Elawyers Elawyers
Ohio| Change

CORNING OPTICAL COMMUNICATIONS WIRELESS LTD. v. SOLID, INC., 5:14-cv-03750-PSG. (2015)

Court: District Court, N.D. California Number: infdco20150918d95 Visitors: 6
Filed: Sep. 16, 2015
Latest Update: Sep. 16, 2015
Summary: OMNIBUS ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL (Re: Docket Nos. 231, 237, 238, 246, 252, 253, 258, 262, 275, 279) PAUL S. GREWAL , Magistrate Judge . Before the court are numerous administrative motions to seal. "Historically, courts have recognized a `general right to inspect and copy public records and documents, including judicial records and documents.'" 1 Accordingly, when considering a sealing request, "a `strong presumption in favor of access' is the starting point." 2 Parties seeking to seal j
More

OMNIBUS ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL (Re: Docket Nos. 231, 237, 238, 246, 252, 253, 258, 262, 275, 279)

Before the court are numerous administrative motions to seal. "Historically, courts have recognized a `general right to inspect and copy public records and documents, including judicial records and documents.'"1 Accordingly, when considering a sealing request, "a `strong presumption in favor of access' is the starting point."2 Parties seeking to seal judicial records relating to dispositive motions bear the burden of overcoming the presumption with "compelling reasons" that outweigh the general history of access and the public policies favoring disclosure.3

However, "while protecting the public's interest in access to the courts, we must remain mindful of the parties' right to access those same courts upon terms which will not unduly harm their competitive interest."4 Records attached to nondispositive motions therefore are not subject to the strong presumption of access.5 Because the documents attached to nondispositive motions "are often unrelated, or only tangentially related, to the underlying cause of action," parties moving to seal must meet the lower "good cause" standard of Rule 26(c).6 As with dispositive motions, the standard applicable to nondispositive motions requires a "particularized showing"7 that "specific prejudice or harm will result" if the information is disclosed.8 "Broad allegations of harm, unsubstantiated by specific examples of articulated reasoning" will not suffice.9 A protective order sealing the documents during discovery may reflect the court's previous determination that good cause exists to keep the documents sealed,10 but a blanket protective order that allows the parties to designate confidential documents does not provide sufficient judicial scrutiny to determine whether each particular document should remain sealed.11

In addition to making particularized showings of good cause, parties moving to seal documents must comply with the procedures established by Civ. L.R. 79-5. Pursuant to Civ. L.R. 79-5(b), a sealing order is appropriate only upon a request that establishes the document is "sealable," or "privileged or protectable as a trade secret or otherwise entitled to protection under the law." "The request must be narrowly tailored to seek sealing only of sealable material, and must conform with Civil L.R. 79-5(d)."12 "Within 4 days of the filing of the Administrative Motion to File Under Seal, the Designating Party must file a declaration as required by subsection 79-5(d)(1)(A) establishing that all of the designated material is sealable."13

With these standards in mind, the courts rules on the instant motions as follows:

Motion Document to be Sealed Result Reason/Explanation to Seal 231 Plaintiff's Motion Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Regarding Improper black on pages 5:13-17, 6-11 at narrowly tailored to Privilege Claims Docket No. 231-3 SEALED; all confidential business other designations UNSEALED. information. 231 Exhibit A SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 231 Exhibit B SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 231 Exhibit C SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 231 Exhibit D UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 231 Exhibit E UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 231 Exhibit F Docket No. 231-18 at 125:23-24, Only sealed portions 126:25-127:1, 127:7-9, 127:16-18, Narrowly tailored to 127:20-23, 135:5-6, 135:11-12 confidential business 135:21-24, 137:2-24, 148:1-6, information. 148:10-11, 148:14, 148:16-17, 148:21-24, 149:2-3, 149:5-16, 149: 20-25, 150:5-17, 150:19-23, 151:6-8, 151:11-13, 151:15-18, 151:20-25 SEALED; all other designations UNSEALED. 231 Exhibit G Docket No. 231-20 at 72:1-23, Only sealed portions 73:1-25 SEALED; all other narrowly tailored to designations UNSEALED. confidential business information. 231 Exhibit H Docket No. 231-22 at 32:8-10, Only sealed portions 32:13-15, 32:18-25 SEALED; all narrowly tailored to other designations UNSEALED. confidential business information. 237 Plaintiff's Rule 30(b)(6) Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Motion black at Docket No. 237-3 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 237 Exhibit K Docket No. 237-10 at 109:1-25, Only sealed portions 110:2-19 SEALED; all other narrowly tailored to designations UNSEALED. confidential business information, according to Defendants' declaration in support filed with the court.14 237 Exhibit L Docket No. 237-12 at 51:2-52:9, Only sealed portions 100:1-4, 100:8-20, 102:7-13, narrowly tailored to 102:20-103:9, 103:19-22, confidential business 103:25, 108:15-109:25 information, SEALED; all other designations according to UNSEALED. Defendants' declaration in support filed with the court.15 237 Exhibit M Docket No. 237-14 at 23:10-20, Only sealed portions 24:1-21, 24:25-25:25, 50:1-53:25, narrowly tailored to 64:1-25, 67:1-25, 74:3-16, confidential business 75:3-14 SEALED; all other information. designations UNSEALED. 237 Exhibit N UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 238 Plaintiff's Motion to Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Compel and Preclude black on pages 7-10 at Docket narrowly tailored to No. 237-3 SEALED; all other confidential business designations UNSEALED. information. 238 Exhibit O UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 238 Exhibit P UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 238 Exhibit Q Docket No. 238-12 at 37:1-14:15, Only sealed portions 43:1-45:25, 54:3-25, narrowly tailored to 57:1-60:25, 67:9-25, 69:1-70:25, confidential business 262:2-263:25 SEALED; all other information. designations UNSEALED. 238 Exhibit R Docket No. 238-14 at 22:1-25, Only sealed portions 24:1-26:25, 27:12-25, 29:5-25, narrowly tailored to 38:1-25, 47:6-48:25, 52:9-25, confidential business 57:1-58:25, 59:6-25, 64:1-68:23, information. 69:9-25, 73:3-25 SEALED; all other designations UNSEALED. 238 Exhibit S Docket No. 238-16 at 89:7-9, Only sealed portions 89:20-90:25 SEALED; all other narrowly tailored to designations UNSEALED. confidential business information. 238 Exhibit T UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 238 Exhibit U UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 238 Exhibit V UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 238 Exhibit W UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 246 Defendants' Opposition to Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Plaintiff's Privilege Motion yellow at Docket No. 246-4 narrowly tailored to SEALED; Docket No. 246-4 at confidential business 8:19-28 SEALED; all other information. designations UNSEALED. 246 Exhibit 1 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 246 Exhibit 2 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 246 Exhibit 3 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 246 Exhibit 4 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 246 Exhibit 5 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 246-16 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 246 Exhibit 6 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 246-18 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 246 Exhibit 7 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 246 Exhibit 8 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 246 Exhibit 9 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 246-24 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 246 Exhibit 10 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 246 Exhibit 11 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 246 Kim Declaration at Docket Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions No. 246-43 yellow at Docket No. 246-43 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 247 Defendants' Opposition to Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Plaintiff's Rule 30(b)(6) yellow at Docket No. 247 narrowly tailored to Motion and Motion to SEALED; all other designations confidential business Compel UNSEALED. information. 247 Exhibit 2 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 247-5 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 247 Exhibit 4 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 247-8 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 247 Exhibit 5 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 247-10 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 247 Exhibit 7 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 247-13 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 247 Exhibit 8 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 247 Exhibit 9 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 247 Exhibit 10 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 247 Exhibit 11 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 247 Exhibit 12 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 247 Exhibit 15 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 247-31 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 247 Exhibit 16 Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions yellow at Docket No. 247-33 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 247 Exhibit 19 Docket No. 247-38 at ¶¶ 73, 85, Only sealed portions 87 and Ex. B SEALED; all other narrowly tailored to designations UNSEALED. confidential business information. 247 Exhibit 20 SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 252 Plaintiff's Reply in Support UNSEALED No declaration in of Plaintiff's Motion support filed with the Regarding Improper court as required by Privilege Claims Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). Defendants' Response refers to declarations not filed with the court.16 252 Exhibit A UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). Defendants' Response refers to declarations not filed with the court.17 252 Exhibit B UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). Defendants' Response refers to declarations not filed with the court.18 252 Exhibit C UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). Defendants' Response refers to declarations not filed with the court.19 253 Plaintiff's Reply in Support UNSEALED No declaration in of Plaintiff's Discovery support filed with the Motions court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). Defendants' Response refers to declarations not filed with the court.20 258 Defendants' Motion for Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Summary Judgment yellow on pages 7 n.7, 10:4-14, narrowly tailored to 10:24, 11:2-19, 13:9-10, 13:16-14:19 confidential business 15:2, 19:25, 20:5, 21, 26-30, information. 36:18-20, 38:4-7, 40:1-3 at Docket No. 258-3 SEALED; all other designations UNSEALED. 258 Sandfeld Declaration at UNSEALED No declaration in Docket No. 258-10 support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 258 Exhibit 1 to Platt Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Declaration yellow on pages 8, 100-143 at narrowly tailored to Docket No. 258-15 SEALED; all confidential business other designations UNSEALED. information. 258 Exhibit 2 to Platt Docket No. 258-17 at 15:2-10, Only sealed portions Declaration 18:24-19:15, 67:9-187:11 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 258 Exhibit 3 to Platt Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Declaration yellow at Docket No. 258-19 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 258 Exhibit 4 to Platt UNSEALED No declaration in Declaration support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 258 Exhibit 5 to Platt Docket No. 258-23 at 102:21-222:22 Only sealed portions Declaration SEALED; all other narrowly tailored to designations UNSEALED. confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 7 to Platt Docket No. 258-26 at 17:24-185:25 Only sealed portions Declaration SEALED; all other narrowly tailored to designations UNSEALED. confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 10 to Platt Docket No. 258-30 at 98:20-181:20 Only sealed portions Declaration SEALED; all other narrowly tailored to designations UNSEALED. confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 11 to Platt UNSEALED No declaration in Declaration support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 258 Exhibit 12 to Platt Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Declaration yellow at Docket No. 258-34 narrowly tailored to SEALED; all other designations confidential business UNSEALED. information. 258 Exhibit 13 to Platt Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Declaration yellow at Docket No. 258-36 narrowly tailored to SEALED; Docket No. 258-36 at confidential business 33:12-19, 40:12-25 SEALED; all information. other designations UNSEALED. 258 Exhibit 14 to Platt UNSEALED No declaration in Declaration support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 258 Exhibit 17 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 18 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 19 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 20 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 21 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 22 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 23 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 24 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 25 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 26 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 27 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 28 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 29 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 30 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 31 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 32 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 33 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 34 to Platt UNSEALED No declaration in Declaration support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 258 Exhibit 35 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 38 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 39 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 40 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 41 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 42 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 44 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 46 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 258 Exhibit 47 to Platt UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored Declaration to confidential business information. 259 Exhibit 48 to Platt Docket No. 259-1 at ¶¶ 2-7 Only sealed portions Declaration (portions relating to continuing narrowly tailored to obligations for equipment, confidential business payment and taxes) SEALED; information. all other designations UNSEALED. 259 Exhibit 49 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 259 Exhibit 50 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 259 Exhibit 51 to Platt SEALED Narrowly tailored to Declaration confidential business information. 259 Exhibit 52 to Platt UNSEALED No declaration in Declaration support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 259 Exhibit 53 to Platt UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored Declaration to confidential business information. 259 Exhibit 54 to Platt UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored Declaration to confidential business information. 259 Exhibit 58 to Platt Only specific dollar amounts Only sealed portions Declaration SEALED; all other designations narrowly tailored to UNSEALED. confidential business information. 259 Exhibit 59 to Platt UNSEALED No declaration in Declaration support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 259 Exhibit 63 to Platt UNSEALED Not narrowly tailored Declaration to confidential business information. 259 Exhibit 67 to Platt UNSEALED No declaration in Declaration support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 259 Exhibit 68 to Platt UNSEALED No declaration in Declaration support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 259 Exhibit 69 to Platt Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Declaration yellow on pages 92, 94, 95 and narrowly tailored to Tab 8 at Docket No. 259-33 confidential SEALED; all other designations information as UNSEALED. designated by Defendants; for the remainder, no declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 259 Exhibit 70 to Platt Docket No. 259-35 at ¶¶ 67, 74 Only sealed portions Declaration and associated footnotes narrowly tailored to SEALED; specific dollar confidential amounts and percentages in information. Docket No. 259-35 at ¶¶ 14-16, 56, 80, 84-85, 87-88, 90-91 and Exs. A-K SEALED; all other designations UNSEALED. 275 Corning's Opposition to Docket No. 275-3 at 27:17, Only sealed portions Defendants' Motion for 27:22-28:3, 28:5-8, 28:11, 28:15, narrowly tailored to Summary Judgment 28:17-22, 28:24-29:1, 29:14, confidential 29:18-19, 29:27-28, 32:21-22 information. SEALED; all other designations UNSEALED. 275 Exhibit B Docket No. 275-8 at 47:12-16, Only sealed portions 52:1-2, 55:1-57:2, 172:15-18, narrowly tailored to 173:21-24, 174:7-24, 175:3-20, confidential 176:3-178:13, 178:17-21, information. 182:12-183:25, 222:6-18, 223:4-15, 223:19-25 SEALED; all other designations UNSEALED. 275 Exhibit D Docket No. 275-11 at 8:5-8, Only sealed portions 25:25-29:9, 29:21-37:21, 38:9-39:16, narrowly tailored to 39:21-25, 40:4-20, 40:22-41;2, confidential 41:14-16, 42:4-8, 42:12-15, information. 42:24-43:1, 43:4-44:10, 46:6-22, 46:24-47:3, 48:5-17, 49:7-11, 49:21-23, 50:2-51:3, 51:12-24, 52:12-15 SEALED; all other designations UNSEALED. 275 Exhibit E UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit F SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 275 Exhibit G SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 275 Exhibit H SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 275 Exhibit I SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 275 Exhibit J SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 275 Exhibit K SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 275 Exhibit L SEALED Narrowly tailored to confidential business information. 275 Exhibit M Docket No. 275-32 at 7:16-40:23 Only sealed portions SEALED; Docket No. 275-33 at narrowly tailored to 41:1-72:17 SEALED; all other confidential designations UNSEALED. information. 275 Exhibit N UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit P Docket No. 275-38 at 16:4-7, Only sealed portions 16:12-17 SEALED; all other narrowly tailored to designations UNSEALED. confidential information. 275 Exhibit Q UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit R UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit S UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit T UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit U UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit V UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit W UNSEALED No declaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit X UNSEALED No delaration in support filed with the court as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). 275 Exhibit Y Docket No. 275-61 at ¶¶ 34-35, Only sealed portions 67, 74 and associated footnotes narrowly tailored to SEALED; specific dollar confidential amounts and percentages in information. Docket No. 275-61 at ¶¶ 14-16, 16, 56, 80, 84-85, 87-88, 90-91 SEALED; all other designations UNSEALED. 275 Defendants' Reply in Designations highlighted in Only sealed portions Support of Motion for yellow on pages 2:16 (second narrowly tailored to Summary Judgment designation), 3, 11, 13, 14:3-4 at confidential Docket No. 258-3 SEALED; all information. other designations UNSEALED.

SO ORDERED.

FootNotes


1. Kamakana v. City & County of Honolulu, 447 F.3d 1172, 1178 (9th Cir. 2006) (quoting Nixon v. Warner Commc'ns, Inc., 435 U.S. 589, 597 & n. 7 (1978)).
2. Id. (quoting Foltz v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 331 F.3d 1122, 1135 (9th Cir. 2003)).
3. Id. at 1178-79.
4. Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., 727 F.3d 1214, 1228-29 (Fed. Cir. 2013).
5. See id. at 1180.
6. Id. at 1179 (internal quotations and citations omitted).
7. Id.
8. Phillips ex rel. Estates of Byrd v. Gen. Motors Corp., 307 F.3d 1206, 1210-11 (9th Cir. 2002); see Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c).
9. Beckman Indus., Inc. v. Int'l Ins. Co., 966 F.2d 470, 476 (9th Cir. 1992).
10. See Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1179-80.
11. See Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(A) ("Reference to a stipulation or protective order that allows a party to designate certain documents as confidential is not sufficient to establish that a document, or portions thereof, are sealable.").
12. Civ. L.R. 79-5(b). In part, Civ. L.R. 79-5(d) requires the submitting party to attach a "proposed order that is narrowly tailored to seal only the sealable material" which "lists in table format each document or portion thereof that is sought to be sealed," Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(b), and an "unredacted version of the document" that indicates "by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version." Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(d).
13. Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1).
14. See Docket No. 240 at ¶ 5.
15. See Docket No. 240 at ¶ 5.
16. See Docket No. 257 at 2-4.
17. See Docket No. 257 at 2-4.
18. See Docket No. 257 at 2-4.
19. See Docket No. 257 at 2-4.
20. See Docket No. 257 at 4-5.
Source:  Leagle

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.
Ask a Question
Search for lawyers by practice areas.
Find a Lawyer