The Issue The issue is whether Petitioners, as beneficiaries of their deceased father's life insurance policy, are entitled to a payment of $7,500 in addition to the $2,500 benefit already paid. As set forth more fully herein, since Florida's statutory and rule framework do not require that notice provided to the Division of Retirement be shared with the Division of State Group Insurance, Petitioners did not demonstrate that they are entitled to the additional benefit.
Findings Of Fact The Division of State Group Insurance (DSGI) is an administrative unit located within the Department of Management Services (DMS), and pursuant to Section 110.123(3), Florida Statutes, is designated as the agency responsible for the administration of the State Group Insurance Program (Program). The life insurance program at issue in these proceedings is a part of the Program. DMS has contracted with Northgate Arinso, formerly Convergys, Inc., to provide human resources management services, including assisting in the administration of employee benefits. Convergys primarily performs these tasks through an online system known as "People First." The term "employee benefits" refers to insurance, but not to retirement benefits. People First became the system of record for DSGI benefits data, including addresses, on January 1, 2005. Petitioners Martha L. Kenerson and David R. Kenerson, Jr., are the daughter and son of David R. Kenerson (Mr. Kenerson), a retired employee of the State of Florida, and the beneficiaries of the life insurance that was provided through the Program. Mr. Kenerson died a resident at 156 56th Street South, St. Petersburg, Florida, on March 31, 2009. Since Mr. Kenerson's retirement, the State of Florida, through DSGI, has maintained a Group Life Insurance Policy (the Policy) covering the individual lives of its former employees who elected to be covered. The Policy is a benefit available to retirees of the State of Florida which Mr. Kenerson, as a retiree, accepted. The Insured, Mr. Kenerson, was entitled to inclusion in the group of State of Florida retirees who were covered under the Policy that was offered by the State of Florida to its retirees. Mr. Kenerson received a pension for life from the State of Florida. Beginning January 1, 2000, and subsequently, the life insurance coverage was $10,000. It was changed beginning in Plan Year 2007, as to all retirees, due to DSGI's determination of the impending loss of the Advanced Premium Account. As to Mr. Kenerson, it was reduced from $10,000 to $2,500 beginning in Plan Year 2007 for the following reasons: He defaulted in responding to the Open Enrollment Notice; Neither Mr. Kenerson nor anyone on his behalf submitted any notification of election pursuant to such Open Enrollment Notice; and DSGI determined that it was necessary to change the coverage for death benefits because of such impending loss of the Advanced Premium Account. On April 10, 2009, Minnesota Life Insurance Company claims examiner Latrice S. Tillman contacted Petitioner Martha L. Kenerson regarding the death of Mr. Kenerson, asking for the death certificate of the Insured and the Preference Beneficiary Statements from both Petitioners. On April 17, 2009, Petitioners filed the appropriate documents with the Minnesota Life Insurance Company as beneficiaries of Mr. Kenerson's life insurance policy. On May 20, 2009, Petitioners each received a check in the amount of $1,257.59, constituting $1,250 of insurance proceeds (totaling $2,500) and the balance of interest on the $2,500 insurance proceeds. On May 24, 2009, Petitioner Martha L. Kenerson wrote a letter to DSGI requesting an appeal. On June 9, 2009, Ms. Kenerson received a letter dated July 9, 2009, from Michelle Robleto, the Director of DSGI, denying Petitioners' Level II Appeal and informing Petitioners of their right to request a hearing. On June 26, 2009, Ms. Kenerson timely petitioned for an evidentiary hearing regarding Mr. Kenerson's policy. Approximately 29,391 State of Florida retirees were covered under the Policy in Class A (i.e., with initial $10,000 coverage excluding Classes having such initial coverage) at the time when Respondent sent the Change Notice of the proposed changes in coverage that applied also to Mr. Kenerson's Policy. Approximately 5,921 State of Florida retirees were covered under Class A of the Policy and elected, in response to the Change Notice, to increase the premium in order to retain the coverage at $10,000. None of the State of Florida retirees in Class A under the Policy who failed to respond in writing to the Change Notice was contacted by Respondent prior to the effective date of coverage change. Respondent never attempted to call retirees regarding their wishes as to the Change Notice. Respondent has no proof that it spoke with the Insured to explain the proposed change of coverage and/or premium in January 2007. Respondent did not mail the Open Enrollment Notices to retirees by a method that required affirmative identification of the recipient, such as by certified return receipt or other postal proof of delivery. The premiums for the Policy were paid by the State of Florida from Mr. Kenerson's pension as a deduction from the payment of the gross pension payments. From at least January 1, 2003, to the end of the Open Enrollment Period for Plan Year 2007, the Department of Financial Services (DFS) never communicated to Respondent the address that DFS was using for Mr. Kenerson. DFS has a separate and independent data base from that used by Respondent. At no time did DMS send to the Insured c/o Petitioner David R. Kenerson, Jr., any Open Enrollment Notice for any plan year before the 2008 plan year relating to the terms of the Policy. As administrator of the Policy, it is and has been DMS's responsibility to maintain a database of addresses for contacting retirees who are eligible for coverage under the Policy. In August 2002, DMS contracted with Convergys as a third party service provider to perform administrative functions, including the maintenance of the retirees "address of record" database for insurance purposes and for recordkeeping relating to retirees whose lives were insured under the Policy. With respect to the July 31, 2006, mailing to retirees, DMS retained direct control of the stuffing, sending, and addressing of the letters, as well as the collection of mail that was returned as undeliverable. In 2004, DMS delivered to Convergys a copy of the retiree address of record contained in the Cooperative Personnel Employment System (COPES), previously maintained only by DMS. Tom Lockridge, Respondent's Benefits Team Manager in 2005, noted his confusion with how many different databases exist that cover retirees of the State of Florida. He was aware that DSGI and the Division of Retirement Services (DRS) each has its own databases. Retirees entitled to enroll in the Policy managed by DSGI are also entitled to pension eligibility or other post- retirement activities managed by DMS, DRS, or the State University System. Since the inception of the DMS website, www.myflorida.com, two separate databases, the People First database and the DRS database, have been maintained. At all times since 2000, Mr. Kenerson was listed as a retiree of the State of Florida in the databases of DSGI and DRS. During the Open Enrollment period for Plan Year 2007 for the Policy, DMS records maintained by Convergys in the "address of record" database showed that Mr. Kenerson lived at 1737 Brightwaters Boulevard, St. Petersburg, Florida. DMS, through its agent Convergys, sent the Open Enrollment Notice for Plan Year 2007 for the Policy to Mr. Kenerson at the Brightwaters Boulevard address. In 2001, Mr. Kenerson sent to DRS, but not to DSGI, a written notice of change of address showing his new address as 156 56th Street South, Villa 37, St. Petersburg, Florida. DMS never received an affirmative notice from Mr. Kenerson electing to either adopt the $2,500 coverage; increase to $10,000 in coverage; or terminate his enrollment altogether. In connection with the Open Enrollment notice, DMS contract with Convergys did not require Convergys to seek data from other Florida agencies or divisions to update the database of retirees' addresses and contact information. In connection with the Open Enrollment notice, DMS records management policies did not require DMS personnel to obtain data from other Florida agencies or divisions to update the DMS database of retirees' addresses and contact information. In designing the offered choices on the Open Enrollment notice, DMS allocated $6.33 per month from the Advance Premium Account to subsidize each retiree's premium for Plan Year 2007. Approximately 80 percent of the then-current retirees elected, or were deemed to have elected by default, to reduce their coverage from $10,000 to $2,500 as a result of the Open Enrollment process conducted by DMS. As of October 2006, 24,488 retirees elected the $2,500 life insurance policy for Plan Year 2007, while 4,769 retirees elected the $10,000 coverage. The Open Enrollment notice did not explain why those electing the $10,000 in coverage were required to pay almost eight times the amount of premium charged for $2,500 of coverage ($35.79 per month versus $4.20 per month). A "positive enrollment" means an individual must affirmatively elect each and every benefit or a certain type of benefit. A "passive enrollment" is where, by taking no action, the individual continues to have the same benefit level as previously. Respondent used the "passive enrollment" system for Plan Year 2008, when the life benefit premium changed due to the fact that Convergys would have charged a significant fee (seven figures) to conduct a "positive enrollment." DMS elected not to incur the additional expense. Since the state has designated People First as the system of record for its retirees relating to their benefits and information regarding Open Enrollment, any changes in address are made through the People First system. The agreement between DMS and Convergys does not require Convergys to communicate with other agencies regarding updating of the address of record database for retirees. Convergys, as the contractor to DMS, routinely destroys mail returned as undeliverable after 90 days. Neither DMS nor Convergys maintains a list of "bad addresses," those to which mail has been returned as undeliverable. DMS told Convergys not to synchronize their address database with the Florida Retirement System (FRS) database. DMS was aware that there were retirees who sent address changes to DRS and not to People First. DMS was aware that its address of record database for retirees contained at least some addresses that were not current for some customers. DMS was aware that some number of Open Enrollment packages was returned every year as undeliverable due to incorrect addresses. DMS does not maintain a record of returned Open Enrollment packages. DMS has adopted no rules to record the names and addresses of retirees whose Open Enrollment packages have been returned as undeliverable. DMS has adopted no rules to compare or synchronize the DMS address of record used for Open Enrollment packages with other databases maintained by DMS, DFS, the Florida Department of Revenue, the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles, local voter registration, or any other State of Florida address lists. DMS has adopted no rules to update the address of record database used by DMS for notices to retirees relating to group term life insurance policies such as the one at issue here. DMS has adopted no rules to create, preserve, or update records, and to destroy names of retirees whose notices are returned by the U.S. Postal Service as undeliverable due to no forwarding address. The ultimate custodian of the State of Florida database containing addresses of record for retirees' insurance benefits is Convergys, Inc. At all times from January 1, 2001, to April 30, 2009, the FRS, administered by DMS, has maintained a database of State of Florida retirees that includes their address records in connection with pension and retirement income and expense matters. This FRS database is separate from the address of record database maintained by Convergys/People First for the same period. The letter dated July 31, 2006, relating to the 2007 plan year, advised State of Florida retirees that they could change their election of life insurance benefit up to and including January 19, 2007. Mike Waller, an employee of DSGI, maintains benefits data for People First/DSGI. In July 2006, Mr. Waller was asked to prepare a file containing the names and addresses of all retirees who were covered by life insurance. He created a file used in a mail merge program to send all retirees a copy of the July 31, 2006, letter. In preparing the file containing the mailing addresses of retirees covered by life insurance in July 2006, Mr. Waller used the addresses of record from the benefits data he maintained. The DSGI address of record for Mr. Kenerson in July 2006 was 1737 Brightwaters Boulevard, St. Petersburg, Florida 33704, and was included in the mailing addresses file. Mr. Waller prepared the file and delivered it to Dick Barnum and Thomas Lockridge on July 3, 2006. Thomas Lockridge delivered the file to Laura Cutchen, another employee of DSGI. DSGI contracted with Pitney Bowes, a mailing system company, to mail the July 31, 2006, letter to all State of Florida retirees. After obtaining copies of the letter from the DSGI print shop, Ms. Cutchen delivered the letters and the file containing the names and addresses of the retirees to Pitney Bowes to assemble. The letters were assembled by Pitney Bowes and delivered to the U.S. Post Office, accompanied by Ms. Cutchen, and the State of Florida first class mailing permit had been applied to each envelope. The letter dated July 31, 2006, was mailed to Mr. Kenerson at the Brightwaters address, by first class mail, using the State of Florida permit for DSGI. The return address on the envelope containing the July 31, 2006, letter was DSGI, 4050 Esplanade Way, Suite 215, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0949. Any letters returned to DSGI as undeliverable were processed by Janice Lowe, an employee of DSGI. Each letter returned to DSGI was handled in one of two ways: If the envelope showed a different address on the yellow sticker applied by the U.S. Postal Service, the letter was re-mailed to that address; or If the returned envelope did not provide a different address, a manual search of the database of DRS was made; a copy of the print screen showing the address in the DRS database was made, if different from the address on the database of DSGI; and the original envelope and letter were placed in another envelope and mailed to the address from the DRS database. A copy of each DRS print screen that was accessed by Ms. Lowe was printed and inserted in alphabetical order in a binder. There was a DRS print screen for every person whose letter was returned and for which there was not another address. The absence of a DRS print screen indicates that the initial letter was not returned. No DRS print screen exists for Mr. Kenerson, an indication that the letter to him dated July 31, 2006, was not returned to DSGI. Prior to Convergys assuming responsibility for the administration of benefits, DSGI maintained benefits information in COPES. When Convergys assumed responsibility for the management of benefits on January 1, 2005, the benefits information from COPES was imported into the Convergys/People First system. People First and DRS do not share databases and each maintains its own database of names and addresses. In addition to the letter discussed at length above, each year, DSGI must hold an "Open Enrollment" period for the health program. Open Enrollment is the period designated by DMS during which time eligible persons, not just State of Florida retirees, may enroll or change coverage in any state insurance program. Prior to Open Enrollment each year, DSGI provides employees and retirees a package that explains the benefits and options that are available for the next plan year. The 2006 Open Enrollment period for the 2007 plan year ran from September 19, 2006, through October 18, 2006. During Open Enrollment for Plan Year 2007, the People First Service Center was charged with the responsibility of sending Open Enrollment packages to State of Florida retirees and other employees. People First mailed Mr. Kenerson's Open Enrollment package to the Brightwaters Boulevard address on September 3, 2006. The mailing of Open Enrollment packages is noted on the Open Enrollment screen by the Item Code "FSAE." The Open Enrollment packages, like the July 31, 2006, letter to retirees, were mailed by People First through the U.S. Post Office, first class prepaid postage. The Open Enrollment package mailed to Mr. Kenerson on September 3, 2006, contained Mr. Kenerson's Benefits Statement; a letter from John Mathews, former Director of DSGI; Information of Note; a Privacy Notice; a Notice Regarding Prescription Coverage; and the 2007 Benefits Guide. The Information of Note included a detailed description of the reduction in life insurance benefits from $10,000 to $2,500 unless an affirmative election was made to pay a higher premium. Neither Mr. Kenerson nor anyone on his behalf affirmatively elected to continue $10,000 in life insurance coverage during the enrollment period in 2006 for Plan Year 2007. Because the $10,000 life insurance option was not affirmatively made by the Insured or anyone on his behalf, upon his death, Respondent determined that he was entitled to $2,500 in death benefit. For those retirees who did not make a timely election pursuant to the Open Enrollment notice sent in 2006 for Plan Year 2007, the death benefit automatically became $2,500, effective January 1, 2007, for a monthly premium of $4.20. As of Open Enrollment 2005, the People First Service Center was charged with the responsibility of sending Open Enrollment packages to State of Florida retirees and other employees. The letter contained in the Open Enrollment package for 2006 for Plan Year 2007 stated as follows: The State conducts a "passive enrollment." If you want to keep the same insurance and benefits plans indicated, you do not have to do anything. Your Flexible Spending Account will be continued at the same annual amounts if no charges are made during Open Enrollment. The reverse side of this letter contains important information regarding changes, new offerings, and reminders regarding processes necessary to ensure a successful enrollment. Please review these items of note. Included in the Open Enrollment package was an "Information of Note" which set forth the reduction in life insurance benefit as well as the amounts to be charged for either the $2,500 or $10,000 benefit. Prior to January 1, 2007, funds in the Advanced Premium Account were applied to payment of costs of life insurance premiums under the policy for retirees. Once the funds in the Advanced Premium Account were depleted, the monthly premium for the $10,000 policy increased significantly to $35.79. DSGI has consistently mailed Open Enrollment packages, including Benefits Guides, to the addresses of record for all retirees, including Mr. Kenerson. Prior to May 1999, Mr. Kenerson actually resided at the Brightwaters Boulevard address, which had been his address of record since at least 1988. DSGI had mailed all correspondence to that address for Mr. Kenerson. In the past, DSGI had mailed, from time to time, newsletters to retirees. These newsletters were mailed to the addresses of record for the retirees. The newsletter for January-March 1999 contains the telephone number and address for DSGI and the following notice under the heading "Reminder Tidbits": "Notify both the Division of Retirement and the Division of State Group Insurance in writing if your mailing address changes." The newsletter for July-September 1999 contained the following: "Q. What if I do not receive my Open Enrollment package? A. If you do not receive the Open Enrollment package by September 17, contact the Division of State Group Insurance. You should also confirm your mailing address when you call." Prior to Mr. Kenerson moving from the Brightwaters Boulevard address, notices mailed to him there included notification that retirees were required to update any changes in address with DSGI. Throughout the years, the Benefits Guides that are included in the Open Enrollment packages have informed all program participants of their responsibility to maintain a current address with DSGI. Even if Mr. Kenerson had changed his address with DRS, such update would not have been provided to DSGI. Neither DSGI nor DRS notifies the other of receipt of a change of address. A change of address with one division of DMS does not automatically change the address in another since the two divisions have separate databases. Within DMS there is no centralized database of records containing addresses of record for all DMS functions. Retirees and active employees of the State of Florida are not required to have one address of record for all functions and services received through DMS. In fact, many State of Florida employees have different addresses for different DMS division functions. DSGI and DRS serve different functions and do not share databases. DRS consists of all retirees who participate in FRS, including local governments. The total number of individual participants is over 300,000. The synchronization of databases would be an expensive undertaking and no funding has been provided to synchronize DSGI with DRS or any other state agency or public entity. No evidence demonstrated that Mr. Kenerson informed DSGI in any way that he desired to maintain his $10,000 life insurance benefit, or that DSGI assumed or accepted that responsibility.
Recommendation Based upon the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Department of Management Services, Division of State Group Insurance, enter a final order dismissing the petition in its entirety. DONE AND ENTERED this 10th day of November, 2010, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S ROBERT S. COHEN Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 10th day of November, 2010. COPIES FURNISHED: Sonja P. Mathews, Esquire Department of Management Services Office of the General Counsel 4050 Esplanade Way, Suite 260 Tallahassee, Florida 32399 Martha Lynne Kenerson, Esquire Bierce & Kenerson, P.C. 420 Lexington Avenue, Suite 2920 New York, New York 10170 William B. Bierce, Esquire Bierce & Kenerson, P.C. 420 Lexington Avenue, Suite 2920 New York, New York 10170 John Brenneis, General Counsel Department of Management Services 4050 Esplanade Way Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0950
