The Issue Whether Petitioner's application for a Florida Educator's Certificate should be granted or denied for the reasons set forth in the Notice of Reasons issued by Respondent on December 13, 2010.
Findings Of Fact Based on the evidence presented at hearing, the following Findings of Fact are made: Ms. Cappi Cay Arroyo1/ was born in Boulder, Colorado, on September 16, 1964. On or about August 22, 1986, Ms. Arroyo knowingly and intentionally distributed cocaine to another person, knowing that what was distributed was cocaine or some other prohibited drug. From 1984 until in or about December 1986, she willfully and knowingly entered into an agreement to accomplish the illegal objective of the distribution of cocaine, with the intent to commit the offense of distribution of cocaine. Ms. Arroyo pled guilty pursuant to a plea agreement and was convicted of the offenses of distributing cocaine under 21 U.S.C. § 841(a)(1) and of conspiracy to distribute cocaine under 21 U.S.C. § 846 in the United States District Court for the District of Hawaii. Ms. Arroyo committed acts involving moral turpitude. On January 28, 1988, Ms. Arroyo was sentenced to two years imprisonment with a Special Parole Term of three years, with the execution of the sentence suspended and Ms. Arroyo placed on probation for a period of five years, on the condition that she pay a fine of $500.00 and serve 100 hours of community service. On April 3, 1991, Ms. Arroyo was discharged from probation. Ms. Arroyo later returned to Colorado. She attended Colorado Christian University and received her Bachelor's Degree in Computer Information Systems in 2002. She began working at Grand Junction High School in 2005 as a Library Media Specialist, where she worked until 2010. She received her Master's Degree in Educational Media in 2006 from the University of Northern Colorado. She received an Outstanding Educator for 2007 award given by the Grand Junction Area Chamber of Commerce, and was selected as the Outstanding Teacher by the students of the Class of 2009. The Ethics in Education Act, creating section 1012.315, Florida Statutes, and adding the phrase "as defined by rule of the State Board of Education" to section 1012.795(1)(d), became effective on July 1, 2008. On June 3, 2010, Ms. Arroyo submitted an on-line application for a Florida Educator's Certificate as an Educational Media Specialist. On the application, she provided her social security number and answered "Yes" to a question asking if she had ever been convicted of a criminal offense. She filled in the "Charges" block with the words "Drug Charges" and the "Disposition" block with the word "Probation." By June 9, 2010, the Bureau of Educator's Certification had received the application, the evidence of her bachelor's degree, the grades transcript, and the fee. Ms. Arroyo meets the basic requirements for licensure. She was at least 18 years of age at the time of her application; she submitted an electronically authenticated affidavit that stated she would uphold the principles incorporated in the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of Florida and that the information provided in her application was true, accurate, and complete; she documented her receipt of a bachelor's degree from an accredited institution and a master's degree; she submitted to background screening; she is of good moral character; she is competent and capable of performing the duties, functions, and responsibilities of an educator; she holds a valid professional standard teaching certificate issued by the State of Colorado, demonstrating her mastery of general knowledge, mastery of subject area knowledge, and mastery of professional preparation and education competence. The Department of Education is the state agency responsible for licensure of instructional personnel for the public schools. On or about July 7, 2010, the Bureau of Educator Certification of the Department of Education issued Ms. Arroyo an Official Statement of Status of Eligibility. This statement advised Ms. Arroyo that she was eligible for a three-year nonrenewable Temporary Certificate upon receipt by the Bureau of: 1) documentation showing verification of employment; 2) a request for issuance of certificate on the appropriate certification form from a Florida public school; and 3) results of her fingerprint processing, noting that if there was a criminal offense, her file would be referred to Professional Practices Services for further review and that issuance of her Temporary Certificate would be contingent on the results of that review. The Statement included some additional requirements for the issuance of a Florida Educator's Certificate valid for five years covering Educational Media Specialist (Prekindergarten- Grade 12). Mr. Troy Sanford, the principal at Horizon Academy at Marion Oaks, a school in the Marion County School District, interviewed Ms. Arroyo for a media specialist position at the school in August of 2010. At the end of that interview, she began to tell Mr. Sanford of her conviction, but he stopped her and told her that it was the Human Resources Department that checked into applicant's backgrounds. When Mr. Sanford later talked to the Human Resources Department, he advised them that he was recommending someone for the position who had indicated she had something in her background, and asked to be told if it would hinder her appointment. The Human Resources Department had further conversations with Mr. Sanford, telling him about a criminal conviction, but stating that because it had occurred over ten years ago, it should not be a limiting factor. Ms. Arroyo was hired at Horizon Academy and worked there during the 2010-2011 and 2011-2012 academic years as a library media specialist. Ms. Arroyo has excellent knowledge of her subject area and exhibits great enthusiasm in encouraging students to become life-long readers. Ms. Arroyo has effectively become a "co-teacher" with many of the classroom teachers and has helped them craft research projects that are meaningful to students. Horizon Academy has a high percentage of minority students, some of whom are underprivileged. Ms. Arroyo has made special efforts to get books into the hands of students who have never read a book before. She has created a culture of reading at Horizon Academy. Her efforts at her school have caused the library circulation to dramatically increase, which has had an effect on the district-wide data. Ms. Arroyo re-arranged the library to accommodate more students. Ms. Arroyo was selected as the Horizon Academy teacher of the year. Ms. Arroyo became a member of the Library of Congress Teaching with Primary Sources Mentor Program, one of only 19 educators from across the United States with such membership. Ms. Arroyo has helped children with lost or overdue books who are not permitted to withdraw books from the library by loaning them her personal books. She has purchased books from the Book Fair and given them to underprivileged students. She has given Christmas gifts to needy children who might otherwise not receive any gifts. When Ms. Arroyo came to Horizon Academy, it was a "C" school, but it is now an "A" school. The principal believes that there was a direct link between Ms. Arroyo's efforts and the improvement of the school. On October 13, 2010, the Department of Education received background check information on Ms. Arroyo from the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. On October 19, 2010, Ms. Arroyo's file was referred to the Bureau of Professional Practice Services for consideration of the background information regarding her conviction. On October 22, 2010, Ms. Arroyo was sent a letter from Ms. Ellie Evans, Applicant Investigator of the Bureau, advising Ms. Arroyo that her application had been referred to the Bureau of Professional Practices Services because of her criminal history, and requesting further information regarding Ms. Arroyo's conviction. On November 16, 2010, the Department received from Ms. Arroyo copies of a judgment in her criminal case, United States v. Cappi C. Eminger, Case No. CR87-01061-03, from the United States District Court for the District of Hawaii, dated January 28, 1988, consisting of three pages, and including an Order Terminating Probation Prior to Original Expiration Date in the same case filed April 8, 1991, consisting of one page. On December 13, 2010, Commissioner of Education Eric Smith sent Ms. Arroyo a letter advising her that her application for a Florida Educator's Certificate was denied, attaching a Notice of Reasons, and advising her of her right to a hearing on the intended action. Ms. Arroyo requested a formal hearing. Ms. Arroyo will be unable to pursue a career teaching students in Florida without educator certification. Ms. Arroyo is substantially affected by the intended decision to deny her certification. On or about March 23, 2011, the Bureau issued Ms. Arroyo a second Official Statement of Status of Eligibility. This statement advised Ms. Arroyo that her Colorado Teaching Certificate had been received and that she was eligible for a Florida Educator's Certificate valid for five years upon receipt of clearance to issue the certificate from the Bureau of Professional Practices Services. On or about June 8, 2011, Ms. Arroyo applied to the Florida Office of Executive Clemency for a pardon of her convictions. Ms. Arroyo also applied to the President of the United States for a pardon. On October 28, 2011, the Department received from Petitioner a notice of intent to rely on the default license provision in section 120.60(1), Florida Statutes. Although the charges of statutory violations drafted by Respondent as grounds for the denial of her application could have been crafted with more care, Petitioner was not prejudiced in preparing her defense. Hearing was held on December 6, 2011. At hearing, Petitioner testified that she did not distribute cocaine and that she did not conspire to distribute cocaine, maintaining that her guilty plea was the result of coercion and intimidation by Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) agents. Her testimony on these points was not credible. She testified that the DEA agents took her vehicle and showed up at her house with guns. She testified that there were 33 charges in the indictment. She testified that she told the DEA agents that it was her ex-boyfriend who had distributed cocaine. She said that the DEA agents told her that she was guilty simply because she was aware of what he did, even if she did not distribute cocaine herself. Petitioner testified that she could not remember whether her attorney advised her about entering into the plea agreement. At another point in her testimony she testified that her attorney did not advise her as to the guilty plea. She was somewhat evasive during cross-examination as to her appearance before the judge when pleading guilty. She later said that she did not remember that appearance at all. She testified she did not remember the judge asking her if she knowingly and intentionally distributed 55.2 grams of cocaine. Petitioner did testify that she believed what the DEA agents had told her and signed a plea agreement that she was guilty of 2 of the 33 charges, based only upon this mistaken belief. Ms. Arroyo's testimony and selective memories about these long-ago events seemed to be shaped more by convenience than candor. Ms. Arroyo failed to prove her guilty plea resulted from threats, coercion, or fraudulent means. Despite the fact that Ms. Arroyo distributed cocaine and conspired to distribute cocaine and her selective memories and lack of credibility concerning those events, she is of good moral character. A few isolated events are not determinative of her character today. Ms. Arroyo's actions since her youthful criminal activity show a consistent pattern of personal accomplishment and public service over a very long period of time, with no evidence of any other criminal activity. Ms. Arroyo has substantially rehabilitated herself. Her receipt of several education awards demonstrates that she is a dedicated and accomplished professional. Testimony at hearing established that Ms. Arroyo exhibits a compassionate and generous attitude toward students, especially the underprivileged. On January 3, 2012, Respondent filed certified copies of records of the United States District Court for the District of Hawaii, including sentencing minutes, the indictment, a superseding indictment, sentencing memorandum, and other documents, requesting their official recognition and admission as a late-filed exhibit. The State Board of Education has not defined the term "gross immorality" by rule, and there was no evidence presented that Ms. Arroyo's behavior met any rule definition of that term.
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is: RECOMMENDED that the Education Practices Commission enter a final order denying Petitioner's application for a Florida Educator's Certificate, without prejudice to her reapplication should she later become eligible. DONE AND ENTERED this 31st day of May, 2012, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S F. SCOTT BOYD Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 31st day of May, 2012.
The Issue The issues in this case are whether Respondent, Caren Christine Olsen (Respondent), committed the violations alleged in an Administrative Complaint issued April 20, 2010, and, if so, the penalty that should be imposed.
Findings Of Fact Petitioner, as the Commissioner of the Florida Department of Education, is responsible to investigate and prosecute complaints against persons who hold a Florida Educational Certificate who are alleged to have violated the provisions of law related to the education profession in the State of Florida. See §§ 1012.79 and 1012.795, Fla. Stat. At all times material to the allegations of this case, Respondent held Florida Educator's Certificate No. 999159, covering mathematics, which was valid through June 30, 2010. At all times material to this case, Respondent was employed at Freedom High School in Orange County, Florida. As a secondary teacher, Respondent was required to complete ESOL training. In order to meet the ESOL requirement, on or about January 14, 2008, Respondent enrolled in an ESOL class taught by Mr. Biggs. Mr. Biggs was a district compliance specialist who was fully approved to teach the ESOL class. He required that participants in the ESOL course attend all of the class sessions. The ESOL class requirements were: attendance at the 14 sessions, pre- and post-curriculum tests, completion of a portfolio of the course, and completion of a final evaluation of the course. Although enrolled in Mr. Biggs’ class, Respondent did not attend all of the class sessions. According to Mr. Biggs, Respondent left the class after the tenth session and did not return. In addition to missing the last sessions, Respondent did not turn in the portfolio or complete the evaluation of the course. Although Respondent maintained she had completed the portfolio, Mr. Biggs did not have record of such completion. In April 2009, Respondent was required to present a certificate that verified she had completed the aforementioned ESOL class. Although Respondent presented a certificate of completion for the ESOL course to school personnel, record of the credit for such completion could not be located. Eventually, it was discovered that Respondent did not have credit for the class because she had not completed the class and had not been given a certificate of completion by the instructor (Mr. Biggs). Thus, the issue of how Respondent could present a certificate of completion when none had been issued was raised by Orange County School District personnel. In fact, the certificate presented by Respondent lacked the Orange County Public School logo. In follow-up to this discovery, Respondent’s principal initiated a formal investigation to resolve the matter. When it was determined that Respondent could not produce a valid certificate of completion for the ESOL course, Respondent’s employment with the Orange County School District was terminated.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that Petitioner and the Education Practices Commission enter a Final Order that suspends Respondent's teaching certificate for a period not to exceed one year. DONE AND ENTERED this 27th day of September, 2011, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S J. D. PARRISH Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 27th day of September, 2011. COPIES FURNISHED: Kathleen M. Richards, Executive Director Education Practices Commission Department of Education Turlington Building, Suite 224 325 West Gaines Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0400 Todd P. Resavage, Esquire Brooks, LeBoeuf, Bennett, Foster and Gwartney, P.A. 909 East Park Avenue Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Caren Christine Olsen 2429 Shelby Circle Kissimmee, Florida 34743 Lois Tepper, Interim General Counsel Department of Education Turlington Building, Suite 1244 325 West Gaines Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0400 Marian Lambeth, Bureau Chief Bureau of Professional Practices Services Department of Education Turlington Building, Suite 1244 325 West Gaines Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0400
The Issue Whether Petitioner demonstrated entitlement to issuance of a Florida Educator’s Certificate.
Findings Of Fact Respondent, as Commissioner of the Florida Department of Education, is charged with the duty to issue Florida Educator's Certificates to persons seeking authorization to become school teachers in the State of Florida. Petitioner is a current resident of Puerto Rico. Petitioner was convicted of federal conspiracy to commit money laundering on October 26, 1999, and sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 46 months, with credit for time served. Petitioner was released from prison in April 2001. He began teaching physical education in Puerto Rico, starting in August 2001. He has taught continuously in Puerto Rico for the past 17 years without incident. Stipulated Facts Petitioner was charged with multiple criminal offenses in the case of United States of America v. Luis Amarante, a/k/a Chiqui, a/k/a El Grandote, et al., Criminal Case No. 98-189(HL). Petitioner pled guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit money laundering in the case of United States of America v. Luis Amarante, a/k/a Chiqui, a/k/a El Grandote, et al., Criminal Case No. 98-189(HL). Petitioner was found guilty of one count of conspiracy to commit money laundering in the case of United States v. Luis Amarante, a/k/a Chiqui, a/k/a El Grandote, et al., Criminal Case 98-189(HL). Petitioner was sentenced to serve 46 months in prison based upon his plea agreement entered in the case of United States of America v. Luis Amarante, a/k/a Chiqui, a/k/a El Grandote, et al., Criminal Case 98-189(HL). Petitioner submitted an application for a Florida Educator’s Certificate on July 13, 2016. On the application, Petitioner answered “no” to the questions: “Have you ever been convicted of a criminal offense?” “Have you ever been found guilty of a criminal offense?” “Have you ever pled guilty to a criminal offense?” The answer of “no” to each of these questions was false. Petitioner submitted written responses to Respondent’s Request for Admissions on November 6, 2018, in which he affirmed in writing his statements set forth above. Facts Adduced at Hearing Immediately below Petitioner’s electronic signature on his application was the following: WARNING: GIVING FALSE INFORMATION IN ORDER TO OBTAIN OR RENEW A FLORIDA EDUCATOR’S CERTIFICATE IS A CRIMINAL OFFENSE UNDER FLORIDA LAW. ANYONE GIVING FALSE INFORMATION ON THIS AFFIDAVIT IS SUBJECT TO CRIMINAL PROSECUTION, AS WELL AS DISCIPLINARY ACTION BY THE EDUCATION PRACTICES COMMISSION. Petitioner was not able to convincingly explain why he would have checked “no” for three separate questions regarding his criminal conviction on the electronic application. His testimony ranged from an unsuccessful attempt to change his answer to the question before he submitted it via his telephone, to a misunderstanding as to the period of time for which information was being requested. There was no evidence that Petitioner contacted the Department of Education to correct, amend, or withdraw his application. Petitioner gave no indication of an inability to perform the duties of a physical education teacher. The crime for which he was convicted was non-violent in nature, and occurred more than 20 years ago. He testified that he “talk[s] with young people and I explain what I did, you know, trying to -- they don’t do the same, you know, that they continue in the right path.” Petitioner appeared to be sincere in his desire to teach with the benefit of his experience. Despite the foregoing, it is Petitioner’s burden to demonstrate his entitlement to an Educator’s Certificate. Petitioner testified as to his 17 years of teaching in Puerto Rico -- which testimony is entitled to some degree of weight, as the passage of time can be persuasive evidence of rehabilitation and good character. The application includes the jurisdiction, certificate numbers, and dates of expiration for his Puerto Rico Teacher’s Certificate. The evidence that Petitioner has been certified to teach and has been employed as a physical education teacher in Puerto Rico was not disputed by Respondent. The testimony offered by Petitioner at the formal hearing failed to provide any explanation or contrition for his criminal conduct. He offered no specific proof of his good moral character in the form of admissible references from employers or coworkers to substantiate his testimony.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Department of Education enter a final order denying Petitioner, Luis Amarante’s application for a Florida Educator’s Certificate. DONE AND ENTERED this 14th day of January, 2019, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S GARY EARLY Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 14th day of January, 2019.
