The Issue The issue in this case is whether Respondent, a noninstructional employee of Petitioner's, should be fired.
Findings Of Fact Material Historical Facts At all times material to this case, Respondent Jimmie Alvin ("Alvin") was a School Security Monitor in the Miami-Dade County School District ("District").1 From 1989 until September 2003, when Petitioner Miami-Dade County School Board ("Board") suspended him without pay, Alvin worked at Miami Beach Senior High School. During the 2001-02 school year, Alvin failed to show up for work without authorization at least twice, and he was tardy some 28 times. Alvin was disciplined for this poor performance at a conference-for-the-record held on April 25, 2002. Alvin's attendance improved thereafter, and during the 2002-03 school year, he was late for work just six times. Other problems arose, however. In September 2002, a female student accused Alvin of having touched her arm inappropriately while, allegedly, simultaneously calling her a "whore" in front of others. Following the student's complaint, the District charged Alvin with violating the School Board Rule against improper employee- student relationships. School detectives investigated the charge and found it "substantiated" on conflicting evidence. At the final hearing in this case, however, Alvin credibly denied the allegations. For its part, the Board offered no persuasive, competent, nonhearsay evidence to prove that Alvin actually committed the acts of which the female student had accused him. Thus, it is determined as a matter of ultimate fact that the evidence fails to establish Alvin's guilt with regard to the charge of engaging in an improper employee- student relationship. On March 3, 2003, Alvin was arrested and charged with possession of cocaine and marijuana with intent to sell. On April 24, 2003, Alvin pleaded "no contest" to the criminal charge and was sentenced to one year's probation. At a conference-for-the-record on May 6, 2003, Alvin was notified that the District would review information concerning his past attendance problems, the alleged improper relationship with a student, and his recent criminal conviction, to determine an appropriate disciplinary response. At its regularly scheduled meeting on September 10, 2003, the Board suspended Alvin without pay pending the termination of his employment for just cause. At all times material, Alvin was a member of United Teachers of Dade ("UTD"), a teachers' union. The conditions of Alvin's employment were governed by a collective bargaining agreement referred to in the record as the "UTD Contract."2 Ultimate Factual Determinations The undersigned is unable to determine whether, as a matter of ultimate fact, Alvin should be fired for reasons stated in the collective bargaining agreement, because the UTD contract is not in the evidentiary record.3 Therefore, it is determined that the Board has failed to carry its burden of proving the alleged grounds for dismissal by a preponderance of the evidence.
Recommendation Based on the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is RECOMMENDED that the Board enter a final order: (a) exonerating Alvin of all charges brought against him in this proceeding; (b) providing that Alvin be immediately reinstated to the position from which he was suspended without pay; and (c) awarding Alvin back salary, plus benefits, that accrued during the suspension period, together with interest thereon at the statutory rate. DONE AND ENTERED this 19th day of March, 2004, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. S JOHN G. VAN LANINGHAM Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 www.doah.state.fl.us Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 19th day of March, 2004.
The Issue Whether the Education Practices Commission should take disciplinary action against respondent for the reasons alleged in the administrative complaint?
Findings Of Fact Respondent Bobby Leon Murphy holds a Florida teacher's certificate, No. 170876. He began his teaching career in Mobile, Alabama, at Satsuma High School, in 1958. Now 55 years old, he has served as aquatic coordinator for Escambia County and director of the Washington Aquatic Center since June 14, 1982, twelve days before he lost the eldest of his three sons in an automobile accident. Sherman L. Robinson, the black principal of Washington High School, was among the first to learn of the tragedy, and came promptly to the family home to console his friend, "Bobby Lee," as he is known. It was Mr. Robinson to whom Coach Murphy referred, on some ten occasions, in conversations with another employee of Washington Aquatic Center, as a "big nigger" or simply as a "nigger." He once called his principal "just a big nigger trying to throw his weight around." T.102. Wife To Blame Mr. and Mrs. Murphy were with friends at Rosie O'Grady's in Pensacola on April 14, 1968, when a dispute arose between respondent Murphy and another patron. The gentlemen decided to pursue the matter outside. Mr. Murphy landed the first and perhaps only blow before a policeman ended the altercation and placed him under arrest for "assault with hands." Eventually, Mr. Murphy paid a $50.00 fine on account of the incident, or so he testified at hearing. On his application for extension of certificate dated March 24, 1987, after these proceedings began, Mr. Murphy reported that he had been fined $75.00. The application for extension was granted. On three previous applications for teacher's certificates, dated November 16, 1971, July 27, 1973, and April 4, 1983, there was no mention of the arrest. In response to the question, "Have you ever been arrested or involved in a criminal offense other than a minor traffic violation?" the box in front of "No" had been checked on the 1971 and 1973 applications. On the 1983 application, "No" had been checked in response to the question "Have you ever been convicted or had adjudication withheld in a criminal offense other than a minor traffic violation or are there any criminal charges now pending against you other than minor traffic violations?" Petitioner's Exhibit No. 2. Respondent testified that he had not meant to mislead anybody in submitting the applications he did after his arrest and before the present charges were laid. It was just that his wife had filled earlier applications out, he explained, while he himself had completed the most recent and only accurate application. Life at Poolside Mr. Murphy has coached swimming for many years, and enjoys an interstate (Florida and Alabama) reputation as a good swimming coach. Since former Superintendent Stokes named him director of the Washington Aquatic Center, however, his principal duties have been administrative. The Center was built on the campus of Washington High School, but is used by junior and senior high students from other Escambia County schools as well. The office Mr. Murphy occupied at the Center opens onto the pool deck, and the office door is mostly glass. Almost all of the office is visible from outside, but passersby cannot see the corner of the office into which he retreated one day in the summer of 1982, while addressing Susan Lynn Graham, then 18 years old, and the only other occupant of the office. He urged her to join him in the corner and rub her "boobs" against him, but she declined. Ms. Graham was a pool attendant at the time. Mr. Robinson, the principal, had delegated to Mr. Murphy authority to hire and fire pool attendants, young people paid minimum wage to work as lifeguards, and to help with teaching, coaching and keeping the Center clean. Coach Murphy regularly hugged the pool attendants and others, and Ms. Graham was no exception. A witness described these as lateral, as opposed to frontal, hugs. Standing beside the recipient, he placed an arm around his or her shoulders, and pulled, squeezing the near shoulder against the side of his chest. For the most part, these hugs were gestures of friendship, encouragement or commendation, but, in Ms. Graham's case, he whispered into her ear when he hugged her, "I'm going to make love to Sue Graham," or "I'm going to make love to Sue Graham before the summer's over," or "Don't you forget it, baby, or something of the kind. This happened repeatedly. Once, when just the two of them were in his office, he told her he would eat her "pussy," then stuck his tongue out, emitted a "kind of laugh," (T.22) and shook his head. At this, she left the office, shocked and embarrassed, telling him not to say things like that. He seemed to her always to be leering: sometimes he raised his eyebrows. He offered to meet her "any time" at his condominium. (T.24) He once told her he liked watching her jump up and down on the diving board and seeing her bosom bounce. Ms. Graham told co-workers that Mr. Murphy had made passes at her and asked them not to leave her alone with him. When she complained to Mike Haas, however, the Center's assistant director, he seemed to support Mr. Murphy. She decided against reporting Mr. Murphy's attentions to his superiors, and left her job in May of 1983. She "just decided that it was not worth the pressure [she] was under to continue to work there." (T.24) Ann Cobb Palmer had known Mr. Murphy since she was eight years old, maybe even longer. He had been her swimming coach. Hired by respondent as a lifeguard at Washington Aquatic Center, she felt intimidated and degraded one day at work when, in her presence, he said to two young men, Messrs. Haas and Martin, "I wonder what she would be like in bed." (T.70) Eighteen years old at the time, she burst into tears and left his office crying a few days later when, again in her hearing, Coach Murphy told Mike Martin, "I would like to get in her pants." Id. Teresa Hunter Murphy, no relation to the respondent, was a married college graduate when she began working as a swimming instructor at Washington Aquatic Center in the summer of 1982. In October of 1982, as she and Coach Murphy sat in his office, he "stared at [her] crotch and said, mmmmm, I think I could eat on that thing for a few days," (T.96) adding, "[B]aby, we'd have to send out for room service." (T.97) When she expressed dismay at his language and stood up to leave, he asked, "[D]on't you like it?" Id. During the three years or so she worked under respondent's supervision, Ms. Murphy's first marriage deteriorated and eventually came to an end. Coach Murphy, who was aware of her marital problems, said to his assistant Mike Haas, "Mike, Teresa is not getting any, can you handle that[?]" (T.94) Another time, Coach Murphy asked her if she would "go for" dating or having sex with either of the "PE coaches" at Washington High School. Looking at a picture of the Washington High School girls' swim team one day, Coach Murphy pointed out to Ms. Murphy that "several of the girls on the front row had shown through their bathing suits" (T.95) and said it "looked like they had been busted wide open . . . [meaning that they] were not virgins any longer." (T.96) The pool attendants had no guarantee of continued employment and, at least one, Katherine Taylor, was dismissed by Mr. Haas, who said he and Coach Murphy had reached the decision together. At the time, the only explanation he offered was that it was for her benefit. (T.53) At hearing, however, he testified she was fired because she had been unwilling to clean a toilet. Keys to the Condo Coach Murphy hired Julie Ann Halpern Schweitzer, 22 years old and unmarried, to work at the Washington Aquatic Center as a lifeguard in September of 1983. At school board expense, he sent her to a coaching convention in Orlando in the company of his assistant, Mike Haas, Teresa Murphy, and Mike Byrd, who did not work at the Center. Upon their return, Coach Murphy summoned Ms. Halpern, as she then was, to his office. When she arrived, Mike Haas was already there. Coach Murphy asked if anything had happened on the trip, "insinuating hanky-panky and asked Mike Haas if he made a pass at [Ms. Halpern]. Mike Haas said he had tried. But the truth was, he never had tried." (T.42) After more banter in "almost a sick joking manner," Id., Coach Murphy handed some keys to Ms. Halpern, saying, "Julie, these are the keys to my condo. I want you and Mike to go out there and finish your business." (T.43) Mike Haas drove Ms. Halpern to the condominium and, after she declined his invitation to go inside, to Cordova Mall where they bought a birthday card for a boy they worked with, before returning to Washington Aquatic Center. This excursion took place "on Aquatic Center time." (T.47) After it was over, Coach Murphy called them into his office and asked what had happened. When Ms. Halpern told him they had not even gone inside the condominium, "he was upset very . . .silent." (T.45) "[H]e was silent for two days straight. For that whole week, we didn't get much out of him. We had to walk on eggshells." (T.47) This lack of communication made him less effective as an administrator. Many of the young women working under Coach Murphy's supervision avoided him, even though they needed to communicate with him regularly to do their jobs as well as possible. His behavior toward young women impaired his effectiveness as an administrator. New employees were sometimes told to avoid him. Electioneering Ann Cobb Palmer, a pool attendant named Daniel, Katherine Taylor, Teresa Murphy, Mike Haas, Michael T. Martin all were directed by respondent to display signs or make telephone calls on behalf of Charles Stokes, the former superintendent of schools who sought reelection, and did so, many of them on school time, during the fall of 1984. Respondent gave Renee Branum permission to make telephone calls on behalf of the Stokes candidacy on school phones during her working hours. (T.305) Students Not Involved As far as the evidence showed, respondent never propositioned any student or discussed any sexual topic with a student. He testified without contradiction, "I don't even have sex, and I haven't for the past three or four years." (T.295)
The Issue Whether Petitioner's actions on December 13, 1994, were in violation of Section 231.17(3)(c)6, Florida Statutes (1997), which requires the holder of a Florida Educator's Certificate to be of good moral character. Whether Petitioner has been guilty of gross immorality or an act involving moral turpitude, in violation of Section 231.28(1)(c), Florida Statutes (1997). Whether the Petitioner committed an act which would authorize the Education Practices Commission to revoke his teaching certificate, pursuant to Section 231.17(10)(a), Florida Statutes (1997).
Findings Of Fact On or about September 9, 1997, Petitioner filed an application for Florida Educator's Certificate. Petitioner taught a drop-out prevention class at Cypress Lake High School in Ft. Myers, Florida, for approximately half of the 1997-98 school year. After the Notice of Reasons was issued in February 1998, Petitioner continued to work at Cypress Lake High School. He was transferred to a non-instructional position in the in-school suspension program, where he worked for the remainder of the 1997-98 school year. Petitioner returned to that position for the 1998-99 school year. Both before and after the Notice of Reasons was issued, Petitioner worked as a coach for football and baseball at Cypress Lake High School during the 1997-98 school year, and during the 1998-99 school year. Petitioner has a Bachelors of Arts Degree in English Education from Wright State University in Ohio. He completed the Beginning Teacher Program in Florida while working at Cypress Lake High School. All other requirements for certification have been completed by the Petitioner. After Petitioner applied for his Florida Teachers' Certificate, he was informed by Respondent's investigators that he needed to provide additional information regarding an arrest that had occurred in Key West, Florida, in 1994. Petitioner provided the Respondent's investigators with a letter explaining that he was arrested in Key West on a domestic battery charge involving his girlfriend at that time, Dory Catahan. Petitioner entered into a Pre-trial Intervention agreement with the local State Attorney's office. At the end of his probation term, on or about November 30, 1995, the State Attorney filed a Nolle Prosse dismissing the charges against him. Petitioner has not been convicted of a crime or had adjudication withheld in any jurisdiction in the United States. On or about December 13, 1994, Petitioner came home from work to the apartment he shared with his live-in girlfriend, Catahan. Catahan was angry at Petitioner because a young lady, whose name was either Stephanie or Carolyn, had called the apartment looking for him. Catahan was jealous, and she began yelling and screaming at Petitioner, accusing him of cheating on her. Petitioner tried to ignore her to get her to calm down, but instead Catahan became more enraged, and began pushing and hitting Petitioner. She tried to kick him in the groin area, and he took steps to hold her back, in an attempt to protect himself from being hurt by her attack. One of the steps Petitioner took to protect himself was to hold her arm and try to keep her from kicking him. He also had one hand on her neck area to hold her off as she repeatedly tried to kick him in the groin. On one of her kicks, he caught her foot, and told her, "Stop this or I'll break your damn ankle." Petitioner used that threat to try to get her to stop kicking before she hurt him. He did not do any harm or damage to her ankle, letting go after holding on to it for a minute or so. Catahan became even angrier when he pinned her against the wall to stop her attacks. Petitioner was still trying to get her to calm down. She finally said she was going to call the police. Petitioner dialed the police for her. When the police arrived, Petitioner was arrested and charged with Domestic Battery against Catahan. He spent the night of December 13, 1994, in jail, and was released the following day. Subsequently, Petitioner moved out of the couple's apartment for a few weeks. After a few weeks apart, Petitioner and Catahan resumed their relationship without further incident, until they broke up when he left Key West and moved back to Ohio in 1996. Petitioner felt responsible for Catahan becoming angry at him because he knew she was a jealous and possessive woman. He felt he should not have been trying to "cheat" on her. When he went to court Petitioner was assigned a public defender. His attorney advised him that the State's Attorney was willing to offer him a Pre-Trial Intervention as a disposition of his case, if he was willing to undergo a period of probation, community service, and attend an anger management class. Petitioner accepted the Pre-trial Intervention because he was informed that he would not have any permanent record and would not go to jail. Petitioner's testimony relating to the incident on December 13, 1994, is credible. No witness testified contrary to the version of the events provided by the Petitioner. The evidence failed to prove Petitioner battered his girlfriend or make any threat to do bodily harm to her in an offensive or aggressive way on December 13, 1994. The only touching or threats made by Petitioner to the shoulders and neck of Catahan were defensive in nature, and designed to prevent his girlfriend from harming him. Back in Ohio, Petitioner was a substitute for a short period of time. He then moved to Ft. Myers, Florida, in June of 1997. In August of 1997, Petitioner was hired as a teacher and coach at Cypress Lake High School, in Ft. Myers, Florida. Petitioner had been pursuing a career in teaching since his graduation from college, with a degree in English Education. In fact, when he moved to Key West in 1994, he was trying to find work as a teacher, but the job market was very difficult in Monroe County, and he ended up working in a marina. Petitioner is dedicated to teaching. He wants to make it his career. Petitioner cares about children; he feels he can make a difference. He believes he is a good teacher. His co-workers and peers at Cypress Lake High School have given positive references and reported that Petitioner is a good teacher, with a good demeanor with children, including those students who have difficult discipline problems at school. Two vice-principals at Cypress Lake High School were very supportive of Petitioner. They had positive recommendations about his character, his teaching skills and aptitude, as well as his demeanor around children. Petitioner has been recommended for a permanent teaching position at Cypress Lake. Through the efforts of persons in the administration, Petitioner has stayed on at Cypress Lake in the non-instructional position in the In- School Suspension program. David LaRosa is the Athletic Director at Cypress Lake High School. He hired Petitioner as a football and baseball coach. LaRosa was also the teacher whose class Petitioner took over during the 1997-98 school year. In his dealings with Petitioner, he found him to be very competent, and trustworthy with freshman football players. They are a very special group of athletes which require coaches with special abilities. In spite of his knowledge about Petitioner's arrest in Key West, LaRosa had no misgivings whatsoever about Petitioner's character and abilities as a teacher and coach. Rose Marie Bobbs is a parent of a student that was on Petitioner's football team. She is also an employee at Cypress Lake High School. She was active in the booster program at Cypress Lake and was very comfortable and satisfied with Petitioner's work as a football coach of her child. She had no qualms about having her children in Petitioner's classes or athletic teams. Michael Cooper, a Sergeant with the Sanibel Police Department, with 14 years experience in law enforcement, has known Petitioner since they were coaches together for the Cypress Lake High School freshman football team during the 1997-98 school year. Through his dealings with Petitioner, he found him to be a very honest person, and one who was very caring for his students. Petitioner did not engage in any acts of moral turpitude that should prevent him from teaching in the State of Florida. Petitioner did not engage in any acts that would justify or authorize the Commissioner to deny his teaching certificate. Petitioner is competent and morally fit to teach students in the State of Florida.
Recommendation Upon the foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of law, it is RECOMMENDED that a Final Order be entered by the Education Practices Commission granting the Petitioner a Florida Teacher's Certificate. DONE AND ENTERED this 23rd day of October, 1998, in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida. DANIEL M. KILBRIDE Administrative Law Judge Division of Administrative Hearings The DeSoto Building 1230 Apalachee Parkway Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060 (850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675 Fax Filing (850) 921-6847 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 23rd day of October, 1998. COPIES FURNISHED: David Brooks Kundin, Esquire 906 Thomasville Road Tallahassee, Florida 32302 Charles T. Whitelock, Esquire Whitelock and Williams, P.A. 300 Southeast Thirteenth Street Ft. Lauderdale, Florida 33316 Kathleen Richards, Executive Director Professional Practices Services Department of Education 224-E Florida Education Center 325 West Gaines Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0400 Jerry W. Whitmore, Program Director Professional Practices Services Department of Education 325 West Gaines Street, Suite 224-E Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0400 Michael H. Olenick, General Counsel Department of Education The Capitol, Suite 1701 Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0400
Findings Of Fact Based upon my observation of the witnesses and their demeanor while testifying, the documentary evidence received and the entire record complied herein, the following relevant facts are found. By letter dated October 1, 1980, Respondent, David K. Witherspoon, and his parents were advised by the Pinellas County Superintendent of Schools, Gus Sakkis, that he was being suspended from the public schools of Pinellas County for the remainder of the 1980/81 and 1981/82 school years based on an allegation that Respondent committed a battery while on school grounds on September 19, 1980, following a high school football game. (Joint Exhibit 1) Respondent is scheduled to graduate from high school at the end of the 1981/82 school year. Following the expulsion, Respondent has been assigned and is attending an evening alternative education school program sponsored by the Pinellas County School System. According to testimony, that a system provides two hours of instruction each week day evening. Respondent appealed the Superintendent's expulsion and the parties stipulated that the Division of Administrative Hearings has jurisdiction to resolve this controversy. According to the Code of Student Conduct, students are expected to conduct themselves at all times in a manner that "shall [not] infringe on the rights of others. A battery, according to the Code of Student Conduct, is the unlawful, intentional touching . . . or force to another person, done in a rude, insolent and angry manner shall subject a student to disciplinary action which may include suspension or expulsion from school." Paragraph 3(a)2, Code of Student Conduct. The material allegations of this controversy are that following the football game at Gibbs Senior High School (Gibbs) on September 19, 1980, Respondent while in the company of four other black males struck Anthony Scott Taylor, a seventeen year old senior at Gibbs, his mother and his fiancee in the school's parking lot. Anthony Taylor charged that Respondent kicked him across his eye; struck him with his fist, bruising his nose and caused his eye to bleed. Taylor has know Respondent for more than two years and has had no prior run-ins or altercations with Respondent. Taylor alleges that approximately 20 or more black students encircled him during the altercation with Respondent. Taylor, while on his knees in a slouched position when he was allegedly hit an kicked by Respondent, glanced up to identify Respondent. Taylor admitted that he was preoccupied with ensuring that his fiancee and mother could leave the parking area without difficulty. He also commented that blood was streaming from his right eye from the blow he received. Ann Taylor, Anthony Taylor's mother, was also struck by a black male as she was leaving the September 19, 1980, football game at Gibbs. Mrs. Taylor testified that her son was knocked down he (Anthony) told one of the black males "that's my mother you knocked down." Mrs. Taylor testified that she was unable to identify any of the students involved in the altercation and noted that her son was dazed when he left the area where the fight occurred. Lori Bush, Respondent's fiancee, also accompanied the Taylors following the football game. Ms. Bush also could not identify any of the students involved in the altercation with them. Ms. Bush and Anthony Taylor's mother picked him up and carried him to their car. Ms. Bush did not recall having seen Respondent prior to the hearing in this cause. Paula Sitzelberger, a detective with the St. Petersburg Police Department investigated the subject incident which occurred at Gibbs on September 19, 1980. Detective Sitzelberger spoke to Respondent at school on September 23, 1980, and after questioning him, reported that Respondent denied striking Anthony Taylor following the game. Detective Sitzelberger noted that Respondent admitted to having shoved another white male whose identity is unknown in another area of the parking lot after the white male allegedly pulled or struck Respondent. Detective Sitzelberger was unable to locate any independent witnesses to the subject incident. Jerry Young, a witness called on behalf of Respondent, recalled the numerous fights which occurred following the September 19, 1980, football game at Gibbs. Young followed Respondent throughout the school ground area and denied that Respondent had any involvement in the subject incident. He corroborated Respondent's testimony to the effect that Respondent's hand was injured in another incident in another area of the school's parking area after Respondent was first enmeshed in an altercation with another white male. Respondent related the incident following the September 19, 1980, football game at Gibbs. Respondent has been attending evening sessions at Mirror Lake Adult High School since his expulsion from the regular public schools of Pinellas County. According to Respondent, Tony Taylor was struck by a group of other blacks and Respondent denied any involvement on his part in that incident. Respondent surmised that Tony Taylor shouted that he recognized him while he was being struck in an effort to gain some sympathy from the group that was striking him. Respondent, after hearing Tony Taylor shouted that he recognized him while he was being struck in an effort to gain some sympathy from the group that was striking him. Respondent, after hearing Tony Taylor repeatedly shout that he knew him, left the area with companion Young although he got involved in another altercation with another white male which resulted in an injury to his hand. Respondent first became aware of his alleged involvement in the Anthony Taylor incident the following Monday when he was questioned by Dean Jones and Detective Sitzelberger. 2/
Recommendation Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, it is hereby RECOMMENDED: That the Respondent be reinstated in the Pinellas County School System; that the suspension be revoked and that the student be permitted to make up the school work missed as provided in Chapter 4(b)1(h) of the Code of Student Conduct adopted by the Pinellas County School System. RECOMMENDED this 14th day of January, 1981, in Tallahassee, Florida. JAMES E. BRADWELL, Hearing Officer Division of Administrative Hearings Room 101, Collins Building Tallahassee, Florida 32301 (904) 488-9675 Filed with the Clerk of the Division of Administrative Hearings this 14th day of January, 1981.
