1948 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 218">*218
Income -- Estate --
10 T.C. 631">*632 OPINION.
The Commissioner determined a deficiency of $ 13,099.04 in income tax of the estate of this decedent for the calendar year 1944. The facts have been submitted by agreement of the parties.
The decedent died on November 4, 1943, and the petitioner is his estate. The return for the estate for 1944 was filed with the collector of internal revenue for the third district of New York.
The decedent was employed, for many years and up to his death, by American Cyanamid Co. That company had had a bonus plan in which the decedent had participated for a number of years. No employee had any enforceable right to any allotment for the current year under the plan until his share was designated by the proper officer. No share of the bonus for 1943 was designated for the decedent until March 14, 1944, several months after his death. It amounted to $ 28,143.651948 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 218">*220 and was paid to his estate on March 16, 1944. The estate did not report that amount as income on its return for 1944, but the Commissioner added it to income in determining the deficiency for that year. He explained that it was a salary bonus of the decedent for 1943 services which the estate should have reported when received in 1944, since it was income under sections 22 (a) and 126 (a).
The first issue for decision is whether the $ 28,143.65 was income of the estate for 1944.
The petitioner's argument misconceives the purpose and effect of the statute. The decedent need not have had a legally enforceable right to the amount at the time of his death. Prior revenue laws had packed the uncollected remnants of each decedent's income into 10 T.C. 631">*633 his final taxable period as if received by him during his life. Congress felt that:
* * * While such income should be subject to income tax, hardship results in many cases from including in the income for the decedent's last taxable period amounts which ordinarily would be receivable over a period of several years. This
* * * *
All amounts of gross income which are not includible in the income of the decedent will, when received, be includible in the income of the person receiving such amounts by inheritance or survivorship from the decedent under
Congress endeavored to put the recipient, here his estate, in the exact place of the decedent in all respects with reference to the taxability of such income. Congress meant that no income earned by the decedent should escape income tax and meant to tax to the estate amounts of such income received by it after the death of the decedent where the estate "[acquired] the right to such amounts by reason of the death of the decedent." 1948 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 218">*223 Finance Committee Report,
The petitioner included an amount in the gross estate for estate tax purposes representing the bonus considered in the first issue. The respondent makes no argument against the petitioner's alternative contention that a credit under