wiki errata to copyrighted text
A Physics text I'm studying is full of typographical errors, and errors of analysis. I propose to put up a wiki
for readers of the book to accumulate an errata. I've emailed the publisher proposing it, and gotten a vague reply.
I argue that putting up a wiki commenting in detail on the text is equivalent to quoting and criticizing
the text in a student term paper or thesis, which is allowable.
The wiki would not make a profit, or show advertising, or have any other commercial aspect.
The contents would be covered
under GNU or copyleft.
Is this legal under the copyright laws? Could the publisher object?
The publisher can incorporate the corrections into the next edition of the text without objection. It seems
to be in their interest.
The community of students benefits from having a good errata for an
uneven, but necessary, text.
Your thoughts/