The Issue Should Petitioner impose discipline on Respondent's Florida Educator's Certificate No. 843208, covering the area of English, based upon the allegations in the Administrative Complaint, Case No. 023-1821-R, before the State of Florida Education Practices Commission?
Findings Of Fact The Respondent holds Florida Educator's Certificate No. 843208, covering the area of English, which is valid through June 30, 2003. At all times pertinent hereto the Respondent was employed as an English teacher at Philip Randolph Academy School (Randolph Academy), in the Duval County School District.1 J.L.J. was a female student at Randolph Academy in the school year 2002-2003. Her date of birth is October 29, 1987. She was familiar with Respondent when he taught there. J.L.J. had conversations with Respondent over time, conversations in which Respondent would ask her questions she deemed inappropriate and would follow with comments that she found unacceptable. As will be revealed, her perceptions about Respondent's conduct were correct. Most of the conversations complained of took place in the hallway or in a teacher's classroom. They made J.L.J. feel uncomfortable. The conversations were in the presence of other students and J.L.J. was embarrassed for that reason. One example of the conversations took place on a day when J.L.J. wore medical scrubs to school. Respondent commented that J.L.J. should not wear the scrubs because he could not see her curves. This is taken to mean that he was commenting on the shape of J.L.J.'s body. On other occasions Respondent would comment on J.L.J.'s attire. He would tell her that she should not wear a certain "outfit" because it made her look a certain way or didn't make her look a certain way. At one point in time at school Respondent asked J.L.J. if she had "black in you." Respondent followed his question by commenting that he had asked her that because J.L.J. was "shaped like a black girl." Respondent told J.L.J. that she was "sexy." He told her that her "butt" was big and that it was sexy. Respondent commented about J.L.J.'s hair and make-up. He would suggest to her certain ways that her hair should be styled and how her make-up should be presented. At a point in time, J.L.J. asked Respondent to leave her alone, referring to his remarks about her appearance. For a couple of days Respondent made no further comments but he began to act the same way that he had before in relation to comments about J.L.J.'s body, specifically her "butt" and her hair. E.S.H. was another female student at the Randolph Academy in the school year 2002-2003. Her date of birth is August 7, 1987. Respondent was her teacher. Respondent had conversations involving J.L.J. and E.S.H. on an almost daily basis. As had been identified by J.L.J., these conversations took place in the hallways and in a teacher's classroom. The substance of the conversations to which E.S.H. was privy, coincide with those recounted by J.L.J. and were principally directed to J.L.J. concerning J.L.J.'s hair, face, and overall appearance. E.S.H. was there when Respondent commented about the scrubs worn by J.L.J. She recalls Respondent saying that J.L.J. should not wear the scrubs because they made J.L.J. look like everyone else and did not show her shape, her curves. J.L.J. complained to E.S.H. about these remarks when Respondent walked away from that conversation. As E.S.H. recalls, J.L.J. and E.S.H. went to Respondent and complained about the comments that he made to J.L.J. concerning J.L.J.'s appearance. Respondent apologized but he also said that if the two female students went to the principal to complain that it would be his word against theirs. E.S.H. explained that about two days later J.L.J. came to her complaining about Respondent. This agrees with J.L.J.'s recollection of the place and time in which Respondent returned to his habit of making inappropriate comments about J.L.J. E.S.H. overheard Respondent comment to J.L.J. about J.L.J.'s "butt" and how it was getting big, and how that it was shaped like a "black girl." If J.L.J. were wearing certain clothes, Respondent would ask J.L.J. if her body was spreading because to him it looked as if J.L.J.'s "butt" was getting bigger. Those remarks were overheard by E.S.H. E.S.H. was also present when Respondent commented about J.L.J.'s face and her make-up, whether it was too much, or whether not enough time had been spent by J.L.J. applying make- up that morning. These encounters between Respondent and J.L.J. left E.S.H. with the impression that Respondent was attracted to J.L.J. Disciplinary History There is no indication that Respondent has been subjected to prior discipline.
Recommendation Based upon the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law reached, it is RECOMMENDED: That a Final Order be entered which finds Respondent in violations of Counts 2 through 5, dismisses Count 1, and suspends Respondent's Educator's Certificate for a period of 30 days. DONE AND ENTERED this 28th day of June, 2004, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S CHARLES C. ADAMS Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 28th day of June, 2004.
The Issue Whether or not Ossie L. Gardner, the Respondent, on or about August 2, 1977, in Duval County, Florida, did expose his sexual organs by masturbation inside a pornographic booth in the presence of a plain clothes city vice detective at a Jacksonville movie theater, and further, whether or not Ossie L. Gardner plead guilty to the lesser charge of "indecent exposure" and was fined 550.00 plus court costs, all in violation of Sections 231.09 and 231.28, Florida Statutes, and Sections 6A-4.37, 60-1 and 60-5, Florida Administrative Code, in that it is conduct which is inconsistent with good morals and the public conscience, not a proper example to students, and conduct which is sufficiently notorious to bring Ossie L. Gardner and the education profession into public disgrace and disrespect. Whether or not Ossie L. Gardner, the Respondent, on or about June 29, 1967, in Leon County, Florida, did solicit for a lewd and lascivious act by an offer to commit and engage in lewdness, to wit, fellatio with an employee of the Tallahassee Police Department, in violation of Sections 231.09 and 231.28, Florida Statutes, and Sections 6A-4.37, 6B-1 and 6B-5, Florida Administrative Code, in that it is conduct which is inconsistent with good morals and the public conscience, not a proper example for students, and conduct which is sufficiently notorious to bring Ossie L. Gardner and the education profession into public disgrace and disrespect.
Findings Of Fact This cause comes on for consideration based upon the Petition for Revocation of Teacher's Certificate filed by the Petitioner, Professional Practices Council, against Ossie L. Gardner, the Respondent. At the commencement of the hearing, the parties entered into several stipulations. The first of those stipulations was that the statements in the Petition for Revocation of Teacher's, Certificate found under the title "Jurisdictional Matters" are agreed to and established as facts in this cause; therefore, with the recitation of those facts in the following quotation, those facts under the title "Jurisdictional Matters" are hereby established. "JURISDICTIONAL MATTERS" "OSSIE L. GARDNER is the holder of Post-Graduate, Rank II Florida teaching certificate number 181441, covering Math, Emotionally Disturbed and Junior College, which is valid until June 30, 1993." "OSSIE L. GARDNER has been employed as a math/science teacher at the Juvenile Shelter in Jacksonville, Florida. He holds a tenure contract in Duval County where he continues to teach at this time. The Professional Practices Council received a report from Buford H. Galloway, Director of Evaluation and Development, indicating that OSSIE L. GARDNER was charged with Exposure of Sexual Organs by Masturbation on August 2, 1977. Pursuant to this report and under the authority contained in Section 231.28, Florida Statutes, staff of the Department of Education conducted a professional inquiry into the matter and on February 13, 1978 made its report to the Executive Committee of the Professional Practices Council. The Executive Committee recommended that the Commissioner of Education find that probable cause exists to believe that OSSIE L. GARDNER is guilty of acts which provide grounds for the revocation of his Florida teaching certificate. The Commissioner of Education found probable cause on February 13, 1978, and directed the filing of this petition. The Petitioner has authority under Section 6A-4.37, Rules of the State Board of Education to file this Petition. The State Board of Education has authority under action 231.28, Florida Statutes to revoke the teaching certificate of OSSIE L. GARDNER." At the commencement of the hearing, the parties further agreed to stipulate to the introduction of certain items of evidence without the necessity for authentication of those documents. Finally, the parties agreed to stipulate to the introduction of the deposition of Otha Lee Wooden, as a late-filed exhibit, to be used by the undersigned in the same way as the testimony offered in the course of the hearing. The facts in the case revealed that on August 2, 1977, between 3:30 and 4:00 P.M., Officer J. W. Lockley of the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office, Duval County, Florida, was making a routine check of the J & K Adult Theater in the 400 block of Main Street, Jacksonville, Florida. This theater contains material of sexual content. Among other features of the theater are certain booths located behind a curtained area, which is separated from the other part of the establishment. Those booths have coin-operated projectors which allow for the display of preselected film clips which have been obtained from the proprietor. The booths are approximately four feet by seven or eight feet in dimension and the patron may stand up or in some cases may sit down in the booths. The booths have a further feature which is a door which has instructions that it must be closed during the course of the film being shown. On the date in question, Officer Lockley went into the area of the theater which contains the booths and observed the Respondent, Ossie L. Gardner, in Booth No. 8. At that time, the door to the booth was open and Gardner was observed with his sexual organs exposed, and was observed stroking his exposed penis with his hand in an upward and downward motion. A film was playing in the booth, being projected on a small screen. The film depicted sexual activity between male participants, specifically fellatio. Officer Lockley passed up the aisle from where he had observed this activity on the part of the Respondent and then returned to the area of the booth in which Mr. Gardner was located. At that point, Gardner continued to stroke his penis and to look and obtain eye contact with Lockley and then to look down at his penis. Lockley subsequently arrested Gardner for exposure of sexual organs, in violation of Section 80003, Florida Statutes. Gardner later plead guilty to a municipal ordinance violation of indecent exposure, City of Jacksonville Ordinance No. 330.124. For this violation, Gardner was given a judgment and sentence of a $50.00 fine plus $2.00 court costs. In the course of the arrest, the Respondent indicated to Officer Lockley that he had bean arrested for similar conduct before in a matter in Tallahassee, Florida. This incident pertained to a situation which occurred in the Greyhound Bus Station in Tallahassee, Florida, on June 29, 1967. At that time, C. A. McMahan, an employee of the State Prison Camp, Division of Corrections, Tallahassee, Florida, was working as an agent with the Tallahassee Police Department to assist in the investigation of vice activities. In particular, McMahan was assisting in the investigation of alleged homosexual activities in the men's restroom of the Greyhound Bus Station. On the date in question at around 10:00 P.M., McMahan went into the men's restroom and entered one of the closed-in stalls in which a commode was located; Gardner went to one of the urinals in the bathroom facility. Before entering the stall, McMahan observed Gardner masturbating at the urinal. McMahan then closed the door to the stall and was seated in the area of the commode when Gardner moved into the area next to McMahan's stall and continued to masturbate as observed through a hole in the wall between the stall in which McMahan was located and the area where Gardner was positioned. After a period of three or four minutes, Gardner stuck his penis through a hole in the partition wall into the area where McMahan was located. At that point, McMahan left to tell Captain Burl S. Peacock of the Tallahassee Police Department, Tallahassee, Florida, of his observation. Both of these individuals went back into the restroom, at which point Gardner was arrested. Gardner, after being advised of his constitutional right to remain silent, admitted that he had gone to the restroom with the thought that he could get some "sexual relief", and further admitted putting his penis through the hole in the partition for the purpose of getting that "sexual relief." Gardner also admitted to Peacock that he had been involved in homosexual activities as early as the age of 18 and had performed sodomy on one occasion and had been a passive partner in homosexual activities at other times. Subsequent to the June 29, 1967, arrest, Gardner received psychiatric attention for his problem. For the incidents related in the matters of August 2, 1977, and June 29, 1967, the Respondent has been charged with violations of Sections 231.09 and 231.28, Florida Statutes, and Sections 6A-4.37, 60-1 and 6B-5, Florida Administrative Code; in that his conduct is alleged to be inconsistent with good morals and the public conscience; not a proper example for students and conduct which is sufficiently notorious to bring Ossie L. Gardner and the education profession into public disgrace and disrespect. A review of those stated sections of the Florida Statutes and the The Florida Administrative Code reveals that any substantive allegations cognizable through this complaint are found in provision of Section 231.09(2), Florida Statutes, and Section 231.28(1), Florida Statutes, only. Therefore, no further reference will be made to Section 6A- 4.37, 60-1 and 60-5, Florida Administrative Code. Section 231.09(2), Florida Statutes, reads as follows: "(2) EXAMPLE FOR PUPILS.--Labor faithfully and earnestly for the advancement of the pupils in their studies, deportment and morals, and embrace every opportunity to inculcate, by precept and example, the principles of truth, honesty and pat- riotism and the practice of every Christian virtue." The conduct which has been established in the facts pertaining to the incidents of August 2, 1977, and June 29, 1967, involving the exposure of the Respondent's sexual organs and the surrounding activities in those incidents, is conduct which shows that the Respondent is not laboring faithfully and earnestly for the advancement of the pupils in their deportment and morals' in violation of Section 231.09(2), Florida Statutes. No other violation of that provision has been established. Section 231.28(1), Florida Statutes, together with the preamble to the overall Section 231.28, Florida Statutes, reads as follows: "231.28 Suspension or revocation of certificates. The Department of Education shall have authority to suspend the teaching certificate of any person for a period of time not to exceed 3 years, thereby denying him the right to teach for that period of time, after which the holder may return to teaching as provided in subsection (6); to revoke the teach- ing certificate of any person, thereby denying him the right to teach for a period of time not to exceed 10 years, with reinstatement subject to provisions of subsection (6); or to revoke permanently the teaching certificate of any person, provided: (1) It can be shown that such person obtained the teaching certificate by fraudulent means, or has proved to be incompetent to teach or to perform his duties as an employee of the public school system, or to teach in or to operate a private school, or has been guilty of gross immorality or an act involving moral turpitude, or has had his certificate revoked in another state, or has been convicted of a mis- demeanor, felony, or any other criminal charge, other than a minor traffic violation, or upon investigation has been found guilty of personal conduct which seri- ously reduces his effectiveness as an employee of the school board, or has otherwise violated the provisions of law, the penalty for which is the revocation of the teaching certificate, or has refused to comply with the regulations of the State Board of Education or the school board in the district in which he is employed." Again, the acts of August 2, 1977, and June 29, 1967, involving the exposure by the Respondent of his sexual organs and the facts therein, show that the Respondent has been guilty of gross immorality or an act involving moral turpitude. The only other possible violation under Section 231.28(1), Florida Statutes, which might be argued is the allegation of possible conduct which seriously reduces the Respondent's effectiveness as an employee of the school board. The sole testimony offered in the course of the hearing which would address that substantive accusation would be that testimony found in the deposition of Otha Lee Wooden. A review of that testimony indicates that the opinion of the principal of the school in which the Respondent teaches, to wit, the school No. 182, Juvenile Shelter School, is to the effect that the facts in these cases are not known to other persons in the school. Consequently, there is no testimony to indicate that there would be any loss of effectiveness if Mr. Gardner continued to teach. No other violations were alleged or proven.
Recommendation In the course of the hearing, matters in mitigation and aggravation were considered. In that presentation, it was demonstrated that the Respondent is a teacher with an outstanding background, as revealed by his personnel file, which is the Respondent's Exhibit No. 8 admitted into evidence. It was also established that the Respondent is a man of distinguished service to his country through service in the United States Army, as established in the Respondent's Exhibits Nos. 1 through 7. Further, it was established that absent these incidents alluded to in the course of this Recommended Order, the Respondent has not been the subject of disciplinary action by the Petitioner on any other occasion. Nonetheless, in consideration of the nature of his profession, it is recommended that the Respondent, Ossie L. Gardner, have his Post-Graduate Rank II Florida Teaching Certificate No. 181441 REVOKED for a period of three (3) years. DONE and ENTERED this 15th day of September, 1978, in Tallahassee, Florida. CHARLES C. ADAMS Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings Mail: 530 Carlton Building 101 Collins Building Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550 COPIES FURNISHED: L. Haldane Taylor, Esquire 2516 Gulf Life Tower Jacksonville, Florida Charles E. Grabill, Jr., Esquire 168 Blanding Boulevard, Suite 2 Orange Park, Florida 32073 Mr. M. Juhan Mixon Professional Practices Council 319 West Madison Street, Room 3 Tallahassee, Florida 32304
The Issue The issue for determination is whether Respondent should deny Petitioner's application for a teaching certificate.
Findings Of Fact 1. Petitioner submitted her application for a teaching certificate on May 26, 1993. Respondent notified Petitioner of its proposed denial of the application on April 5, 1994. Respondent's proposed agency action is based on events that occurred while Petitioner was teaching in the Florida public school system in 1988 and 1989. Background From August, 1988, until February, 1989, Petitioner taught Spanish as a first-year teacher at Lake Wales Senior High School ("Lake Wales") in Polk County, Florida. In the fall of 1988, Petitioner met Brian Keith Swinney. Mr. Swinney was a junior at Lake Wales but was not one of Petitioner's students. Mr. Swinney attended school in the morning and worked as a professional entertainer at Cypress Gardens in the afternoon. Although Mr. Swinney was not one of Petitioner's students, Mr. Swinney and Petitioner knew each other at school. Mr. Swinney's Spanish teacher shared a classroom with Petitioner. Mr. Swinney was also a varsity cheerleader, and Petitioner was a chaperon for the cheerleaders when they traveled to various games. Petitioner and Mr. Swinney dated and developed a relationship that included sexual relations. Sexual relations began on October 4, 1988. In November or December, 1988, Mr. Swinney began residing with Petitioner. On or about February 1, 1989, Petitioner resigned her position with Lake Wales. On February 12, 1989, Petitioner and Mr. Swinney were married. At the time of their marriage, Petitioner was 22. Mr. Swinney was 17 years old on February 17, 1989. Mr. Swinney's parents consented to the marriage. Mr. Swinney's mother drove Mr. Swinney and Petitioner to South Carolina where he and Petitioner were lawfully married. Petitioner and Mr. Swinney moved to California. A child was born of the marriage, and Petitioner remained married to Mr. Swinney for approximately five years. Following a period of separation, Petitioner and Mr. Swinney were divorced on February 28, 1994. After separating from Mr. Swinney, Petitioner relocated to Lee County, Florida. Petitioner applied for a teaching position with the Lee County School District. The District issued a letter of eligibility, and Petitioner began teaching in May, 1993. Current Qualifications And Good Moral Character Petitioner applied for a teaching certificate on May 26, 1993. Petitioner satisfies all of the academic and professional requirements for a teaching certificate. She is over the age of 18. She received her bachelor's degree from Florida Southern College, an accredited institution of higher learning. She executed the required loyalty oath for the state and federal constitutions. Her application was properly completed and executed. Petitioner is competent to perform the duties, functions, and responsibilities of a teacher. Petitioner taught school in several localities in California. Petitioner taught for the Lee County School District during the 1993-1994 school year. She taught as a full-time teacher at Paul Lawrence Dunbar Middle School ("Dunbar") during the day. At night, she taught in the District's night school program at Cape Coral High School ("Cape Coral") in Cape Coral, Florida. Petitioner was recommended for re-employment as a teacher with the Lee County School District for the 1994-1995 school year. Petitioner is a "very capable" and "creative" teacher. Both Renee Highbaugh, Assistant Principal at Dunbar and Petitioner's immediate supervisor, and Belle DeKoff, Administrator for the adult education program at Cape Coral, testified to Petitioner's competence and capability. Respondent stipulated that Petitioner is an "excellent" teacher. Petitioner is of good moral character. Ms. Highbaugh testified to Petitioner's good moral character. Her testimony was credible and persuasive. Petitioner's good moral character is further evidenced by her exemplary teaching record in California and Florida since 1989. Alleged Violations In Notice Of Reasons In 1988 and 1989, Petitioner did not fail to make a reasonable effort to protect students from conditions harmful to their learning. Petitioner and Mr. Swinney did not engage in public displays of affection on campus. Nor did either of them create any condition that was otherwise harmful to students' learning. Petitioner did not fail to protect Mr. Swinney from conditions harmful to his learning. Mr. Swinney's grades did not decline during his relationship and subsequent marriage to Petitioner. Mr. Swinney voluntarily chose to marry Petitioner and obtain his G.E.D. He did so with his parents' permission. Mr. Swinney joined the United States Air Force and was honorably discharged. He is a licensed helicopter pilot. He attends helicopter flight school in California for certification as a commercial instrument instructor. He has a job waiting for him in his desired field when he graduates in February or March, 1995. Mr. Swinney is remarried and resides with his wife in California. Petitioner did not intentionally expose Mr. Swinney to unnecessary embarrassment or disparagement in 1988 and 1989. Petitioner passed notes to Mr. Swinney on occasions. Once, the two kissed in an empty classroom. The notes and kiss were not observed by students or faculty. In January, 1989, Mr. Swinney transferred to Winter Haven High School ("Winter Haven"). He transferred so that he and Petitioner could continue seeing each other without jeopardizing Petitioner's job. By January, rumors about Petitioner's relationship with Mr. Swinney had begun at Lake Wales, and Mr. Swinney wished to avoid further rumors. Mr. Swinney used a false address to enroll at Winter Haven. School officials discovered the false address but permitted Mr. Swinney to attend Winter Haven anyway. At Winter Haven, a male teacher told Mr. Swinney in front of the class, "I know what happened with you in Lake Wales, and that crap's not going to work over here." Mr. Swinney was embarrassed, but his embarrassment was intended by the teacher at Winter Haven and not by Petitioner. Petitioner did not exploit her relationship with Mr. Swinney for personal gain or advantage. Petitioner did not pressure him into their relationship. Mr. Swinney testified that he entered the relationship by his own volition. Petitioner did not commit an act of gross immorality or moral turpitude in 1988 and 1989. Mr. Swinney was a professional entertainer. He periodically lived outside his parents' home with their permission. He frequented adult nightclubs where alcohol was served. He was sexually active and engaged in sexual intercourse with approximately four other partners before meeting Petitioner. Mr. Swinney's parents consented to his marriage to Petitioner and assisted the couple in getting married. Assuming arguendo that, in 1988 or 1989, Petitioner either lacked good moral character, committed an act of gross immorality or moral turpitude, or otherwise violated the provisions of law or rules of the State Board of Education, the prior incidents, standing alone, do not support a conclusion that Petitioner currently lacks the good moral character required for a teaching certificate. Since 1989, Petitioner has demonstrated her good moral character through an exemplary teaching record in California and Florida. Petitioner is a valuable asset to the Lee County School District. The District observed Petitioner in the classroom, recommended Petitioner for re- employment, and is satisfied that Petitioner is of good moral character.
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Educational Practices Commission enter a Final Order finding Petitioner not guilty of the allegations in the Notice Of Reasons and authorizing the issuance of Petitioner's teaching certificate, forthwith. RECOMMENDED this 13th day of January, 1995, in Tallahassee, Florida. DANIEL MANRY Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 13th day of January, 1995.
Findings Of Fact Upon consideration of the evidence adduced at the hearing, the following relevant facts are found: At all times material to this proceeding, Respondent held Florida Teaching Certificate No. 139016 covering the area of history and qualifying him to teach grades 7 through 12. From on or about January 27, 1988, until August 29, 1989 the Respondent was employed by the Board as a teacher at Sandalwood Junior/Senior High School, teaching 8th grade gifted students ranging in age from 13 to 14 years and 11th and 12th grade advanced placement history students ranging in age from 16 to 18 years. Respondent is presently employed by the Board, assigned to the Media Center in Jacksonville, Florida where he was assigned on August 29, 1989. Prior to his present employment with the Board, the Respondent had been employed by the Florida Community College of Jacksonville (FCCJ) for 21-1/2 years as a teacher/administrator. Before assuming his teaching duties at Sandalwood, Respondent had read the Code of Ethics of the Education Profession and understood and accepted the obligations and responsibilities placed on him by the code. On June 21, 1989, S.L.W. ran away from her home in North Carolina and while standing outside of a local fast food restaurant, a short distance from her home, an individual called Adrian Freeman offered her a ride. S.L.W. was not acquainted with Freeman before he offered her a ride. Freeman learned from S.L.W. that she had run away from home and offered to help her and not tell anyone. S.L.W. spent the night at Freeman's house and while there she became intoxicated and "passed out." While S.L.W. was passed out, Freeman sexually assaulted her. The next day, June 23, 1989, S.L.W. decided to leave Freeman's house and he drove her to the bus station. At first, S.L.W. was going to Myrtle Beach but because the bus for Jacksonville, Florida left earlier she decided to go to Jacksonville. Before S.L.W. left for Jacksonville, Freeman made arrangements with the Respondent for him to meet S.L.W. in Jacksonville and find her a place to stay. Upon arriving in Jacksonville, S.L.W. was met at the bus station by Respondent. The Respondent told S.L.W. that he was a high school teacher. S.L.W. told Respondent that she was in the tenth grade and a runaway. Respondent then told S.L.W. that she would be staying at the home of Lee Daniels. Respondent then bought S.L.W. some food. When S.L.W. finished eating he carried her to the home of Lee Daniels but they were told to come back later. Respondent and S.L.W. later returned to the home of Daniels around 10:00 a.m. Respondent showed S.L.W. to her room and told her to take a shower. After taking she shower she put on her clothes and got under the cover. At this point, Respondent returned to the room with an alcoholic beverage for S.L.W. Respondent then told S.L.W. to remove her clothes item by item and once she was undressed began to massage her body. Later Respondent attempted sexual intercourse with S.L.W. and, although Respondent did not have an ejaculation he did penetrate S.L.W.'s vagina with his penis. Respondent then left Daniels' home and was seen by S.L.W. on only two other occasions. There was no physical contact between them on these occasions. S.L.W. remained at Daniels' home for approximately three weeks. Eventually, S.L.W. was picked up by a State Trooper at a bar and through the Jacksonville Sheriff's Department was returned to her mother. S.L.W. identified Respondent for the sheriff's department as the person who sexually assaulted her by pointing him out in a high school year book. Based on this identification, Respondent was arrested and charged with lewd and lascivious assault upon a minor. Respondent's conduct involving S.L.W. was immoral, reflects on his character, not only as an individual but more specifically as a teacher, and is in violation of the Duval County Teacher's Tenure Act and the Code of Ethics of the teaching profession. Although the publicity of Respondent's involvement with S.L.W. created by several newspaper articles and television stories and by word of mouth of the students, teacher and parents of Sandalwood seriously impaired his effectiveness as a teacher at Sandalwood, there was insufficient evidence to show that Respondent's effectiveness as a teacher had been seriously impaired in the Duval County School System as a whole.
Recommendation Having considered the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, the evidence of record and the candor and demeanor of the witnesses, it is, RECOMMENDED that the Board enter a Final Order finding Respondent guilty of having violated Section 4(a) of the Duval County Teacher Tenure Act and terminating his employment with the Board. DONE AND ENTERED this 12th day of July, 1990, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. WILLIAM R. CAVE Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, FL 32399-1550 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 12th day of July, 1990. APPENDIX TO RECOMMENDED ORDER IN CASE NO. 89-6704 Specific Rulings on Proposed Findings of Fact Submitted by the Petitioner 1-4. Adopted in Findings of fact 1, 3, 2 and 4, respectively. 5-7. Rejected as not being material or relevant to this case or not being supported by any substantial competent evidence in the record. 8. Adopted in Finding of Fact 5. 9-10. Adopted in Finding of Fact 2. 12-55. Adopted generally in Findings of Fact 6 through 19, otherwise rejected as not being material or relevant, or being redundant or subordinate, or not supported by any substantial competent evidence in the record. Specific Rulings on Proposed Findings of Fact Submitted by the Respondent 1.-2. Adopted in Finding of Facts 2 and 3. 3.-4. Adopted generally in Finding of Fact 17, otherwise rejected as not being material or relevant. Rejected as not being material or relevant. Covered in Preliminary Statement. 7.-10. Adopted generally in Findings of Fact 6-17, otherwise rejected as not being material or relevant, or redundant or subordinate, or not supported by any substantial competent evidence in the record. 11.-15. Adopted in Findings of Fact 19, otherwise rejected or not being material or relevant, or being redundant or subordinate, or not being supported by any substantial competent evidence in the record. 16. Rejected as not being supported by any substantial competent evidence in the record. See Findings of Fact 10 through 18. COPIES FURNISHED: Dr. Larry Zenke, Superintendent Duval County School Board 1701 Prudential Drive Jacksonville, Florida 32207 Gail A. Stafford, Esquire 421 West Church Street, Suite 715 Jacksonville, Florida 32202 David A. Hertz, Esquire 1601 Atlantic Boulevard Jacksonville, Florida 32207 Honorable Betty Castor Commissioner of Education The Capitol Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0400 =================================================================
