1957 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 105">*105
Alimony v. Child Maintenance --
28 T.C. 1131">*1131 OPINION.
The Commissioner determined deficiencies in income tax as follows:
Year | Amount |
1949 | $ 147.90 |
1950 | 147.84 |
1951 | 261.00 |
1952 | 140.59 |
The only issue for decision is whether the Commissioner erred in including an amount representing alimony in the petitioner's income for each year. The parties have filed a stipulation of facts which is adopted as the findings of fact.
The petitioner filed her individual income tax returns for the taxable years with the collector of internal revenue for the district of Kentucky.
The petitioner was divorced from Thomas Hummel on April 5, 1947, in the Campbell Circuit Court, Campbell County, Kentucky. She was awarded1957 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 105">*106 custody of the one child of the marriage, Christine Hummel, who was then 2 years of age. The petitioner and Thomas Hummel entered into an agreement which was incorporated in the decree of divorce. The agreement contained,
The Commissioner, in determining the deficiencies, added to the petitioner's reported income $ 1,420 for 1949, $ 1,430 for 1950 and and 1951, and $ 550 and 1952, as alimony. He explained that those amounts, which she had received from her divorced husband under the divorce decree of April 5, 1947, were includible in her gross income under
The Commissioner relies upon decisions of this Court holding that the entire amount of payments received by a wife from her divorced husband are taxable to the wife irrespective of how the money was used or expended, if no specific part or amount of the total payments was fixed or designated under the decree of the agreement as payable to the wife for the support of a child.
The petitioner contends that all, or at least some part, of the periodic payments should be recognized as paid for the support of the child, particularly since she spent more than the amount of the payments for the support and maintenance of the child. A similar situation existed in the
The petitioner also points to the stipulated facts showing that the master1957 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 105">*108 commissioner of the Campbell Circuit Court made a recommendation on December 12, 1952, that Frances Hummel "be awarded maintenance for the support of the infant child herein in the sum of Twenty-Two and 50/100 ($ 22.50) Dollars per week until further order of the Court." That recommendation was confirmed by the judge of the court on March 9, 1953. The recommendation was made as a result of the request by Frances for an increase in the allowance for the maintenance of the child and a motion by Thomas to terminate all of the alimony requirements to be paid to Frances as of May 13, 1952, and to reduce the amount to be paid for the maintenance of the child to $ 15 a week. The recommendation and the confirmation which occurred later were in no way retroactive, corrected no error, and are of no significance in the decision of the present case. Cf.
The Commissioner conceded another issue.