Elawyers Elawyers
Washington| Change

Personal injury plaintiffs usually bring lawsuits that turn on a defendant’s negligence. Generally, the plaintiff must prove the following elements of negligence by a preponderance of the evidence: the defendant’s duty, the defendant’s breach of duty, actual and proximate cause, and damages. The elements can vary somewhat based on the situation that gave rise to the negligence. Whether a personal injury case arises out of premises liability, product defects, medical malpractice, or a car accident, the nature and severity of the injuries is what determines the value of the case.

Personal injury lawsuits can arise from many types of injuries, including:

  • Brain Injury
  • Broken/Fractured Bones
  • Burn Injury
  • Catastrophic Injury
  • Drowning
  • Electrocution
  • Fire/Burn Injury
  • Spinal Cord/Back Injury
  • Loss of Limb
  • Scarring/Disfigurement
  • Paralysis
The Relationship Between Injuries and Damages

In general, a plaintiff’s attorney will present the plaintiff’s testimony, as well as the testimony of a treating doctor or other expert, to discuss the nature and severity of the plaintiff’s injuries. Often, the past and future medical bills associated with the injuries are not the full extent of the damages available to address them.

For example, when a patient suffers paralysis in a truck accident, he or she may sue the truck driver and the trucking company. At trial, the victim may testify primarily as to pain and suffering and loss of enjoyment of life. However, he or she may also present a treating physician to testify as to the cause of the paralysis, objective findings, and the extent to which this kind of paralysis typically limits patients’ lives. He may need to present expert testimony from a vocational rehabilitation expert to show that he or she will no longer be able to work and will require household services that would not otherwise be needed. The expert will present evidence quantifying these future losses.

To counter the extent of the damages claimed by the plaintiff, the defense attorney will try to minimize the injuries suffered. Generally, the defendant will need to retain one or more experts, including a vocational rehabilitation expert, to respond to the plaintiff’s claim of damages. This expert may testify that the plaintiff can work and that the other expert is wrong, or he or she may testify that the plaintiff cannot work in the same capacity, but is qualified to work in other jobs that pay a similar amount and have job openings. Often, the defense will attack the plaintiff’s credibility not only as to the events that gave rise to the injuries, but also regarding the extent to which the plaintiff is limited by them.

Insurance companies that insure defendants in various types of claims retain investigators to look into suspicious claims of injuries and to conduct surveillance on the plaintiff. In general, as long as the investigation takes place in public places or online in spaces where there is no reasonable expectation of privacy, evidence from these investigations can be used to discredit plaintiffs.

One common error in judgment made by plaintiffs is to post pictures or status updates on Facebook or other social media. A prudent defendant’s investigator will use any public information to show that a plaintiff is exaggerating his or her injuries. For example, a plaintiff in a motorcycle accident who claims back injuries from a car accident, but posts status updates about extreme sports events and hiking, may expose himself to being discredited at deposition or in front of a jury about the extent of his back injuries.

Recent Topics

  • Brain Injury

    According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), around 1.4 million Americans suffer a brain injury every year. "Brain injury" is a term that encompasses everything from mild concussions to serious trauma. Symptoms may be subtle or ...

  • Broken/Fractured Bones

    Broken or fractured bones are common injuries arising out of accidents, and their existence and severity are hard to refute. In general, if somebody suffers a broken or fractured bone, the radiologist will take an x-ray image that provides informatio...

  • Burn Injury

    About 1.4 million persons in the United States suffer burns each year. Burn injuries are very complex and can affect all the major organ systems. A well-known cause of burns is accidental fires. Other sources of burns include scalding liquids or stea...

  • Catastrophic Injury

    Generally, catastrophic injuries are those injuries that permanently prevent an individual from performing work and enjoying life the way he or she would have before the accident. Often, they involve permanent disabilities or have very long-term effe...

  • Drowning

    Drowning is a form of asphyxia. It is caused by the aspiration of fluid into an airway, usually caused when the nose and mouth are submerged in water for a sufficient period of time. Initially, when someone falls into the water, he or she will sink d...

  • Electrocution

    Electrocution happens when someone is exposed to high voltage electricity and shocked, and it can cause injuries that result in death. Toddlers and adolescents are the age groups most likely to suffer electrocution in the United States. The severity ...

  • Burn Injury

    About 1.4 million persons in the United States suffer burns each year. Burn injuries are very complex and can affect all the major organ systems. A well-known cause of burns is accidental fires. Other sources of burns include scalding liquids or stea...

  • Amputation

    Amputation occurs when any limb or piece of the body is severed, either in an accident or in a planned surgery. An amputation can be partial or total. Losing a limb entirely can have devastating consequences. People who suffer an amputation or requir...

  • Paralysis

    Paralysis is an injury in which the victim loses muscle function in part or the entirety of his or her body. Initially, it can be very frightening to the person suffering from it. It can be partial or complete, and it may occur on one side of the bod...

  • PTSD and Other Psychological Conditions

    Many types of physical injuries are easy to prove. If you break your leg in a slip and fall, or if you suffer burns in a car crash, it would be hard to deny that these injuries occurred. The situation can become more complicated if a victim suffers f...

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.
Ask a Question
Search for lawyers by practice areas.
Find a Lawyer