The Issue The issue is whether the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles should approve the establishment of a proposed dealership by SunL Group, Inc., in Gulfport, Florida.
Findings Of Fact TRM is in the business of selling motor scooters in Gulfport, which is in Pinellas County. TRM is owned by Thomas R. Malin, III. TRM is currently an authorized dealer of scooters manufactured and/or imported by Carter Brothers and Tank Sports. Those scooters sell in the $2,000 to $3,000 price range. TRM is seeking through this proceeding to become an authorized dealer of scooters imported by SunL.1 Those scooters sell in the $1,450 to $1,995 price range. No evidence was presented at the hearing regarding the location or products sold by West Coast, and there is no evidence that West Coast sells SunL scooters. There are no dealers selling SunL scooters in the Pinellas County area, according to Mr. Malin. West Coast was provided due notice of the date, time, and location of the final hearing in this case. No representative of West Coast appeared at the final hearing.
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Department issue a final order dismissing West Coast’s protest and approving TRM’s proposed SunL dealership in Gulfport. DONE AND ENTERED this 12th day of March, 2007, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S T. KENT WETHERELL, II Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 12th day of March, 2007.
The Issue The issue is whether Petitioners should be allowed to establish a new point dealership for the sale of motorcycles manufactured by Taizhou Zhongneng Motorcycle Co., Ltd. (ZHNG), in Jacksonville, Florida.
Findings Of Fact On October 10, 2008, the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (Department) published a notice in the Florida Administrative Weekly. The notice advised that Galaxy Powersports, LLC d/b/a JCL International, LLC, intends to allow the establishment of Putnam City Motors, d/b/a PC Motors, as a dealership for the sale of motorcycles manufactured by Taizhou Zhongneng Motorcycle Co., Ltd. (ZHNG) at 7033 Beach Boulevard, Jacksonville, Duval County, Florida, on or after September 29, 2008. By letter received by the Department on October 31, 2008, Respondent, Roadpower USA LLC, opposed the establishment of the dealership selling the same products as Roadpower USA, LLC, within 11 miles from its established dealership. On November 14, 2008, the Department referred this matter to the Division of Administrative Hearings to conduct an evidentiary hearing. By Initial Order entered November 14, 2008, Petitioners and Respondent were required to provide certain information for the scheduling of the final hearing in this cause. None of the parties responded to the Initial Order. A Notice of Hearing by Video Teleconference was entered on December 12, 2008, scheduling this case for final hearing on May 7, 2009, at 1:00 p.m. An Order of Pre-hearing Instructions was entered that same date, which required the parties to exchange witness lists and copies of exhibits no later than seven days prior to the final hearing. Copies of the witness lists were also required to be filed with the Division of Administrative Hearings. No witness lists have been filed. At 1:00 p.m. on May 7, 2009, the final hearing was convened. The only persons present were the court reporter, who was at the Jacksonville site, and the undersigned, who was at the Tallahassee site. The undersigned waited until approximately 1:25 p.m., but neither the Petitioners nor the Respondent appeared for the final hearing. The hearing was adjourned at approximately 1:30 p.m. No one on behalf of Petitioners or Respondent contacted the undersigned’s office with any explanation of their non-appearance before the hearing was adjourned, or thereafter.
Recommendation Based on the forgoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is ORDERED: That the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles enter a final order denying Petitioners’ application for the new point dealership at issue in this case. DONE AND ENTERED this 19th day of May, 2009, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S BARBARA J. STAROS Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 19th day of May, 2009. COPIES FURNISHED: Michael James Alderman, Esquire Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room A-432 2900 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32344 Leo Su Galaxy Powersports, LLC, d/b/a JCL International, LLC 2667 Northhaven Road Dallas, Texas 75229 Pete Biltoc Claudio Biltoc Putnam City Motors, Inc. 7033 Beach Boulevard Jacksonville, Florida 32216 Jim Lee Road Power USA, LLC 927 North 3rd Street Jacksonville Beach, Florida 32250
The Issue Whether the proposed relocations of the existing Fort Lauderdale sales and service operations of Petitioner Holman Automotive, Inc. (Holman) for BMW passenger cars, BMW light trucks, and MINI passenger cars, as more particularly described in the notices of intent published by BMW of North America, LLC (BMW NA) in the Florida Administrative Weekly, should be permitted.
Findings Of Fact Based on the evidence adduced at hearing, and the record as a whole, the following findings of fact are made to supplement the factual stipulations set forth in the parties' Pre-hearing Stipulation: BMW NA is a Florida-licensed importer and distributor of BMW passenger cars and BMW light trucks (hereinafter referred to collectively as "BMW Vehicles"), as well as MINI passenger cars (MINIs). BMW passenger cars, BMW light trucks, and MINIs constitute three separate line-makes. In 2007, BMW Vehicles competed in the following luxury passenger and light truck segments: entry compact (against Acura, Audi, Saab, and Volvo models); compact wagon (against Audi, Jaguar, Saab, and Volvo models); compact sedan (against Acura, Audi, Infiniti, Jaguar, Lexus, Mercedes, Saab, and Volvo models); compact coupe (against Infiniti and Mercedes models); compact performance (against Audi models); compact convertible (against Audi, Mercedes, Saab, and Volvo models); midsize sedan (against Acura, Audi, Infiniti, Jaguar, Lexus, Mercedes, Saab, and Volvo models); midsize super performance (against Audi, Jaguar, and Mercedes models); midsize performance (against Audi, Infiniti, Jaguar, Lexus, Mercedes, and Volvo models); midsize wagon (against Audi, Mercedes, Saab, and Volvo models); specialty roadster/coupe (against Audi, Mercedes, and Porsche models); prestige sedan (against Audi, Jaguar, Lexus, and Mercedes models); prestige convertible coupe (against Jaguar, Lexus, and Mercedes models); super convertible/coupe (against Audi, Mercedes, and Porsche models); and prestige SUV (against Acura, Cadillac, Infiniti, Land Rover, Lexus, Mercedes, Porsche, Saab, Volkswagen, and Volvo models). In 2007, the MINI Cooper competed against Smart and Volkswagen models; the MINI Cooper S competed against Chevrolet, Honda, Mitsubishi, Scion, Subaru, Volkswagen and Volvo models; the MINI Cooper convertible competed against Chrysler, Pontiac, Saturn, Smart, and Volkswagen models; and the Cooper Convertible S competed against Mazda, Pontiac, Saturn, and Volkswagen models. BMW NA distributes vehicles in the United States and Puerto Rico through a network of franchised dealers. Its dealers not only sell new vehicles, they service them as well. BMW NA's free maintenance program brings customers back to the dealership for service on a regular basis. BMW NA maintains a policy of limiting the supply of vehicles available to its dealers in order to maintain pricing power. Allocation of product to each dealer is based, in part, on the Sales Planning Guide (SPG) BMW NA assigns the dealer. The higher the SPG, the greater the supply of product the dealer will be able to receive. Each dealer is assigned a "Primary Market Area" (PMA) for which it is responsible pursuant to the terms of its franchise agreement with BMW NA. The dealer's PMA is the geographic "area [comprised of aggregated zip codes] designated by BMW NA in which [the] [d]ealer is expected to focus its activities under [its] [d]ealer [a]greement [with BMW NA]. Evaluation of [the] [d]ealer's performance [under its agreement is] primarily based upon [the] [d]ealer's activities in its [PMA]." Another factor, among others, that BMW NA considers in evaluating its dealers is the "feedback from [the] [d]ealers' customers measured by the results of customer satisfaction surveys provided to [the] dealer by BMW NA." From these survey results, a Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI) is constructed in various categories for each dealer. Some dealers have more than one dealership location in the PMA for which they are responsible. These dealers exercise their discretion to determine how the product they receive from BMW NA (for their PMAs) should be divided. In 2007, in the United States and Puerto Rico, there were approximately 340 PMAs represented by BMW Vehicle dealers and 83 PMAs represented by MINI dealers. The BMW Vehicle PMAs, collectively, cover virtually the entire United States and Puerto Rico. Contrastingly, there are significant land areas in the United States and Puerto Rico that are not included in the 83 MINI PMAs. These are referred to as "unrepresented" areas. Florida has 21 BMW Vehicle PMAs (in which there are 26 dealership locations) and 8 MINI PMAs (half of which are in two counties, Broward and Miami-Dade). Holman and Vista are each Florida BMW Vehicle and MINI dealers with operations in Broward County. There are no other BMW Vehicle or MINI dealers located in Broward County. Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA covers the southern portion of Broward County and extends just over the border (to the south) into northeastern Miami-Dade County. Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA covers the northern portion of Broward County and extends just over the border (to the north) into southern Palm Beach County. The two PMAs cover Broward County in its entirety. Holman's MINI PMA covers the southeastern portion of Broward County and extends just over the border into northeastern Miami-Dade County. Vista's MINI PMA covers the northern portion of Broward County and extends just over the border into southern Palm Beach County. The southwestern portion of Broward County is unrepresented by any dealer. There are two BMW Vehicle dealers and two MINI dealers located south of Broward County in Miami-Dade County. Braman Miami operates a BMW Vehicle dealership (Braman Miami BMW) and a MINI dealership (Braman Miami MINI) from a location on Biscayne Boulevard (U.S. Route 1/Federal Highway) in the area of downtown Miami. (At this location, Braman Miami is building a "five- story parking deck with service on two floors," which will "significant[ly] expan[d]" its service capability.) To the south, there is another BMW Vehicle dealership and another MINI dealership, both run by South Motors3 (South Motors BMW and South Motors MINI, respectively). These are the only BMW Vehicle and MINI dealership locations in Miami-Dade County. Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA and its MINI PMA cover most of northern Miami-Dade County. South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA covers the southern portion of Miami-Dade County and all of Monroe County (which has no BMW Vehicle dealerships). South Motors' MINI PMA covers the remaining represented portions of Miami-Dade County (that is, those represented areas not represented by Holman's MINI PMA or Braman Miami's MINI PMA). (Monroe County has no MINI representation.) In Palm Beach County, immediately to the north of Broward County, there is one BMW Vehicle dealership location and one MINI dealership location. Both dealerships (Braman West Palm Beach BMW and Braman West Palm Beach MINI) are run by the Braman organization. Compared to Miami-Dade County and Palm Beach County, Broward County has two and four times, respectively, as many BMW Vehicle dealership locations. It has the same number of MINI dealership locations as Miami-Dade County and twice as many as Palm Beach County. Holman has two BMW Vehicle dealership locations in Broward County, a "primary" location in the downtown Fort Lauderdale area (Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale) and a "satellite" location in Pembroke Pines (Holman BMW Pembroke Pines). Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's sales facility is located at 1400 South Federal Highway, 21.5 miles (by air) north of Braman Miami BMW (22.3 miles, if driving). This location puts it on a well traveled north-south pathway to downtown Fort Lauderdale. Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's sales facility is staffed by 16 new BMW Vehicle sales consultants, the maximum amount the facility can accommodate. Saturdays are particularly busy days at the facility. To decrease the amount of time customers have to wait to be helped, Holman has "ma[d]e it mandatory for every sales consultant to work every Saturday," a move that was not well received by the sales consultants, but one that Holman believed "from a business perspective [it had to make] so that [it] had enough people on hand to handle the volume of customers that were coming through the door." The sales facility's air-conditioned showroom has enough space to display no more than seven BMW Vehicles, less than what is necessary to "have a representative sample of every [vehicle] that [Holman] sell[s]." Customers must go outside and deal with the sometimes uncomfortable south Florida weather to view other display vehicles. Customer parking at the sales facility is limited. Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's service facility is located at 1812 South Andrews Avenue, several blocks away from its sales facility. Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale has had these separate sales and service locations since the 1980s. Having sales and service facilities at different locations makes it more difficult for the sales staff to take advantage of the marketing opportunities that exist when customers come in to have their vehicles serviced, but this has not prevented Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale from being a successful and profitable dealership. (In 2007, for example, Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's business operations generated a net profit of $15 million for Holman.) Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' sales and service facilities are located at 14800 Sheridan Street in Pembroke Pines, 18.8 miles (by air) north of Braman Miami BMW (23.5 miles, if driving) and 14 miles (by air) from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's sales facility (18.3 miles, if driving). These facilities occupy 11 acres of a 17.5 acre parcel. The remainder of the parcel is occupied by a Lincoln-Mercury dealership owned by Holman. Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' service facility has 45 service stalls. Holman has a single MINI dealership location in Broward County (Holman MINI). Holman MINI's sales facility is located at 1440 South Federal Highway in Fort Lauderdale. It sits on the same 1.5 acre parcel that Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's sales facility and pre-owned vehicle operation also occupy (Holman Fort Lauderdale Parcel). There is room on the Holman Fort Lauderdale Parcel for 40 new BMW Vehicles and MINIs. Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI typically have a combined new vehicle inventory of 225 vehicles. Those new vehicles for which there is no room on the Holman Fort Lauderdale Parcel are stored off-site at a location about three miles away, near where Holman operates a Honda dealership. Also located off-site, at 1777 South Andrews Avenue in Fort Lauderdale, is Holman's in-house accounting department. Sales consultants "need[ing] to pull a deal file to get information [about] a previous customer" or needing other documents held by the accounting department are not able to retrieve them as quickly and reliably as they would if the accounting department were housed on-site. The customer parking at Holman MINI's sales facility is even more limited than it is at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's sales facility (where most MINI customers wind up having to park). There is room to display no more than three vehicles in Holman MINI's showroom. The display area is located right next to where the sales consultants sit down and talk to customers, resulting in the possibility that conversations concerning personal financial information and other private matters may be overheard by those looking at vehicles in the display area. Holman MINI shares the service facility used by Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale (Holman Fort Lauderdale Service Facility). The Holman Fort Lauderdale Service Facility has a small, four-lane combined service drive for BMW Vehicles and MINIs, which often gets "back[ed] up" in the morning when customers drop off their vehicles, as well as at the end of the day when vehicles are picked up. The facility has 37 service stalls for the BMW Vehicles and MINIs that are brought in to be serviced. In the interest of "[c]ustomer convenience," Holman has given Enterprise Rent-A-Car space in the facility to conduct rental car operations. There is a parts department located at the facility, but the space it occupies is not "big enough to store all the parts" it needs to be fully operational. As a result, parts are also kept in a "remote warehouse" located where the new vehicle inventory is stored (near the Holman Honda dealership), as well as at a body shop that Holman operates in Hollywood, Florida, near the corner of U.S. Route 1/Federal Highway and Sheridan Street. There are a total of 150 spaces available for parking vehicles at or around the Holman Fort Lauderdale Service Facility, 79 of which are across the street from the facility (on the west side of Andrews Avenue) and are used for employee parking and to "stage the [vehicles] waiting to be [serviced]." These 79 spaces are leased on a month-to-month basis. Under the terms of the lease, no overnight parking is allowed, so any vehicles in these spaces must be moved to the service facility before closing time. As a general rule, customers can get same day appointments to have their vehicles serviced at the Holman Fort Lauderdale Service Facility. There are "always . . . enough slots to handle emergencies," but "from time to time," during busy periods, it may take as long as two weeks to get an appointment for a regularly scheduled maintenance visit. Vista, like Holman, has two BMW Vehicle dealership locations in Broward County, a "primary" location in Coconut Creek (Vista BMW Coconut Creek) and a "satellite" location in the downtown Pompano Beach area (Vista BMW Pompano Beach). (Although they each have two BMW Vehicle dealership locations in Broward County, Vista and Holman are assigned only one PMA each.) Vista BMW Coconut Creek's sales and service facilities are located at 4401 Sample Road in Coconut Creek, which is 33 miles (by air) from Braman Miami BMW (34.7 miles, if driving); 12.1 miles (by air) from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's sales facility (14.5 miles, if driving); and 19.7 miles (by air) from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines (25.8 miles, if driving). Vista BMW Pompano Beach's sales and services facilities are located at 744 North Federal Highway in Pompano Beach, which is 31 miles (by air) from Braman Miami BMW (32.8 miles, if driving); 9.5 miles (by air) from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's sales facility (10.5 miles, if driving); 21 miles (by air) from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines (26.8 miles, if driving); and 5.6 miles (by air) from Vista BMW Coconut Creek (8 miles, if driving). The service facility at this location has 34 service stalls. Vista has a single MINI dealership location in Broward County (Vista MINI). Vista MINI and Holman MINI are currently the two closest MINI dealerships in the State of Florida. Vista MINI's sales and service facilities are located at 4401 Sample Road in Coconut Creek (on the same campus as Vista BMW Coconut Creek). Vista has a total of 51 service stalls on its Coconut Creek campus. Prior to 2002, in Broward County, there were only two BMW Vehicle dealership locations and no MINI dealership locations. The two BMW Vehicle dealership locations were both east of I-95. One was Holman BMW Forth Lauderdale. The other was a Vista dealership operation at 700 North Federal Highway in Pompano Beach. Holman MINI and Vista MINI were opened in March 2002 and October 2003, respectively. Holman's decision to house its MINI operations at its existing BMW Vehicle facility in the downtown Fort Lauderdale area resulted in a reduction in the amount of space it had available there for BMW sales and service operations. BMW NA prefers (but does not require) that its MINI dealerships with sales volumes similar to that of Holman MINI be located in exclusive facilities and not co-located with BMW operations. In October 2003, Vista also moved its BMW Vehicle dealership (which at the time had only one location) from 700 North Federal Highway in Pompano Beach to newly-constructed facilities at 4401 Sample Road in Coconut Creek (the present site of Vista BMW Coconut Creek). Vista spent $21 million to build the Coconut Creek campus that houses its BMW Vehicle and MINI dealerships. In December 2003, a third BMW Vehicle dealership location, Holman BMW Pembroke Pines, was opened in Broward County. In November 2004, the Department entered a Final Order authorizing Vista to establish an additional dealership location at 744 North Federal Highway in Pompano Beach, which was "next door" to, and just north of, the site it had vacated when it had moved its BMW Vehicle dealership to Coconut Creek in October 2003. An "old Daewoo facility" had been located at 744 Federal Highway. Vista purchased and subsequently renovated the site, at a cost of $5.5 million. In April 2006, Vista opened Vista BMW Pompano Beach (the authorized additional dealership location), bringing to four the total number of BMW dealership locations in Broward County, two east of I-95 (Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Vista BMW Pompano Beach) housed in smaller, older facilities typical of urban dealerships and two in the faster-growing area west of I-95 (Holman BMW Pembroke Pines and Vista BMW Coconut Creek) housed in large, modern, state-of-the-art facilities. Although it opened the Pompano Beach dealership location, Vista still had "additional plans for expansion and renovation" for which it needed local governmental approval. Vista has only recently obtained this approval, and it has not yet begun this planned expansion and renovation project. Since returning to the Pompano Beach area in April 2006, after a two-and-a-half-year absence, Vista has attempted to build back up its business in that part of the county. These efforts, which are ongoing, have included making substantial expenditures for advertising. In reconfiguring and expanding the BMW Vehicle dealer network in Broward County to make its products and services more conveniently accessible to customers in the area, and in adding MINI representation in the county, BMW NA worked with its existing dealers, Vista and Holman, in an effort to allow them to grow with the market. Calendar year 2007 was the first complete calendar year that Broward County had as many BMW Vehicle dealership locations as it presently has.4 It was also the most recent period for which a full, calendar year's worth of sales data was available at the time of the final hearing. In 2007, there were 3,664 new BMW passenger cars registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA, 2,126 of them sold by Holman, 801 of them sold by Vista, 356 of them sold by Braman Miami, 108 of them sold by South Motors, and 89 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 3,388 new BMW passenger cars registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA, 2,101 of them sold by Vista, 563 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach, 402 of them sold by Holman, 61 of them sold by Braman Miami, and 24 of them sold by South Motors. In 2007, there were 4,008 new BMW passenger cars registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA, 1,792 of them sold by Braman Miami BMW, 939 of them sold by South Motors, 595 of them sold by Holman, 382 of them sold by Vista, and 70 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 2,587 new BMW passenger cars registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA, 1,548 of them sold by South Motors, 636 of them sold by Braman Miami, 144 of them sold by Holman, 111 of them sold by Vista, and 36 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 2,048 new BMW passenger cars registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA, 1,457 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach, 261 of them sold by Vista, 49 of them sold by Holman, 23 of them sold by Braman Miami, and 13 of them sold by South Motors. In 2007, Holman sold a total of 3,392 new Florida- registered BMW passenger cars. Of this number, 62.68% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 17.54% were registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA; 11.85% were registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA; 4.25% were registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA; and 1.44% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 58.02% did so from Holman; 21.86% did so from Vista; 9.80% did so from Braman Miami; 2.95% did so from South Motors; and 2.43% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, Vista sold a total of 3,726 new Florida- registered BMW passenger cars.5 Of this number, 56.39% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 21.50% were registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA; 10.25% were registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA; 7% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA; and 2.98% were registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 62.01% did so from Vista; 16.62% did so from Braman West Palm Beach; 11.87% did so from Holman; 1.80% did so from Braman Miami; and 0.71% did so from South Motors. In 2007, Braman Miami sold a total of 2,917 new Florida-registered BMW passenger cars. Of this number, 61.43% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 21.80% were registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA; 12.31% were registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA; 2.09% were registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA; and 0.79% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 44.71% did so from Braman Miami; 23.43% did so from South Motors; 14.85% did so from Holman; 9.53% did so from Vista; and 1.75% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, South Motors sold a total of 2,681 new Florida-registered BMW passenger cars. Of this number, 57.74% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 35.02% were registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA; 4.03% were registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA; 0.90% were registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA; and 0.48% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 59.84% did so from South Motors; 24.58% did so from Braman Miami; 5.57% did so from Holman; 4.29% did so from Vista; and 1.39% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, Braman West Palm Beach sold a total of 2,389 new Florida-registered BMW passenger cars. Of this number, 60.99% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 23.57% were registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA; 3.73% were registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA; 2.93% were registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA; and 1.51% were registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 71.14% did so from Braman West Palm Beach; 12.74% did so from Vista; 2.39% did so from Holman; 1.12% did so from Braman Miami; and 0.63% did so from South Motors. In 2007, in terms of total sales of new BMW passenger cars, Vista, Holman, Braman Miami, South Motors, and Braman West Palm Beach were the number one, two, three, six, and eight dealers, respectively, in the United States. (In 2006, Vista was number one, Holman was number two, Braman West Palm Beach was number four, Braman Miami was number five, and South Motors was number seven. In 2008, as of October 9, 2008, Vista was number one, Holman was number two, Braman Miami was number three, South Motors was number six, and Braman West Palm Beach was number nine.) In 2007, there were 848 new BMW light trucks registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA, 494 of them sold by Holman, 202 of them sold by Vista, 70 of them sold by Braman Miami, 21 of them sold by South Motors, and 20 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 672 new BMW light trucks registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA, 430 of them sold by Vista, 95 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach, 78 of them sold by Holman, 17 of them sold by Braman Miami, and 4 of them sold by South Motors. In 2007, there were 1,103 new BMW light trucks registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA, 510 of them sold by Braman Miami, 256 of them sold by South Motors, 147 of them sold by Holman, 86 of them sold by Vista, and 18 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 567 new BMW light trucks registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA, 363 of them sold by South Motors, 96 of them sold by Braman Miami, 37 of them sold by Vista, 34 of them sold by Holman, and 10 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 445 new BMW light trucks registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA, 342 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach, 50 of them sold by Vista, 6 of them sold by Holman, 4 of them sold by Braman Miami, and 1 of them sold by South Motors. In 2007, Holman sold a total of 772 new Florida- registered BMW light trucks. Of this number, 63.99% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 19.04% were registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA; 10.10% were registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA; 4.40% were registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA; and 0.78% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 58.25% did so from Holman; 23.82% did so from Vista; 8.25% did so from Braman Miami; 2.48% did so from South Motors; and 2.36% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, Vista sold a total of 824 new Florida- registered BMW light trucks. Of this number, 52.18% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 24.51% were registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA; 10.44% were registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA; 6.07% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA; and 4.49% were registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 63.99% did so from Vista; 14.14% did so from Braman West Palm Beach; 11.61% did so from Holman; 2.53% did so from Braman Miami; and 0.60% did so from South Motors. In 2007, Braman Miami sold a total of 706 new Florida- registered BMW light trucks. Of this number, 72.24% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 13.60% were registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA; 9.92% were registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA; 2.41% were registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA; and 0.57% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 46.24% did so from Braman Miami; 23.21% did so from South Motors; 13.33% did so from Holman; 7.80% did so from Vista; and 1.63% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, South Motors sold a total of 648 new Florida- registered BMW light trucks. Of this number, 56.02% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 39.51% were registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA; 3.24% were registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA; 0.62% were registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA; and 0.15% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 64.02% did so from South Motors; 16.93% did so from Braman Miami; 6.53% did so from Vista; 6.00% did so from Holman; and 1.76% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, Braman West Palm Beach sold a total of 516 new Florida-registered BMW light trucks. Of this number, 66.28% were registered in its BMW Vehicle PMA; 18.41% were registered in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA; 3.86% were registered in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA; 3.49% were registered in Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA; and 1.94% were registered in South Motors' BMW Vehicle PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Braman West Palm Beach's BMW Vehicle PMA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 76.85% did so from Braman West Palm Beach; 11.24% did so from Vista; 1.35% did so from Holman; 0.90% did so from Braman Miami; and 0.22% did so from South Motors. In 2007, in terms of total sales of new BMW light trucks, Vista, Braman Miami, Holman, and South Motors, were the number one, three, four, and five dealers, respectively, in the United States, with Braman West Palm Beach not making the top ten. (In 2006, Holman was number one, Vista was number two, South Motors was number three, and Braman Miami was number four, with Braman West Palm Beach again not making the top ten. In 2008, as of October 9, 2008, Vista was number one, Holman was number two, Braman Miami was number three, South Motors was number six, and Braman West Palm Beach was number nine.) Broward County is also home to the number one (in total sales volume) Lexus, Infiniti, Porsche, and Volkswagen dealership locations in the United States. In 2007, there were 346 new MINIs registered in Holman's MINI PMA, 182 of them sold by Holman, 67 of them sold by Braman Miami, 66 of them sold by Vista, 11 of them sold by South Motors, and 8 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 309 new MINIs registered in Vista's MINI PMA, 197 of them sold by Vista, 45 of them sold by Holman, 43 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach, 10 of them sold by Braman Miami, and 3 of them sold by South Motors. In 2007, there were 804 new MINIs registered in Braman Miami's MINI PMA, 523 of them sold by Braman Miami, 180 of them sold by South Motors, 55 of them sold by Holman, 27 of them sold by Vista, and 6 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 370 new MINIs registered in South Motors' MINI PMA, 231 of them sold by South Motors, 99 of them sold by Braman Miami, 19 of them sold by Holman, 16 of them sold by Vista, and 3 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, there were 247 new MINIs registered in Braman West Palm Beach's MINI PMA, 179 of them sold by Braman West Palm Beach, 40 of them sold by Vista, 11 of them sold by Holman, and 7 of them sold by Braman Miami. South Motors sold none of these new MINIs. In 2007, Holman sold a total of 457 new Florida- registered MINIs.6 Of this number, 39.82% were registered in its MINI PMA; 12.04% were registered in Braman Miami's MINI PMA; 9.85% were registered in Vista's MINI PMA; 4.16% were registered in South Motors' MINI PMA; and 2.41% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's MINI PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Holman's MINI PMA purchasing new MINIs, 52.60% did so from Holman; 19.36% did so from Braman Miami; 19.08% did so from Vista; 3.18% did so from South Motors; and 2.31% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, Vista sold a total of 419 new Florida- registered MINIs. Of this number, 47.02% were registered in its MINI PMA; 15.75% were registered in Holman's MINI PMA; 9.55% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's MINI PMA; 6.44% were registered in Braman Miami's MINI PMA; and 3.82% were registered in South Motors' MINI PMA.. In 2007, of the consumers in Vista's MINI PMA purchasing new MINIs, 63.75% did so from Vista; 14.56% did so from Holman; 13.92% did so from Braman West Palm Beach; 3.24% did so from Braman Miami; and 0.97% did so from South Motors. In 2007, Braman Miami sold a total of 789 new Florida-registered MINIs. Of this number, 66.29% were registered in its MINI PMA; 12.55% were registered in South Motors' MINI PMA; 8.49% were registered in Holman's MINI PMA; 1.27% were registered in Vista's MINI PMA; and 0.89% were registered in Braman West Palm Beach's MINI PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in Braman Miami's MINI PMA purchasing new MINIs, 65.05% did so from Braman Miami; 22.39% did so from South Motors; 6.84% did so from Holman; 3.36% did so from Vista; and 0.75% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, South Motors sold a total of 467 new Florida-registered MINIs. Of this number, 49.46% were registered in its MINI PMA; 38.54% were registered in Braman Miami's MINI PMA; 2.36% were registered in Holman's MINI PMA; and 0.64% were registered in Vista's MINI PMA. There were no registrations in Braman West Palm Beach's MINI PMA. In 2007, of the consumers in South Motors' MINI PMA purchasing new MINIs, 62.43% did so from South Motors; 26.76% did so from Braman Miami; 5.14% did so from Holman; 4.32% did so from Vista; and 0.81% did so from Braman West Palm Beach. In 2007, Braman West Palm Beach sold a total of 357 new Florida-registered MINIs. Of this number, 50.14% were registered in its MINI PMA; 12.04% were registered in Vista's MINI PMA; 2.24% were registered in Holman's MINI PMA; 1.68% were registered in Braman Miami's MINI PMA; and 0.84% were registered in South Motors' MINI PMA.. In 2007, of the consumers in Braman West Palm Beach's MINI PMA purchasing new MINIs, 72.47% did so from Braman West Palm Beach; 16.19% did so from Vista; 4.45% did so from Holman; and 2.83% did so from Braman Miami. No purchases were made from South Motors. For purposes of the instant consolidated cases, and solely for the purposes of these cases, BMW NA, through its expert witness, James Anderson, created, as alternatives to the PMAs that BMW NA is contractually obligated to use in its dealings with its dealers, what Mr. Anderson termed, "Areas of Geographic Advantage" (AGAs). An AGA, as described by Mr. Anderson, is a geographic area in which each dealer or dealership location (in those PMAs having more than one dealership location) has a competitive advantage over other dealers or locations of the same line-make due solely to its geographic proximity to customers. Mr. Anderson created AGAs for Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, Holman BMW Pembroke Pines, Vista BMW Coconut Creek, Vista BMW Pompano Beach, Braman Miami BMW, South Motors BMW, Holman MINI, Vista MINI, Braman Miami MINI, and South Motors MINI. The Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale AGA consists of southeastern Broward County. The Holman BMW Pembroke Pines AGA consists of southwestern Broward County and extends just over the border into northwestern Miami-Dade County. The Vista BMW Coconut Creek AGA consists of northwestern Broward County and extends just over the border into southwestern Palm Beach County. The Vista BMW Pompano Beach AGA consists of northeastern Broward County and extends just over the border into southeastern Palm Beach County. The Vista MINI AGA is very similar to its PMA. The Holman MINI AGA is larger than its PMA, covering almost all of southern Broward County. In 2007, there were 1,326 new BMW passenger cars registered in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA, 507 of them sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, 255 of them sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek, 181 of them sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines, and 141 of them sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach. In 2007, there were 2,335 new BMW passenger cars registered in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA, 1,203 of them sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines, 312 of them sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek, 219 of them sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, and 60 of them sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach. In 2007, there were 2,297 new BMW passenger cars registered in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA, 1,266 of them sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek, 174 of them sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach, 146 of them sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, and 122 of them sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. In 2007, there were 996 new BMW new passenger cars registered in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA, 399 of them sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek, 222 of them sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach, 101 of them sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, and 22 of them sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. In 2007, there were a total of 1,431 new BMW passenger cars sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale. Of this number, 35.43% were registered in its AGA; 15.30% were registered in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA; 10.20% were registered in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA; and 7.06% were registered in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA. In 2007, of the consumers in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 38.24% did so from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale; 19.23% did so from Vista BMW Coconut Creek; 13.65% did so from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines; and 10.63% did so from Vista BMW Pompano Beach. In 2007, there were a total of 1,961 new BMW passenger cars sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. Of this number, 61.35% were registered in its AGA; 9.23% were registered in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA; 6.22% were registered in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA; and 1.12% were registered in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA. In 2007, of the consumers in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 51.52% did so from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines; 13.36% did so from Vista BMW Coconut Creek; 9.38% did so from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale; and 2.57% did so from Vista BMW Pompano Beach. In 2007, there were a total of 2,865 new BMW passenger cars sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek. Of this number, 44.19% were registered in its AGA; 13.93% were registered in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA; 10.89% were registered in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA; and 8.90% were registered in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA. In 2007, of the consumers in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 55.12% did so from Vista BMW Coconut Creek; 7.58% did so from Vista BMW Pompano Beach; 6.36% did so from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale; and 5.31% did so from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. In 2007, there were a total of 861 new BMW passenger cars sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach. Of this number, 25.78% were registered in its AGA; 20.21% were registered in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA; 16.38% were registered in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA; and 6.97% were registered in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA. In 2007, of the consumers in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA purchasing new BMW passenger cars, 40.06% did so from Vista BMW Coconut Creek; 22.29% did so from Vista BMW Pompano Beach; 10.14% did so from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale; and 2.21% did so from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. In 2007, there were 291 new BMW light trucks registered in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA, 106 of them sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, 62 of them sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek, 42 of them sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines, and 25 of them sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach. In 2007, there were 540 new BMW light trucks registered in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA, 288 of them sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines, 77 of them sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek, 50 of them sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, and 15 of them sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach. In 2007, there were 470 new BMW light trucks registered in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA, 291 of them sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek, 31 of them sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, 27 of them sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach, and 19 of them sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. In 2007, there were 185 new BMW light trucks registered in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA, 80 of them sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek, 29 of them sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach, 26 of them sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, and 4 of them sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. In 2007, there were a total of 317 new BMW light trucks sold at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale. Of this number, 33.44% were registered in its AGA; 15.77% were registered in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA; 9.78% were registered in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA; and 8.20% were registered in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA. In 2007, of the consumers in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 36.43% did so from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale; 21.31% did so from Vista BMW Coconut Creek; 14.43% did so from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines; and 8.59% did so from Vista BMW Pompano Beach. In 2007, there were a total of 455 new BMW light trucks sold at Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. Of this number, 63.30% were registered in its AGA; 9.23% were registered in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA; 4.18% were registered in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA; and 0.88% were registered in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA. In 2007, of the consumers in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 53.33% did so from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines; 14.26% did so from Vista BMW Coconut Creek; 9.26% did so from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale; and 2.78% did so from Vista BMW Pompano Beach. In 2007, there were a total of 678 new BMW light trucks sold at Vista BMW Coconut Creek. Of this number, 42.92% were registered in its AGA; 11.80% were registered in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA; 11.36% were registered in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA; and 9.14% were registered in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA. In 2007, of the consumers in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 61.91% did so from Vista BMW Coconut Creek; 6.60% did so from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale; 5.74% did so from Vista BMW Pompano Beach; and 4.04% did so from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. In 2007, there were a total of 146 new BMW light trucks sold at Vista BMW Pompano Beach. Of this number, 19.86% were registered in its AGA; 18.49% were registered in Vista BMW Coconut Creek's AGA; 17.12% were registered in Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's AGA; and 10.27% were registered in Holman BMW Pembroke Pines' AGA. In 2007, of the consumers in Vista BMW Pompano Beach's AGA purchasing new BMW light trucks, 43.24% did so from Vista BMW Coconut Creek; 15.68% did so from Vista BMW Pompano Beach; 14.05% did so from Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale; and 2.16% did so from Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. Holman's and Vista's inability to obtain vehicles hampered their sales performances in 2007 (as well as in 2005 and 2006). They both could have sold more BMW Vehicles and MINIs during this period had BMW NA supplied them with more product. Subsequent to 2007, with deteriorating macro-economic conditions and slackening nationwide demand, supply constraints affecting Holman and Vista have dissipated, at least with respect to BMW Vehicles. The United States economy has "officially" been in recession since February 2008. There has been a "substantial contraction of economic activity since then," with the rate accelerating following the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy on September 15, 2008, which resulted in "great distress [to] the financial markets" and the "worst financial panic this country has seen since the Great Depression." Statewide, there has been the "sharpest fall in housing starts in our state's history," a record number of foreclosures, and "a very strong deceleration in population growth." Broward County has not been spared from the economic slowdown, as reflected by the fact that it has lost population and the growth in the number of those employed in the county has almost come to a halt after 16 years of impressive growth. These less than favorable market conditions resulted in fewer BMW Vehicles being sold in the United States (and by Holman and Vista) the first nine months of 2008 compared to the same period in 2007.7 In fact, in 2008, Holman even "gave cars back to BMW [NA]." Responding to these conditions, BMW NA, in or around August 2008, announced production cuts of BMW Vehicles for the United States market of approximately 12%. Production volume for 2009 is anticipated to be about the same as it was for 2008. There no doubt will be an economic recovery, but there is insufficient record evidence upon which to base a finding as to when this recovery will occur, how strong it will be, and whether it will result in the market demand for BMW Vehicles returning to pre-2008 levels. Nationally, MINI sales have bucked the industry trend and increased over the first nine months of 2008, compared to the same period the previous year, with "[v]irtually all dealers asking for more MINIs" and the "factory . . . operating very close to capacity" to keep up with demand in the United States. BMW NA is working with its existing MINI dealers in the United States to enable them "to continue to grow," and it is also "selectively adding new dealers in white [unrepresented] spots around the country where the drive to a MINI dealer would be far too far for someone to consider." Market penetration is a measure of the sales performance of a line-make in a particular geographic area relative to that of competing line-makes. To determine whether a line-make's market penetration in an area has met reasonable expectations, it is necessary to select a reasonable market penetration standard (adjusted using segmentation analysis) against which that performance can be gauged. Comparing the number of actual registrations in the area to the number of expected registrations based on the selected standard yields a registration effectiveness rating (RER), expressed as a percentage. An RER of 100% or above signifies that reasonable expectations in terms of market penetration have been met or exceeded. An RER of less than 100% means that market penetration has been below reasonable expectations. The parties differ as to the market penetration standards that should be used in the instant consolidated cases. With respect BMW passenger cars and light trucks, BMW NA and Holman advocate application of a standard consisting of the average market penetration (as adjusted) of these line-makes in the Braman Miami BMW and South Motors BMW AGAs combined (Miami BMW Standard), while Vista contends that the average market penetration (as adjusted) achieved in Florida as a whole (Florida BMW Standard) should be used. In 2007, only two of the BMW Vehicle PMAs in Florida (those of Sandy Sansing BMW in Pensacola8 and Braman Miami BMW), and less than ten percent of the BMW Vehicle PMAs in the United States, had an RER of 100% or above applying the Miami BMW Standard. The Florida BMW Standard is a lower standard than the Miami BMW Standard; however, the average market penetration of BMW Vehicles has historically been higher in Florida than it has been regionally or nationally. Applying the Florida BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the area covering Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA, Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA, and Braman Miami's BMW Vehicle PMA combined, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 108.73%, 106.44%, and 110.64%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 120.55%, 120.08%, and 120.80%, respectively. Applying the Florida BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the area covering Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA and Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA combined, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 104.16%, 103.73%, and 105.58%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 106.97%, 111.01%, and 111.61%, respectively. Applying the Miami BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the area covering Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA and Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA combined, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 88.9%, 93.9%, 90.4%, and 96.7%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 77%, 89.5%, 90.4%, and 93.7%, respectively. Applying the Florida BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 113.15%, 110.20%, and 111.26%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 111.59%, 114.85%, and 117.15%, respectively. Applying the Miami BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in Holman's BMW Vehicle PMA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 96.7%, 99.7%, 95.3%, and 101.1%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 80.4%, 92.6%, 95%, and 99.4%, respectively. Applying the Florida BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 95.59%, 97.41%, and 100%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 101.87%, 106.74%, and 105.33%, respectively. Applying the Miami BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in Vista's BMW Vehicle PMA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 81.5%, 88.3%, 85.5%, and 92.2%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 73.4%, 86%, 85.3%, and 87%, respectively. Applying the Florida BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale AGA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 110.26%, 110.61%, and 112.65%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 109.43%, 119.44%, and 115.08%, respectively. Applying the Miami BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale AGA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 94.7%, 74%, 96.7%, and 103.5%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 78.8%, 96.2%, 93.2%, and 113.2%, respectively. Applying the Florida BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the Holman BMW Pembroke Pines AGA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 118.19%, 112.48%, and 112.15%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 112.67%, 115.26%, and 116.41%, respectively. Applying the Miami BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the Holman BMW Pembroke Pines AGA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 100.8%, 101.7%, 95.9%, and 101.1%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 81.1%, 93%, 94.4%, and 90.3%, respectively. Applying the Florida BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the Vista BMW Coconut Creek AGA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 92.66%, 94.39%, and 95.95%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 102.04%, 104.21%, and 105.62%, respectively. Applying the Miami BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the Vista BMW Coconut Creek AGA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 79%, 85.4%, 81.9%, and 86.1%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 73.5%, 84.2%, 85.6%, and 86.9%, respectively. Applying the Florida BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the Vista BMW Pompano Beach AGA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 97.48%, 104.28%, and 107.56%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 100%, 114.88%, and 105.11%, respectively. Applying the Miami BMW Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the Vista BMW Pompano Beach AGA, the RERs for new BMW passenger cars were 83.2%, 94.6%, 92.3%, and 102.7%, respectively, and the RERs for new BMW light trucks were 72.1%, 92.8%, 85.3%, and 88%, respectively. The Florida BMW Standard is a reasonable market penetration standard, in contrast to the unreasonably high Miami BMW Standard; and therefore it, not the Miami BMW Standard, should be used to determine the pertinent "reasonably expected market penetration." With respect MINI, BMW NA and Holman urge use of a market penetration standard reflecting MINI's average market penetration (as adjusted) in the Braman Miami MINI and South Motors MINI AGAs combined (Miami MINI Standard). Vista, on the other hand, asserts that the average market penetration attained by MINI in those portions of Florida where there is MINI representation (as adjusted) should be the benchmark (Florida Represented MINI Standard). In 2007, only one MINI PMA in Florida (Braman Miami's MINI PMA) and 16 of the 83 MINI PMAs in the United States had an RER of 100% or above applying the Miami MINI Standard. The Florida Represented MINI Standard is a lower standard than the Miami BMW Standard; however, the average market penetration of MINI has historically been higher in represented areas of Florida than it has been regionally or nationally. Applying the Florida Represented MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the area covering Holman's MINI PMA, Vista's MINI PMA, Braman Miami's MINI PMA, and the unrepresented portion of southwestern Broward County combined, the RERs for new MINIs were 111.83%, 111.76%, and 107.22%, respectively. Applying the Florida Represented MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the area covering Holman's MINI PMA and Vista's MINI PMA combined, the RERs for new MINIs were 97.12%, 91.67%, and 85.96%, respectively. Applying the Miami MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the area covering Holman's MINI PMA and Vista's MINI PMA combined, the RERs for new MINIs were 76.8%, 68.1%, 65.4%, and 71.2%, respectively. Applying the Florida Represented MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the area covering the Holman MINI AGA and Vista MINI AGA combined, the RERs for new MINIs were 96.01%, 88.79%, and 82.34%, respectively. Applying the Miami MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the area covering the Holman MINI AGA and Vista MINI AGA combined, the RERs for new MINIs were 75.9%, 66.1%, 62.9%, and 70.9%, respectively. Applying the Florida Represented MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the Holman MINI PMA, the RERs for new MINIs were 104.89%, 97.69%, and 100.87%, respectively. Applying the Miami MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the Holman MINI PMA, the RERs for new MINIs were 83.9%, 73%, 77.4%, and 79.9%, respectively. Applying the Florida Represented MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the Holman MINI AGA, the RERs for new MINIs were 102.19%, 93.50%, and 92.21%, respectively. Applying the Miami MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the Holman MINI AGA, the RERs for new MINIs were 81%, 69.9%, 71%, and 77.8%, respectively. Applying the Florida Represented MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the Vista MINI PMA, the RERs for new MINIs were 91.47%, 87.36%, and 73.40%, respectively. Applying the Miami MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the Vista MINI PMA, the RERs for new MINIs were 71.7%, 64.6%, 55.9%, and 63.9%, respectively. Applying the Florida Represented MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, and 2007, in the Vista MINI AGA, the RERs for new MINIs were 90.39%, 84.78%, and 72.24%, respectively. Applying the Miami MINI Standard, in 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008 (through June), in the Vista MINI AGA, the RERs for new MINIs were 70.9%, 62.7%, 55%, and 63.6%, respectively. The Florida Represented MINI Standard is a reasonable market penetration standard, in contrast to the unreasonably high Miami MINI Standard; and therefore it, not the Miami MINI Standard, should be used to determine pertinent "reasonably expected market penetration." BMW NA believes that the market penetration of new BMW Vehicles and new MINIs in the areas that it has identified as the relevant "communit[ies] or territor[ies]" in these cases can be improved if Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI are relocated to the Proposed Location. Vista (whose Vista BMW Coconut Creek, Vista BMW Pompano Beach, and Vista MINI dealership locations are within a 12.5 mile radius of the Proposed Location) has protested these proposed relocations, and these protests are the subject of the instant cases. BMW NA and Holman are dissatisfied with the sales and service facilities at Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale's and Holman MINI's present locations. For each of these dealerships, they would like to have facilities that are larger, and sales and service operations that are adjacent to, not distant from, each other. They also want to avoid having to make MINI customers (who often stay at the dealership and watch their vehicles being serviced) share service facilities (as they do now) with BMW Vehicle customers (with whom they generally do not share similar interests). BMW NA has established minimum standards that the facilities of its BMW Vehicle and MINI dealers must meet. These standards deal with such things as the "size of [the] showroom," the "size of the new car display area," and the "number of service stalls in the service department," and they are "based on factors such as market potential, units in operation, and potential growth." In PMAs with two dealership locations, in determining whether the dealer has facilities that are in compliance with minimum standards, the facilities at both locations are "combined" and looked at together. Notwithstanding BMW NA's and Holman's dissatisfaction with the existing facilities at the Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI dealership locations, Holman's BMW Vehicle and MINI facilities in Broward County meet the minimum standards required by BMW NA. Despite the facility-related operational challenges it faces, Holman's CSIs for its BMW Vehicle and MINI franchises are at or slightly above average, with the CSI for Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale being comparable to that for Holman BMW Pembroke Pines. Moreover, Holman is one of the highest volume BMW Vehicle dealers in the United States, and with respect to its new MINI sales, in 2007, these sales exceeded Holman's 400 unit SPG and were greater, by 38, than the new MINI sales of Holman's Broward County intrabrand competitor, Vista, which operated out of newer and more spacious facilities. According to Daniel Villani, the general manager of Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale, selling 175 new BMW Vehicles per month (2,100 per year) "pushes right up against" the limit of "what th[at] facility can handle" to "maintain an appropriate sales experience for the customers." In 2007, Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale sold a total of "a little less" than 1,800 new BMW Vehicles (1,748 of which were registered in Florida). Its sales declined in 2008. Holman made an extensive, good faith, but unsuccessful, effort over several years to find a reasonable and feasible way to have the sales and service facilities it wants for Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI without having to relocate these dealerships outside a two-mile radius of their present locations. Holman purchased the Proposed Location (for $27 million) only after having engaged in this exhaustive search. The Proposed Location is a 10-acre site that is large enough to accommodate the facilities that Holman wants to construct for Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI. These facilities would be considerably larger and more modern than those that these dealerships now have, potentially making consumers' shopping and service experiences at the dealerships more pleasant and enjoyable and improving the working conditions of the dealerships' employees. Construction of these new facilities would cost, according to Holman's current plans, between $20 and $25 million. There is no reason to believe that, if the Department approved the proposed relocations of Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI to the Proposed Location (which is already zoned appropriately "for a car dealership"), Holman would not carry through with its construction plans. No evidence was presented of any obstacles, financial or otherwise, that would prevent or deter it from doing so. Accordingly, in assessing the potential impact of these proposed relocations, it is reasonable to assume that, if the proposed relocations are approved by the Department, the planned facilities will be built at the Proposed Location. Holman will be allocated more BMW Vehicles and MINIs to sell at these larger, new facilities inasmuch as BMW NA has agreed of increase Holman's SPGs if Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI are relocated, as proposed. The Proposed Location is situated at the intersection of U.S. Route 1/Federal Highway and East Sunrise Boulevard in Fort Lauderdale, which, in 2007, had an average daily traffic count of 63,500 vehicles, 15,500 more vehicles than passed by the existing sales facilities of Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI (Existing Sales Facilities). More vehicles going to and coming from downtown Fort Lauderdale, however, travel past the Existing Sales Facilities than the Proposed Location. To state the obvious, for these motorists, the Existing Sales Facilities would be more convenient, whereas the Proposed Location would be more convenient for those who drive by it every day. The Proposed Location is in an area that the Holman organization knows well as a result of its years of experience operating Honda, Rolls-Royce, and Bentley dealerships a short distance away. There has been new development in the immediate vicinity of the Proposed Location. A new Home Depot was recently constructed and condominium apartment buildings are under construction. To the south and west is Holiday Park, next to which is an established residential neighborhood. The Proposed Location is 2.23 miles (by air) north of the Existing Sales Facilities (2.5 miles, if driving). Moving Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI to this location would situate them closer to their Vista intrabrand competitors to the north and further away from their Braman Miami intrabrand competitors to the south. The relocated dealerships would be 7.3 miles (by air) from Vista BMW Pompano Beach (8.2 miles, if driving); 10 miles (by air) from Vista BMW Coconut Creek and Vista MINI (12.4 miles, if driving); and 23.8 miles from Braman Miami BMW and Braman Miami MINI (24.8 miles, if driving), leaving consumers in northeastern Miami-Dade County and southeastern Broward County with slightly farther to travel to comparison shop for BMW and MINI products. The proposed relocations would also result in slight increases in the average distances BMW Vehicle and MINI customers in Holman's BMW Vehicle and MINI PMAs would have to travel to reach the nearest BMW or MINI dealership location. In short, the Proposed Location "is not optimal" and is less convenient "from a distance perspective" than the Existing Sales Facilities. The proposed relocation of Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale would result in Vista's BMW Vehicle dealerships losing "geographic advantage" to Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale in three zip codes (one zip code in which Vista BMW Coconut Creek currently has geographic advantage and, in 2007, 18 new BMW passenger vehicles and four new BMW light trucks sold by Vista BMW Coconut Creek were registered; and two zip codes in which Vista BMW Pompano Beach currently has geographic advantage and, in 2007, a total of 23 new BMW passenger vehicles and three new BMW light trucks sold by Vista BMW Pompano Beach were registered). The proposed relocation of Holman MINI would result in Vista MINI losing "geographic advantage" to Holman MINI in one zip code. In 2007, Vista MINI did not sell any MINIs that were registered in this zip code in which it would losing "geographic advantage." Any loss of "geographic advantage" to Holman would make it more difficult, but not impossible, for Vista to compete effectively against Holman. Vista is certainly capable of capturing sales in zip codes in which another dealer has "geographic advantage." Vista would be further disadvantaged as a result of the proposed relocations by having to compete (with respect to both BMW Vehicle and MINI sales and service) against Holman dealerships (Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI) which would have improved facilities with greater capacity, making these dealerships more formidable competitors than they would be if the status quo were maintained. The impact of the proposed relocations on Vista, if Vista were to make no changes in its operations or facilities, would likely be negative (in terms of lost sales and service business), but the evidentiary record is insufficient for the undersigned, with any degree of confidence, to quantify, in dollars, what that negative impact would be. Vista dealership operations are "extremely profitable," and the company has a "strong" balance sheet, enabling it to withstand the changes in its competitive position of the type that the proposed relocations might bring about. It is possible that Vista could make changes in its operations (such as lowering prices) or to its facilities (such as following through with its "additional plans for expansion and renovation" of Vista BMW Pompano Beach) that would overcome the disadvantages resulting from the proposed relocations and help it to maintain its competitive position. Making these changes, however, could adversely effect Vista's bottom line. Because of the increase in SPGs Holman has been promised if it relocates its Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI dealerships, Holman would gain allocation and have more BMW Vehicles and MINIs to sell if these proposed relocations were approved. This would result, were market demand to return to pre-2008 levels, in more BMW Vehicles and MINIs being sold in areas served by these Holman dealerships than would otherwise be the case, thereby benefiting BMW NA (a goal BMW NA would also be able to accomplish by simply increasing allocations to its dealers serving these areas to meet demand, without requiring any of them to relocate and build new facilities to receive these increased allocations). The evidentiary record is devoid of any evidence that BMW NA attempted to coerce Vista or any other existing dealer into consenting to the proposed relocations. Neither does the evidentiary record contain evidence that Vista is not in substantial compliance with its franchise agreements with BMW NA.9
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is hereby RECOMMENDED that the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles issue a final order denying approval of the proposed relocations of Holman BMW Fort Lauderdale and Holman MINI to the Proposed Location inasmuch as BMW NA has failed to meet its burden of proving a lack of "adequate representation" of the BMW passenger car, BMW light truck, and MINI line-makes in the Relevant Com/Ters. DONE AND ENTERED this 27th day of April, 2009, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S STUART M. LERNER Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 27th day of April, 2009.
The Issue The issue is whether Petitioners should be permitted to establish an additional dealership for the sale of motorcycles manufactured by Astronautical Bashan Motorcycle Manufacturer Company, Ltd., at 5720 North Florida Avenue, Tampa, Florida.
Findings Of Fact Based on the evidence adduced at hearing and the record as a whole, the following Findings of Fact are made: On March 7, 2008, the Florida Administrative Weekly published a notice that Peace Industry Group intended to allow the establishment of Mobility Tech as a dealership for the sale of motorcycles manufactured by BASH at 5720 North Florida Avenue in Tampa (Hillsborough County), Florida. The notice also stated that the "new point" location for the proposed dealership is in a "county of more than 300,000 population, according to the latest population estimates of the University of Florida, Bureau of Economic and Business Research." Respondent is an existing franchised dealer of motorcycles manufactured by BASH. Respondent's dealership is located at 5908 North Armenia Avenue in Tampa, Florida. The driving distance between Respondent's dealership and the location of the new dealership that Peace Industry proposes to establish is 2.05 miles.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles issue a final order denying Petitioners, Peace Industry Group, Inc., and Mobility Tech, Inc.'s, approval to establish a new BASH motorcycle dealership at 5720 North Florida Avenue, Tampa, Florida. DONE AND ENTERED this 19th day of November, 2008, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S CAROLYN S. HOLIFIELD Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 19th day of November, 2008.
The Issue The issue in this case is whether Petitioners are entitled to a motor vehicle dealership that is proposed to be located in Fort Walton Beach, Florida.
Findings Of Fact The evidence showed that the dealership proposed by Petitioners would sell the same line and make of motorcycles as those sold by Respondent. The proposed dealership would also compete in the Respondent’s territory since it would be located in the same county as Respondent and would be within 20 miles of Respondent. Respondent has standing to protest the establishment of the proposed dealership. On September 18, 2007, a Notice of Hearing setting the date, time and location of final hearing was issued in this case. The Notice of Hearing was mailed to the last known, valid addresses of the Petitioners, which were also the addresses provided in Petitioners’ Notice of Publication. Neither Notice of Hearing was returned. This cause came on for hearing as noticed. After waiting more than an hour, the Petitioners failed to appear to prosecute their claim. There has been no communication from the Petitioners before, during, or since the hearing to indicate that they would not be attending the final hearing. Because of Petitioners’ failure to appear, there was no evidence to demonstrate that Petitioners are entitled to a franchise motor vehicle dealership in Fort Walton Beach, Florida. Absent such evidence, the establishment of the proposed dealership should be denied.
Recommendation Accordingly, in consideration of the foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of law, it is RECOMMENDED that a final order be entered by the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles denying the establishment of Petitioners’ proposed franchise. DONE AND ENTERED this 31st day of January, 2008, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S DIANE CLEAVINGER Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 31st day of January, 2008. COPIES FURNISHED: Michael J. Alderman, Esquire Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room A-432 2900 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0635 Carl A. Ford, Director Division of Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room B-439 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0635 Judson M. Chapman, General Counsel Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building 2900 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0500 David Wray Wholesale Nation Automotive, Inc. 319 Miracle Strip Parkway Fort Walton Beach, Florida 32548 Mei Zhou SunL Group, Inc. 8551 Esters Boulevard Irvine, Texas 75063 Curtis Mitchell Coastal Powersports 12 Eglin Parkway Southeast Fort Walton Beach, Florida 32548
The Issue The issue in this case is whether Respondents' application to establish a dealership to sell motorcycles manufactured by Chongqing Astronautical Bashan Motorcycle Manufacturer Co., Ltd. (BASH line-make), should be approved.
Findings Of Fact Petitioner filed an “Official Notice of Protest – Petition for Determination” dated August 21, 2014, with the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (HSMV). The protest/petition opposes Respondent’s noticed intention to establish a dealership to be called Wild Hogs Scooters and Motorsports, LLC, at 1431 South Woodland Boulevard, Deland (Volusia County), Florida. Notice of that intent was duly published in the Florida Administrative Register on August 29, 2014. (There was no explanation provided as to why Petitioner’s protest/petition was filed before the publication of the notice.) Petitioner’s protest/petition asserts that Respondent’s proposed new dealership will be located “within our territory.” Petitioner further asserts that Peace Industry Group is its “number two supplier of scooters, and represents 38% of our scooter sales.” Petitioner did not appear at final hearing or present any competent evidence to support these allegations. Respondent provided evidence suggesting that Petitioner has only purchased seven motor-scooters from Peace Industry Group. Petitioner did not appear at final hearing and present evidence as to its “standing to protest” as required by section 320.642(3), Florida Statutes. (Unless specifically stated otherwise herein, all references to Florida Statutes will be to the 2014 version.) Conversely, Respondent presented evidence that Petitioner’s dealership in Deland, Florida, has closed and gone out of business. This unrefuted evidence proves that Petitioner no longer has standing to protest Respondent’s proposed new dealership in the area. The propriety of Petitioner’s protest is the only issue in this proceeding. A petitioner without standing cannot pursue such a challenge.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that a final order be entered by the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles denying Petitioner, Navitas Financial Group, Inc., d/b/a Pompano Pats Deland's protest of Respondent's proposed new dealership. DONE AND ENTERED this 12th day of January, 2015, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S R. BRUCE MCKIBBEN Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 12th day of January, 2015. COPIES FURNISHED: Jennifer Clark, Agency Clerk Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room A430 2900 Apalachee Parkway, MS 61 Tallahassee, Florida 32399 (eServed) Julie Baker, Chief Bureau of Issuance Oversight Division of Motorist Services Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room A-338 2900 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0635 (eServed) Steve Hurm, General Counsel Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room A-432 2900 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0500 (eServed) Meiredith Huang Peace Industry Group (USA), Inc. 2649 Mountain Industrial Boulevard Tucker, Georgia 30084 Patrick M. Johnson The Navitas Financial Group, Inc. 2075 South Woodland Boulevard Deland, Florida 32720 Jeff Rupp Wild Hogs Scooters and Motorsports, LLC 1861 Marysville Drive Deltona, Florida 32725 G. Michael Smith, Esquire Smith Collins, LLC 8565 Dunwoody Place Building 15 Atlanta, Georgia 30350 (eServed)
The Issue The issue in the case is whether an application for a new point franchise motor vehicle dealership filed by El Sol Trading, Inc., and Fishers Auction Services, Inc., d/b/a Fisher Auto Equipment Sales (Petitioners), should be approved.
Findings Of Fact There was no evidence presented at the hearing to establish that Respondent has a franchise agreement to sell or service SHEN motor vehicles, the line-make to be sold by Cycles and More, Inc. There was no evidence presented at the hearing that Respondent's dealership is physically located so as to meet the statutory requirements for standing to protest the establishment of the new point franchise motor vehicle dealership.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Department enter a final order dismissing the protest filed in this case by Cycles and More, Inc., and granting Petitioners' request to establish a new point franchise motor vehicle dealership for the sale of SHEN motorcycles. DONE AND ENTERED this 7th day of July, 2010, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S JAMES H. PETERSON, III Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 7th day of July, 2010. COPIES FURNISHED: Gloria Ma El Sol Trading, Inc., d/b/a Motobravo, Inc. 19877 Quiroz Court City of Industry, California 91789 Raymond L. Fisher Fishers Auction Services, Inc., d/b/a Fisher Auto Equipment Sales 119 Dixwood Avenue Edgewood, Florida 32132 Jeanne Ciriello Cycles & More, Inc. 5797 South Ridgewood Avenue Port Orange, Florida 32127 Carl A. Ford, Director Division of Motor Vehicles Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room B-439 2900 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0500 Robin Lotane, General Counsel Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building 2900 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0500
Conclusions This matter came before the Department for entry of a Final Order upon submission of an Order Closing File by Stuart M. Lerner, Administrative Law Judge of the Division of Administrative Hearings, pursuant to Petitioner's Notice Of Voluntary Dismissal, a copy of which is attached and incorporated by reference in this order. The Department hereby adopts the Order Closing File as its Final Order in this matter. Accordingly, it is hereby ORDERED that this case is CLOSED. Filed December 3, 2010 4:44 PM Division of Administrative Hearings DONE AND ORDERED this ,,,11L day of December, 2010, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. r Division of Motor Vehicles Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building Tallahassee, Florida 32399 Filed with the Clerk of the Divist Motor Vehicles .,,,, -- u -'" this day of December, 2010. N . DNlerl5cenMAdmlnlstralor NOTICE OF APPEAL RIGHTS Judicial review of this order may be had pursuant to section 120.68, Florida Statutes, in the District Court of Appeal for the First District, State of Florida, or in any other district comt of appeal of this state in an appellate district where a party resides. In order to initiate such review, one copy of the notice of appeal must be filed with the Department and the other copy of the notice of appeal, together with the filing fee, must be filed with the court within thirty days of the filing date of this order as set out above, pursuant to Rules of Appellate Procedure. CAF/vlg Copies furnished: Dean Bunch, Esquire Nelson, Mullins, Riley & Scarborough LLP 3600 Maclay Boulevard South, Suite 202 Tallahassee, Florida 32312 A. Edward Quinton III, Esquire Adams, Quinton & Paretti, P. A. Brickell Bayview Center 80 Southwest 8th Street, Suite 2150 Miami, Florida 33130 Stuart M. Lerner Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550 Nalini Vinayak Dealer License Administrator
Conclusions This matter came before the Department for entry of a Final Order upon submission of an Order Closing File and Relinquishing Jurisdiction by Jessica E. Varn, Administrative Law Judge of the Division of Administrative Hearings, pursuant to Petitioner’s Notice Of Withdrawal of Proposed Dealer Agreement from Consideration by Respondents and Motion to Dismiss as Moot, a copy of which is attached and incorporated by reference in this order. The Department hereby adopts the Order Closing File and Relinquishing Jurisdiction as its Final Order in this matter. Accordingly, it is hereby ORDERED that this case is CLOSED. DONE AND ORDERED this AY day of May, 2013, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. Bureau of Issuance Oversight Division of Motorist Services Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room A338 Tallahassee, Florida 32399 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Motorist Services this 4 day of May, 2013. NOTICE OF APPEAL RIGHTS Judicial review of this order may be had pursuant to section 120.68, Florida Statutes, in the District Court of Appeal for the First District, State of Florida, or in any other district court of appeal of this state in an appellate district where a party resides. In order to initiate such review, one copy of the notice of appeal must be filed with the Department and the other copy of the notice of appeal, together with the filing fee, must be filed with the court within thirty days of the filing date of this order as set out above, pursuant to Rules of Appellate Procedure. JB/jdc Copies furnished: Dean Bunch, Esquire Nelson, Mullins, Riley and Scarborough, LLP 3600 Maclay Boulevard South, Suite 202 Tallahassee, Florida 32312 dean.bunch@nelsonmullins.com John W. Forehand, Esquire South Motors Automotive Group 16165 South Dixie Highway Miami, Florida 33157 john.forehand@southmotors.net David Seymour Leibowitz, Esquire Braman Management Association 2060 Biscayne Boulevard, 2"! Floor Miami, Florida 33137 davidl|@bramanmanagement.com Richard N. Sox, Esquire Bass Sox Mercer, P.A. 2822 Remington Green Circle Tallahassee, Florida 32308 rsox@dealerlawyer.com Jessica E. Varn Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550 Nalini Vinayak Dealer License Administrator STATE OF FLORIDA DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, vs. SOUTH MOTOR COMPANY OF DADE COUNTY, d/b/a SOUTH MOTORS BMW, Respondent. BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, vs. POMPANO IMPORTS, INC., Respondent. BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, vs. POMPANO IMPORTS, INC., Respondent. a a aU OOOO ee Oe eee Case No. Case No. Case No. 12-3385 12-3386 12-3387 BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, vs. Case No. 12-3389 SARASOTA AUTOMOTIVE MANAGEMENT, LLC, d/b/a BMW OF SARASOTA BERT SMITH OLDSMOBILE, INC., d/b/a BERT SMITH INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL EUROCARS, INC., d/b/a CAPITAL BMW IMPORT CITY, INC., d/b/a QUALITY BMW REEVES IMPORT MOTORCARS, INC., Respondents. BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, _ Petitioner, vs. Case No. 12-3390 BRAMAN MOTORS, INC., d/b/a BRAMAN BMW PALM BEACH IMPORTS, INC., d/b/a BRAMAN MOTORCARS, Respondents. ORDER CLOSING FILES AND RELINQUISHING JURISDICTION This case came before the undersigned on the Petitioner's Notice of Withdrawal of Proposed Dealer Agreement from Consideration by Respondents and Motion to Dismiss as Moot, filed January 29, 2013, and the undersigned being fully advised, it is, therefore, ORDERED that: 1. The final hearing scheduled for May 13 through 17, 2013, is canceled. 2. The files of the Division of Administrative Hearings are closed. Jurisdiction is relinquished to the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles. DONE AND ORDERED this llth day of February, 2013, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. aw JESSICA E. VARN Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 11th day of February, 2013. COPIES FURNISHED: Jennifer Clark, Agency Clerk Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Neil Kirkman Building, Room A-430 2900 Apalachee Parkway, Mail Stop 61 Tallahassee, Florida 32399 John W. Forehand, Esquire South Motors Automotive Group 16165 South Dixie Highway Miami, Florida 33157 john. forehand@southmotors.net Dean Bunch, Esquire Nelson, Mullins, Riley, and Scarborough LLP Suite 202 3600 Maclay Boulevard, South Tallahassee, Florida 32312 dean.bunch@nelsonmullins.com David Seymour Leibowitz, Esquire Braman Management Association 2nd Floor 2060 Biscayne Boulevard Miami, Florida 33137 davidl@bramanmanagement.com Richard N. Sox, Esquire Bass Sox Mercer, P.A. 2822 Remington Green Circle Tallahassee, Florida 32308 rsox@dealerlawyer.com STATE OF FLORIDA DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, v8. Case No. 12-3385 SOUTH MOTOR COMPANY OF DADE COUNTY, d/b/a SOUTH MOTORS BMW, Respondent. BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, vs. Case No. 12-3386 POMPANO IMPORTS, INC., d/b/a Vista BMW of Pompano Beach, Respondent. BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, vs. . Case No. 12-3387 POMPANO IMPORTS, INC., d/b/a Vista BMW of Coconut Creek, Respondent. Filed January 29, 2013 8:53 AM Division of Administrative Hearings BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, vs. SARASOTA AUTOMOTIVE MANAGEMENT, LLC, d/b/a BMW OF SARASOTA; BERT SMITH OLDSMOBILE, INC., d/b/a" BERT SMITH INTERNATIONAL; CAPITAL EUROCARS, INC., d/b/a CAPITAL BMW; IMPORT CITY, INC., d/b/a QUALITY BMW; and REEVES IMPORT MOTORCARS, INC., Respondents. BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, Petitioner, vs. BRAMAN MOTORS, INC., d/b/a BRAMAN BMV, and PALM BEACH IMPORTS, INC., d/b/a BRAMAN MOTORCARS, Respondents. Case No. 12-3389 Case No. 12-3390 NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF PROPOSED DEALER AGREEMENT FROM CONSIDERATION BY RESPONDENTS AND MOTION TO DISMISS AS MOOT Comes now BMW of North America, LLC ("BMW NA") and notifies the Administrative Law Judge that it has withdrawn its notice to Respondents concerning the proposed dealer agreement which is the subject of this proceeding. withdrawal of notice, BMW NA moves to dismiss this matter as moot. motion, BMW NA states: As a result of this In support of its 1. On July 17, 2012, BMW NA notified Respondents of its intent to offer them the superseding/merged BMW Center Agreement for BMW passenger cars and BMW light trucks ("the Merged Agreement"), which was proposed to supersede, modify and replace the existing BMW Dealer Agreement for BMW passenger cars and the existing BMW SAV Center Agreement for BMW light trucks (collectively "the Existing Agreements"). 2. Respondents filed complaints with the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles ("DHSMV"), contesting the terms of the proposed Merged Agreement. These complaints were transferred by the DHSMV to the Division of Administrative Hearings. 3. On January 29, 2013, BMW NA, by letters attached hereto as Exhibit A, notified Respondents, as follows: BMW of North America, LLC ("BMW NA") hereby withdraws its notice, transmitted to you on July 17, 2012, with respect to the superseding/merged BMW Center Agreement (‘Agreement’) for BMW passenger cars and BMW light trucks. You and your successors may remain on your current forms of: dealer agreements: the BMW Dealer Agreement for BMW passenger cars (‘Old Agreement’) and the BMW SAV Center Agreement for BMW light trucks (‘SAV Center Agreement') or sign the Agreement which was offered to you, at any time in the future. 4. Inasmuch as BMW NA has withdrawn the July 17, 2012 notice that entitled Respondents to file their protests, and confirmed to Respondents that they and their successors', have the option to remain on the Existing Agreements unless, at any time in the future, they elect to sign the Merged Agreement, Respondents’ protests should now be dismissed as moot. ' Motor vehicle dealerships, and equity interests therein, are transferable to buyers as provided in Section 320.643, Florida Statutes. 3 Respectfully submitted, Lh. bL Dean Bunch dean.bunch@nelsonmullins.com C. Everett Boyd, Jr. everett. boyd@nelsonmullins.com Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP 3600 Maclay Blvd., S., Suite 202 Tallahassee, FL 32312 Telephone: (850)907-2505 Attorneys for BMW of North America, LLC CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that the forgoing was served by electronic transmission, this at day of January, 2013, upon the following: | Jennifer Clerk, Agency Clerk clark. jennifer@hsmv.state.fl.us Dept. of Highway Safety Neil Kirkman Bldg., Room A-430 2900 Apalachee Parkway, Mail Stop 61 Tallahassee, FL 32399 John W. Forehand, Esq. john. forehand@southmotors.net 16165 South Dixie Highway Miami, FL 33157 Richard N. Sox, Esq. rsox@dealerlawyer.com Nicholas A. Bader, Esq. nbader@dealerlawyer.com 2822 Remington Green Circle Tallahassee, FL 32308 David Leibowitz, Esq. davidl@bramanmanagement.com Timothy Grecsek, Esq. timothyg@bramanmanagement.com Braman Management Association 2060 Biscayne Bivd., Second Floor Miami, FL 33137 ~ Attorney
