Copyright claim for use of an image of the U.S. Flag
I recently received a letter from a company named Getty Images demanding $1,000 for using an image on my web site that apparently belongs to them or a photographer they represent. If I recall correctly, I obtained this image from a 'free'' clip art web site. Obviously I should not have trusted that site, and I no longer have a record of what site that was. I have removed the image from my site.
Ordinarily I would start seeing if I could settle up with them. However, the image in question is a photograph of the U.S. Flag. There is no object in the photo except the flag. I have done some research of my own. I can't find a case that says that an image which contains no other objects in it other than the U.S. Flag is copyrightable.
I have found cases that say that one can copyright an image which includes the flag along with other elements, such as an Eagle or a mountain. But no court I can find has said there's a way to manipulate, crop, backlight, blur or otherwise modify an image of the flag so it is original enough to copyright. I have already written to them denying liability and stating that I don't believe the image in question is copyrightable. Any other suggestions as to what I should be doing?