The Issue Whether or not on or about October 31, 1975, the Respondents, Bossie Mae and Willie Mae Browdy, licensed under the beverage laws as a package store, and/or their agent, servant or employee, to wit: Bossie Mae Browdy did allow or permit the consumption of alcoholic beverages on their licensed premises, contrary to Rule 7A-3.05, Florida Administrative Code. Whether or not on or about November 1, 1975, the Respondents, Bossie Mae and Willie Mae Browdy, licensed under the beverage laws as Browdy's Mini Market with a 2-APS license to wit: Bossie Mae Browdy did allow gambling (card) on the licensed premises, contrary to Section 849.08, Florida Statutes and in violation of Section 561.29, Florida Statutes.
Findings Of Fact At present, and on October 31, 1975 and November 1, 1975, the Respondents, Bossie Mae and Willie Mae Browdy are and were the holders of a beverage license with the State of Florida, Division of Beverage number 69-299, 2-APS. On October 31, 1975, Eugene Fogel, a Division of Beverage enforcement officer entered the premises licensed by the State of Florida, Division of Beverage, which was operated by the Respondents at Avenue B on Chuluota Road, Oviedo, Florida. While in the store he observed an unknown black female consuming a beverage which was marked Millers High-Life. This consumption was taking place in the presence of the Respondent, Bossie Mae Browdy, and in the course of the consumption a conversation was taking place between the unknown black female and Bossie Mae Browdy. The bottle which Officer Fogel observed was marked with identifying information which the officer based upon his experience, felt indicated that it contained an alcoholic beverage. On November 1, 1975, officer Fogel returned to the licensed premises of the Respondents and entered into a card game in a porch like area which is immediately at the front of the store and connected to the store. This card game was between Fogel and several black males who were participating in a card game when he approached. The game took place over 45 minutes and money was exchanged at 25 cents a game for the winner, for a total amount of approximately $2.00. During the course of the game, Bossie Mae Browdy came to the door and looked out at the card game being played.
Recommendation It is recommended that the Respondents, Bossie Mae and Willie Mae Browdy, be fined in the amount of $100 for the offense as established through this administrative complaint. DONE and ENTERED this 24th day of November, 1976, in Tallahassee, Florida. CHARLES C. ADAMS, Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings Room 530, Carlton Building Tallahassee, Florida 32304 (904) 488-9675 COPIES FURNISHED: Charles Curtis, Esquire Division of Beverage The Johns Building Tallahassee, Florida 32304 Carl Thompson, Esquire 25 South Magnolia Avenue Orlando, Florida 32801
Findings Of Fact 1718, Inc. held alcoholic beverage license number 58- 1581, Series 2-Cop; for the premises of the Fox Hunter, 1718 South Orange Avenue, Orlando, Florida, at all times relevant to these proceedings. The license was issued on June 18, 1981. Although the testimony of Captain Jack B. Wallace that John and Fay Knight (Knights) were the owners of the real property located at 1718 South Orange, Orlando, Florida, went unrebutted, the record does not reveal the date when John and Fay Knight became the owners of the real property located at 1718 South Orange Street, Orlando, Florida. The Knights were absentee landlords and leased the premises to 1718, Inc. d/b/a/ Fox Hunter (Fox Hunter) through a real estate agency in Orlando, Florida. On June 3, 1985 Petitioners mailed a letter to the Knights informing them that the alcoholic beverage license of Fox Hunter had been suspended on an emergency basis due to 13 alleged sales of narcotics on the premises by employees of Fox Hunter; that Respondent had requested a hearing on the charges; that Petitioner would seek license revocation with prejudice as provided in Section 561.58, Florida Statutes (1983); that the Petitioner would present evidence at the hearing in support of license revocation with prejudice; and that the Knights would be advised of the date, time and location of the hearing at a later date. The record does not reveal that Petitioner ever advised the Knights as to the date, time and location of the hearing, however, counsel for Respondent announced at the time of the hearing that he would be representing the Knights. Additionally, the record does not reveal that a copy of the original or Amended Notice To Show Cause was ever furnished to the Knights. Nor does the record reveal that the Knights had any knowledge of any previous violations at the premises. On April 29, 1985, Orlando Police Officer Kerry Farney (Farney) went to the premises of Fox Hunter and spoke to dancer Joyce Travis concerning the purchase of cocaine. Joyce agreed to sell Farney a half gram for $50.00. Farney gave Joyce $55.00, including $5.00 for a dance which she performed, and Joyce returned to Farney a dollar bill wrapped around two- plastic packages of cocaine. Officer Farney returned to the Fox Hunter on April 30, 1985, and spoke with dancer Lisa Nolen a/k/a Dusty concerning the purchase of a quarter gram of cocaine. Dusty agreed to sell the cocaine and obtained $25.00 from Farney. She later returned to Farney and handed him a plastic package containing cocaine. Officer Farney again returned to the Fox Hunter on May 2, 1985 and was later met there on this same day by Investigator Rodney Russ (Russ). The Officers arranged to purchase cocaine from the dancer Dusty. Farney gave Dusty $30.00, $5.00 for a dance and $25.00 for a quarter gram of cocaine. Russ gave Dusty $50.00 for one half gram of cocaine. After going into the dancers' locker room, Dusty returned to the officers and handed to Farney a dollar bill wrapped around two plastic packages of cocaine and asked Farney to pass it to Russ. Farney passed the cocaine wrapped in the money to Russ which Russ opened and inspected the two plastic-packages of cocaine contained therein. Later that same night Dusty delivered the cocaine to Farney which he had paid for earlier. Russ returned to the Fox Hunter on May 3, 1985 and entered into conversation with dancer Laura, who asked if he was looking for a quarter gram of cocaine. Russ stated that he wanted a half gram and Laura responded that she would see what she could do. After speaking with an unknown male patron, Laura returned to Russ and stated that all he had left was three- tenths of a gram for $30.00. Russ stated that he would take the three tenths of a gram and gave Laura $30.00. Laura again approached the unknown patron and then returned to Russ after being assured by Russ that he was not a cop or with law enforcement, placed a bill in his pocket. Russ removed and opened the bill and inspected the plastic package of cocaine. Russ returned to the Fox Hunter on May 7, 1985 and entered into conversation with the dancer Joyce concerning the purchase of a half gram of cocaine. Joyce stated that she would be able to get it later. Joyce subsequently asked Russ how much he wanted to buy and Russ responded that he wanted a half gram. Russ gave Joyce a $100.00 bill and she went into the women's dressing room. Joyce later returned to Russ and gave him $25.00 change wrapped around two clear plastic packages of cocaine. Russ returned to the Fox Hunter on May 8, 1985, and was solicited by dancer Joyce for the purchase of two beers. Russ returned to the premises of the Fox Hunter on May 9, 1985, and entered into conversation with the dancer Joyce concerning the purchase of a half gram of cocaine. Joyce left Russ to talk to an unidentified black male and returned to inform Russ that she could get the half gram of cocaine from the black male after he split it up and that Russ would have delivery soon. The male went into the restroom and when he emerged from the restroom, Joyce approached him and then went into the women's restroom. After exiting the restroom, Joyce performed a dance for Russ, during which she told him to take a dollar bill out of her garter. Russ took the dollar bill and opened it up to inspect two tinfoil packages of cocaine. Russ returned to the licensed premises on May 10, 1985, and again entered into conversation with the dancer Joyce concerning the purchase of a half gram of cocaine. When Joyce agreed, Russ handed her $75.00. Joyce subsequently returned to Russ and handed him a plastic package of cocaine which Russ placed into the cellophane wrapper of his cigarette pack. Joyce stated that the person from whom she had obtained the cocaine only had a quarter gram but would be getting a delivery soon, at which time Joyce would give Russ his other quarter gram. Russ did not obtain the additional quarter gram prior to leaving the premises on this occasion. Russ returned to the Fox Hunter later the night of May 10, 1985 and spoke with Joyce about obtaining his remaining quarter gram of cocaine and she advised him that delivery had not been made. Russ then talked with dancer Laura about obtaining some cocaine. Laura first said that it would be after 2:00 a.m. when the bar closed but when Russ told her he could not wait that long she obtained a short quarter gram from an unidentified white male. Laura then left to go into the women's restroom. When she returned to Russ, Laura placed a plastic package of cocaine in his pocket stating that she had tried the substance and it was good. Russ removed the package from his pocket and inspected it. As Russ was leaving, Joyce approached him near the entrance and handed him a plastic package containing his remaining quarter gram of cocaine. Russ returned to the premises of the Fox Hunter on May 15, 1985, and was solicited by the dancer Dusty to purchase her a bottle of champagne for $5.75, which he did. Russ again went to the Fox Hunter on May 16, 1985 and entered into conversation with the dancer Laura concerning the purchase of a half gram of cocaine. Laura stated that she would be able to get him some. Laura approached and spoke to an unknown patron and the dancer Michelle, after which she went into the women's dressing room. She shortly returned to Russ and placed two plastic packages of cocaine into his pocket. On May 17, 1985, the Respondent served an Emergency Order of Suspension and Search Warrant on the Fox Hunter. Located during the search was a dollar bill wrapped around a package of cocaine, a plastic package of cocaine, a package of marijuana and several marijuana cigarettes. The sale or delivery of the cocaine on April 29, 30, 1985 and May 2, 3, 7, 9, 10, 16, 1985 to investigator Farney and Russ took place in and around the dance area of the premises. On April 20, 1982 the Respondent served a letter of warning to Fox Hunter alleging that on August 4, 1981, an employee had solicited the sale of an alcoholic beverage in violation of Section 562.131, Florida Statutes and further alleging that on October 30, 1981, an employee had delivered a controlled substance to a police officer on the premises. No proof was offered as to the disposition of those matters, or indeed, whether the incidents ever actually took place. In July, 1984, the manager of Fox Hunter --Lawrence Siegel -- apprehended one of its employees and a patron engaged in a drug transaction: he detained them and called the Orlando Police Department, and the two were taken into custody. The Petitioner's response to this action was to issue a citation against the Fox Hunter for the alleged sale, even though it was Lawrence Siegel who uncovered the transaction and apprehended the perpetrators. Mr. Siegel contacted Lt. Farmer of the Orlando Police Department and requested assistance in placing an undercover officer in the lounge as an employee. Mr. Siegel wanted to interdict narcotics and assist in the apprehension of the persons who might be dealing with them. However, the request was turned down because, as Lt. Farmer explained, the police department did not have the necessary resources to assist in this manner. The record is not clear as to the period of time Lawrence Siegel maintained contact with the police, but he did contact them about the problem, identifying suspected dealers and providing names and descriptions of vehicles. However, Jason Robaudo replaced Lawrence Siegel as night manager during this period of time. James Robaudo was present in the licensed premises during most of, if not all of, the time during which the unlawful activities accursed. Although the record is not entirely clear on the details, there were other alcoholic beverage establishments in the same general area that had been charged with the sale of controlled substances on the premises where a heavy fine plus a short license suspension had been imposed rather than a license revocation or a license revocation with prejudice.
Recommendation For all of the foregoing reasons it is RECOMMENDED that the Petitioner, Department of Business Regulation, Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco enter a Final Order revoking alcoholic beverage license number 58-1581, Series 2-COP, issued to 1718, Inc., d/b/a Fox Hunter. Respectfully submitted and entered this 3rd day of September, 1985, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. WILLIAM R. CAVE Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 FILED with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 3rd day of September, 1985. COPIES FURNISHED: Louisa E. Hargrett, Esq. Department of Business Regulation 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301-1927 Richard L. Wilson, Esq. 1212 East Ridgewood Street Orlando, Florida 32803 Howard M. Rasmussen, Director Department of Business Regulation Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco The Johns Building 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Richard B. Burroughs, Jr. Secretary Department of Business Regulation The Johns Building 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301
The Issue Should Petitioner discipline Respondent's Alcoholic Beverage License based upon Respondent's president selling, serving or giving an alcoholic beverage, on the licensed premises, to a person under the age of twenty-one contrary, to Section 562.11(1)(a), Florida Statutes?
Findings Of Fact Respondent, Rose Anne, Inc., d/b/a Scooters, holds license number 74-05039 SRX, Series 4COP issued by Petitioner for the premises located at 217 North Woodland Boulevard, Deland, Florida. Scott A. Price is the president and owner of that business. On October 22, 1997, Petitioner, through its agents, made random checks of businesses holding alcoholic beverage licenses issued by Petitioner. Those checks were made in Deland, Florida. In particular, the checks were designed to determine if businesses holding alcoholic beverage licenses were acting in compliance with the prohibition against selling, serving or giving alcoholic beverages on their licensed premises, to persons under the age of twenty-one, in violation of Section 562.11(1)(a), Florida Statutes. Respondent's premises was one of the licensed premises checked on that date. Petitioner's employees involved in the random checks included Special Agents Betty D. Adazzio, Melissa Winford and Kristin Hunt, operating with the assistance of Sergeant Steve Dovi of the Deland Police Department. The law enforcement personnel were supported in their activities by Ryan N. Luttrell, an under-aged person, who was used to determine if persons within the licensed premises under consideration would sell, serve or give Mr. Luttrell an alcoholic beverage in the licensed premises. Mr. Lutrell was born on November 23, 1978, as reflected on a Florida driver's license issued to him. That driver's license bore a picture of Mr. Luttrell which accurately depicted his appearance at the time. The license also indicated in bold print that Mr. Luttrell was under twenty-one years of age. In contact with Mr. Price, within Respondent's licensed premises, Mr. Luttrell used the license as a means of identification. Mr. Luttrell entered the licensed premises on the date in question. At that moment Mr. Price was tending the bar in the premises. Mr. Price brought Mr. Luttrell a menu and asked Mr. Luttrell if he wanted anything to drink. Mr.Luttrell told Mr. Price to give Mr. Luttrell a minute to decide. Mr. Luttrell then asked Mr. Price for a Bud Lite, an alcoholic beverage which is a beer. Mr. Luttrell also ordered cheese sticks. Mr. Price asked Mr. Luttrell for identification. Mr. Luttrell then produced the driver's license that has been described. Mr. Price briefly looked at the driver's license. Then Mr. Price took the driver's license to another area within the premises and held the license up by a chart. Mr. Price came back to where Mr. Luttrell was seated and asked what Mr. Luttrell would like. Mr. Luttrell repeated that he wanted a Bud Lite. Mr. Price filled a glass with beer and brought it back to Mr. Luttrell's location placing the glass of beer and a napkin in front of Mr. Luttrell. Mr. Price remarked that the cheese sticks would be right out. Mr. Luttrell asked Mr. Price where the bathroom was. Mr. Luttrell took the beer in the glass with him and took a sample of the beer and placed it in a vial. Mr. Luttrell went back to the bar area, and in further conversation with Mr. Price, Mr. Luttrell claimed that his pager had gone off, and used that excuse as a reason to exit the licensed premises. Once outside, Mr. Luttrell realized that he had not paid for the beer and Agent Adazzio sent Mr. Luttrell back into the premises to pay it. Mr. Luttrell re-entered the premises. Mr. Price was still behind the bar. Mr. Luttrell paid Mr. Price for the beer that Mr. Price had given Mr. Luttrell. Mr. Luttrell then again exited the licensed premises. At the time of the incident Respondent was not qualified as a Responsible Vendor pursuant to Section 561.705, Florida Statutes, and entitled to protections against suspension or revocation of its beverage license for the illegal sale of an alcoholic beverage to a person not of lawful drinking age, as envisioned by Section 561.706, Florida Statutes. Respondent's disciplinary history involves a violation of Section 561.501, Florida Statutes, for failure to timely file surcharge reports and to remit surcharges collected for periods in 1990. That case was resolved by entry into a Consent Agreement on December 17, 1990, in which Respondent acknowledged the violations and agreed to remit the sum of $250.00, as a civil penalty. This circumstance was in association with Respondent doing business as Scooters Coast To Coast at U.S. Highway #1, MM92.5, Tavernier, Monroe County, Florida, under license number 54-00658, Series 2COP.
Recommendation Upon consideration of the facts found and conclusions of law reached, it is RECOMMENDED: It is recommended that a final order be entered finding Respondent in violation of the aforementioned provisions and imposing a seven day suspension, together with a civil penalty of $1,000.00. DONE AND ENTERED this 12th day of August, 1998, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. CHARLES C. ADAMS Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 12th day of August, 1998. COPIES FURNISHED: Susan C. Felker-Little, Esquire Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1007 Scott A. Price, President Rose Anne, Inc., d/b/a Scooters 102½ West Rich Avenue Deland, Florida 32720 Richard Boyd, Director Department of Business and Professional Regulation Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1007 Lynda L. Goodgame, Esquire Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1007
Findings Of Fact Based upon the evidence adduced at hearing, and the record as a whole, the following Findings of Fact are made: At all times material to the instant case, Respondent has held alcoholic beverage license number 16-07413, authorizing him to sell alcoholic beverages on the premises of Pic A Pac (hereinafter also referred to as the "Store"). Respondent was the owner of Pic A Pac until February of 1994, when he sold the Store. Pic A Pac is a "drive-through" convenience store located at 3390 West Davie Boulevard in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. It has two "drive through" windows at which motorists are able to purchase items without leaving their vehicles. On the evening of June 12, 1992, John Raymond drove up to one of these windows in his red, four-door, 1987 Ford Escort and asked Respondent, who was manning the window, for two bottles of Jack Daniels Lynchburg Lemonade, a "wine cooler" product that is marketed as an alcoholic beverage. Raymond was born on September 25, 1974, and thus was only 17 years of age on June 12, 1994. Notwithstanding that he had shoulder length hair and was wearing a nose ring and an earring, Raymond's appearance that evening was not such that an ordinarily prudent person would have believed him to be 21 years of age or older. 2/ Moreover, Raymond neither said nor did anything to give Respondent reason to believe that he was not under 21 years of age. He did not show Respondent, nor did Respondent ask him to produce, any identification. Nonetheless, Respondent sold to Raymond the two bottles of Jack Daniels Lynchburg Lemonade that Raymond had requested. He did not give Raymond a receipt. After Raymond paid him, Respondent put these alcoholic beverages in a brown paper bag and handed the bag to Raymond. 3/ He did not give Raymond a receipt. Raymond took the bag and placed it on the disengaged emergency brake between the driver's and front passenger seat. The latter was occupied by Respondent's companion, Jason Campbell, who like Raymond, appeared to be well under 21 years of age. Raymond then drove off. 4/ The transaction between Respondent and Raymond was observed, through binoculars, by Albert Heinermann, a special agent with the Department, who, along with two other Department special agents, was on surveillance in the area. Heinermann was in a vehicle parked approximately 40 to 50 yards from the Store. When Heinermann saw Raymond drive off, he followed after him in his vehicle and pulled him over less than a block from the Store. A search of the vehicle revealed the paper bag containing the two bottles of Jack Daniels Lynchburg Lemonade that Raymond had purchased from Respondent. The bottles were unopened. Heinermann confiscated the alcoholic beverages and arrested Raymond and Campbell. One of the other special agents working with Heinermann that evening, Mike Fraher, went to the Store and arrested Respondent. Criminal charges were filed against Respondent. After the conclusion of the criminal case, the two bottles of Jack Daniels Lynchburg Lemonade that Raymond had purchased from Respondent and that Heinermann had confiscated were destroyed.
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is hereby recommended that the Department enter a final order dismissing the charge in the Notice to Show Cause that Respondent unlawfully possessed fireworks on his licensed premises, finding Respondent guilty of the charge in the Notice to Show Cause that he unlawfully sold alcoholic beverages on his licensed premises to a person under 21 years of age, and penalizing Respondent for such unlawful conduct by suspending his alcoholic beverage license for a period of seven days and fining him $1,000.00. DONE AND ENTERED in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida, this 24th day of June, 1994. STUART M. LERNER Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 24th day of June, 1994.
The Issue The Administrative Complaint, as amended, in this case alleges that Respondent engaged in or permitted gambling activity on the licensed premises in violation of Sections 849.14 and 561.29(1)(a), Florida Statutes. The issue for resolution is whether that violation occurred and, if so, what discipline is appropriate.
Findings Of Fact Petitioner is the agency responsible for issuing licenses permitting the sale of alcoholic beverages in Florida and is responsible for enforcing the beverage laws, Chapters 561-568, Florida Statutes. Respondent is a Florida corporation holding alcoholic beverage license number 15-00185, series 4COP, which authorizes it to sell alcoholic beverages at retail at the licensed premises, Bottoms Up Bar, located at 8400 US-1, South, Micco, in Brevard County, Florida. Lynette Tummolo is the president of Bottoms Up Bar, Inc. Ms. Tummolo's first bar was a restaurant and liquor bar in Palm Bay, Florida: Duke's Place. She and Robert Bench owned the bar as 50/50 partners. Duke's Place was moved to a new location after a hurricane and in August 1996, Ms. Tummolo and Mr. Bench sold their license to David Oliver. In March 1997, Ms. Tummolo started another business, a beer and wine bar, which opened in Micco, Florida. The Articles of Incorporation dated February 19, 1997, and filed with the Secretary of State for Bottoms Up Bar, Inc., list the incorporator as Lynette Tummolo, and the members of the board of directors as Lynette Tummolo and Robert Bench. The most recent annual report, dated March 23, 1998, and filed with the Secretary of State, reflects that Lynette Tummolo and Robert Bench are both directors of the corporation. In June 1997, after David Oliver defaulted on his payments for the license, Lynette Tummolo purchased back the liquor license and had it transferred to Bottoms Up Bar, Inc. Ms. Tummolo applied to the Department of Business and Professional Regulation, Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco (DABT) and had approved, a transfer of the liquor license and change of location to Bottoms Up Bar in Micco. The application submitted by Ms. Tummolo lists herself as president and 60% stockholder, Robert Bench as secretary and 40% stockholder, herself as treasurer, and Robert Bench as director. A personal questionnaire form for Robert Bench is attached to Ms. Tummolo's application. This form states that Mr. Bench is the director/manager of Bottoms Up Bar and that he was investing no funds in the business. At the hearing in this proceeding, Ms. Tummolo stated that Robert Bench was not an owner or officer of the corporation Bottoms Up Bar, Inc., but the only reason she put him on the application form was that a staff person from DABT told her that she had to put officers of the corporation and had to show a percentage of stock. Ms. Tummolo's testimony is inconsistent with her sworn affidavit at the end of the form. The testimony is also inconsistent with any established policy of DABT. Ann (Annie) Raftery works as manager of Captain Hiram's, a restaurant and lounge in Sebastian, Florida, near Micco. She regularly patronizes Bottoms Up Bar and is a friend of Robert Bench. She also sometimes helps clean up at Bottoms Up Bar after closing. In January 1998, Ms. Raftery decided on her own to start a football pool for the Super Bowl. She drew the grid and collected $20 for each square on the grid representing a wager. Individuals placing a wager wrote their names or some identification on the square they selected. Ms. Raftery carried the grid sheet around with her on a plastic clip-board. On the Friday night before Super Bowl Sunday 1998, Annie Raftery arrived at Bottoms Up Bar around 10:30 p.m. She handed the football pool sheet on the plastic clip-board, for safekeeping, to Robert Bench, who was working as bartender. He stashed it behind the bar for her. On that same Friday, January 23, 1998, in response to a complaint, Sergeant Sam Brewer (at that time, a DABT special agent) commenced an undercover investigation of Bottoms Up Bar. Late that evening he and other agents entered the bar, mingled with the crowd, played darts, and socialized. At one point, Special Agent Brewer asked an individual whether she knew of any pools for the upcoming Super Bowl football game. She responded that he would have to talk to "the boss" and pointed out Robert Bench behind the bar. Agent Brewer then sat at the bar and started talking to Mr. Bench. During the course of the conversation, Mr. Bench reached next to the cash register behind the bar and handed a plastic clip-board with the football pool sheet to a female patron sitting at the bar. This individual looked at it and handed it to another woman, later identified as Annie Raftery. Annie Raftery then gave the clip-board to Lynette Tummolo. Agent Brewer asked Robert Bench about the pool and Bench replied that it belonged to Captain Hiram's. Mr. Bench then got Ms. Raftery and directed her to Agent Brewer. Agent Brewer conversed with Ms. Raftery about the pool. She had the clip-board again and explained how to place a wager. Agent Brewer selected a square and put the name, Steve B., on the grid and paid Ms. Raftery $20. She told him she would be at Captain Hiram's or Bottoms Up Bar on Sunday, and he left, as it was closing time. Agent Brewer returned on Sunday, around half-time of the Super Bowl. He approached Mr. Bench at the bar and asked where he could see the football pool sheet to check his numbers. Mr. Bench replied that they had copies, but Ms. Raftery had the original and pointed her out at the end of the bar. Ms. Raftery showed Agent Brewer the pool sheet and he confirmed that it was the one he had marked earlier. He then made a covert telephone call to the other agents waiting outside. They, and assisting officers of the sheriff's office, arrested Mr. Bench and Ms. Raftery. They retrieved $1,200 from Ms. Raftery's car and $440 from her home. The remainder of the $2,000 she collected had already been paid out for the first quarter of the game. Ms. Tummolo is at Bottoms Up Bar every night, seven nights a week. She remembers Friday, January 23, 1998, was particularly busy. At the hearing she described a plastic clip- board kept at the bar with a sheet on which the bartenders must record the liquor they remove from the back stockroom. Ms. Tummolo insists that if she had been seen with a clip-board, it would have been the liquor record and not a football pool. Agent Brewer saw Ms. Tummolo with the football pool, however, the night he placed his wager. Bottoms Up Bar does not participate in the Responsible Vendors Program. Ms. Tummolo meets regularly with her bartenders and, at least since the Super Bowl Sunday event, she reminds them that gambling in any form is not tolerated.
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law set forth herein, it is RECOMMENDED: That the agency enter its Final Order finding Respondent guilty of violating Sections 561.29(1)(a), Florida Statutes, and 849.14, Florida Statutes, and assessing a penalty of $250.00. DONE AND ENTERED this 19th day of November, 1998, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. MARY CLARK Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 19th day of November, 1998. COPIES FURNISHED: Thomas D. Winokur, Esquire Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1007 Joe Teague Caruso, Esquire 800 East Merritt Boulevard Merritt Island, Florida 32954-1271 Richard Boyd, Director Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1007 Lynda L. Goodgame, General Counsel Department of Business and Professional Regulation 1940 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0792
The Issue Whether or not on or about the 14th of March, 1976, Pearlie Mae Smith, a licensed vendor, did have in her possession, permit or allow someone else, to wit: Junior Lee Smith, to have in their possession on the licensed premises, alcoholic beverages, to wit: 5 half-pints of Smirnoff Vodka, not authorized by law to be sold under her license, contrary to s. 562.02, F.S.
Findings Of Fact On March 14, 1976, and up to and including the date of the hearing, the Respondent, Pearlie Mae Smith, held license no. 72-65, series 2-COP with the State of Florida, Division of Beverage. The licensed premises is located at 1013 West Malloy Avenue, Perry, Florida. On the morning of March 14, 1976, Officer B.C. Maxwell with the State of Florida, Division of Beverage acting on an informant's information, searched the informant to determine if the informant had monies other than the money that the officer had given him or any alcoholic beverages on his person. Once the informant had been searched and it was determined that the informant was carrying with him only the money that the officer had given him to purchase alcoholic beverages, the informant was sent into the subject licensed premises. The informant returned with a half-pint bottle of alcoholic beverage not permitted to be sold on the licensed premise and indicated that this purchase was made from one Junior Lee Smith. Later in the morning, around 11:30, officers of the State of Florida, Division of Beverage entered the licensed premises and an inspection of those premises revealed a bag containing 5 half-pint bottles of Smirnoff Vodka in the kitchen area of the licensed premises. This bag and contents were admitted as Petitioner's Exhibit #2. The 5 half-pint bottles of Smirnoff Vodka are alcoholic beverages which are not allowed to be sold under the series 2-COP license on the subject premises. When the officers entered, the same Junior Lee Smith was in the licensed premises and indicated that he was in charge of the licensed premises and had been selling alcoholic beverages for "quite some time" together with his wife, Pearlie Mae Smith, the licensee. The bag he indicated, had been whiskey that had been left over from the night before.
Recommendation It is recommended that based upon the violation as established in the hearing that the licensee, Pearlie Mae Smith, have her beverage license suspended for a period of 30 days. DONE and ENTERED this 19th day of December, 1976, in Tallahassee, Florida. CHARLES C. ADAMS, Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings Room 530, Carlton Building Tallahassee, Florida 32304 (904) 488-9675 COPIES FURNISHED: Larry D. Winson, Esquire Staff Attorney Division of Beverage 725 Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32304 Mrs. Pearlie Mae Smith 1013 West Malloy Avenue Perry, Florida
The Issue Whether, under the facts and circumstances of this case, Respondent is guilty of the violation alleged in the Notice To Show Cause issued October 20, 1989 by the Director of the Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco, Department of Business Regulation and filed herein.
Findings Of Fact Upon consideration of the oral and documentary evidence adduced at the hearing, the following relevant facts are found: At all times material to this case, OB's Restaurant and Lounge, Inc. held a Department of Business Regulation, Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco (Division) license for the premises known as OB's Restaurant and Lounge (OB's), alcoholic beverage license number 74-2421 SRX, Series 4-COP, located at 913 Highway 17, Pierson, Volusia County, Florida. Christine Shuter O'Brien, president of OB's Restaurant and Lounge, Inc. owns 100 per cent of the stock in the corporation. Ms. O'Brien has owned and operated OB's since July 1989. Camiel Long, born July 3, 1969, who was 20 years of age on October, 1989, works with law enforcement investigators of District 12 of the Division, Daytona Beach, Florida, as an Investigation Aide in determining whether licensed establishments are selling alcoholic beverage within their licensed premises to persons under the age of 21 years. On Saturday, October 7, 1989, Long met with Investigator Ron Sullivan for the purpose of Sullivan explaining the procedure used to effect underage investigation. At this time, Sullivan explained to Long that he would enter a licensed premises first and Long was to follow a few minutes later. Upon entry of the licensed premises Long was to approach the appropriate point of sale and ask to purchase an alcoholic beverage. Long was instructed to carry his own personal Florida Driver's license and to present the driver's license upon request. Long's Florida driver's license depicted him as having a mustache. The photographs taken on October 7, 1989 depicts Long as being clean shaven, without a mustache. One of the targeted licensed premises for October 7, 1989 was OB's because of a complaint received from the local police department. At approximately 9:45 p.m. on October 7, 1989, Sullivan and Long arrived at OB's parking lot and Sullivan then entered OB's, with Long following in approximately five minutes. Kevin Cox was in charge of checking identification (ID) at the door of OB's to keep out underage persons, and was in fact checking ID's at the door of OB's on Saturday night, October 7, 1989. On Saturday night, October 7, 1989, at the time Long entered OB's and purchased the beer, the bar was quite busy, some customers were playing pool and a band was playing, as was normal on Friday and Saturday night On Saturday night, October 7, 1989 there were several signs over the entrance to the bar at OB's indicating that proper identification was required and that it would be checked When Long entered OB's, Cox was checking several other persons' ID cards, and did not stop Long to check his ID as he "skirted" around him because he appeared to be about the same age as those persons Cox was checking who were in the 24-25 year-old bracket according to their ID cards. After entering OB's, Long found a seat at the bar, sat down, and ordered a Budweiser beer from Christine Shuter O'Brien who was tending bar at that time, along with Lorraine Ware. Ms. O'Brien opened a long-neck 12 ounce bottle of Budweiser beer, an alcoholic beverage, and served the beer to Long who paid Ms. O'Brien for the beer. Ms. O'Brien did not question Long's age or require any type of ID from him before selling and serving him the beer. Upon receiving the beer and his change, Long turned and handed the beer to Sullivan, and Long left the premises. Sullivan identified himself to Ms. O'Brien and advised her that he had observed her sell an alcoholic beverage to a person under the age of 21 years. Sullivan then requested that they move to area where they could speak. After moving to another area, Sullivan presented O'Brien with a Notice to Appear, in lieu of arrest. Ms. O'Brien has had no previous Beverage Law violation in any establishment that she has owned, including one in DeLand and one in Illinois. Ms. O'Brien's policy concerning the serving of alcoholic beverages is that if someone appears to be of age (21 years or older), then it is not necessary to request an ID to confirm their age. Both Kevin Cox and Lorraine Ware was aware of this policy, as well as other employees. Lorraine Ware, through experience and having taken a course taught by the Division concerning serving underage persons, is aware that it is her responsibility to avoid serving an underage person alcoholic beverage. Ware has also received instruction from Ms. O'Brien not to sell alcoholic beverages to an underage person. Long's appearance on Saturday night, October 7, 1989 and on the day of the hearing (February 13, 1990), four months later, was very similar, except for his clothing, and would cause an ordinary prudent person to question whether he was 21 years of age or older. Long's appearance should have caused both Cox and Ms. O'Brien to require him to confirm his age by some type of identification. O'Brien's failure to require confirmation of Long's age before selling him the beer on Saturday night, October 7, 1989 showed a lack of due diligence on her part, notwithstanding her presumption that Cox had checked Long's ID at the door, or the fact that she had several signs posted concerning the checking of ID's.
Recommendation Having considered the foregoing Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, the evidence of record, the candor and demeanor of the witnesses and the mitigating circumstances surrounding the sale, it is, therefore, RECOMMENDED that the Petitioner enter a Final Order finding Respondent guilty of a violation of Section 562.011(1)(a), Florida Statutes, and for such violation assess a civil penalty of $500.00. DONE AND ENTERED this 21st day of March, 1990, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. WILLIAM R. CAVE Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 21st day of March, 1990. APPENDIX TO THE RECOMMENDED ORDER IN CASE NO. 89-6962 Specific Rulings on Proposed Findings of Fact Submitted by the Petitioner 1.-2. Adopted in Findings of Fact 1 and 3, respectively. Adopted in Findings of Fact 4 and 5. Adopted in Findings of Fact 6 and 7. 5.-9 Adopted in Findings of Fact 8, 12, 13, 14 and 12, respectively. 10. Adopted in Findings of Fact 2, 15. 11.-15. Adopted in Findings of Fact 16, 8, 18, 9 and 18, respectively. 16 Rejected as not being supported by substantial competent evidence in the record. Specific Rulings on Proposed Findings of Fact Submitted by the Respondent 1.-3. Covered in Preliminary Statement. Covered in beginning paragraphs. Covered in Preliminary Statement and in Findings of Fact 5. Adopted in Findings of Fact 5, as modified. Adopted in Findings of Fact 4 and 5, as modified. Adopted in Findings of Fact 7, 12 and 14, as modified, except for the last sentence which was rejected because O'Brien was not arrested but given Notice To Appear in lieu of an arrest. 9.-14. Rejected as being more of a restatement of testimony than proposed findings of fact, but if stated as proposed findings of fact then adopted in Findings of Fact 8, 9, 10, 12 and 17. COPIES FURNISHED: Stephen R. MacNamara, Secretary Department of Business Regulation The Johns Building 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1000 Joseph A. Sole, Esquire General Counsel Department of Business Regulation The Johns Building 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1000 Harry Hooper, Esquire Department of Business Regulation The Johns Building 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399- Joseph A. Scarlett, Esquire 208 West Howry Avenue Deland, Florida 32720
Recommendation Based on the foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of law, it is Recommended that respondent be found guilty of violating Subsection 562.12(1), Florida Statutes, and that she be given a $100 fine to be paid within fifteen days after the entry of a final order in this cause. DONE and RECOMMENDED this 28th day of October, 1983, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. DONALD R. ALEXANDER, Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 28th day of October, 1983. COPIES FURNISHED: James N. Watson, Esquire Department of Business Regulation 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Irene B. Wright 1655 East 21st Street Jacksonville, Florida 32206 Gary R. Rutledge, Secretary Department of Business Regulation 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Howard Milan Rasmussen, Director Division of Alcoholic Beverages and Tobacco 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301
Findings Of Fact At all pertinent times, Escandar, Inc. had a valid alcoholic beverage license, No. 23-1461 4 COP. The parties so stipulated. Rafael Escandar is president of Escandar, Inc. which owns the building in which he manages the "Apartment Lounge," a bar, featuring "female nude dancing as entertainment." (I T. 25) On August 5, 1981, petitioner formally advised respondent that solicitation by employees of alcoholic beverages from patrons was proscribed by law. The year before allegations of such offenses had resulted in a stipulated $500.00 penalty against respondent. On March 26, 1982, at about quarter past ten, Officers Louis J. Terminello, and Juanita Loud entered the Apartment Lounge, posing as customers. In a separate group, three other undercover agents, Officers Davis, Chastain and Iturralde also visited the establishment. The place was dark and noisy. Aside from illuminated exit signs, the only lights were on stage and in the girls' dressing room. Loud music but no light emanated from the juke box. People could not be heard from one table to the next and had to speak very loudly to be heard from one bar stool to the next. These conditions obtained on all subsequent visits, as well. Mr. Terminello and Ms. Loud struck up a conversation with Carol Brooks, a dancer who stopped at their table clad in a sheer negligee, between dances. They asked her for a gram of cocaine. She said she didn't think a gram was available on the premises, but took Ms. Loud back to the dressing room and gave her an amber glass vial containing a smaller amount of cocaine. On their return to the table where Mr. Terminello had stayed, he passed a ten dollar bill to Ms. Loud, who gave it to Ms. Brooks. At her request, Mr. Terminello bought Ms. Brooks a drink. At one point Terminello left the table for the bar, and another dancer, Lorrie Jobes, asked him for a drink, which he bought for her. Later, after the undercover officers brought up the subject of drugs, Ms. Jobes sold them a gram of cocaine for $70.00. The transaction took place in the women's restroom. Less than a gram may have in fact been involved, since the chemist received only two tenths of a gram of cocaine. Petitioner's Exhibit No. 4. Both groups of undercover agents returned to the Apartment Lounge on the following Thursday, April 1, 1982. Terminello and Loud asked a third dancer, Bonnie Smith, about cocaine and purchased a small amount from her for $5.00. This transaction occurred at a table in the bar. The next night both groups showed up again. Mr. Terminello gave Lorrie Jobes $70.00 for a gram of cocaine which she delivered to him at his table shortly after midnight. At one point Ms. Loud left the table and a dancer offered to give Mr. Terminello a blow job in his car when she got off work for $20.00. Later another dancer, Jill Carpenter, offered to commit oral sex on her next break for $50.00 in the parking lot. Bonnie Smith told Terminello that Linda Vonluttichau, another dancer, had good cocaine for sale at $80.00 per gram with a two gram minimum. After speaking to Ms. Vonluttichau himself, Mr. Terminello left $160.00 inside a napkin on the bar. After she had picked up the money, she waved him over to the bar and gave him some cocaine in a Zip-Loc bag. Later Laurie Hegarty, a barmaid, asked Mr. Terminello if she could ingest some of the cocaine he had purchased because, she said, she had heard it was very good. He obliged. Still later, Mr. Terminello purchased half a gram of cocaine from Lorrie Jobes for $30.00. About twenty of eleven on the night of April 3, 1982, Officers Loud, Terminello, Chastain, Iturralde and Davis made a fourth visit to the Apartment Lounge. Bonnie Smith led Terminello to the women's restroom where he purchased half a gram of cocaine from one William Golden for $30.00. Later the same evening he bought a gram of cocaine for $80.00 from Linda Vonluttichau, which she delivered to him over the bar while Rafael Escandar was seated near the other end of the bar. Another visit by the undercover agents, on April 9, 1982, was no less eventful. Mr. Terminello purchased six Quaalude tablets from still another dancer, Ms. Chitty, a marijuana cigarette from Jill Carpenter for $2.00, and two ounces of marijuana from Sherry Mays, also a dancer at the Apartment Lounge, not to mention drinks for Ms. Chitty and Bonnie Smith. Sherry Mays asked Terminello to buy her a drink, as well. It was also Sherry Mays who, seeing that Mr. Terminello's shirt bore the legend "SUNOCO," indicated her willingness to "agree to exchange a tank full of gas for oral sex on a regular basis, two or three times a week." (II T. 8) After talking to Ms. Linda Vonluttichau about purchasing two grams of cocaine and at her direction, Mr. Terminello gave Ms. Hegarty $160.00. Ms. Vonluttichau later delivered the cocaine to Mr. Terminello at his table. Still later Mr. Terminello accompanied Ms. Hegarty to the women's rest room where she ingested some of the cocaine Mr. Terminello had just purchased. The undercover agents made a final visit to the Apartment Lounge on April 16, 1982. That night Rafael Escandar told Mr. Terminello that "an old friend of his in the North Miami Police Department . . . [advised that the bar was under investigation] for narcotics and that [Terminello] needed to be especially careful because the person who called him described [Terminello] and Loud as having bought narcotics on the premises. "So he cautioned me about being careful, that the police were going to arrest [Terminello and Loud] if they found [them] or something like that." (II T. 18-19) This was shortly before other beverage officers arrived and executed a search warrant. The search turned up about one fifth of a gram of cocaine. Petitioner's Exhibit Nob. 14. Rafael Escandar was on the licensed premises every night the undercover agents were there, except for April 1, 1982. He routinely spent time at the bar on a particular stool, in between bookkeeping chores that he performed in an office closed off from the bar's not inconsiderable distractions. As standard practice, hem and Barbara Abbott, who has worked at the Apartment Lounge for more than a decade, specifically warned the dancers, many of whom were transient, against prostitution, drug vending and solicitation of drinks. Dancers have been fired for failing to observe one or more of these prohibitions. According to Tom Mandy, formerly a police officer who visited the Apartment Lounge regularly "to make sure there was no prostitution going on in the place," II T. 223, and occasionally to evict unruly patrons, management's "rules" were strictly enforced, and Mr. Escandar, if the police "wanted people fired that [they] thought were undesirable . . . would fire them immediately. There wouldn't be any questions asked." (II T. 231) Nothing in the evidence suggested that Mr. Escandar expected any share of the money (or gasoline) solicited or obtained by the dancers in exchange for their illegal goods and services. Except for Laurie Hegarty and Linda Vonluttichau, who was employed as a barmaid for a year and a half, the offending employees had not worked long for the Apartment Lounge. Kimberly Chitty worked less than a full night, one of only 20 nights over a period of a few months. Generally, they were transients or "street girls." Lorrie Jobes worked only ten days, she was fired before the raid on April 16, 1982. The evidence did not show what extent, if any, Mr. Escandar or Escandar Inc. profitted from sales of drinks solicited by the dancers. Early on in the investigation, Mr. Escandar noticed officers Loud and Terminello. They stood out because they came together as a couple and because dancers congregated at their table. Mr. Escandar testified that he "never thought about drugs." II. T. 270 Instead, he said he "thought that they were there to have some, trying to make out, to get a party at the end of the night." II. T. 270 On April 16, 1982, Escandar testified, he decided they were undesirables and told them that the police were coming, in an effort to get them to leave the bar. He explained that he had not earlier sought to discourage their presence in the bar, "because the girls ke[pt] telling me that they were spending money." (II. T. 274) There was no evidence of drug sales to anybody other than undercover agents. Mr. Terminello and Ms. Loud developed a certain rapport with many of the dancers, one of whom propositioned Ms. Loud. In preparing the foregoing findings of fact, respondent's proposed findings of fact, to the extent they have been extricable from proposed conclusions of law, have been largely adopted, in substance. To the extent they have been rejected, they have been deemed irrelevant or unsupported by the weight of the evidence.
Recommendation Upon consideration of the foregoing, it is RECOMMENDED: That petitioner revoke respondent's beverage license. DONE AND ENTERED this 20th day of December, 1982, in Tallahassee, Florida. ROBERT T. BENTON, II Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 20th day of December, 1982. COPIES FURNISHED: Harold F. X. Purnell, Esquire Department of Business Regulation 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Paul R. Lipton, Esquire 1031 North Miami Beach Boulevard North Miami Beach, Florida 33162 Captain John Harris Ernest R. Graham Building 1350 Northwest 12 Avenue Miami, Florida 33136 Charles A. Nuzum, Director Department of Business Regulation Division of Alcoholic Beverages & Tobacco 725 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32301
Findings Of Fact Respondent held valid alcoholic beverage licenses for Pirate Jim's Restaurant and Lounge and Island House Games People Play at all times relevant to these proceedings. Thomas Joseph Dorsey was a principal corporate officer during such relevant period. Dorsey was arrested in the Miami area for trafficking in cannabis on or about September 2, 1981. The testimony of a Florida Department of Law Enforcement special agent established that he attempted to arrange the purchase of a large quantity of marijuana from Dorsey pursuant to their agreement. The evidence did not establish that the substance viewed by the special agent was, in fact, marijuana. Further, there was no evidence that any sale or delivery took place or that any controlled substances were seized as a result of the proposed transaction.
Recommendation From the foregoing, it is RECOMMENDED: That Petitioner enter a Final Order dismissing the charges against Respondent. DONE and ENTERED this 7th day of December, 1982, in Tallahassee, Florida. R. T. CARPENTER, Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 7th day of December, 1982.
