Filed: Aug. 25, 2015
Latest Update: Aug. 25, 2015
Summary: ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO SEAL CHARLES R. BREYER , District Judge . Now before the Court is Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s amended administrative motion to seal records in connection with its motions for summary judgment. In a series of initial motions, Wal-Mart sought to seal voluminous records that extended far beyond the "compelling reasons" standard that governs the sealing of documents in support of dispositive motions. See Order Re Administrative M
Summary: ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO SEAL CHARLES R. BREYER , District Judge . Now before the Court is Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s amended administrative motion to seal records in connection with its motions for summary judgment. In a series of initial motions, Wal-Mart sought to seal voluminous records that extended far beyond the "compelling reasons" standard that governs the sealing of documents in support of dispositive motions. See Order Re Administrative Mo..
More
ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO SEAL
CHARLES R. BREYER, District Judge.
Now before the Court is Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s amended administrative motion to seal records in connection with its motions for summary judgment. In a series of initial motions, Wal-Mart sought to seal voluminous records that extended far beyond the "compelling reasons" standard that governs the sealing of documents in support of dispositive motions. See Order Re Administrative Motions to Seal (dkt. 1129) (describing motions); Kamakana v. City and County of Honolulu, 447 F.3d 1172, 1177 (9th Cir. 2006) (describing legal standard). In response, the Court ordered Wal-Mart to reassess its initial motion and seek to seal only a narrowly tailored list of documents in compliance with the applicable standard. See Order Re Administrative Motions to Seal.
As stated in that Order, when a motion to seal is made in connection with dispositive motions, there is "a strong presumption in favor of access to court records." See Foltz v. State Farm Mutual Auto. Insurance Company, 331 F.3d 1122, 1135 (9th Cir. 2003). "When discovery material is filed with the court . . . its status changes. If the documents are not among those which have `traditionally been kept secret for important policy reasons,' then `the public policy reasons behind a presumption of access to judicial documents (judicial accountability, education about the judicial process etc.),' apply." Id. at 1134 (quoting Times Mirror Co. v. United States, 873 F.2d 1210, 1219 (9th Cir. 1989) and Phillips ex rel. Estates of Byrd v. General Motors Corp., 307 F.3d 1206, 1213 (9th Cir. 2002)). Thus, a party must have "compelling reasons" to justify sealing court records; examples of such justification exist "`when such court files might have become a vehicle for improper purposes,' such as the use of records to gratify private spite, promote public scandal, circulate libelous statements, or release trade secrets." Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1179 (quoting Nixon v. Warner Communications, 435 U.S. 589, 598 (1978)). "The mere fact that the production of records may lead to a litigant's embarrassment, incrimination, or exposure to further litigation will not, without more, compel the court to seal its records." Id. (citing Foltz, 331 F.3d at 1136).
The Court has carefully reviewed Wal-Mart's amended motion to seal in light of the Court's order that Wal-Mart narrowly tailor its requests to those that comply strictly with the "compelling reasons" standard. As detailed in the following tables, the Court finds that the material Wal-Mart identified is in large part sealable, with the exception of several items falling into two categories: 1) information related to the Plaintiffs; and 2) information relevant to the underlying issues of this suit. The items that may be sealed fall into three broad categories: 1) trade secrets; 2) non-party personal information; and 3) non-party employment information.
The Court hereby ORDERS the parties to file on the public record the items indicated in the tables below as non-sealable ("NS") within ten (10) days of the entry of this Order. All other items shall remain under seal.
EXHIBITS TO THE DECLARATION OF RACHEL S. BRASS IN SUPPORT OF WAL-MART STORES, INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT (Dkt. 1066)
No Name of Document Stated Reason Seal (S)/Not Seal (NS):
Reason
1 Brass Dec., Ex. 11: Redactions for S: Trade secret.
Feb. 17, 2015 Letter competitively sensitive
from Jenna Yott to information.
Christine Webber.
EXHIBITS TO THE DECLARATION OF MARK A. PERRY IN SUPPORT OF WAL-MART STORES, INC.'S REPLY MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (Dkt. 1121)
2 Perry Dec., Ex. 5: Redactions for S: Trade secret.
Deposition of Paula competitively sensitive
Vaccaro (pg. 40). information.
DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF WAL-MART STORES, INC.'S MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
3 Dec. of Ryan Redactions for S: Trade secret (2:8-9).
Puryear. competitively sensitive
information.
4 Dec. of Lisa Riley Redactions for S: Trade secret (5:26).
(pg. 5). competitively sensitive
information.
5 Exhibits to Dec. of Wal-Mart policy S: Trade secret (pages 6-9,
Lisa Riley reflecting maximum 12-16, 18, 20-22).
Riley Dec., Ex. K: pay ranges subject to
Field Non-Exempt protective order.
Associate Pay Plan
(Effective Sept. 11,
2010).
6 Exhibits to Dec. of
Michelle Medlin
a) Medlin Dec., Ex. a) Reflecting Global a) NS: Food safety audit
5: Aug. 2004 Global Food Safety Audit results.
Food Safety Audit. results.
b) Medlin Dec., Ex. b) Reflecting Global b) NS: This document may
6: Feb., Apr., May., Food Safety Audit have been incorrectly
June, July, & Sept. results. labeled. It is a Commitment
2004 Global Food Matrix detailing each store's
Safety Audits. rank and score in various
categories. Includes YTD
sales, but not trade secrets.
c) Medlin Dec. Ex.: c) Reflecting Global c) NS: Food safety audit
7: WMDukes- Food Safety Audit results.
000147-015- results.
9000036,
WMDukes-000147-
015-9000120 -
90000121.
7 Exhibits to the
Dec. of Brandyn
Zobel in Support
of Wal-Mart
Stores, Inc.'s
Reply
Memorandum in
Support of Its
Motions for
Summary
Judgment
a) Zobel Dec., Ex. a) Current Wal-Mart a) S: Trade secret.
B: Sam's Club 2011 policy subject to
Field Compensation protective order.
Changes.
b) Zobel Dec., Ex. b) Current Wal-Mart b) S: Trade secret.
C: Sam's Club 2007 policy subject to
Facility Exempt Pay protective order.
Plan.
PLAINTIFFS' EXHIBITS
8 Renick Dec., Ex. Redactions for S: Trade secret.
46: Feb. 17, 2015 competitively sensitive
Letter from Jenna information.
Yott to Christine
Webber (duplicate
of Brass Dec., Ex.
11).
EXHIBITS TO THE DECLARATION OF RACHEL S. BRASS IN SUPPORT OF WAL-MART STORES, INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT (Dkt. 1066)
1 Brass Dec., Ex. 1:
Deposition of betty
Dukes, Vol. 1
a) Page 217:19-20; a) Testimony re: non- a) S: Non-party information.
255:2-4 and 8; party employment
257:8 and 14. information redacted
for privacy.
b) Exhibits 1, 2, 10, b) Contact and non- b) S: Non-party information.
12, 16 and 21. party information
redacted for privacy
and/or under FRCP §
5.2.
2 Brass Dec., Ex. 5:
Deposition of
Kenneth S. Cagle
a) Page 3:17-18, a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party contact
and 21. information redacted information.
for privacy and/or
under FRCP § 5.2.
b) Pages 262:7-8 b) Testimony re: non- b) S: Names of non-parties
and 18-25; 265:11- party employment (262:6-7, and 18; 265:11;
12; 286:21; 287:1. information redacted 286:1; 287:1).
for privacy.
3 Brass Decl., Ex. 13: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacted information.
Profile of Arturo for privacy.
Mireles (Dkt. 1069-
45).
4 Brass Decl., Ex. Non-party personal S: Non-party contact
14: Deposition of information redacted information.
Arturo Mireless for privacy and under
(Dkt. 1069-46) FRCP § 5.2.
Page 4:12-13, and
15.
5 Brass Dcl., Ex. 15: Non-party employment S: Damages report re:
Expert Report of information redacted Plaintiff Dukes cause of
Denise Neumann for privacy. action. Only seal non-party
Martin. name on page 11 and the
numbers within the chart
from page 11 (as trade
secret). The chart itself
should not be redacted.
6 Brass Decl., Ex. 21: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Personnel File of information redacted information.
Carl Kirkland (Dkt. for privacy.
1069-48).
7 Brass Decl., Ex. 22: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Personnel File of information redacted information.
Isidro Francisco for privacy.
(Dkt. 1069-49).
8 Brass Dec., Ex. 26:
Deposition of
Christine
Kwapnoski, Vol. 1
a) Page 9:19-20. a) Contact information. a) S: Contact information.
b) Pages 296:16-20; b) Testimony re: non- b) S: Testimony re: non-
297:10-11; 297:15- party employment party employment
298:3; 298:8-22. information redacted information.
for privacy.
c) Exhibits 5, 23, c) Redacted for privacy c) S: Non-party information.
32, and 34. under FRCP § 5.2.
9 Brass Dec., Ex. 27: Testimony re: non- S: Non-party information.
Deposition of party employment
Christine information redacted
Kwapnoski, Vol. II for privacy.
Pages 57:4-5; 8-9,
and 23; 77:13.
10 Brass Dec., Ex. 29: Non-party information S: Non-party information.
Deposition of Alan redacted for privacy
Oshier and under FRCP § 5.2.
Page 4:8-9 and 11.
11 Brass Dec., Ex. 33: Non-party information S: Non-party information.
Deposition of Ben redacted for privacy
Dolan and under FRCP § 5.2.
Page 6:14-15, 20,
and 22.
12 Brass Dec., Ex. 34:
Deposition of Paula
Vaccaro
a) Page 7:16-17. a) Non-party information a) S: Non-party information.
redacted for privacy.
b) Pages 119:2-25; b) Testimony re: non-party b) S: Vaccaro deposition contains
122:10-11, 14, 16-17, and employment information pertinent information re: Kwapnoski
20-22; 123:1, 5, 20, and redacted for privacy. COA and general wage information
24; 124:1, 4, 9, 12, 17-18, re: certain promotions and positions
21, and 24; 125:10; 126:9- relative to Kwapnoski. Only names
11 and 15; 127:3, 10, and of non-parties and their employment
23-24; 128:2 and 7; information should be sealed
154:10 and 25; 155:15, 1 (119:24-25; 122:10-11, 14, 16-17,
and 231 156:4, 13, 16, and and 20-22; 123:1, 20 and 24; 124:1,
20-22; 157:5, 10, 13, 16 4, 9, 12, 17-18, 21, and 24; 126:10-
and 25; 158:5, 12, 19-23, 11, and 15; 127:3, 10, and 23-24;
and 25; 159:1-2, and 20; 128:2; 154:10, and 25; 155:15, and
160:1, 4, 8, 10, 12-14, 21, 23; 156:4, 13, 16, and 20-22; 157:5,
and 25; 161:1-2, 4, 10, 10, 13, 16, and 25; 158:5, 12, 19-23,
and 21; 162:2, 9, 12, 15- and 25; 159:1-2, and 20; 160:1, 4, 8,
17; 163:7-9 and 22-23; 10, 12-14, 21 and 25; 161:1-2, 4, 10,
164:2-3, 13, 18, and 22; and 21; 162:2, 9, 12, and 15-17;
165:3 and 12 163:7-9, and 22-23; 164:2-3, 13, 18,
and 22; 165:3).
13 Brass Dec., Ex. 35:
Deposition of
Phillip A. Goodwin
a) Page 4:4-5. a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party personal
information redacted information.
for privacy.
b) Pages 24:14-24. b) Testimony re: non- b) S: Testimony re: non-
party information party information.
redacted for privacy.
14 Brass Dec., Ex. 37: Contact information S: Contact information.
Associate History redacted for privacy.
Profile of Christine
Kwapnoski.
15 Brass Dec., Ex. 38: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
E-mail from Karen information redacted information.
Koons to Mary Beth for privacy.
Lewis.
16 Brass Dec., Ex. 43: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
PCA01355, information, information, contact
PCA01360, information relating to information, and personal
PCA01373-01375, a non-party minor, and information (including
PCA01439-01440, contact information family matters concerning
PCA01452-01455, redacted for privacy. non-party minor).
PCA01543-01544,
and PCA 01559-
01561.
17 Brass Dec., Ex. 44: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacted information.
Profile of Brian for privacy.
Lothamer (Dkt.
1069-65).
18 Brass Dec., Ex. 45: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile of Roy for privacy.
Matherly (Dkt.
1069-66).
19 Brass Dec., Ex. 46: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile of Michael for privacy.
Montgomery (Dkt.
1069-67).
20 Brass Dec., Ex. 47: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile of Alberto for privacy.
Padilla (Dkt. 1069-
68).
21 Brass Dec., Ex. 48: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile Joshua for privacy.
Reynold (Dkt.
1069-69).
22 Brass Dec., Ex. 49: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile of Bryce for privacy.
Sherman (Dkt.
1069-70).
23 Brass Dec., Ex. 50: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile of Chris for privacy.
Ward (Dkt. 1069-
72).
24 Brass Dec., Ex. 51: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile of Tyler for privacy.
Whitney (Dkt.
1069-72).
25 Brass Dec., Ex. 52: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile of Marc for privacy.
Arnold (Dkt. 1069-
73).
26 Brass Dec., Ex. 53: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Associate History information redacting information.
Profile of Paul for privacy.
Cortopassi (Dkt.
1069-74).
EXHIBITS TO THE DECLARATION OF MICHELE L. MARYOTT IN SUPPORT OF WAL-MART STORES, INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT (Dkt. 1071)
27 Maryott Dec., Ex.
1: Deposition of
Marvin Raps
a) Pages 3:11-12, a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party personal
14. information redacted information.
for privacy and under
FRCP § 5.2.
b) Pages 120:16-20. b) Testimony re: non- b) S: Testimony re: non-
party employment party employment
information redacted information.
for privacy.
28 Martyott Dec., Ex. Non-party personal S: Non-party personal
7: Deposition of information redacted information.
Tanya Ellis (Dkt. for privacy.
1071-21)
Page 2:10-11, and
13.
29 Maryott Dec., Ex. 8: Non-party employment S: Non-party personal
Personnel File of information redacted information.
Shaun Collins (Dkt. for privacy.
1071-22).
30 Maryott Dec., Ex. Non-party employment S: Non-party personal
12: Personnel File information redacted information.
of Baljinder for privacy.
Jawanda (Dkt.
1071-23).
31 Maryott Dec., Ex.
15: Deposition of
Bernard Seaman
a) Page 3:13-16, 18, a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party personal
and 20. information redacted information.
for privacy.
b) Page 111:3-4. b) Testimony re: non- b) S: Non-party employment
party employment information.
information redacted
for privacy.
c) Exhibit 3. c) Non-party c) S: Non-party employment
employment information.
information redacted
for privacy.
32 Maryott Dec., Ex.
16: Deposition of
David Riggs
a) Page 4:18-19, a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party personal
and 21. information redacted information.
for personal
information.
b) Pages 241:21- b) Testimony regarding b) S: Non-party employment
242:4. non-party employment information.
information redacted
for privacy.
33 Maryott Dec., Ex. Non-party personal S: Non-party personal
17: Deposition of information redacted information.
Varazat "John" for privacy and under
Kocharian FRCP § 5.2.
Pages 4:18-19, 22,
and 24.
34 Maryott Dec., Ex. Non-party personal S: Non-party personal
18: Deposition of information redacted information.
Judy Evans (Dkt. for privacy.
1071-28)
Page 4:9-10, and
20.
35 Maryott Dec., Ex.
19: Deposition of
Lori Schmidt
a) Pages 7:20 and a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party personal
22-23. information redacted information.
for privacy.
b) Exhibits 2 and 7. b) Non-party b) S: Typo in Motion -
employment should be Exhibits 6 and 7.
information redacted Non-party employment
for privacy. information.
36 Maryott Dec., Ex. Testimony re: non- S: Non-party employment
20: Deposition of party employment information.
Edith Arana II information redacted
(Dkt. 1070-30) for privacy.
Pages 69:3-6.
37 Maryott Dec., Ex. Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
21: Personnel File information redacted information.
of Edith Arana. for privacy.
38 Maryott Dec., Ex. Non-party personal S: Non-party personal
22: Deposition of information redacted information.
Mickey Anderson for privacy and under
Page 4:11-12, 14, FRCP § 5.2.
18, 23, and 25.
39 Maryott Dec., Ex. Testimony re: non- S: Non-party employment
24: Deposition of Party employment information.
Deborah Gunter information redacted
Pages 23:1-26:13; for privacy.
28:1-29:22; 34:7-
20; 116:21-117:2;
126:8-16; 162:9-18.
40 Maryott Dec., Ex. Non-party personal S: Non-party personal
26: Deposition of information redacted information.
Jacqueline for privacy.
Williams
Page 7:18 and 20-
21.
EXHIBITS TO THE DECLARATION OF MARK A. PERRY IN SUPPORT OF WAL-MART STORES, INC.'S REPLY MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (Dkt. 1121)
41 Perry Dec., Ex. 4:
Deposition of
Charles Salby
(Dkt. 1122-40)
a) Page 4:16-20. a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party personal
information redacted information.
for privacy and under
FRCP § 5.2.
b) Exhibit 1. b) Non-party personal b) S: Non-party employment
information redacted information.
for privacy and under
FRCP § 5.2.
42 Perry Dec., Ex. 5:
Deposition of
Paula Vaccaro
a) Page 7:16-17. a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party personal
information redacted information.
for privacy.
b) Pages 75-76, b) Non-party b) S: Non-party employment
218, and Exhibit 8. employment information; 75:1, and 11-
information redacted 12; 76:17, 20, and 22, 218
for privacy. and Exhibit 8.
43 Perry Dec., Ex. 7: Non-party employment S: Name of non-party.
Deposition of information redacted
Christine for privacy.
Kwapnoski
Page 156:12.
44 Perry Dec., Ex. 8: Non-party employment S: Damages report re:
Damages Report by information redacted Plaintiff Kwapnoski; wages
Kirk Marangi. for privacy. earned, comparative wages
per position, etc. Seal pay
rate amount (trade secret).
45 Perry Dec., Ex. 10: Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Personnel File of information redacted information.
Jon Salomone (Dkt. for privacy.
1122-44).
451 Perry Dec., Ex. 13:
Deposition of Peter
Danoff
a) Page 6:13-14. a) Non-party personal a) S: Non-party personal
information. information.
b) Pages 56:3, 6, b) Non-party b) Non-party employment
and 9; 99:1, 5, and employment information.
22-23; 103:2 and 6. information.
46 Perry Dec., Ex. 15: Non-party personal S: Non-party personal
Deposition of information redacted information.
Jacqueline for privacy.
Williams (Dkt.
1122-56)
Pages 7:8, 20-21.
DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF WAL-MART STORES, INC.'S MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
47 Declaration of Testimony relating to S: Non-party minor
Donald Taylor. non-party minor information.
redacted for privacy.
48 Exhibits to Declaration
of Tracy Englebrecht
a) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. a) Exhibit A: Non-party a) S: Non-party wage and
B: Mar. 12, 2015 Letter employment information. employment information.
from Jenna Yott to
Christine Webber.
b) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. b) Exhibit A: Non-party b) S: Non-party wage and
C: Mar. 17, 2015 Letter employment information. employment information.
from Jenna Yott to
Christine Webber.
c) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. c) Exhibit C: Non-party c) S: Non-party wage and
D: Mar. 17, 2015 Letter employment information. employment information.
from Jenna Yott to
Christine Webber.
d) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. d) Exhibits A-B: Non-party d) S: Non-party wage and
G: Mar. 10, 2015 Letter employment information. employment information.
from Jenna Yott to
Christine Webber.
e) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. e) Exhibit A: Non-party e) S: Non-party wage and
H: Mar. 5, 2015 Letter employment information. employment information.
from Jenna Yott to
Christine Webber.
f) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. f) Exhibit A: Non-party f) S: Non-party wage and
I: Mar. 19, 2015 Letter employment information. employment information.
from Jenna Yott to
Christine Webber.
49 Declaration of Non-party employment - NS: 2:17-18: Wage
Paula Vaccaro information redacted information for Plaintiff
Pages 2:17-18, 22- for privacy. Dukes.
23, and 25-26; 3:2- - S: 2:22-23, and 25-26:
5, 10, and 13; 4:27- Employment information of
5:2; 5:7-8. a non-party.
- S: 3:2-5: Non-party
employment information.
- NS: 3:10 and 13: Wage
and employment
information of Plaintiff
Dukes.
- S: 4:27-5:2: Wage
information of non-party.
-NS: 5:7-8: Wage
information of Plaintiff
Arana.
50 Exhibits to Non-party employment NS: (Dkt. 1068-27)
Declaration of information. Investigation as to Christine
Paual Vaccaro Kwapnoski. Document
Vaccaro Decl., Ex. should not be sealed in its
1: June 2012 entirety, but names of non-
Redbook parties should be sealed.
Investigation (ECF (Dkt. 1068-27): E-mails re:
Nos. 1068-27 and Kwapnoski. Seal contact
1068-28). information for non-parties.
51 Exhibits to
Declaration of
Michelle Medlin
a) Medlin Decl., Ex. a) Non-party a) S: Letter from non-party
1: WMDukes- employment re: Plaintiff Kwapnoski.
086012-009- information redacted Only seal signature.
000000311. for privacy.
b) Medlin Decl., Ex. b) Non-party b) S: Letter from non-party
2: WMDukes- employment re: Plaintiff Kwapnoski.
000147-014- information redacted Seal names of non-party
00000014- for privacy. individuals.
00000021.
c) Medlin Decl., Ex. c) Non-party personal c) S: Declaration re:
3: WMDukes- and employment statement made by Plaintiff
000147-012- information redacted Kwapnoski. Seal names
00000014- for privacy. non-party individuals.
00000015.
d) Medlin Decl., Ex. d) Non-party d) S: Investigation report re:
4: Isenburg Report employment Plaintiff Kwapnoski. Seal
(PCA02584- information redacted names/information of non-
PCA02599). for privacy. party individuals.
52 Declaration of Non-party employment S: Non-party employment
Brandyn Zobel in information redacted information.
Support of Wal- for privacy.
Mart Stores, Inc.'s
Reply
Memorandum in
Support of Its
Motions for
Summary
Judgment
Pages 5-6.
53 Exhibits to the Decl, of
Brandyn Zobel in
Support of Wal-Mart's
Reply Memorandum in
Support of its Mot. for
Summary Judgment
a) Zobel Dec., Ex. A: a) Non-party employment a) S: Non-party employment
March 17, 2015 Letter information redacted for information.
from Jenna Yott to privacy.
Christine Webber, Ex. B.
b) Zobel Dc., Ex. D: b) Non-party employment b) S: Non-party employment
March 9, 2015 Letter from information redacted for information.
Jenna Yott to Christine privacy.
Webber, Exhibits B & D
(excerpts).
c) Zobel Dec., Ex. E:
Associate History Profile c) Non-party employment c) S: Non-party employment
of William Biggs. information. information.
d) Zobel Dec., Ex. F:
Associate History Profile d) Non-party employment d) S: Non-party employment
of Shawn Hill. information. information.
e) Zobel Dec., Ex. G:
Associate History Profile e) Non-party employment e) S: Non-party employment
of Dwayne Givens. information. information.
f) Zobel Dec., Ex. H:
Associate History profile f) Non-party employment f) S: Non-party employment
of Arthur French. information. information.
g) Zobel Dec., Ex. I: g) Non-party employment g) S: Non-party employment
Associate History Profile information. information.
of Ian Holm.
h) Zobel Dec., Ex. J: h) Non-party employment h) S: Non-party employment
Associate History Profile information. information.
of Bruce Dreier.
i) Zobel Dec., Ex. K: i) Non-party employment i) S: Non-party employment
Associate History Profile information. information.
of Chad Penn.
j) Zobel Dec., Ex. L: j) Non-party employment j) S: Non-party employment
Associate History Profile information. information.
of Ronald Olguin.
k) Zobel Dec., Ex. M: k) Non-party employment k) S: Non-party employment
Associate History Profile information. information.
of Frederic Frost.
l) Zobel Dec., Ex. N: l) Non-party employment l) S: Non-party employment
Associate History Profile information. information.
of Zechariah Meyer.
BRIEFS
54 Wal-Mart Stores, Non-party employment S: Only non-party names
Inc.'s Notice of information redacted and information should be
Motion and Motion for privacy. sealed (4:6-9; 24:4).
for Partial Summary
Judgment Against
Plaintiff Betty
Dukes on her
Second and Third
Claims for Relief;
Memorandum of
Points and
Authorities in
Support Thereof.
55 Wal-Mart Stores, Non-party employment S: Only non-party names
Inc.'s Notice of information redacted and information should be
Motion and Motion for privacy. sealed (10:8-9).
for Partial Summary
Judgment Against
Plaintiff Christine
Kwapnoski on her
Second Claim for
Relief;
Memorandum of
Points and
Authorities in
Support Thereof.
56 Wal-Mart Stores, Non-party employment S: Only non-party names
Inc.'s Notice of information redacted and information should be
Motion and Motion for privacy. sealed.
for Partial Summary
Judgment Against
Plaintiffs Patricia
Surgeson, Edith
Arana, and Deborah
Gunter on their
Second Claim for
Relief;
Memorandum of
Points and
Authorities in
Support Thereof.
57 Wal-Mart Stores, Non-party employment S: Only non-party names
Inc.'s Reply in information redacted and information should be
Support of Motion for privacy. sealed (17:14-18).
for Partial Summary
Judgment Against
Plaintiff Betty
Dukes.
58 Wal-Mart Stores, Non-party employment S: Only non-party names
Inc.'s Reply in information redacted and information should be
Support of Motion for privacy. sealed (15:2-21).
for Partial Summary
Judgment Against
Plaintiff Christine
Kwapnoski.
59 Wal-Mart Stores, Non-party employment S: Only non-party names
Inc.'s Reply in information redacted and information should be
Support of Motion for privacy. sealed (15:28-16:5-7; 30:6-
for Partial Summary 7).
Judgment Against
Plaintiffs Patricia
Surgeson, Edith
Arana, and Deborah
Gunter.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
