The Issue Whether Respondent committed the violations alleged in the Administrative Complaint. If so, what disciplinary action should be taken against her.
Findings Of Fact Based upon the evidence adduced at hearing and the record as a whole, the following Findings of Fact are made: Respondent held Florida teacher's certificate number 681506, covering the areas of Pre-K through Grade 3, which was valid until June 30, 1995. On or about November 4, 1986, Respondent was charged with battery by information filed in Dade County Court Case No. 86-79409. On December 29, 1986, following a non-jury trial, Respondent was found guilty as charged. Adjudication of guilt was withheld and Respondent was ordered to pay $77.00 in court costs. In 1990, Respondent submitted an Application for Florida Educator's Certificate to the Bureau of Teacher Certification of the Department of Education (Bureau). On the application, she checked "no" in response to the following question: Have you ever been convicted of a crime, found guilty, or entered a plea of nolo contendre (no contest) even if adjudication was withheld? Your answer to this question will be checked against local, state and federal records. Failure to answer this question accurately could cause denial of certification. Please Check One: Yes No If yes, you must give complete details for each charge. As Respondent was aware, her negative response to this question was untrue inasmuch as, in 1986, she had been found guilty of the crime of battery in Dade County Court Case No. 86-79409. In 1992, Respondent submitted another Application for Florida Educator's Certificate to the Bureau. On the application, knowing that her response was false, she answered "no" in response to the following question: Yes No Have you ever been convicted, found guilty, or entered a plea of nolo contendre (no contest) to a crime other than a traffic violation? A YES or NO answer is required by Florida Law. If you check the YES box, you must give the information requested for each charge In 1993, Respondent submitted a third Application for Florida Educator's Certificate to the Bureau. On the application, she knowingly gave false information by checking "no" in response to the following question: Yes No Have you ever been convicted, found guilty, entered a plea of nolo contendre (no contest), or had adjudication withheld in a criminal offense other than a minor traffic violation (DUI is NOT a minor traffic violation); or are there any criminal charges now pending against you? SEALED or EXPUNGED records must be reported pursuant to s.943.058, F.S. Failure to answer this question accurately could cause denial of certification. A YES or NO answer is required by Florida Law. If you check the YES box, you must give the information requested for each charge. On February 7, 1994, while working as a teacher at Golden Glades Elementary School, a public school located in Dade County, Respondent was involved in an altercation with a student, C.K., in the doorway to Respondent's classroom.2
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Commission issue a final order: (1) finding Respondent guilty of the violations of subsection (1) of Section 231.28, Florida Statutes, alleged in the Administrative Complaint, as amended, concerning her falsification of the 1990, 1992, and 1993 certification applications she submitted to the Bureau; (2) barring Respondent from applying for certification for a period of three years for having committed these violations; and (3) dismissing the remaining counts of the Administrative Complaint, as amended. DONE AND ENTERED this 29th day of July, 1997, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. STUART M. LERNER Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (904) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (904) 921-6847 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 29th day of July, 1997.
Findings Of Fact Florida law requires that persons employed to serve in instructional capacities in the public schools hold valid certificates to teach. The Respondent, Florida Department of Education, is charged by statute with the responsibility of issuing such teaching certificates, and with the concomitant responsibility to suspend or revoke teaching certificates under appropriate circumstances. Sections 231.14 - 231.28, Florida Statutes. Purporting to act under authority of this statutory framework, the Respondent has adopted Rules 6A-4.37, and 6B-2.01 through 6B-2.17, Florida Administrative Code, as its rules establishing practices to be followed in suspending or revoking teaching certificates. The Respondent's rules establish a procedure whereby a teacher charged with conduct that would justify suspension or revocation of a teaching certificate is presented with the options of taking no action, which results in informal procedures at which the appropriate penalty is the only issue; or of requesting a hearing. If a hearing is requested, the teacher is permitted to choose between a hearing conducted by a Hearing Officer of the Division of Administrative Hearings as provided in Section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes, or a hearing conducted by a panel of the Professional Practices Council ("PPC" hereafter). Rule 6A-4.37(2) provides in pertinent part as follows: When the commissioner of education finds that probable cause exists, he shall direct a filing of a formal petition against the certificate holder for the revocation or suspension of a teacher's certificate, together with a form permitting waiver of a hearing officer pursuant to section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes, as hereinafter provided. If section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes, shall be waived by both the respondent and the chairman of the professional practices council by executing and filing the waiver form with the commissioner of education within twenty (20) days from service of the petition upon the respondent, the commissioner of education shall direct the chairman of the professional practices council to prosecute the matter before a hearing panel of three members of the professional practices council each of whom has not participated in nor was an informed party in any preliminary investigation of the cause. If section 120.57(1) Florida Statutes, is not waived by the parties, the matter shall be prosecuted before a hearing officer of the division of administrative hearings. The professional practices council may retain an attorney to prosecute the cause. The professional practices council may retain a different attorney to advise the hearing committee and act as a law officer for said committee. On completion of the hearing as hereinafter set forth, the hearing panel or officer, shall transmit through the commissioner of education to the state board of education a transcript of the proceedings and a report, which shall contain specific findings of fact, conclusions of law, interpretations of rules and a recommended order. The state board of education shall review the transcript of testimony and the report. The waiver form utilized is as follows: WAIVER OF RIGHT TO A HEARING BEFORE A HEARING OFFICER OF THE DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS IN PREFERENCE TO A HEARING BEFORE A PANEL OF THE PROFESSIONAL PRACTICES COUNCIL In the matter of the revocation of the teaching certificate of and pursuant to the provisions of 120.57, Florida Statutes, I hereby waive my right to a hearing before a hearing officer of the Division of Administrative Hearings. In the alternative I do hereby request that this matter be heard before a panel of professional educators from the membership of the Professional Practices Council as provided in 6A-4.37, Rules of the State Board of Education. DATE RESPONDENT The remaining paragraphs of 6A-4.37 delineate specific procedures to be followed whether the hearing is conducted by a Hearing Officer, or by a PPC panel. The rule was adopted at a May, 1977 meeting of the State Board of Education. Prior to its adoption, public hearings were conducted, and members of the public, including the Petitioner, were allowed an opportunity to comment. The Joint Administrative Procedures Committee of the Florida Legislature reviewed the rule. The rules set out at Chapter 6B-2.01 through 6B-2.16, Florida Administrative Code, establish additional procedures for public hearings conducted by the PPC. These rules pertain to teaching certificate suspension or revocation proceedings and to other matters. They are in large part inconsistent with the provisions of Rule 6A-4.37, and with the Administrative Procedure Act (Ch. 120, Florida Statutes). The rules are no longer followed by the PPC except those provisions which relate to the appointment of a law officer to aid a PPC panel in conducting hearings. The Respondent has been in the process of revising these rules for more than one year. Rule 6B-2.17 relates to probable cause hearings to be conducted by an executive committee. The rule is somewhat vague, but it appears to relate to proceedings under Section 231.57, Florida Statutes, rather than teaching certificate suspension or revocation proceedings. The rule does not relate to the issue of whether a final hearing will be conducted by a Hearing Officer of the Division of Administrative Hearings, or a panel of the PPC. During 1977, three-member PPC panels conducted thirteen hearings in teaching certificate suspension or revocation proceedings. Fourteen such hearings were conducted by Hearing Officers. During 1978, eighteen were conducted by PPC panels, and eleven by Hearing Officers. The Petitioner, Florida Education Association/United AFT-AFL-CIO, is a statewide organization composed of persons involved in the field of education. The members are primarily teachers. The Petitioner is a confederation of local affiliates. Its local affiliates serve as collective bargaining representatives for teachers in approximately half of the local school districts in Florida. Among the Petitioner's functions are to protect its members, and members of the teaching profession with respect to the terms and conditions of their employment as teachers. The Petitioner provides services which local affiliates are largely unable to perform, including legal assistance and lobbying assistance. In many instances the Petitioner provides legal counsel to its members in connection with teaching certificate suspension or revocation proceedings. At the Petitioner's October, 1978 convention, its members authorized Petitioner's executive council to examine the status of the PPC, and to take steps to clarify the role of the PPC. The instant rule challenge was authorized by the executive council in accordance with that mandate of the membership. There are approximately 90,000 teachers in Florida. The Petitioner represents approximately 30,000 of them.
