The Issue The issue in this case is whether Ailani Sanchez suffered a birth-related injury as defined by section 766.302(2), Florida Statutes, for which compensation should be awarded under the Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Plan (the Plan).
Findings Of Fact Ailani Sanchez was born a live infant at 5:46 a.m., on October 29, 2015, at Lakeland Regional Medical Center. Ailani was a single gestation, weighing 2,950 grams at birth. Ailani was delivered via cesarean section for suspected abruption/velamentous insertion of cord by Dr. Zollicoffer who was a NICA participating physician on October 29, 2015. Ailani's Apgar scores were 2/4/4. Upon delivery, she was floppy and pale and had no respiratory effort. Pulse oximetry was within target saturations for age and her heart rate remained 100 or greater. She was intubated at seven minutes of age and transferred to the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU). No seizures were noted. Ailani had increasing spontaneous respiratory effort and whole body cooling was started prior to her transfer to St. Joseph's Hospital NICU on October 29, 2015. Upon admission to St. Joseph's Hospital on October 29, 2015, Ailani was lethargic with decreased reactions to stimuli, but appeared pink and well perfused. Neurologically, she was noted to be improving; she was breathing spontaneously and moving all extremities to stimuli. After a complicated newborn hospital course, Ailani was ultimately discharged from St. Joseph's Hospital on January 6, 2016. At the time of her discharge, she was noted to be feeding by mouth and was overall gaining weight. Prior to her discharge, an EEG on October 30, 2015, showed seizures predominantly on the right side of her brain and generalized brain dysfunction. A brain MRI obtained on November 5, 2015, revealed restricted diffusion related to acute infarction in the right temporal occipital region with laminar necrosis. Additional laminar necrosis in the frontal lobes and insular cortex bilaterally was noted. An EEG on November 16, 2015, was consistent with nonspecific cerebral dysfunction with occasional sharp waves in the temporal parietal regions bilaterally with no evidence of seizures and irregular slow waves with slightly more predominance to the right. Ailani was seen for a newborn visit by her pediatrician, Dr. Bou Salvador, on January 7, 2016. Nutritionally, she was noted to be breast feeding adequately, with supplements with formula. Developmentally, she was noted to have equal movements of all extremities and follow midline. She responded to a bell and was able to lift her head while lying on her stomach. Examination of her spine, extremities, and peripheral pulses were all normal. Neurologically, she was reportedly normal, with normal strength, tone, and reflexes reported. On January 19, 2016, Ailani was evaluated at All Children's Outpatient Care upon referral by St. Joseph's Hospital secondary to hypoxic ischemia. The occupational therapist's impression included decreased bilateral coordination, decreased developmental milestones, decreased gross motor skills, decreased play skills, decreased strength, and fine motor deficits. Skilled therapy was identified to have the potential to improve her functional level in the areas of manipulation. It was recommended that Ailani undergo 30 minutes of occupational therapy once a week for six months. Her prognosis for achieving goals established by her therapist was noted to be excellent. On February 4, 2016, Ailani was evaluated for participation in, and deemed eligible for, the Early Steps Program. On February 18, 2016, Ailani was evaluated by Dr. Qureshi at Kids Neurology. Developmentally, she was noted to smile and coo and focus. It was noted that Ailani had three seizures at the age of one day old, but none since. At this time, she was taking Keppra and Phenobarbital, from which she was being weaned. A sleep deprived EEG, obtained since the last visit, was normal. She was noted to be doing very well neurologically. Her physical examination revealed she was lifting her chest and head with her arms extended. Early head control with bobbing motion was noted. She was noted to say "aah," smile, and follow pass midline. The plan noted at this time was to continue to wean and discontinue Keppra and Phenobarbital. Ailani was again seen by Dr. Bou Salvador on March 4, 2016, for her four-month well visit. Nutritionally, she was noted to be feeding with formula adequately. She had been started on solids for one to two feeds. Developmentally, she was noted to squeal and laugh. She was able to follow 180 degrees. She turned to void and was able to hold her head up 90 degrees while lying on her stomach. She was able to sit with support with her head up. She was able to pull to sit with no head lag. She could bring her hands together and had no persistent fist clenching. Her physical examination was normal. Her neurological examination was also normal, with normal strength, tone, and reflexes reported. Ailani was again seen by Dr. Bou Salvador on May 4, 2016, for her six-month well visit. Nutritionally, she was noted to be breast feeding adequately. Developmentally, she was noted to be social and smiling responsively. Adaptive equal movements of all extremities and the ability to follow midline were noted. She could respond to a bell and was able to lift her head while lying on her stomach. A physical examination was normal. A neurological examination was also normal, with normal strength, tone, and reflexes reported. On May 24, 2016, Ailani returned to Dr. Qureshi at Kids Neurology. It was noted that Ailani had been weaned from her seizure medication and had had no seizures for the last three months. She was noted to be doing very well neurologically. Physically and developmentally, she was noted to have no head lag, to be rolling over, to have her chest up in a prone position, to be trying to crawl, to be lifting her head, and to be sitting briefly unsupported. She was also noted to be leaning forward on her hands, engaging in bounce activity, supporting most of her weight, reaching out and grasping large objects, transferring from hand to hand, babbling, enjoying mirror, and using polysyllable sounds. She was noted to be feeding herself. Dr. Qureshi reported that Ailani was in occupation therapy but that it was on hold since her evaluation was "pretty unremarkable." Ailani was noted to be progressing well for her age and was receiving Early Steps intervention once a week at home. She was given a prescription of Phenobarbital for use only if a seizure occurred. On June 18, 2016, Ailani was seen by Dr. Frances Arrillaga at Pediatric Cardiology Associates for a cardiology consultation secondary to a history of pulmonary hypertension, and an echocardiogram that showed a patent foramen ovale (PFO). Ailani's mother reported that since her discharge from St. Joseph's, she was doing well. Cyanosis, difficulty breathing and unexplained diaphoresis and feeding problems, were denied. An echocardiogram on this date showed a PFO, with otherwise normal anatomy. There were normal right ventricular (RV) pressures, normal left ventricular (LV) size and function. No cardiovascular restrictions were given and she was told to return in one year for further follow up. Ailani was again seen by Dr. Bou Salvador on August 4, 2016, for her nine-month well visit. Nutritionally, she was reported to be feeding adequately. She was feeding 2 to 3 varieties of solid foods with no problems and was starting with a cup for water and juice. Developmentally, she was reported to be playing pat-a-cake and looking for fallen objects. She could bang two cubes in her hand with thumb-finger grasp. She could say "dada" and "mama" and walk while holding on. She was also noted to be crawling and standing momentarily. Her physical and neurological examinations were noted to be normal, with normal strength, tone, and reflexes noted. An August 22, 2016, a progress note from Early Intervention reflects that Ailani was babbling two syllables together, was happy, pulling to a stand and cruising along furniture, and was responding to her name. Attendance at Early Intervention was noted to be consistent and once a week. Ailani was again seen by Dr. Bou Salvador on November 3, 2016, for her 12-month well visit. Nutritionally, she was noted to be eating two to three varieties of solid foods with no problems and was feeding herself finger foods. Developmentally, she was reported to be playing pat-a-cake and drinking from a cup. She was able to bang two cubes held in her hands with thumb-finger grasp. She was saying "mama" and "dada," imitated speech sounds, could say three words other than "mama" and "dada," and understood "no." She was able to walk while holding on, and was reported to stand alone and walk well. A physical examination revealed normal extremities. A neurologic examination was also normal, with normal strength, tone, and reflexes reported. On November 21, 2016, Ailani returned to Dr. Qureshi at Kids Neurology. It was noted that Ailani had been weaned off medications six months earlier and had no seizure activity since. She was noted to be doing very well. It was noted that no therapy was being provided at this time, although she was evaluated for occupational therapy but did not qualify for it. Developmentally, she was noted to be walking with one hand held, rising independently, taking several steps, getting to sitting, pulling to stand, standing for two seconds, saying a few words besides "mama" and "dada," playing ball game, making postural adjustment to dressing, waiving "bye bye," and indicating what she wants. She was noted to have pincer grasp, releasing objects to others when grabbed, and banging two things. Dr. Qureshi noted "she is doing amazing right now." A December 24, 2016, emergency room record (for a cough/choking episode after eating a piece of Dorito) from Florida Hospital Tampa reflects that Ailani had not had seizures since birth, and had been off Keppra and Phenobarbital for almost a year. A physical examination revealed an active, well- developed, and well-nourished child. Neurologically, she was noted to be awake, alert, and interacting with family and staff. She was also noted to be active and playful. An Early Intervention progress note from February 15, 2017, reflects Ailani had age-level play skills, could communicate using vocalizations and some single words, could follow routine directions, and was independent with walking and floor transfers. Good progress was noted to be made, many goals were reported met, and the parents decided to reduce services to one time per month. On January 30, 2017, Ailani was reevaluated for participation in Early Steps. It was noted that Ailani's mother had no concerns at this time. The report notes that Ailani liked the slide, liked to kick the ball, liked to play with her siblings and cousins, and that she is very curious. No hearing or vision concerns were noted. It was reported that many of her goals had been met, and that Ailani was using a variety of vowels and consonants, identifying at least three family members when named, that she was saying a variety of words, and was using a sign for "more food." Ailani was noted to still be eligible for Early Steps secondary to her diagnosis of hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy. Ailani was seen by Dr. Bou Salvador on March 28, 2017, for her 16-month well visit. She was noted to have good eating habits and a good appetite. No mealtime problems were reported, and she was noted to be eating solid foods with no problems. She was noted to have socially appropriate behavior for her age. She was talking well and was able to balance on one foot for five seconds, could throw a ball overhead, and pedal a tricycle. Her orthopedic and neurologic examinations were normal, with normal strength, tone, and reflexes reported. At the request of NICA, Donald C. Willis, M.D., who specializes in obstetrics and gynecology and maternal-fetal medicine, reviewed the medical records included in the Stipulated Record as Joint Exhibits A through G. In his report dated August 2, 2017, which was admitted into evidence without objection, Dr. Willis noted in pertinent part that Ailani's mother was cramping when she presented to the hospital, and was three centimeters dilated with suspected amniotic membranes ruptured. Contractions were noted to be occurring occasionally. Medical records indicated the presence of late decelerations on admission, which progressed to bradycardia, for which an immediate Cesarean section was recommended. Dr. Willis observed that Ailani was depressed at birth with Apgar scores of 2/4/4, and that cord blood gas was abnormal with a pH of only 6.97. He further noted that Ailani was floppy, pale, and had poor perfusion; that bag and mask ventilation was initiated, followed by intubation for continued respiratory distress; that hypotension was present and required IV fluids; that the initial blood count was low; and that Ailani remained acidotic after birth with a pH of 6.7 and a base excess of -27 at 90 minutes after birth. Dr. Willis further noted Ailani's hospital course consistent with her medical records and ultimately opined that “there was an obstetrical event that resulted in loss of oxygen to the baby's brain during labor, delivery and continuing into the immediate post delivery period. The oxygen deprivation resulted in brain injury.” Dr. Willis was unable to comment about the severity of the injury, however. At the request of NICA, Laufey Y. Sigurdardottir, M.D., who is board certified in neurology and specializing in pediatric neurology, reviewed the medical records included in the Stipulated Record as Joint Exhibits A through G, and performed a thorough examination of Ailani on October 18, 2017. Dr. Sigurdardottir's summary of Ailani's medical history, along with her findings upon a full physical and neurological examination, is documented within her written report, which was admitted into evidence without objection. Dr. Sigurdardottir noted that Ailani was a non-dysmorphic, interactive toddler with normal facial features and apparently intact vision. No abnormalities in Ailani's extremities were noted other than occasional toe walking. Neurologically, Ailani was noted to be interactive, curious, and exhibiting normal joint attention. Ailani exhibited pretend play with a stethoscope, said the word "mom" a few times, pointed to her mouth when asked to do so, enjoyed playing with a tablet computer, shook her head for "no," exhibited understandable words, and exhibited no autistic features. Cranial nerves were intact, facial grimacing was symmetric and normal, and hearing seemed intact. No drooling was noted. Muscle tone was noted to be normal, strength was full and symmetric and deep tendon reflexes were symmetric and within normal limits. Gross and fine motor skills were noted to be within normal limits for age. Overall, Dr. Sigurdardottir determined that despite her initial abnormal neurological examination, and delays in early development, Ailani's current neurologic and developmental functioning is age-appropriate. She went on to opine in relevant part that, Ailani is not found to have substantial delays in motor and mental abilities at this time . . . . In review of available documents, there is evidence of impairment consistent with a neurologic injury to the brain or spinal cord acquired due to oxygen deprivation . . . . The prognosis for full motor and mental recovery is excellent and the life expectancy is full In light of evidence presented I believe Ailani does not fulfill criteria of a substantial mental and physical impairment at this time. I do not feel that Ailani should be included in the NICA program. Neither Petitioner nor Intervenor submitted or introduced into evidence any expert reports rebutting the opinions of Dr. Willis and/or Dr. Sigurdardottir.
The Issue At issue in the proceeding is whether Daniel Sicard, a minor, suffered an injury for which compensation should be awarded under the Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Plan.
Findings Of Fact As observed in the preliminary statement, neither Petitioners nor anyone on their behalf appeared at hearing, and no proof was offered to support their claim. Respondent, in light of such failure, declined the opportunity to offer any evidence. Consequently, there being no proof, it cannot be factually resolved whether Daniel Sicard, a minor, suffered a "birth-related neurological injury" as alleged in the claim for benefits.
Findings Of Fact Calise L. Muniz was born on May 2, 2015, at Holmes Regional Medical Center, located in Melbourne, Florida. Calise weighed in excess of 2,500 grams at birth. Donald Willis, M.D. (Dr. Willis), was requested by NICA to review the medical records for Calise. In a medical report dated January 24, 2017, Dr. Willis opined in pertinent part as follows: In summary, the mother apparently became hypotensive after placement of epidural anesthesia with resulting fetal distress. The baby was depressed at birth. The initial ABG was consistent with metabolic acidosis. Cooling protocol was initiated for HIE. EEG was normal for age. No MRI or CT scan was done during the newborn hospital course. There was an apparent obstetrical event that resulted in loss of oxygen during labor and delivery. However, there was no documentation of actual brain injury. NICA retained Laufey Y. Sigurdardottir, M.D. (Dr. Sigurdardottir), a pediatric neurologist, to examine Calise and to review her medical records. Dr. Sigurdardottir examined Calise on February 1, 2017. In a medical report dated February 1, 2017, Dr. Sigurdardottir summarized her examination of Calise and opined in pertinent part as follows: Summary: Calise is a 21-month-old female who was born via emergency cesarean section after nonreassuring fetal heart rate tracings were noted after a high spinal anesthesia. She had poor Apgars of 2, 4 and 5 after 1, 5 and 10 minutes, and was treated with cooling protocol. She did not have any neonatal seizures and the only neuroimaging available is a head ultrasound on day of life 1 that was normal. On neurologic exam today she is normal, both with her motor skills and cognition and language development. There are no signs of autistic features. Results as to question 1: Calise is not found to have substantial physical or mental impairment at this time. Results as to question 2: In review of available documents, she does have the clinical picture of an acute birth-related hypoxic injury. Results as to question 3: The prognosis for full motor and mental recovery is excellent and her life expectancy is full. In light of the normal cognitive abilities and normal neurologic exam, I do not feel that Calise should be included in the NICA program. If needed, I will be happy to answer additional questions. A review of the file in this case reveals that there have been no expert opinions filed that are contrary to the opinion of Dr. Willis that while there was an apparent obstetrical event that resulted in loss of oxygen to the baby's brain during labor and delivery, there was no documentation of actual brain injury. Dr. Willis’ opinion is credited. There are no expert opinions filed that are contrary to Dr. Sigurdardottir’s opinion that Calise does not have a substantial physical or mental impairment. Dr. Sigurdardottir’s opinion is credited.
Findings Of Fact Uzziah Walker was born on November 23, 2012, at Sacred Heart Hospital located in Pensacola, Florida. Uzziah weighed in excess of 2,500 grams at birth. Donald Willis, M.D. (Dr. Willis), was requested by NICA to review the medical records for Uzziah. In an affidavit dated May 24, 2015, Dr. Willis described his findings in pertinent part as follows: In summary, there was no apparent fetal distress during labor. Spontaneous vaginal delivery resulted in a large subgaleal hemorrhage with blood loss and poor perfusion. The baby was not hypoxic at birth. Cord blood gas was normal (pH 7.25). However, blood loss from the scalp hemorrhage and poor perfusion resulted in intraventricular hemorrhage during the immediate post delivery period. There was an apparent obstetrical event that resulted in scalp hemorrhage and poor perfusion with loss of oxygen to the baby’s brain during the immediate post delivery period. The poor perfusion resulted in brain injury. I am unable to comment about the severity of the brain injury. NICA retained Michael Duchowny, M.D. (Dr. Duchowny), a pediatric neurologist, to examine Uzziah and to review his medical records. Dr. Duchowny examined Uzziah on March 11, 2015. In an affidavit dated May 29, 2015, Dr. Duchowny opined in pertinent part as follows: Review of medical records and imaging studies sent on February 4 and 6, 2015 was performed. They detail Uzziah’s birth at Baptist Hospital Health System in Pensacola with a forceps assisted delivery after a rapid decent. Uzziah evidenced tachycardia and some retractions at the time of delivery but his Apgar scores were 7 and 8. He was observed to have a subgaleal hematoma; a CT scan of the brain on November 23 revealed a large soft tissue hematoma and a small collection of subdural blood over the right cerebellar tent with a small amount of right ventricular hemorrhage. Of note, there was no cerebral edema or ventricular compression. No skull fractures were noted despite bilateral subgaleal hematomas. The neonatal course was otherwise uncomplicated. In summary, Uzziah’s neurological examination today reveals normal findings. He does not exhibit either mental or physical impairment and his overall development has caught up and is proceeding in an age appropriate fashion. I believe that Uzziah’s perinatal hematomas were resorbed without residual brain injury and his future prognosis is excellent. I explained to his family that Uzziah is doing very well and that his future is favorable from a prognostic standpoint. Given Uzziah’s normal neurological status today, I am not recommending compensation with the NICA program. A review of the file in this case reveals that there have been no opinions filed that are contrary to the opinion of Dr. Willis that there was an apparent obstetrical event that resulted in scalp hemorrhage and poor perfusion with loss of oxygen to the baby's brain during the immediate post-delivery period, and that the poor perfusion resulted in brain injury. Dr. Willis’ opinion is credited. There are no opinions filed that are contrary to Dr. Duchowny’s opinion that Uzziah’s overall development is proceeding in an age appropriate fashion and does not exhibit either mental or physical impairment. Dr. Duchowny’s opinion is credited.
