Elawyers Elawyers
Washington| Change

OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER, DIVISION OF SECURITIES AND INVESTOR PROTECTION vs K. D. TRINH INVESTMENT, INC.; HANDR FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC.; AND STRONG FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC., 95-002411 (1995)

Court: Division of Administrative Hearings, Florida Number: 95-002411 Visitors: 19
Petitioner: OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER, DIVISION OF SECURITIES AND INVESTOR PROTECTION
Respondent: K. D. TRINH INVESTMENT, INC.; HANDR FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC.; AND STRONG FINANCIAL SERVICES, INC.
Judges: ROBERT E. MEALE
Agency: Department of Financial Services
Locations: Port Charlotte, Florida
Filed: May 09, 1995
Status: Closed
Recommended Order on Wednesday, June 4, 1997.

Latest Update: Jan. 16, 1998
Summary: The issues are whether Respondents K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc., Strong Financial Services, Inc., and Loren Reynolds sold unregistered securities in Florida, in violation of Sections 517.07 and 517.12, Florida Statutes, and engaged in fraudulent transactions with concealment and falsification of facts, in violation of Section 517.301(1)(a), Florida Statutes. If so, an additional issue is what penalty should be imposed.Cease and desist order was issued for unregistered dealers selling unregister
More
95-2411

STATE OF FLORIDA

DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS


DEPARTMENT OF BANKING AND ) FINANCE, DIVISION OF )

SECURITIES AND INVESTOR )

PROTECTION, )

)

Petitioner, )

)

vs. ) CASE NO. 95-2411

)

K. D. TRINH INVESTMENTS, ) INC., et al., )

)

Respondents. )

)


RECOMMENDED ORDER


Robert E. Meale, Administrative Law Judge of the Division of Administrative Hearings, conducted the final hearing in Port Charlotte, Florida, on March 24, 1997.

APPEARANCES


For Petitioner: Susan Steinberg Sandler

Assistant General Counsel Office of Comptroller

West Central Florida Regional Office 1313 Tampa Street, Suite 615

Tampa, Florida 33602-3394 For Respondents: no appearance

STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES

The issues are whether Respondents K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc., Strong Financial Services, Inc., and Loren Reynolds sold unregistered securities in Florida, in violation of Sections

517.07 and 517.12, Florida Statutes, and engaged in fraudulent transactions with concealment and falsification of facts, in

violation of Section 517.301(1)(a), Florida Statutes. If so, an additional issue is what penalty should be imposed.

PRELIMINARY STATEMENT


On March 24, 1995, Petitioner filed an Immediate Final Order to Cease and Desist and Notice of Rights and Administrative Complaint to Enter a Cease and Desist Order, Imposing Penalties and Notice of Rights against several Respondents.

In the undated Administrative Complaint to Enter Cease and Desist Order, Imposing Penalties and Notice of Rights, Petitioner alleged that Respondent K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc., a Canadian company, financed its business by selling unregistered securities in the form of short-term interest-bearing notes due at the earlier of 90 days after demand or nine months from the date of the loan and paying a return of 16 points over the prime rate in effect at the time of the loan.

The Administrative Complaint alleges that Respondent Strong Financial Services, Inc. and its principal, Respondent Loren Reynolds, were never registered with the Division of Securities and Investor Protection pursuant to Chapter 517, Florida Statutes. The Administrative Complaint alleges that Respondent Loren Reynolds sold the above-described notes to Florida investors in the State of Florida. The Administrative Complaint does not allege whether Respondent Loren Reynolds did so in the course of his employment with Respondent Strong Financial Services, Inc.

The Administrative Complaint alleges that, on March 14, 1986, Respondent Alexander Legault, the president of Respondent

K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc., was indicted in federal court in New Orleans for conspiracy, wire fraud, and mail fraud and was undergoing deportation from Canada as a result of his apprehension following the issuance of a traffic citation against him in March 1993.

The Administrative Complaint alleges that Respondents K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc. and Loren Reynolds failed to inform investors, including Robert F. Thomson and Thomas P. Hall, that Legault was under indictment for fraud and had fled to Canada to avoid prosecution. In mid-1994, Mr. Thomson and Mr. Hall allegedly invested $25,000 and $30,000 respectively in the above- described notes, although not through Respondent Strong Financial Services, Inc. or Loren Reynolds. As to these Respondents, the Administrative Complaint alleges only that Respondent Loren Reynolds did not inform Mr. Hall of the indictment of Respondent Alexander Legault.

Count I of the Administrative Complaint alleges that all of the Respondents are guilty of selling or offering to sell unregistered and unlicensed securities in Florida to Florida investors, in violation of Sections 517.161 and 517.221. Count II alleges that all of the Respondents are guilty of violations of Sections 517.07 and 517.12 due to the failure of Respondent K.

D. Trinh Investments, Inc. to register its securities. Count III

alleges that all of the Respondents made material omissions to investors by failing to disclose the indictment of Respondent Alexander Legault, thus violating Section 517.301(1)(a) concerning fraudulent transactions and falsification and concealment of facts.

The Administrative Complaint seeks an order requiring each Respondent to cease and desist its violations, imposing fines of not more than $5000 per violation, and revoking or suspending all licenses held by Respondents under Section 517.161.

Petitioner entered a default order against two Respondents, Bernard Wendt and Alexander Legault. The remaining Respondents demanded a formal hearing.

On August 23, 1995, Petitioner filed an Amended Administrative Complaint. The Amended Administrative Complaint alleges that, since early 1995, Respondent Strong Financial Services, Inc. has been the sole owner of Respondent K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc. and that Respondent Loren Reynolds, acting personally and as an agent of Respondent Strong Financial Services, Inc., has been receiving investors’ money and depositing it into a bank account entitled, “Strong Financial Services, Inc. Controller of K. D. Trinh Investment’s [sic].”

The Amended Administrative Complaint alleges that Respondent Reynolds, in his personal and representative capacities, has removed the investor money from the bank account and spent it on personal items, such as jewelry, college, stereo equipment, and

other personal items. The Amended Administrative Complaint alleges that Respondent Reynolds used Respondent Strong Financial Services, Inc. as a conduit in the sale and offer of sale of unregistered securities.

The case was abated at the request of all the parties, except Respondent Michael DeMots, for over one year pending completion of a criminal investigation by the Office of the Statewide Prosecution. Prior to the final hearing, Petitioner settled its claims against all of the remaining Respondents except Respondents K. C. Trinh Investments, Inc., Strong Financial Services, Inc., and Loren Reynolds.

At the hearing, Petitioner announced that it was seeking only a cease and desist order against the remaining three Respondents.

Petitioner called five witnesses and offered into evidence


15 exhibits, which were all admitted. Respondents did not appear.

The court reporter filed the transcript on April 21, 1997. Petitioner filed a proposed recommended order on April 30, 1997

FINDINGS OF FACT


  1. Respondent K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc. (Trinh) has never been registered with the Division of Securities and Investor Protection (Division) as a dealer or investment advisor and its securities have never been registered with the Division pursuant to Chapter 517, Florida Statutes.

  2. Neither Respondent Strong Financial Services, Inc. (Strong) nor Respondent Loren Reynolds (Reynolds) has ever been registered with the Division as a dealer or investment advisor.

  3. Respondent Alexander Legault (Legault) was the president and general manager of Trinh at all material times.

  4. On March 14, 1986, a grand jury in the Eastern District of Louisiana, United States District Court, returned an indictment against Legault for wire fraud, mail fraud, and conspiracy to commit wire and mail fraud. The indictment alleges that Legault attempted to defraud several institutions in connection with a food brokerage scheme.

  5. The investments in the present case also involve food brokerage operations, according to the information supplied potential investors.

  6. In March 1994, Charles Mortimer of Lake Mary, Florida, attended a seminar in Leesburg, Florida, devoted to three investment opportunities. Mr. Mortimer learned of the seminar through mail flyers or newspaper announcements.

  7. Mr. Mortimer expressed interest at the seminar in a cremation society and the Trinh notes. Reynolds appeared at the seminar and presented these investment opportunities.

  8. The next month, Mr. Mortimer met Reynolds in Lady Lake, Florida, and Reynolds sold Mr. Mortimer one of the Trinh notes. Mr. Mortimer thereafter purchased through Reynolds several more notes for a total investment of $55,000.

  9. At no time prior to making these investments did Reynolds disclose to Mr. Mortimer that Legault was under indictment in New Orleans for criminal fraud and was avoiding prosecution in Canada. Mr. Mortimer would not have invested in the Trinh notes had he known this material fact.

  10. However, the record does not indicate whether Reynolds knew that Legault was under indictment or had escaped to Canada. Nor does the record reveal sufficient background information to support the finding that Reynolds reasonably should have known this fact.

  11. Mr. Mortimer received a total of $600 on this investment. He has lost the remaining $54,400.

  12. Earl Wilson learned of Trinh through Reynolds, who was Mr. Wilson’s tax advisor in 1994 and had been since 1986. Reynolds recommended that Mr. Wilson and his wife should invest a recent inheritance in Trinh notes.

  13. Between his initial investment in 1994 and his final investment on April 25, 1995, Mr. Wilson and his wife invested a little over $200,000 in Trinh notes. They lost the entire investment.

  14. William Dinges first learned of Trinh at a seminar that he attended in 1993. He purchased a $140,000 note in 1995. He lost his entire investment.

    CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

  15. The Division of Administrative Hearings has jurisdiction over the subject matter. Section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes. (All references to Sections are to Florida Statutes.)

  16. Section 517.021(6)(a)1 defines a “dealer” as a person “who engages . . . as a broker or principal in business of offering, . . . selling, or otherwise dealing . . . in securities issued by another person.”

  17. Section 517.021(6)(a)2 defines a “dealer” as any “issuer who through persons directly compensated or controlled by the issuer engages . . . in the business of offering or selling securities which are or are proposed to be issued by the issuer.”

  18. Section 517.021(17)(a) defines a “security” as a “note.”

  19. Section 517.07 prohibits the sale or offer for sale in Florida of unregistered securities.

  20. Section 517.12(1) prohibits an unregistered dealer or unregistered issuer from selling or offering for sale any securities in Florida.

  21. Section 517.221(1) authorizes Petitioner to issue a cease and desist order when a person is violating or has violated any provision of Chapter 517.

  22. Section 517.301(1)(a) prohibits, in the sale or offer for sale of securities, any person to use a device or scheme to defraud, obtain money through an omission to disclose a material

    fact, or engage in a transaction that works a fraud upon a person.

  23. Petitioner must prove the material allegations by clear and convincing evidence. Department of Banking and Finance v. Osborne Stern and Company, Inc., 670 So. 2d 932 (Fla. 1996) and Ferris v. Turlington, 510 So. 2d 292 (Fla. 1987).

  24. Petitioner has proved that the Trinh notes are securities; that Trinh, Strong, and Reynolds were unregistered at the time of the sale or offer of sale of the Trinh notes; and that the Trinh notes were unregistered at the time of the sale or offer of sale.

  25. Petitioner has proved that Reynolds sold and offered for sale the Trinh notes in Florida to Florida residents.

  26. Petitioner has proved that Trinh sold and offered for sale the Trinh notes in Florida to Florida residents.

  27. Petitioner has proved that Reynolds was a dealer in selling and offering for sale the Trinh notes in Florida to Florida residents.

  28. Petitioner has proved that Trinh was a dealer in the sale and offer for sale of the Trinh notes.

  29. Petitioner has not proved the relationship between Strong and either Reynolds or Trinh. Petitioner has not proved that Reynolds was a representative of Strong and, if so, whether he was serving in that capacity while selling and offering for sale the Trinh notes. The evidence does not describe the

    involvement, if any, of Strong to the scheme operated by Trinh and Reynolds.

  30. Petitioner has proved that Trinh fraudulently failed to disclose a material fact to Mr. Mortimer. However, Petitioner has not proved that Reynolds or Strong knew or should have known of Legault’s indictment, so the evidence fails to show that they concealed a material fact.

RECOMMENDATION


It is


RECOMMENDED that the Department of Banking and Finance enter a final order ordering Respondents K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc. and Loren Reynolds to cease and desist from any further violations of Chapter 517 and dismissing the amended administrative complaint against Respondent Strong Financial Services, Inc.

ENTERED in Tallahassee, Florida, on June 4, 1997.


ROBERT E. MEALE

Administrative Law Judge

Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building

1230 Apalachee Parkway

Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060

(904) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675

Fax Filing (904) 921-6847


Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings on June 4, 1997.


COPIES FURNISHED:


Susan Steinberg Sandler Assistant General Counsel Office of Comptroller

West Central Florida Regional Office 1313 Tampa Street, Suite 615

Tampa, Florida 33602-3394


K. D. Trinh Investments, Inc. 1194 Hanna Street East Windsor, Ontario

Canada N8X2P4


Loren Reynolds

Strong Financial Services, Inc.

241 B Ridgewood Avenue Holly Hill, Florida 32117


Harry Hooper General Counsel

Department of Banking and Finance Room 1302, The Capitol Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0500


NOTICE OF RIGHT TO SUBMIT EXCEPTIONS


All parties have the right to submit written exceptions within 15 days from the date of this recommended order. Any exceptions to this recommended order must be filed with the agency that will issue the final order in this case.


Docket for Case No: 95-002411
Issue Date Proceedings
Jan. 16, 1998 Case files returned to the agency sent out.
Sep. 08, 1997 Final Order filed.
Jul. 03, 1997 Final Order filed.
Jun. 19, 1997 (Department) Exceptions to Recommended Order (filed via facsimile).
Jun. 04, 1997 Recommended Order sent out. CASE CLOSED. Hearing held 03/24/97.
May 05, 1997 Letter to REM from K, Sullivan Re: Enclosing replacement page of transcript filed.
Apr. 30, 1997 Petitioner`s Proposed Recommended Order filed.
Apr. 21, 1997 Transcript of Proceedings filed.
Mar. 31, 1997 (Petitioner) Exhibits 1 through 15 filed.
Mar. 24, 1997 CASE STATUS: Hearing Held.
Mar. 21, 1997 Joint Motion for Order Relinquishing Jurisdiction As to George J. Hearmann and H&R Financial Services, Inc.; (Petitioner) Motion for Order Relinquishing Jurisdiction as to Nancy Matalik (filed via facsimile).
Mar. 20, 1997 Department`s Request for Official Recognition filed.
Mar. 14, 1997 Joint Motion for Order Relinquishing Jurisdiction as to Michael Demots filed.
Mar. 03, 1997 (Clyde Caillouet) Notice of Appearance filed.
Dec. 20, 1996 Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for 3/24/97; 12:00 p.m.; Punta Gorda) (Note: Continue through 3/28/97)
Dec. 18, 1996 (Signed by W. Bubsey & W. Moody) Amended Certificate of Service filed.
Dec. 16, 1996 Joint Case Status Report filed.
Dec. 16, 1996 Joint Case Status Report filed.
Dec. 13, 1996 (From W. Bubsey, W. Moody) Motion to Withdraw as Counsel filed.
Dec. 11, 1996 Joint Case Status Report (filed via facsimile).
Sep. 25, 1996 Order of Abatement sent out. (Parties to file status report by 12/16/96)
Sep. 23, 1996 Joint Case Status Report filed.
Sep. 18, 1996 Order of Abatement sent out. (Parties to file status report by 11/15/96)
Sep. 16, 1996 Joint Case Status Report (filed via facsimile).
Jun. 18, 1996 Order of Abatement sent out. (Parties to file status report by 9/16/96)
Mar. 05, 1996 Order of Abatement sent out. (Parties to file status report by 6/17/96)
Mar. 04, 1996 (Petitioner) Motion for Reconsideration filed.
Mar. 01, 1996 Order of Continuance sent out. (hearing cancelled until further notice)
Mar. 01, 1996 (Petitioner) Motion to Abate filed.
Feb. 29, 1996 (Petitioner) Motion for Reconsideration filed.
Feb. 26, 1996 Order sent out. (Petitioner`s motion to abate is denied)
Dec. 19, 1995 Amended Notice of Hearing (as to location only) sent out. (hearing set for March 4-8, 1996; 10:00am; Punta Gorda)
Nov. 15, 1995 Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for March 4-8, 1996; 10:00am; Port Charlotte)
Nov. 15, 1995 (Petitioner) Joint Case Status Report filed.
Nov. 14, 1995 (Petitioner) Joint Case Status Report filed.
Sep. 28, 1995 Notice of Withdrawal and Notice of Appearance (from David Griem) filed.
Sep. 27, 1995 Order of Abatement sent out. (Parties to file status report by 11/15/95)
Sep. 27, 1995 Order Publishing Ex Parte Communication sent out.
Sep. 26, 1995 Department`s and Respondent`s Joint Motion to Continue filed.
Sep. 12, 1995 K. D. Trinth Investments, Inc`s Response to Petitioner`s First Set of Request for Admissions filed.
Aug. 28, 1995 Order Denying Motion to Stay Discovery sent out.
Aug. 23, 1995 (Petitioner) Amended Administrative Complaint to Enter Cease and Desist Order, Imposing Penalties and Notice of Rights filed.
Aug. 22, 1995 (Respondent) Motion to Stay Discovery filed.
Aug. 09, 1995 Prehearing Order sent out.
Aug. 08, 1995 Order On Pending Motions sent out. (Motion to Dismiss of Respondent strong financial services is granted)
Jul. 31, 1995 (Respondents) Motion of Enlargement of Time Within Which to Respond to Department's First Set of Request for Admissions; Notice of Appearance filed.
Jul. 20, 1995 Petitioner`s First Request to Produce; Department`s Response In Opposition to Respondent`s Objections to Petitioner`s First Request for Admissions; Department`s Response In Opposition to Respondent`s Answers and Objections to Petitioner`s First Request fo
Jul. 18, 1995 Department`s Response in Opposition to Respondent`s Motion to Dismiss and Answers to and Objection to Petitioner`s First Request for Admissions and Motion for Protective Order filed.
Jul. 12, 1995 (K.D. Trinh) Answers And Objections to Petitioner's First Request forAdmissions And Motion for Protective Order; Respondents Objection to Petitioner's First Request for Admissions; (SFI) Motion to Dismiss AndAnswers to And Object ion to Petitioner's Firs
Jul. 10, 1995 (5) Department's First Set of Requests for Admission filed.
Jun. 22, 1995 (2) Department`s First Set of Requests for Admissions filed.
May 26, 1995 Notice of Hearing sent out. (hearing set for October 23-27, 1995; 10:30am; Port Charlotte)
May 24, 1995 (Petitioner) Response to Initial Order filed.
May 16, 1995 Initial Order issued.
May 09, 1995 Agency Referral Letter; Special Appearance and Request for Formal Evidentiary Hearing; Petition for Hearing; Administrative Complaint to Enter Cease and Desist Order, Imposing Penalties and Notice of Rights filed.

Orders for Case No: 95-002411
Issue Date Document Summary
Jul. 02, 1997 Agency Final Order
Jun. 04, 1997 Recommended Order Cease and desist order was issued for unregistered dealers selling unregistered securities and for issuer engaging in fraudulent nondisclosure.
Source:  Florida - Division of Administrative Hearings

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.
Ask a Question
Search for lawyers by practice areas.
Find a Lawyer