Findings Of Fact David Kelly, certified since 1973 as an emergency medical technician and as an ambulance driver, does business as Franklin Ambulance Service, under contract to the Franklin County Commission. Franklin Ambulance Service held ambulance service license No. 221 from February 2, 1982, through February 1, 1983. An application for renewal of this license, dated January 19, 1983, has been filed with petitioner Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services (HRS). Franklin County itself owns the two ambulances respondent operates. One ambulance had been driven 160,000 miles at the time of hearing; and the other had been driven more than 200,000 miles. They both require maintenance frequently. The ambulances are converted vans with no barrier between the driver and the back of the vehicle. Typically one ambulance is stationed in Apalachicola and the other in Carrabelle. Cases that Weems Memorial Hospital in Apalachicola is not prepared to handle are generally taken to Tallahassee Memorial Regional Medical Center from the eastern part of the county, and to Bay Memorial Regional Medical Center from the western part of the county. TELEPHONE ACCESS When the ambulance based in Apalachicola is not in use or being serviced, Mr. Kelly keeps it at his residence on 26th Street in Apalachicola. He has a telephone in his house. In addition, according to Mr. Kelly: The County has a volunteer phone system. That means that it is answered by volunteers in the community. There is four phones in Apalachicola, four phones in Carrabelle that are manned by volunteers. In the event that someone is not going to be at the phone and a call comes in, a recorder is put on the telephone to tell the people of Carrabelle, if they need an ambulance, to call the ambulance number in Apalachicola, and the recorder in Apalachicola is very rarely put on, but whenever it is put on, it tells them to call the Weems Memorial Hospital, and the Weems Memorial helps them secure an ambulance. (T. II. p. 77). The ambulances maintain direct radio contact with Weems Memorial Hospital when in service. This system has not always worked perfectly. About noon on September 23, 1982, calls were placed to the ambulance telephones in Apalachicola and in Carrabelle, in an effort to secure an ambulance, but to no avail. Both in Carrabelle and in Apalachicola, volunteers sometimes answered the telephone for Franklin Ambulance Service. Debra Johnson, when she had completed her training as an emergency medical technician but before being certified, was such a volunteer in October of 1982. At the time, Nelson Noble worked for Mr. Kelly and had responsibility for ambulance service in Carrabelle and the eastern part of the county generally, as well as being pastor of the Church of God in Apalachicola. On October 9, 1982, Mr. Noble asked Ms. Johnson to answer the telephone while he went to Apalachicola, leaving an oxygen tank, bandages, air splints and instructions to stabilize any patient who needed it, until he could get back from Apalachicola. On Sunday, October 10, 1982, Mr. Noble had the ambulance at his church. He was gone all day and did not return to relieve the volunteer manning the telephone until ten o'clock that night. At about half past noon on October 12, 1982, Mr. Noble asked Ms. Johnson to answer the telephone and to tell callers that the ambulance was on a run to Tallahassee. At 6:30 or 7:00 that evening, Ms. Johnson was told that Mr. Nelson and the ambulance were at Mr. Noble's house in Carrabelle. She called and complained that he had not kept her informed of his whereabouts. On one occasion, the ambulance went to Tallahassee with a patient and did not return for six hours. Mr. Noble "had been shopping, and had bought parts for his truck. . ." T. 1 p. 151. There was no showing that these particular incidents or other specific interruptions of continuous telephone access by the Carrabelle public were brought to Mr. Kelly's attention at the time. There was no showing that the Apalachicola ambulance was inaccessible to the public at any time, except for good reason. DRIVER ATTENDS WHILE EMT DRIVES On June 27, 1982, two cars travelling in opposite directions across Gorrie Bridge collided head on. Archie Brooks Holton, a Franklin County deputy sheriff, was the first law enforcement officer on the scene. He radioed his dispatcher asking that a fire truck and at least one ambulance be sent to the bridge. Twenty or thirty minutes later the Apalachicola ambulance driven by Mr. Kelly arrived. Seated next to him was James Clark Tomlin. After accident victims had been placed in the ambulance, Mr. Kelly drove off, with Mr. Tomlin attending the patient in the rear of the ambulance. En route to the hospital, one of the patients threw up and Mr. Tomlin cleared out vomitus with his fingers, then used a suction device. At all pertinent times, Mr. Tomlin was a certified ambulance driver, but was not certified as an emergency medical technician. Explaining why Mr. Tomlin, rather than he, attended the patient in the back of the ambulance as they left the Gorrie Bridge accident, Mr. Kelly testified: Whenever I started to leave the accident scene, Jim Tomlin told me that he had left his glasses. He did not have his glasses with him, and he is required on his driver's license, to drive with glasses, and he said that he could not see to back off that bridge and pass those cars and turn around without his glasses, that the glare was too much for him. (T. II. p. 68). Another traffic accident, on State Road 67 five miles north of Carrabelle, resulted in another accident victim's being transported by the Apalachicola ambulance on or about August 31, 1982. Again Mr. Kelly drove and Mr. Tomlin rode in back. Whether or not a physician's assistant was also in the back of the ambulance while it travelled to Dr. Sands' office, Mr. Tomlin and the patient were alone in the back of the ambulance while Mr. Kelly drove it from Dr. Sands' Franklin County office to Tallahassee Memorial Regional Medical Center. Mr. Kelly explained: On the way to the ambulance, Jim Tomlin told me that he had gotten nauseated and sick from working. It was a hot night and he said that he was nauseated and sick to his stomach, and he didn't think that he would be able to drive, and I told him that I would drive him on to the doctor's office, and we would see, when we got there, if he thought he'd be able to drive on to Tallahassee. . .Jim, at that time, informed me that he was not able. . .to drive on to Tallahassee, that he still felt too bad. I told him that, since the patient was stabilized, we had the splints on the patient, to watch him and inform me if anything went wrong, and I would drive on to Tallahassee. (T. II. pp. 61-62). According to Messrs. Kelly and Tomlin these two occasions were the only ones on which Mr. Tomlin rode in the back of the ambulance with a patient while Mr. Kelly drove the ambulance. The weight of the evidence was otherwise. At various times, including November 1, 1982, Vicki Lynn Holton, a nurse at Weems Memorial, saw the Apalachicola ambulance arrive at the hospital with Mr. Kelly driving and Mr. Tomlin attending a patient in the back of the ambulance. Dr. Photis Nichols has on several occasions seen the ambulance leave Weems Memorial with Mr. Tomlin attending the patient in the back and Mr. Kelly driving. Some time in 1981 or 1982 Mr. Kelly drove an ambulance to Tallahassee Memorial Regional Medical Center with a mother and newborn infant in the back attended by Mr. Tomlin. On September 3, 1982, an ambulance left St. Teresa with a patient, his wife, and Mr. Tomlin in the back of the ambulance and Mr. Kelly driving. Dora Lee White, PBX operator at Weems Memorial, has seen Mr. Kelly driving an ambulance and Mr. Tomlin in the back attending a patient from time to time over the last three years. Ms. Julia Barber, another PBX operator at Weems Memorial, can see the ambulance arrive and depart from her work station. Over the last three years, Mr. Kelly has almost always driven and Mr. Tomlin has almost always attended the patient in the back of the ambulance, as far as she has observed. A former employee of the ambulance service, Nancy Cone, observed Mr. Kelly driving and Mr. Tomlin attending a patient in the back of the ambulance, on ten or fifteen occasions. The evidence overwhelmingly established that Mr. Kelly routinely drove the ambulance, leaving Mr. Tomlin to take care of patients. Because of the van configuration, the two men could communicate. In a sense, the licensed driver, Mr. Tomlin, was in the presence of a certified emergency medical technician, Mr. Kelly, when he attended patients in the back of the ambulance Mr. Kelly was driving. When Mr. Noble was hired to take charge of ambulance operations in Carrabelle, he was certified as an ambulance driver, but not as an emergency medical technician. (He was nevertheless paid one third again as much as the two emergency medical technicians he replaced earned between them, perhaps because part of his duties was "public relations.") Mr. Noble had been previously certified as an emergency medical technician and was recertified on October 15, 1982. While working for Franklin Ambulance Service, but before his recertification as an emergency medical technician, Mr. Noble drove or rode in the Carrabelle ambulance numerous times when patients were being transported and without a duly certified emergency medical technician on the ambulance. Mr. Noble's testimony that this occurred only once has not been credited. RECORD KEEPING Whenever one of the ambulances makes a trip, an employee of the ambulance service filled out a "REMSMO Ambulance Report" form. Even though Mr. Kelly drove and Mr. Tomlin acted as ambulance attendant, the "run reports" indicated that Mr. Tomlin drove and Mr. Kelly acted as the attendant. False reporting of this kind occurred repeatedly, including the night of the accident on Gorrie Bridge.
Recommendation Upon consideration of the foregoing, it is RECOMMENDED: That petitioner deny respondent's application for licensure, without prejudice to the filing of a new application 90 days after the effective date of the denial. DONE and ENTERED this 15th day of June, 1983, in Tallahassee, Florida. ROBERT T. BENTON, II Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 15th day of June, 1983. COPIES FURNISHED: Steven W. Huss, Esquire Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services 1323 Winewood Boulevard, Suite 406 Tallahassee, Florida 32301 Van P. Russell, Esquire 41 Commerce Street Apalachicola, Florida 32320 David Pingree, Secretary Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services 1323 Winewood Boulevard Tallahassee, Florida 32301
The Issue The issue for determination is whether Petitioner satisfies the eligibility requirements in Subsection 121.081(1)(f), Florida Statutes (2005), to purchase past service credit in the Florida Retirement System (FRS).
Findings Of Fact Petitioner was employed as a State Certified Paramedic by Harbor City Volunteer Ambulance Squad, Inc. (HCVAS), in Brevard County, Florida, from sometime in December 1976 through September 30, 1999. From October 1, 1999, through the date of the formal hearing, Petitioner was employed as a county employee in an identical capacity with Brevard County Fire Rescue (BCFR). Petitioner's employment with HCVAS and BCFR was continuous, with no break in service. Petitioner performed identical services with HCVAS and BCFR and had identical duties and responsibilities. At BCFR, Petitioner received credit for 80 percent of the seniority and leave accrued while Petitioner was employed with HCVAS. From sometime in October 1992 through September 30, 1999, HCVAS furnished emergency and non-emergency ambulance service in an area the parties refer to as the central part of Brevard County, Florida, that is legally described in Petitioner's Exhibit A (the service area). HCVAS furnished ambulance service pursuant to a contract with the Brevard County Board of County Commissioners (the County). HCVAS was an independent contractor with the exclusive right to provide ambulance service in the service area. The County, rather than HCVAS, provided emergency ambulance service for that part of the County outside the service area. A company identified in the record as Coastal Health Services provided non-emergency ambulance service outside the service area. HCVAS was an "employing entity which was not an employer under the [FRS]," within the meaning of Subsection 121.081(1)(f), Florida Statutes (2005). HCVAS was a private, non-profit company rather than a government entity. However, employees of HCVAS were not volunteers, but were full-time employees of HCVAS. HCVAS paid its employees, including Petitioner, from funds received from the County. The County retained exclusive control of communication and dispatching of emergency calls for the entire County, including the service area. The County required HCVAS to maintain communication equipment that was compatible with the central communication system. On October 1, 1999, the County effected an "assumption of functions or activities" from HCVAS within the meaning of Subsection 121.081(1)(f), Florida Statutes (2005). The County allowed the contract with HCVAS to expire on September 30, 1999. On April 13, 1999, the County authorized BCFR to provide emergency ambulance service to the service area previously served by HCVAS. The County also authorized the county manager to purchase rescue units and equipment and required the county manager to give first priority to units and equipment of HCVAS. Eligibility for HCVAS employees such as Petitioner to participate in the FRS arose through the assumption of HCVAS functions by the County. The County did not employ HCVAS employees, including Petitioner, as a result of competitive selection. The primary conditions of employment for HCVAS employees such as Petitioner were that each HCVAS employee must apply for employment with the County no later than May 29, 1999; possess a valid Florida driver's license; and pass a criminal background check. The County directed its Public Safety Department (Department) to give special consideration to HCVAS employees, including Petitioner, by hiring as many HCVAS employees as possible. Applications for employment from the general public were to be accepted only if employment positions remained unfilled after placing all qualified HCVAS employees in available positions. Approximately 95 HCVAS employees, including Petitioner, applied for employment with the County. The County employed approximately 90 of the 95 applicants. The five applicants who were not employed were rejected because the applicants either did not possess a valid Florida driver's license or did not pass the criminal background screening. Rejection of an applicant required approval of two supervisors. On October 1, 1999, the County recognized past service with HCVAS by new employees such as Petitioner. The County credited each new employee with seniority, annual leave, and sick leave based on a contractual formula negotiated with the labor union equal to 80 percent of seniority, annual leave, and sick leave earned while employed by HCVAS. On October 1, 1999, former HCVAS employees employed by the County, including Petitioner, became entitled to participate in the FRS system through the "assumption of functions or activities" by the County from HCVAS "which was not an employer under the system" within the meaning of Subsection 121.021(1)(f), Florida Statutes (2005). On the same date, Petitioner became a member of the special risk class of FRS and is "entitled to receive past-service credit . . . for the time" Petitioner "was an employee of [HCVAS] . . . the "other employing entity." On November 6, 2003, Petitioner applied to purchase credit in the FRS for his past service with HCVAS. On December 23, 2003, Respondent denied Petitioner's request on the ground that a "merger, transfer or consolidation" of functions between units of government did not occur. On January 8, 2004, Petitioner provided Respondent with a written reply. The reply explained that the application to purchase credit for past service was based on the County's assumption of functions or services by an employing entity that was not an employer under the FRS and not on a merger, transfer, or consolidation of functions between units of government. By letters dated April 16 and May 25, 2004, Respondent issued written statements of proposed Final Agency Action. On April 16, 2004, Respondent based its proposed agency action on the express ground that a "merger, transfer or consolidation" had not occurred when the County undertook emergency ambulance service in the service area. On May 25, 2004, Respondent added the additional ground that an assumption of functions did not occur between governmental units because HCVAS was a "not-for- profit corporation" and not a "unit of government."
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that Respondent enter a final order granting Petitioner's application to purchase credit in the FRS for past service with HCVAS. DONE AND ENTERED this 31st day of January, 2006, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S DANIEL MANRY Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 31st day of January, 2006. COPIES FURNISHED: Robert B. Button, Esquire Department of Management Services Division of Retirement 4050 Esplanade Way, Suite 160 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0950 Adrienne E. Trent, Esquire Allen & Trent, P.A. 700 North Wickham Road, Suite 107 Melbourne, Florida 32935 Alberto Dominguez, General Counsel Department of Management Services Post Office Box 9000 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-9000 Sarabeth Snuggs, Director Division of Retirement Department of Management Services Post Office Box 9000 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-9000
The Issue Whether HRS should revoke respondent Cullifer's certification as an emergency medical technician or take other disciplinary action, for the reasons alleged in the administrative complaint?
Findings Of Fact At one time, James E. Cullifer had charge of the Holmes County Ambulance Service in Bonifay. The parties are in apparent agreement that he has held emergency medical technician certification No. JT 0003257, at all pertinent times. Search Warranted It was freezing cold at about ten o'clock on the night of February 13, 1986, when Eric Adams, Kenneth Allen Tate, Jerry Eldridge and Jesse Joyner, all of the Holmes County Sheriff's Department, arrived to execute a search warrant at the "ambulance shack," the building that Holmes County emergency medical technicians occupied between ambulance runs. The warrant issued earlier the same day, on the strength of an affidavit Wilburn G. Baker had executed that morning at the state attorney's office. (T. 343-4). Mr. Baker's visit to the state attorney's office followed a stormy meeting of the Holmes County Ambulance Service emergency medical technicians. During one such meeting Mr. Baker told Messrs. Sprayberry and Cullifer "that he wished neither one of them had worked there . . . " (T. 195) Wilburn Baker, who obtained his certification as an emergency medical technician in 1978, took over as director of the Holmes County Ambulance Service when Mr. Cullifer "stepped down on his own" (T. 207) in 1985. Mr. Baker was already on board when Wiley R. Sprayberry began, in 1983. Affidavit and warrant notwithstanding, a motion to suppress evidence obtained in the February 13, 1986 search was later granted in the criminal proceeding in which Messrs. Sprayberry and Cullifer were accused of marijuana possession on that night. The criminal prosecution was subsequently abandoned altogether. Apparently, however, on the night of the search, the authorities did not foresee these developments. They had, indeed, invited television crews and other media representatives to be on hand to witness them apprehend the respondents, whom Mr. Baker assured them they would find in possession of marijuana. Gunfire But No Bloodshed As law enforcement personnel, including a dog handler, gathered outside, Messrs. Cullifer and Sprayberry lay in beds inside the ambulance shack, covers drawn, watching a television news program. They had returned not long before from taking a Mr. Whitaker to Dothan. Among those outside the ambulance shack was Mr. Baker. Some hours before the fact (T. 349), the sheriff's office told him when the search was to take place, so that other ambulance attendants could fill in for the respondent and Mr. Sprayberry when they were arrested. After knocking and announcing their intention to execute a search warrant, Officers Adams, Tate and Eldridge entered the ambulance shack. Mr. Sprayberry remained in bed during the reading of the search warrant, but Mr. Cullifer took the opportunity to get dressed. Mr. Cullifer followed Officer Adams outside. As they walked with Officer Tate toward Mr. Cullifer's black Jeep, Officer Adams asked for the keys to the vehicle. Mr. Cullifer answered that "it's not even locked, anybody could have put anything . . . in there." (T. 371) Although the Jeep, "a hunting type vehicle," (T. 263) was capable of being locked, "you could pick the door up and s[e]t it off" (T. 272) and Mr. Cullifer never locked it when he parked it outside the ambulance shack. Instead of giving Officer Adams the keys, respondent Cullifer opened the unlocked door of the Jeep, got inside, inserted a key in the ignition lock, and started the engine. Standing beside the driver's seat and facing him, Officer Adams reached for the keys with his left hand, but Cullifer drove forward, knocking Adams backward, although not down. When his orders to halt went unheeded, Officer Adams fired three shots. A bullet lodged in the back of the driver's seat as the Jeep sped from sight. Cannabis Traces In reaching (unsuccessfully) for the car keys, Officer Adams spotted a large, transparent bag under the driver's seat containing a "[g]reen leafy substance" (T. 13) that resembled marijuana. It was on account of this that he felt justified in firing on Mr. Cullifer, whom he took to be a fleeing felon. Whether the bag was of the "Zip-Loc" type he could not determine. Perhaps five minutes after he left, Mr. Cullifer returned, to be greeted by Officer Tate who wrestled him to the ground and handcuffed him. In the ensuing search of the Jeep, Officers Tate and Joyner "found a roach and all sorts of residue of marijuana." (T. 15) Meanwhile, inside the ambulance shack, respondent Sprayberry had decided to get dressed after all. He had just buckled his belt when he heard gunshots outside. Curious, he started for the door, only to have Officer Eldridge slam him against the wall. He was leaning against the wall, arms outstretched, when the telephone rang. Somebody from the hospital wanted to know what was happening at the ambulance shack. Still inside the ambulance shack, Mr. Sprayberry was asked for the keys to his car. Saying they were not needed since he had left his car unlocked, Mr. Sprayberry nevertheless threw his keys to a sheriff's officer. In fact, however, the Sprayberry car was locked when Officer Adams tried to gain access before going for the key. A search of Mr. Sprayberry's car yielded "cannabis traces," (T. 15) in the form of a cigarette butt or roach. With the help of a specially trained dog, sheriff's officers also searched the ambulance shack. Officer Tate recalled the dog's signalling suspiciously while sniffing a certain filing cabinet drawer, but nobody even opened the drawer at the time. Except inside the vehicles, no marijuana was found. City police arrived in response to reports of gunfire. "[T]here w[ere] cameras everywhere and lights everywhere." (T.311) Mr. Baker, among others, was interviewed by the press, but he was unable to say at hearing whether a newspaper had quoted him correctly to the effect that the arrests came as a surprise to him. (T. 350-354) During the years he had known them, Mr. Baker never saw either Mr. Cullifer or Mr. Sprayberry in possession of marijuana. (T. 158). He nevertheless came to believe that they used marijuana, or so he testified. This belief he claimed sprung from statements he attributed to Mr. Cullifer, who denied making them, and from leafy matter and paraphernalia he said he found at the ambulance shack. But emergency medical technician Robert Mitchell Taylor, who has worked for the Holmes County Ambulance Service for nine years, testified that he never saw "any indication that anybody had possessed marijuana at the ambulance shack." (T. 197) Donnie Ray Brock, a paramedic who worked for the Holmes County Ambulance Service from `78 or `9, through `86 sometime (T. 204) testified that, during his employment there, he never had reason to believe that Messrs. Cullifer or Sprayberry "possessed marijuana while at the ambulance shack." (T. 205-6) Judith Sharon Braxton, aside from Messrs. Baker, Cullifer and Sprayberry, the only other Holmes County Ambulance Service employee who testified, said she had never seen Mr. Cullifer or Mr. Sprayberry in possession of marijuana, although she conceded she probably would not recognize marijuana if she saw it. (T. 216) Attending a Patient On February 7, 1986, respondents transported a 79 year- old man from the hospital in Bonifay to Bay Memorial Medical Center in Panama City. As they left Doctors Memorial Hospital shortly after five o'clock in the afternoon, Mary Elizabeth "Libby" Streep Kolmetz, R.N., Director of Nurses, noticed that "down to the corner, they both remained in the front seat." (T. 73) Mr. Sprayberry was driving. She saw Mr. Cullifer in the other front seat for one or two minutes, including 30 to 60 seconds that elapsed before the ambulance began its journey. The ambulance is "basically a regular van with . . high-top roof . . . [t]wo bucket seats in the front and a sliding door in the middle for the EMT's to go back and forth through." (T. 231) Because the sliding door is routinely locked open, an attendant seated on the edge of the passenger's seat can see and hear the patient while he is on the radio. Not uncommonly the attendant remained in the front seat for a minute or two as the ambulance set out, in order to communicate by radio with Doctors Memorial or Holmes County Ambulance Service. The cord of the only radio that worked was long enough that the attendant could have stood somewhat closer to the patient, but it was unsafe to stand. Although the driver might have operated the radio, this was not customary. The evidence did not show that Mr. Cullifer's performance on February 7, 1986, departed from any standard of care or acceptable practice. Mr. Cullifer's testimony that he only left patients "to make a radio transmission" (T. 237) keeping an eye on them even then, and that he did not "stay away from a patient over two or three minutes," id., has been credited. The record made of the 79-year old passenger's vital signs on February 7, 1986, does not prove otherwise. While this record reflects minimal variation in blood pressure during the 50-minute trip, the reported pulse rates vary more, and the reported rates of respiration show still more variation. Pate Deposition No evidence supports the allegation that respondent Cullifer gave Sherri Pate marijuana. Objection to the use of Ms. Pate's deposition, which was taken in the criminal case, was sustained, although a proffer was allowed.
Recommendation Upon consideration of the foregoing, it is RECOMMENDED: That HRS suspend James E. Cullifer's certificate as an emergency medical technician for thirty (30) days. DONE and ENTERED this 11th day of August, 1988, in Tallahassee, Florida. ROBERT T. BENTON, II Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings The Oakland Building 2009 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550 FILED with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 11th day of August, 1988. APPENDIX TO RECOMMENDED ORDER, CASE NO. 87-3943 Petitioner's proposed findings of fact Nos. 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16 have been adopted, in substance, insofar as material. Petitioner's proposed finding of fact No. 4 is not supported by the record cited. Petitioner's proposed finding of fact No. 8 has been adopted, in substance, insofar as material, except for the characterization of the bag as "Ziplock." Petitioner's proposed finding of fact No. 10 has been adopted, in substance, except as regards where the shots were aimed and where the bullets lodged. The last sentence of petitioner's proposed finding of fact No. 17 has not been adopted, despite testimony to this effect, because using the radio could distract the driver. Petitioner's proposed findings of fact Nos. 18 and 19 are rejected as unsupported by the weight of the evidence. Petitioner's proposed findings of fact Nos. 18 and 19 . are rejected as unsupported by the weight of the evidence. With respect to petitioner's proposed finding of fact No. 20, no evidence supported the allegation that Cullifer had given marijuana to Sherri Pate. Respondent's proposed findings of fact Nos. 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 20, 21 and 22 have been adopted, in substance, insofar as material. With respect to respondent's proposed finding of fact No. 3, the evidence did not clearly and convincingly rule out the possibility that Baker planted the marijuana cigarettes. Respondent's proposed finding of fact No. 7 is consistent with the evidence, but raises the question why he would be "frightened by the presence of police officers." With respect to respondent's finding of fact No .9, nobody corroborated Baker's allegation of marijuana use or possession by respondent at any time other than February 13, 1986. Respondent's proposed finding of fact No. 15 is immaterial. With respect to respondent's proposed, finding of fact No. 19, the cord would not reach far enough to allow the attendant to sit in the patient compartment. Respondent's proposed finding of fact No. 23 is rejected as unsupported by the evidence. COPIES FURNISHED: John R. Perry 2639 North Monroe Street Tallahassee, Florida 32303 Bonnie R. Roberts Post Office Box 667 Bonifay, Florida 32425 Gregory L. Coler, Secretary Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services 1323 Winewood Boulevard Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0700 =================================================================
