initial
Designations)
44:20-45:2 45:3-4
(See National Initial
Designations)
45:10-13 (See National Initial
46:2-12 Designations)
46:16-47:16
47:17-47:20 47:21-25
48:1-3 52:6-7
51:22-52:5 52:21-53:8
(See National Initial
Designations)
53:9-14 (See National Initial
53:25-54:9 Designations)
76:1-7 R; 403; MIL (to 75:16-25 Sustained as to
the extent (See National Initial liability; overruled
played in the Designations) as to damages
liability phase)
77:23-78:3 R; 403; MIL (to (See National Initial Sustained as to
the extent Designations) liability; overruled
played in the as to damages
liability phase)
79:3-5 (See National Initial
Designations)
80:10-80:15 R; 403; MIL (to 80:20-21 Sustained as to
the extent (See National Initial liability; overruled
played in the Designations) as to damages
liability phase)
85:20-86:9 R; 403; MIL (to (See National Initial Sustained as to
the extent Designations) liability; overruled
played in the as to damages
liability phase)
86:13-17 R; 403; L; MIL (See National Initial Sustained as to
(to the extent Designations) liability; overruled
played in the as to damages
liability phase)
97:13-25 R; 403; MIL; (See National Initial Sustained; omit
HS Designations) 97:13-15
99:7-101:12 R; 403 (See National Initial Overruled
101:20-25 Designations)
102:1-11 Untimely 102:12-103:6 Overruled,
103:17-25 105:7-12 provided
104:25-105:6 (See National Initial counterdesignations
Designations) included
105:13-18 R; 403 (See National Initial Overruled
106:1-21 Designations)
107:2-17
112:19-113:3 Untimely 112:25-113:23 Overruled,
113:11-16 (112:25-113:3, (See National Initial provided
114:9-17 113:11-16, Designations) counterdesignations
116:18-24 114:9-17, included
116:25-118:4 116:25-118:4,
118:14- 118:14-119:23)
119:23
120:11-121:7 AC (121:6) (See National Initial Sustained; omit
Designations) 121:6
121:15-21 Untimely; AC (See National Initial Sustained; omit
(121:19-20) Designations) 121:19-20
122:5-10 (See National Initial
Designations)
135:9-10 (See National Initial
Designations)
138:2-140:3 (See National Initial
Designations)
National MFI Counter- NPE Counter- Court's Ruling
Initial MFI Objections designations objections
Designations
7:5-7:9
9:14-9:21
10:1-10:14
14:2-15:6
15:21-16:5
17:21-18:6
29:7-29:24
30:2-30:21
32:3-32:12
37:1-37:7
37:22-38:2
42:2-44:6
49:1-49:7
50:1-50:5
140:13-140:16
141:2-141:25
144:20-145:9
147:3-147:20
148:9-148:21 Rule 602, Lack Overruled
of foundation
(148:18-21)
149:12-150:13 Rule 602, Lack Overruled
of foundation
(149:15-16)
152:17-154:15
155:13-156:15
157:9-158:24
159:2-161:12
162:22-163:4
163:7-163:24
164:2-164:6
164:8-164:9
165:11-166:21
166:24-167:12
168:12-168:18
168:21-168:24
169:1-170:12
170:25-173:10
173:17-174:10 Assumes facts Sustained; omit
not in evidence 174:7-14 through
(174:7-10) "words" (keep
"Would you read the
sentence again?) and
omit 174-15-17
174:13-175:3 Assumes facts Overruled
not in evidence
(175:1-3)
175:5-176:23
177:1-177:4
177:7-177:8
177:24-178:4
178:17-181:21
181:24-182:6 182:7-12; Rule 402; Untimely Overruled as to
182:15-19 182:7-12; sustained
as to 182:15-19; omit
182:15-19
183:5-185:20
186:1-186:24
187:2-187:10 187:11-16
187:18-188:4
188:23-189:21
193:13-195:5
195:10-195:12 195:13-196:4
(ending at
"doubt.")
196:5-196:16
198:7-199:6
199:9-199:18
199:20-199:25
200:2-200:5
200:7-200:12 Rule 402, Lack Overruled
of foundation
(200:10-12)
200:15-201:1 Rule 402, Lack Overruled in part;
of foundation sustained in part;
(200:17-19) omit 200:17
201:4-201:6 201:7-9 Untimely Overruled
201:10-201:14 Rule 402, Lack Overruled
of foundation
201:17-201:24 Rule 402, Lack Overruled
of foundation
220:22-221:3
2) James D. Schuman, PhD., Dec. 1, 2011 (dkt. #148):
National MFI National Court's Ruling
Initial MFI Objections Counterdesignations Counterobjections
Designations
6:2-6:4
6:9-6:15 16:7-8
44:2-44:23 Rule 402, Rule 42:17-43:8 Untimely Overruled as to
403 (44:2-23) both objections
67:8-67:23 66:20-67:7; 67:24- Untimely Overruled
68:8
71:21-73:18,
73:22-74:14
75:7-76:17
82:22-83:15 80:3-80:18
86:17-86:22 87:4-9
88:20-90:7 90:8-22 Untimely Overruled
91:7-91:21
92:6-93:1
93:2-93:18 93:23-94:1 Untimely Overruled
106:11-
106:22
108:16-
109:12
115:2-115:14
115:18-116:3
118:5-120:6 Attorney Sustained in part;
colloquy (118:7- overruled in part;
8) omit 118:7
129:17- Rule 602, Lack Overruled
129:19 of foundation
129:22-130:9 (129:17-19)
145:18-
145:20
146:3-146:19
193:5-193:8
193:24-
194:12
195:18-
195:21
199:12-
199:20
202:3-202:5
204:15-
204:20
205:7-205:10
205:21-206:1,
206:4-206:13
207:13-
207:23,
208:1-208:23
212:11-213:3 213:4-13
218:18-219:7
223:24-224:10
225:16- 226:11-14
226:10
226:15- 229:13-230:8
229:12
230:9-233:17 233:18-25; 234:3-12
234:13-235:4
236:16-
236:19,
236:21-
237:16
237:21-
237:23,
238:2-238:3
240:19- Assumes facts Overruled in part;
241:13, not in evidence sustained in part;
241:16- (241:11-13); omit 241:22-242:20
241:23, Rule 402, Rule
242:3-242:4, 403 (241:22-23;
242:8-242:13, 242:3-4; 242:8-
242:17- 13; 242:18-20)
242:20
243:13-
243:23
245:6-246:3,
246:5-246:16
247:21-248:2
248:5-248:9
248:17-249:8 Attorney Sustained; omit
colloquy (249:6- 249:6-7
7)
249:13-
250:19
253:10-
253:23,
254:2-254:6
247:21-248:2
248:5-248:9
248:17-249:8
249:13- 250:20-251:1 Untimely Overruled
250:19
253:10-
253:23,
254:2-254:6
256:14-257:6
257:10-
258:16
261:4-261:11 261:12-23
262:4-262:13
262:23- 270:2-271:7; 272:6-9;
263:18, 272:11-17
263:22-264:6
273:16- Rule 402, Rule Sustained; omit
273:18, 403 273:16-18, 273:23-
273:23-274:2 274:2
3) Dr. Hershall Ball, Mar. 20, 2012 (dkt. #275):
National MFI National Court's Ruling
Initial MFI Objections Counterdesignations Counterobjections
Designations
15:16-15:19
15:25-16:5
18:3-18:6
18:11-18:19 18:20-19:2
19:3-19:7 19:19-23
19:24-20:9
26:8-26:16
28:18-28:23
29:13-29:23
30:6-30:19 34:1-6; 35:13-24
36:20-37:8
37:14-37:18 37:19-25
52:14-52:19 35:25-36:7; 46:14-16;
46:18-20; 49:19-22
54:4-55:7 55:8-18
58:24-59:5
59:15-60:2
60:3-60:7
74:8-74:14
74:24-75:10
75:17-76:2,
76:7-76:12
76:21-76:22, Rule 402, Rule Sustained; omit
77:3-77:8 403 76:21-22, 77:3-8
78:11-78:15,
78:20-78:25
79:8-79:11 Rule 402, Rule Sustained; omit
403 79:8-11
79:21-79:25 79:17-20 Untimely Overruled
82:16-82:20 83:17-21
84:6-84:14 84:15-17; 84:20-21
86:9-86:14
88:18-89:14 90:20-25
96:6-96:11
97:1-97:8,
97:11
100:2-100:10
101:1-101:16 101:17-22
101:23- 103:12-104:1
102:12
104:20-105:8
106:5-106:12
109:21-110:2
111:12-
112:12
113:18-
113:23
115:11-
115:17
124:13-
125:16
129:13-
129:20
131:4-131:12 131:13-16
132:5-132:10
132:21-133:5,
133:8-133:9
140:18-
140:23
141:18- 142:1-2
141:25
142:3-142:5, 142:19-22; 142:25-
142:8-142:9 143:10; 143:12-14;
144:2-18
182:16-183:8, Rule 602, Lack 184:20-22; 184:24-25 Overruled
183:11-184:6 of foundation
(183:8)
189:4-189:25,
190:3-190:5
191:11- Vague (191:11- Overruled
191:18, 18)
191:21-
191:23
200:12-
200:22
201:7-201:14
203:17-205:3
205:10-
205:20
207:1-207:24,
208:2-208:14
214:15- Vague, Rule 222:3-5; 222:8-10 Incomplete Overruled as to
214:24, 602, Lack of both objections
215:2-215:4 foundation
(214:21-24)
232:15-
233:20
234:3-234:11
234:17-
234:20
235:1-236:9 236:10-14
236:15-
238:22
240:1-242:9 294:2-14; 294:16-20; AC (294:11-12) Sustained; omit
294:23 294:11-12
243:5-243:23, 294:25-295:11;
244:1-245:8 295:14; 295:16-17;
295:20-21; 295:23-
296:7
246:4-246:21 296:16-17; 296:20;
296:22-297:1; 297:4
249:16- 249:23
249:21,
249:24-
250:11
250:23-
251:15,
251:17-
251:21
254:17- 255:12-17; 255:20-23
254:20,
254:25-
255:11
255:25-256:2, 257:9-11; 257:14-15;
256:5-256:7 257:17-258:1
258:2-258:7,
258:9-258:13
258:18-
258:25,
259:2-259:5
259:14-262:7,
262:10-
262:16
263:10-264:2, 264:16-19; 264:23
264:6-264:14
264:25-265:6
272:18-
273:16
273:23-274:4
274:23-
275:13
275:20- Rule 602, Lack Sustained; omit
276:11, of foundation 275:20-276:11,
276:14- (276:8-11) 276:14-24
276:24
277:13-
278:10
279:3-279:10
280:2-281:2
281:13-282:5
282:13-
282:18,
282:21
283:2-283:10
287:1-287:7
287:16-
287:21,
287:23-
287:25
4) Joseph M. Vandepopuliere, Ph.D., Apr. 10, 2012 (dkt. #266):
National MFI National Court's Ruling
Initial MFI Objections Counterdesignations Counterobjections
Designations
7:7-8:10
13:14-13:15
13:17
13:19-13:23
14:14-14:17
15:9
15:12-17:7
17:9-17:10
19:21-20:21
34:15-34:21
34:25-35:2
34:25-35:2
35:8-35:12
35:18-35:25
42:5-42:13
45:1-46:1
46:19-48:19 Rule 402, Rule Sustained; omit
403 (47:23- 47:23-49:10
49:10)
48:22-48:25 Rule 402, Rule
403 (47:23-
49:10)
49:2-49:7 Rule 402, Rule
403 (47:23-
49:10)
49:10-49:15 Rule 402, Rule
403 (47:23-
49:10)
49:18-49:19
50:10-50:22 Rule 402, Rule Sustained; omit
403 50:10-22
50:25-51:4 Rule 402, Rule Sustained; omit
403 50:25-51:4
51:13-51:25
52:3
52:16-53:15
53:22-54:3
54:13-55:2 Rule 602, Lack Sustained; omit
of foundation 55:1-2
(55:1-2, 6-8)
55:6-55:8 Rule 602, Lack Sustained; omit
of foundation 55:6-8
(55:1-2, 6-8)
55:11 Rule 602, Lack Sustained; omit 55-
of foundation 11
57:21-58:14 Rule 602, Lack Overruled
of foundation
(57:22-58:1)
58:17-58:20 Rule 602, Lack Sustained; omit
of foundation 58:19-20, 23
(58:19-20)
58:23-59:1
59:3-59:13
59:16-59:20
59:23-60:14 Rule 602, Lack Sustained; omit
of foundation 60:13-14
(60:13-14)
60:16-60:18 Rule 602, Lack Sustained; omit
of foundation 60:16-18
(60:16-18)
60:21-61:12 Rule 602, Lack Overruled
of foundation
(60:23-61:1)
61:14-61:21
61:24-62:6
62:9-64:7 Compound, Sustained; omit
Vague (64:4-7) 64:4-11
64:10-64:25
65:2-66:8
66:11-66:24
67:2-68:2
68:18-69:22
69:24-70:25
71:2-71:10
71:13
71:15-71:24
72:24-73:20
74:9-74:16 Compound Overruled
(74:14-16;
74:19-24)
74:18-74:24
75:1-75:2
78:9-79:17
81:8-81:20
82:4-82:12
83:2-83:5 83:6-10
84:4-84:6
84:9
86:13-87:16
88:9-88:16
89:12-90:13
90:15-90:16
90:25-91:3
91:6-91:12
91:15-91:23
92:8-93:9
93:11-96:1
97:6-99:2
99:14-100:4
100:12- Rule 602, Lack Sustained; omit
100:13 of Foundation 100:12-13, 16-17
100:16-
100:20
101:2-102:3
102:6-103:5
103:9
103:11-
103:21
108:12-
108:20
108:24-
108:25
109:3-109:4
109:13-110:2
114:18-
115:13
115:16-
115:21
115:24
116:1-116:3
116:6-116:18
116:20-117:1
117:22-
117:25
118:2
118:5-118:6
118:10-
118:20
118:23-119:9
119:11-
119:18
119:20-
119:21
119:23-
120:23
120:25-121:2
121:5
121:8-121:14
121:16-
121:23
121:25-
122:11
124:22-
124:25
125:2
125:5-125:9
125:12-
125:13
125:15-
125:17
125:19-126:2
126:5-127:8
127:11-
127:14
128:4-128:10
130:13-131:1 131:4-8
131:11-
131:16
131:18- 131:21-132:2 AC (131:24-25) Sustained; omit
131:19 131:24-25
132:24-
133:16
133:18-135:8 Rule 802, Rule 133:20 Overruled
602
135:11- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
135:16 602
135:18- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
135:23 602
135:25-136:3 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
136:6-136:23 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
137:1-137:7 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
137:15- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
138:23 602
139:1-139:11 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
140:14- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
140:21 602
140:25-141:2 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
141:4-141:7 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
141:9-141:19 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
141:21-142:3 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
142:6-142:11 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
142:13- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
142:20 602
143:1-143:8 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
143:24-144:3 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
144:5 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
144:7-144:10 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
144:13- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
144:18 602
144:20-145:6 Rule 802, Rule 257:21-260:8 260:12- Rule 402; Rule 403; Overruled as to
602 261:4; 262:7-15; Leading both objections
274:12-275:23; 276:3-
24
145:10- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
145-23 602
146:1-146:9 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
146:11- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
146:15 602
146:18-147:2 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
147:4-147:6 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
147:9-147:18 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602 (147:9)
147:21-148:5
148:8-148:10
148:12-
148:13
148:15- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
148:20 602
148:23- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
149:12 602
149:15- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
149:19 602
149:21-150:6 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
150:9-150:20 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
150:23- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
150:24 602
151:2-151:8 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
151:11- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
151:16 602
151:18- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
151:21 602
151:23-152:2 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
152:5-152:14 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
152:17- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
152:18 602
152:21-153:2 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
153:5-153:9 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
153:11- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
153:16 602
153:20-154:7 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
154:11- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
154:21 602
154:23- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
155:11 602
156:14- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
156:21 602
156:25 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
157:2-157:5 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
157:8-157:10 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
157:13- Rule 802, Rule Overruled
157:18 602
157:21-158:4 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
158:8-158:10 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
159:25- Attorney Sustained in part;
160:12 colloquy (159:25 overruled in part;
- 160:1) omit 159:25-160:1
through "strike
that" (keep in "Did
you expect Dr. Ball
to")
160:15
162:25-
163:11
163:13-
163:22
163:24-
164:11
164:14-
164:19
164:21-165:2
165:4-165:11
165:14
166:19-167:3
167:6-167:17
167:20-168:3
168:6
168:8-16
169:1-9
169:12-13
170:9-24
286:4-286:12
286:15-
286:21
286:23-287:8 Rule 802, Rule Overruled
602
287:22-
287:24
288:1-288:5 Rule 602, Lack Overruled
of foundation
290:20-
290:22
290:24-
290:25
291:3-291:4
291:6-291:7
292:7-292:10
292:13-
292:20
292:23-293:2
293:12-
293:14
294:1-294:3
294:6-294:17
294:23-295:1
295:4-295:19
295:22-
295:24
Source: Leagle
